Tips on adjusting to 1200 calories per day?
Replies
-
TheVirgoddess wrote: »malavika413 wrote: »TheVirgoddess wrote: »malavika413 wrote: »TheVirgoddess wrote: »My first recommendation is to log - everything - for a few weeks. Get an idea of what you're actually eating, and then you can figure out where you should be.
If you do decide to drop down to 1200 (unnecessary, IMO) - eat your exercise calories back.
I did log everything for over a month, no loss. And I burn off quite a few exercise calories (on vacation now, but on the average day I walk about 4 miles), so I feel like eating those back wouldn't help much.
Then my next suggestion is to weigh your food.
I really don't want my roommates to try and stage an intervention again. Would being more strict about not eating back exercise calories not work?
You had an intervention? Yikes.
You can not eat your exercise calories back - but I'd not do that and drop your calories down. I'd pick one or the other. But knowing exactly what you're eating really is going to be the best way to gauge your success.
Here's why:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjKPIcI51lU
I'll check that video out later. By "intervention" they sat down with me and expressed their worries. One of my roommates has an ED history so she was especially distraught.
0 -
Amber_hanson27 wrote: »I'm concerned about you having roommates controlling you. You take care of what you want when you want. Don't allow them to have that kind of power over ANY PART of your life. A scale is very important lol. My family thinks I'm nuts but hey I'm looking good.
I understand their concern though. And in the long run, since I eat at a college dining hall during the school year, weighing won't be practical. I can't exactly take the scale around the buffet without looking like a crazy person.
0 -
I'd suggest weighing your food, too. If your roommate grumbles, say it's to make sure you're eating enough, just as well as not too much. At your young age, you shouldn't need to drop calories that low to lose. Unless your not logging it accurately. And if your not weighing your food, you're probably not. Once you have a good idea what a serving size looks like, it won't be as necessary.
Also, if your walking is "getting from place to place," include that in your daily activity not as extra exercise. Have your settings at lightly active instead of sedentary.0 -
malavika413 wrote: »It's been pretty off and on
and since I don't weigh my food I use exercise calories as a buffer.
I wouldn't recommend making adjustments till you consistently log, which I think you said you have the past month
And weigh your food. How do you know how much your eating right now?
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
The practical difference between 1200 calories per day and 1300 isn't a heck of a lot.
If you do not want to open your diary....what kind of foods on average are you eating now? It would be easier for people to give your practical advice if you opened up your diary for people to take a peek.
Her diary is open.0 -
Timorous_Beastie wrote: »I'd suggest weighing your food, too. If your roommate grumbles, say it's to make sure you're eating enough, just as well as not too much. At your young age, you shouldn't need to drop calories that low to lose. Unless your not logging it accurately. And if your not weighing your food, you're probably not. Once you have a good idea what a serving size looks like, it won't be as necessary.
Also, if your walking is "getting from place to place," include that in your daily activity not as extra exercise. Have your settings at lightly active instead of sedentary.
I have a fitbit so it calculates calories that way.0 -
KisforKrista wrote: »i was eating 1200 but i bumped it up to 1350.
I am getting minor headaches around the afternoon so i think 1200 is too low.
Although oddly if MFP didn't have a no lower then 1200 rule i think my calories per day would of been lower since my deficit wasn't 1000 calories after i put my stats in and put it to lose 2lbs per week.
Anyway i set it to 1.5lbs per week and it spit out 1450 or something to that regard but i think 1350 should be just fine.
I'm only trying to lose 1 pound per week, that put me at just under 1300 calories.0 -
The practical difference between 1200 calories per day and 1300 isn't a heck of a lot.
If you do not want to open your diary....what kind of foods on average are you eating now? It would be easier for people to give your practical advice if you opened up your diary for people to take a peek.
Diary's open. I'm on vacation now, but I usually eat bread, eggs, cereal, some veggies, etc.
Also, I'm planning to eat 1200 without eating back any exercise calories.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
KisforKrista wrote: »malavika413 wrote: »KisforKrista wrote: »i was eating 1200 but i bumped it up to 1350.
I am getting minor headaches around the afternoon so i think 1200 is too low.
Although oddly if MFP didn't have a no lower then 1200 rule i think my calories per day would of been lower since my deficit wasn't 1000 calories after i put my stats in and put it to lose 2lbs per week.
Anyway i set it to 1.5lbs per week and it spit out 1450 or something to that regard but i think 1350 should be just fine.
I'm only trying to lose 1 pound per week, that put me at just under 1300 calories.
Youre probably not as heavy as i am tho :P lol
I am 230lbs currently.
I'm 149 pounds. I'm aiming to be 115-120.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This content has been removed.
-
malavika413 wrote: »The practical difference between 1200 calories per day and 1300 isn't a heck of a lot.
If you do not want to open your diary....what kind of foods on average are you eating now? It would be easier for people to give your practical advice if you opened up your diary for people to take a peek.
Diary's open. I'm on vacation now, but I usually eat bread, eggs, cereal, some veggies, etc.
Oops. I didn't even check if it was open or not. As for the last week (which I realize you are on vacation), but it seems like you aren't logging all your food. I would start there and make sure that even though you are unable to weigh your food that you are accurately at least logging it all.
I'd look to replace and low density foods with high density ones. I'd eat lots of veggies, good amount of fruit. A big bowl of egg beaters and some veggies for breakfast would be very filling for a low calorie punch.
Yeah, last week has been erratic. But on average I do log completely. I'll look into eating more veggies, I have a frozen bag I could use.0 -
I'm eating about 1200 a day. I think overall eating more bulky foods, lots of insoluble fiber, and STRATEGIC fats help with this. (My diary's open, BTW. My fat for today is no bueno, so far, but I'm going to have something...probably buttery...tonight!)
Our current weights are identical and goals similar.0 -
MamaBirdBoss wrote: »I'm eating about 1200 a day. I think overall eating more bulky foods, lots of insoluble fiber, and STRATEGIC fats help with this. (My diary's open, BTW. My fat for today is no bueno, so far, but I'm going to have something...probably buttery...tonight!)
Our current weights are identical and goals similar.
Thank you!0 -
KisforKrista wrote: »Yeah my goal is 135lbs.
However, its good to know that for the time being i can eat at 1300 and lose weight until im a bit smaller. im always so paranoid about upping calories, even if its just a little bit.
I know how you feel. It's not going to be fun eating 1200, but I really want results.0 -
malavika413 wrote: »MamaBirdBoss wrote: »I'm eating about 1200 a day. I think overall eating more bulky foods, lots of insoluble fiber, and STRATEGIC fats help with this. (My diary's open, BTW. My fat for today is no bueno, so far, but I'm going to have something...probably buttery...tonight!)
Our current weights are identical and goals similar.
Thank you!
Whoops, I'm 9 lbs lighter. Didn't read it right!0 -
MamaBirdBoss wrote: »malavika413 wrote: »MamaBirdBoss wrote: »I'm eating about 1200 a day. I think overall eating more bulky foods, lots of insoluble fiber, and STRATEGIC fats help with this. (My diary's open, BTW. My fat for today is no bueno, so far, but I'm going to have something...probably buttery...tonight!)
Our current weights are identical and goals similar.
Thank you!
Whoops, I'm 9 lbs lighter. Didn't read it right!
You do look a lot better than I do, haha. I'm rather fluffy.
0 -
Getting a digital scale for my food was the best thing I ever did for knowing how much I'm really eating.
Yes, 1200 calories a day can leave you feeling hungry. I eat back some of my exercise calories, and I make sure that I have a few generous servings of protein.0 -
Fitbits are usually pretty accurate at calculating your TDEE. Why don't you just eat at Fitbit TDEE -500 Cal?
When you don't weight you may have over/under-estimates.
You could discuss with your room-mates that you are recording your food using MFP and that you want to ensure that you are not UNDER-eating. The concerned room-mate would be able to access your diary and see for herself that you are not restricting too much...
Actually logging your days would be required ;-)
Eating less calorically dense/higher volume foods may make you feel less hungry!0 -
Fitbits are usually pretty accurate at calculating your TDEE. Why don't you just eat at Fitbit TDEE -500 Cal?
When you don't weight you may have over/under-estimates.
You could discuss with your room-mates that you are recording your food using MFP and that you want to ensure that you are not UNDER-eating. The concerned room-mate would be able to access your diary and see for herself that you are not restricting too much...
Actually logging your days would be required ;-)
Eating less calorically dense/higher volume foods may make you feel less hungry!
The fitbit minus 500 gives me around 1600-1700 calories, which I regularly eat. But it feels like way too much food because I'm not losing.0 -
malavika413 wrote: »Fitbits are usually pretty accurate at calculating your TDEE. Why don't you just eat at Fitbit TDEE -500 Cal?
When you don't weight you may have over/under-estimates.
You could discuss with your room-mates that you are recording your food using MFP and that you want to ensure that you are not UNDER-eating. The concerned room-mate would be able to access your diary and see for herself that you are not restricting too much...
Actually logging your days would be required ;-)
Eating less calorically dense/higher volume foods may make you feel less hungry!
The fitbit minus 500 gives me around 1600-1700 calories, which I regularly eat. But it feels like way too much food because I'm not losing.
Let's discuss "not losing".
Go to www.weightgrapher.com and enter your daily weight ins for the past month. What is your trendline?
Losing or not losing?
500 Cal a day is 1lb a week. I am losing a bit faster than that. I have had several 10 to 12 day periods rotating around what seems to be the same weight. And I don't even have to deal with water retention associated with TOM!
So are you actually not losing?
(P.S. Both weightgrapher.com and trendweight.com can automatically import your FITBIT weight data)0 -
malavika413 wrote: »Fitbits are usually pretty accurate at calculating your TDEE. Why don't you just eat at Fitbit TDEE -500 Cal?
When you don't weight you may have over/under-estimates.
You could discuss with your room-mates that you are recording your food using MFP and that you want to ensure that you are not UNDER-eating. The concerned room-mate would be able to access your diary and see for herself that you are not restricting too much...
Actually logging your days would be required ;-)
Eating less calorically dense/higher volume foods may make you feel less hungry!
The fitbit minus 500 gives me around 1600-1700 calories, which I regularly eat. But it feels like way too much food because I'm not losing.
Let's discuss "not losing".
Go to www.weightgrapher.com and enter your daily weight ins for the past month. What is your trendline?
Losing or not losing?
500 Cal a day is 1lb a week. I am losing a bit faster than that. I have had several 10 to 12 day periods rotating around what seems to be the same weight. And I don't even have to deal with water retention associated with TOM!
So are you actually not losing?
I don't weigh in daily because I don't have a scale at my apartment, I weigh whenever I go home, every month or so. It's not great, but it's the best I can do on my budget. I've only lost one pound in 6 weeks.0 -
Secondly, we KNOW that you are not weighing your food. So yes, maybe you are overestimating your calories.
But how do you go from I eat 1600 to 1700 Cal a day to I eat 1200 AND no exercise calories?
Anyway. Do one or the other; not both.
You don't LOOK like you are particularly overweight (I haven't run your numbers). You are young. Have you considered continuing to eat exactly what you are and upping your strength training or other exercise?
The effect will be the same (a larger deficit) and you will feel stronger too instead of "starving" yourself...0 -
Well said. My family thinks I'm nuts too.Amber_hanson27 wrote: »I'm concerned about you having roommates controlling you. You take care of what you want when you want. Don't allow them to have that kind of power over ANY PART of your life. A scale is very important lol. My family thinks I'm nuts but hey I'm looking good.
0 -
Secondly, we KNOW that you are not weighing your food. So yes, maybe you are overestimating your calories.
But how do you go from I eat 1600 to 1700 Cal a day to I eat 1200 AND no exercise calories?
Anyway. Do one or the other; not both.
You don't LOOK like you are particularly overweight (I haven't run your numbers). You are young. Have you considered continuing to eat exactly what you are and upping your strength training or other exercise?
The effect will be the same (a larger deficit) and you will feel stronger too instead of "starving" yourself...
I'm planning to do 1200 with no exercise calories. I'm currently on 1290 with exercise calories, which brings me to 1600-1700.
I only have a face-up picture, I assure you that I look fat and need to lose the weight.0 -
I see multiple 4+ star rated bathroom scales on Amazon.com ranging in price from $13.99, pair one with a digital kitchen scale for a similar price, and some free shipping filler products, and for $35 you are done!malavika413 wrote: »I don't weigh in daily because I don't have a scale at my apartment, I weigh whenever I go home, every month or so. It's not great, but it's the best I can do on my budget. I've only lost one pound in 6 weeks.
Maybe you are correct, and you only lost 1lb between visits. However, water weight can easily account for several lbs. And a 1lb per week loss is only 4lbs or so in a month. Are you taking body measurements? How are your clothes fitting?
How active are you? How many steps/active minutes do you have on your Fitbit?
0 -
I see multiple 4+ star rated bathroom scales on Amazon.com ranging in price from $13.99, pair one with a digital kitchen scale for a similar price, and some free shipping filler products, and for $35 you are done!malavika413 wrote: »I don't weigh in daily because I don't have a scale at my apartment, I weigh whenever I go home, every month or so. It's not great, but it's the best I can do on my budget. I've only lost one pound in 6 weeks.
Maybe you are correct, and you only lost 1lb between visits. However, water weight can easily account for several lbs. And a 1lb per week loss is only 4lbs or so in a month. Are you taking body measurements? How are your clothes fitting?
How active are you? How many steps/active minutes do you have on your Fitbit?
I average at least an hour of active minutes and 10,000 steps. My clothes and measurements have been the same for months.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions