Sugar addiction
lynngree
Posts: 7 Member
Hi I've come back to myfitnesspal because I'm determined to loose weight become healthy an keep the weight off, but I could really use help an advice of quitting sugar from my diet because I eat far too much.
0
Replies
-
I'm new too, and I also have a problem with sugar. I can't have just a little bit so I cut it all out, and I still feel badly from the withdrawal
I'm following a ketogenic diet (LCHF) since I can't have just a small amount. All or nothing for me.
Good luck.0 -
So you aren't going to eat fruit?0
-
It's more likely you eat too many calories. Unless you have a medical condition, there is no reason you need to directly quit sugar. It is perfectly acceptable as part of a well balanced diet that stays within your calorie target. Have you calculated your caloric needs to lose the weight you want? If you don't know that number, it doesn't matter what you remove from your diet.0
-
I'm totally addicted to sugar. I'll eat an entire bag of candy then go out for a Blizzard. Who does that?0
-
Almost no fruit for me. In the last week I ate a kiwi in a smoothie (cream, spinach, avocado), and then I had a couple of slices of canteloupe in a another smoothie. I eat a fair bit of greens and veggies grown above ground, but I eat nothing that uses a starch or flour, and limit fruit to low sugar fruits.
I was never much of a fruit person so restricting fruit is no problem. It's giving up pop, chocolate chips and ice cream that is hard... I'd be going for that blizzard with you Mussronkey.0 -
^^^ people with taste buds!
All kidding aside I feel Ya on the sugar front. I lost so much weight when I gave up sweet tea but now that I regularly have soda it's like the loss never happened. I gave blood the other day and wondered why they didn't have an option besides ocean spray juice and keebler cookies for our follow-up. I get that we need sugar (so to speak) as soon as possible afterward but I know next time I give I need to take some not-so-bad snacks. I'm still craving those peanut butter wafers with chocolate. :-(0 -
mariscott7 wrote: »^^^ people with taste buds!
All kidding aside I feel Ya on the sugar front. I lost so much weight when I gave up sweet tea but now that I regularly have soda it's like the loss never happened. I gave blood the other day and wondered why they didn't have an option besides ocean spray juice and keebler cookies for our follow-up. I get that we need sugar (so to speak) as soon as possible afterward but I know next time I give I need to take some not-so-bad snacks. I'm still craving those peanut butter wafers with chocolate. :-(
OP - here is my advice.
Enter your stats into MFP and set it for one pound a week loss.
Eat to that number
get a food scale and weigh all solids
log everything
use correct MFP database entries
Drop the good food/bad food mentality. If you eat in a calorie deficit and get the majority of your food from nutrient dense sources, then you can eat sugar, be healthy, and lose weight. Food = food it is neither good, bad, evil, etc.
find a form of exercise that you like and do it..this is not necessary but is a good idea for overall health.
if you deprive yourself of something you are going to want more of it, IMO..
oh, and sugar addiction is not real.0 -
Sugar is a craving...not an addiction. I crave it too, but quitting cold turkey just helps me stay on a "diet." Quitting cold turkey doesn't help me deal with my life....after a diet.
There's some good information here....
http://www.webmd.com/diet/13-ways-to-fight-sugar-cravings0 -
There's a difference between an addiction and just really really liking something, which is what most people mean when they use the phrase "sugar addiction." No one has destroyed their families or their own lives because of sugar. No one can say, "I lost my job and house, because ... sugar."
Sugar, like most nutrients, triggers pleasure pathways because eating is good and it keeps you alive. That is not the same thing as addiction.
0 -
There's a difference between an addiction and just really really liking something, which is what most people mean when they use the phrase "sugar addiction." No one has destroyed their families or their own lives because of sugar. No one can say, "I lost my job and house, because ... sugar."
Sugar, like most nutrients, triggers pleasure pathways because eating is good and it keeps you alive. That is not the same thing as addiction.
obviously theres a difference. The prerequisite for an addiction is not that it totally destroys your entire life either. Theres really liking something and then theres relying on it heavily in an unhealthy emotional way. Its possible to become dependent on anything, like I said. To flat out say theres no such thing as a sugar or ____ addiction is simply untrue.
0 -
There's a difference between an addiction and just really really liking something, which is what most people mean when they use the phrase "sugar addiction." No one has destroyed their families or their own lives because of sugar. No one can say, "I lost my job and house, because ... sugar."
Sugar, like most nutrients, triggers pleasure pathways because eating is good and it keeps you alive. That is not the same thing as addiction.
Well said.
0 -
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.0 -
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
And I'm not sure what the existence of an established support program has got to do with whether or not something is legitimate.0 -
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
Petting puppies also "shares characteristics with other forms of addiction." That does not mean that you can get addicted to petting puppies.
Sugar tastes good. We like to eat foods that taste good. A lot of people have issues with eating too much food that tastes good. That does not mean that we are addicted to any of those foods.0 -
OP - similar to nvsmomketo I recommend at least learning about keto diets or something like South Beach diet. When I'm craving something sweet I can't stop at just one serving so I've found it best that I cut out most high carb and sugar foods.
South Beach asks you to cut out carbohydrates and sugars for 2 weeks - "Phase 1". Keep in mind there are plenty of low carb desserts you can purchase or make - so you won't be denied some sweetness. After Phase 1 you incorporate whole wheat pastas and low sugar fruit like cantaloupe. Phase 3 is when you can start incorporating back a regular amount of high carb and sugar foods. The point is to retrain how you view food (pleasure vs nutrition). Sugar cravings decrease greatly and you'll find that even low sugar foods will satisfy your sweet tooth.
Here is a link to the Low-Carb group on MFP that has a lot of good beginner info: community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group0 -
Hi I've come back to myfitnesspal because I'm determined to loose weight become healthy an keep the weight off, but I could really use help an advice of quitting sugar from my diet because I eat far too much.
Assuming your in the US - it's a common issue as we dump sugar and salt on everything. Travel outside the US and you really notice it.
You have to "reset your taste for sweet". Try going sugar free for a week if it bothers you. It may help you reduce your cravings for the sweet.
When it comes to weight loss it doesn't matter where the calories come from; however sugar and salt are hunger triggers, so resetting your taste for both may help you control your appetite.0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
Petting puppies also "shares characteristics with other forms of addiction." That does not mean that you can get addicted to petting puppies.
Sugar tastes good. We like to eat foods that taste good. A lot of people have issues with eating too much food that tastes good. That does not mean that we are addicted to any of those foods.
Congrats to you for never having faced a food addiction of any kind but that doesn't mean your experience extends to anyone else, doc.0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
Petting puppies also "shares characteristics with other forms of addiction." That does not mean that you can get addicted to petting puppies.
Sugar tastes good. We like to eat foods that taste good. A lot of people have issues with eating too much food that tastes good. That does not mean that we are addicted to any of those foods.
Congrats to you for never having faced a food addiction of any kind but that doesn't mean your experience extends to anyone else, doc.
I had a problem with eating too much food for a long time. Especially cookies, ice cream, chocolate, and Little Debbies. I have a weakness for sweets. I would have never in a million years said "I am addicted to sugar." I had to realize that I had the power to control what goes into my mouth. Blaming something like sugar is a cop-out and it takes the responsibility off of the individual and onto the food, which is nonsense.
I do recognize that people with an eating disorder, such as BED, are different in that regard; however, the average overeater is just an overeater, not a binger or an addict. People with disorders are exceptions rather than rules.
So, as far as saying that my experience doesn't extend to anyone else, I'd say that my experience extends to most people. The people with disordered eating who blame specific foods like sugar are projecting their experiences onto everyone else.0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
Petting puppies also "shares characteristics with other forms of addiction." That does not mean that you can get addicted to petting puppies.
Sugar tastes good. We like to eat foods that taste good. A lot of people have issues with eating too much food that tastes good. That does not mean that we are addicted to any of those foods.
Congrats to you for never having faced a food addiction of any kind but that doesn't mean your experience extends to anyone else, doc.
I had a problem with eating too much food for a long time. Especially cookies, ice cream, chocolate, and Little Debbies. I have a weakness for sweets. I would have never in a million years said "I am addicted to sugar." I had to realize that I had the power to control what goes into my mouth. Blaming something like sugar is a cop-out and it takes the responsibility off of the individual and onto the food, which is nonsense.
I do recognize that people with an eating disorder, such as BED, are different in that regard; however, the average overeater is just an overeater, not a binger or an addict. People with disorders are exceptions rather than rules.
So, as far as saying that my experience doesn't extend to anyone else, I'd say that my experience extends to most people. The people with disordered eating who blame specific foods like sugar are projecting their experiences onto everyone else.
Re: the bold, I agree, and not once in this entire thread did I ever imply that this wasn't true. Of course people who take an extreme, unhealthy, obsessive fixation to and emotional reliance on food or whatever else are the minority, the vast majority of people don't ever truly reach that point. My point is that those people who fit in that very small percentage have an experience as real and legitimate as anyone elses, and its wrong to deny they exist or imply that they're lying to themselves.0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »
http://www.asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction
Addiction is a primary, chronic disease of brain reward, motivation, memory and related circuitry. Dysfunction in these circuits leads to characteristic biological, psychological, social and spiritual manifestations. This is reflected in an individual pathologically pursuing reward and/or relief by substance use and other behaviors.
http://www.webmd.com/diet/ss/slideshow-sugar-addiction
I REALLY like chocolate.....but there is no 12 step program. There is no "detoxing" or pharmaceutical remedy for chocolate lovers. Although "detoxes" and "cleanses" are popular weight loss fads right now.
Neither of these links disprove my point. Your first is simply a definition and the second one says it "may" not be an addiction.
For some people their response to sugar shares characteristics with other forms of addiction. Don't discount other peoples experience because you think its simply an impulse control problem.
Petting puppies also "shares characteristics with other forms of addiction." That does not mean that you can get addicted to petting puppies.
Sugar tastes good. We like to eat foods that taste good. A lot of people have issues with eating too much food that tastes good. That does not mean that we are addicted to any of those foods.
Congrats to you for never having faced a food addiction of any kind but that doesn't mean your experience extends to anyone else, doc.
I had a problem with eating too much food for a long time. Especially cookies, ice cream, chocolate, and Little Debbies. I have a weakness for sweets. I would have never in a million years said "I am addicted to sugar." I had to realize that I had the power to control what goes into my mouth. Blaming something like sugar is a cop-out and it takes the responsibility off of the individual and onto the food, which is nonsense.
I do recognize that people with an eating disorder, such as BED, are different in that regard; however, the average overeater is just an overeater, not a binger or an addict. People with disorders are exceptions rather than rules.
So, as far as saying that my experience doesn't extend to anyone else, I'd say that my experience extends to most people. The people with disordered eating who blame specific foods like sugar are projecting their experiences onto everyone else.
Re: the bold, I agree, and not once in this entire thread did I ever imply that this wasn't true. Of course people who take an extreme, unhealthy, obsessive fixation to and emotional reliance on food or whatever else are the minority, the vast majority of people don't ever truly reach that point. My point is that those people who fit in that very small percentage have an experience as real and legitimate as anyone elses, and its wrong to deny they exist or imply that they're lying to themselves.
Right, but disordered eating with a tendency to binge on pleasure foods is not the same as an actual "addiction" to sugar. If true sugar addiction were a thing, then ANY sugar would have the effect. And sugar is in pretty much all fruits and vegetables, breads, oatmeal, dairy, etc.
People binge on the taste-good foods (some people like sugary foods, some are drawn to salty foods, some, fatty foods, etc) because they make the individual feel happy and comfortable, and they are usually easily accessible and are bought in a higher volume, like sleeves of cookies and bags of chips.
*Edit: Please understand that I'm not debating the issue with you just to argue or just to give you a hard time. The reason why I feel like I should say something is because I think it can be easy for people who are just starting out to say "oh well, I guess I can't help it if I'm addicted to sugar." If someone really enjoys sugar and tries to cut it out of their diet completely without knowing anything about nutrition or moderation, then they are at a high risk for falling off the wagon later on and binging on what they have labeled as "bad" and restricted themselves from having. People with legitimate BED should definitely get help with their disorder, but your average overweight Joe/Jane would probably be better off in the long run without giving labels and power to certain foods and learning how to moderate them and include them as part of their healthy lifestyle.0 -
Well, perhaps my problem with sugar is not exactly an addiction but it felt like one. If I didn't eat something with carbs every few hours I started to shake - you could see it in my hands - and I would get very tired and cranky... I imagine that is some insulin resistance but it feels not the best.
When I go over a day without sugar I get crankier and a migraine that last until I get some carbs into me again. In the past three weeks when I have mostly gone without added sugars, restricted my fruit, avoided starches, and ate veggies that were lower carb, I would guess that I've had a migraine for about 15 days (off and on). The migrain would last about 3 days and then I would have something with carbs (on the weekend it was a 1/4 c of potato salad and a small slice of cake while eating at someone's home) and the headache is just today going away.
Don't get me wrong, I know that my love of pop and ice cream is not the/an addiction, but the withdrawal from the sugars in them makes it feel like an addiction... albeit a MUCH weaker one than nicotine, drugs or alcohol.
Whatever it is, I can not handle small amounts of sugar and find that I need to go without it if I want to reduce my intake. I'm okay with that. The human body does not need added sugar or starches to survive anyways - that sugar just makes eating more fun, that's all.
0 -
I scrolled this entire thread and saw not one picture of a lit up brain from an MRI scan. I am disappoint.0
-
Hi lynngree
I absolutely don't do well with sugar. I get those extreme roller coaster rides from my blood sugar spiking and crashing. And then uncontrollable cravings. No fun. Since you eat so much sugar my guess is that is what's happening to you also.
I recently started a low carb diet and after some adjustments over the past 2 weeks I feel so much more in control. One thing I learned is that grains can actually react in your body WORSE than sugar. I had no idea and never would have guessed.
So if you want to stop craving sugar think about eating carbs from fruits and veggies rather than grains or sugar and don't eat a ton of fruit either! I think that could help you tremendously.
I previously tried cutting out sugar and still had cravings. Now I know why-- it was the grains. Knowledge is power!
I hope this bit of info helps you also.0 -
@NVSMOMKETO:
I am very avoidant of white sugar too. I have hypoglycemia and PCOS among other conditions and my doctor is very anti-sugar (white, processed sugar). Truthfully, I feel better when I don't eat it. I can feel its inflammatory effects on my body when I eat it, and it kills my mood and energy level.
When I do eat sugar, I want EVERYTHING with sugar in it. It's definitely a "trigger" type food that starts an unhealthy, bad choices, poor self control downward spiral for me....so I avoid it.
I am wondering if your overall carbs were too low and causing the migraine - not that you were "withdrawing" from sugar? I tried a very low net-carb ketogenic diet before (<20), and I felt like I was DYING. A little fruit mixed in and I feel much better - and my net carbs are still pretty low - within keto ranges.0 -
so you can then use the addiction crutch for anything....so if you can't get a job you are addicted to unemployment? You really want to go down that road?0 -
OP - similar to nvsmomketo I recommend at least learning about keto diets or something like South Beach diet. When I'm craving something sweet I can't stop at just one serving so I've found it best that I cut out most high carb and sugar foods.
South Beach asks you to cut out carbohydrates and sugars for 2 weeks - "Phase 1". Keep in mind there are plenty of low carb desserts you can purchase or make - so you won't be denied some sweetness. After Phase 1 you incorporate whole wheat pastas and low sugar fruit like cantaloupe. Phase 3 is when you can start incorporating back a regular amount of high carb and sugar foods. The point is to retrain how you view food (pleasure vs nutrition). Sugar cravings decrease greatly and you'll find that even low sugar foods will satisfy your sweet tooth.
Here is a link to the Low-Carb group on MFP that has a lot of good beginner info: community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
what does LC or keto have to do with sugar addiction? OR are you saying that keto/LC is sugar free?????0 -
Addiction isn't like diabetes or the flu. There is no blood test or gold standard to decide of someone "has it" or not. Psychiatry has definitely made the whole business of understanding human problems (so often relegated to the "mental health" domain) a lot more confusing, but that's for another discussion, perhaps.
For some people, the consumption of (typically highly processed and hyperpalatable) sugary food behaves like an addiction, and for sure, sugar can active the same brain reward circuitry as cocaine and heroin. But then again, a good Mozart minuet or a beautiful sunset can *also* activate the same brain reward circuitry, so there's that.
Fruit is a wonderful thing, and I'd be hard pressed to recommend a way of eating that cuts it out of one's diet completely. That being said, I tend to avoid certain fruits because they tend to cause sharp insulin spikes (like grapes and bananas) and I tend to emphasize low-GI fruits like berries because of the opposite. A low-carb diet plan may be a really good way to wean oneself off a so-called sugar addiction.
0 -
Addiction isn't like diabetes or the flu. There is no blood test or gold standard to decide of someone "has it" or not. For some people, the consumption of (typically highly processed and hyperpalatable) sugary food behaves like an addiction, and for sure, sugar can active the same brain reward circuitry as cocaine and heroin. But then again, a good Mozart minuet or a beautiful sunset can *also* activate the same brain reward circuitry, so there's that.
please provide evidence of your claim with human trials showing evidence of sugar addiction.
ETA - petting puppies activates the same center as cocaine and heroin too, are people addicted to petting puppies?0 -
This content has been removed.
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions