We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Quality heart rate monitor

Posts: 499 Member
edited November 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
i was set on getting a polar HRM but have heard awful things about the cheat strap not working right. I am looking for some other suggestions!

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
«1

Replies

  • Posts: 197 Member
    i have a FitBit charge HR. i love it :)
  • Posts: 1,395 Member
    edited July 2015
    What are you wanting it for? I run with a Scosche rhythm+ armband--it syncs to my Garmin via ANT+ and could sync to a phone or whatever via Bluetooth. I find the armband *infinitely* more comfortable than the chest strap I tried.

    It can be a little finicky for the first quarter mile or so, but then it settles down pretty nicely and doesn't drop data or anything. The heart rate graph syncs nicely with my pace and elevation graphs, so I assume it's working A-OK.
  • Posts: 146 Member
    So in.....
  • Posts: 499 Member
    What are you wanting it for? I run with a Scosche rhythm+ armband--it syncs to my Garmin via ANT+ and could sync to a phone or whatever via Bluetooth. I find the armband *infinitely* more comfortable than the chest strap I tried.

    It can be a little finicky for the first quarter mile or so, but then it settles down pretty nicely and doesn't drop data or anything. The heart rate graph syncs nicely with my pace and elevation graphs, so I assume it's working A-OK.
    I am wanting to use it for running as well as a new weight training/hiit program in starting soon. I need to know what my heart rate is at certain points of the work outs. I also want a more accurate calorie count. :)
  • Posts: 857 Member
    edited July 2015
    Polar H7 strap works well, not to mention it is very accurate. Where did you "hear" all the negativity?
  • Posts: 499 Member
    Makhai_ wrote: »
    So in.....

    What?
  • Posts: 609 Member
    What awful things have you heard? I've been wearing the same one for 3 years, haven't had any problems. I've used it with my FT80, Loop and bluetooth sensor, and V800 and H7 Sensor, all my sensors still work.
  • Posts: 496 Member
    I've had a Polar FT4 for almost 2 years now and have never had a problem with the chest strap. I had to change the batteries in the watch once but that was it.
  • Posts: 146 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »

    What?
    Sorry, looking for a new one myself. Been using a Timex for years. It works well, but want to see what else is out there and what others are using and like.
  • Posts: 499 Member
    I've had a Polar FT4 for almost 2 years now and have never had a problem with the chest strap. I had to change the batteries in the watch once but that was it.
    A lot of the reviews I've read were saying that the strap wasn't picking up the heart rates well and that the device would go to crap within a short time. I know things happen. I really just want more suggestions to make the "best" purchase. I don't want to have to fiddle with the dang chest strap while trying to work out because it's being a pain. It seems as though a lot of people were having issues with it.
  • Posts: 499 Member
    Makhai_ wrote: »
    Sorry, looking for a new one myself. Been using a Timex for years. It works well, but want to see what else is out there and what others are using and like.

    Haha okay
  • Posts: 499 Member
    What awful things have you heard? I've been wearing the same one for 3 years, haven't had any problems. I've used it with my FT80, Loop and bluetooth sensor, and V800 and H7 Sensor, all my sensors still work.
    Reviews online about the chest strap not picking up heart rates. Maybe user error?
  • Posts: 609 Member
    edited July 2015
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    A lot of the reviews I've read were saying that the strap wasn't picking up the heart rates well and that the device would go to crap within a short time. I know things happen. I really just want more suggestions to make the "best" purchase. I don't want to have to fiddle with the dang chest strap while trying to work out because it's being a pain. It seems as though a lot of people were having issues with it.

    My strap has been through the washer several times and no problem the only time I've had faulty reading is from faulty cardio equipment, but my monitor didn't miss a beat. Most of the problem is with the strap not being wet, and not sticking to your skin. I've found soaking it and applying a little electro gel, or KY jelly fixes that problem.

    The one thing I have noticed, which is not a problem for me. I have the H7 sensor that uses both bluetooth, and the old technology to sync with cardio equipment, is if I sweat to much and my shirt is soaked, it will switch, but I only know this because I see it on my chart, and notice the HR is faded.

  • Posts: 857 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    A lot of the reviews I've read were saying that the strap wasn't picking up the heart rates well and that the device would go to crap within a short time. I know things happen. I really just want more suggestions to make the "best" purchase. I don't want to have to fiddle with the dang chest strap while trying to work out because it's being a pain. It seems as though a lot of people were having issues with it.

    The problem with Amazon reviews is that what you may be reading may not be for the item you are researching. Amazon does a terrible job with making sure reviews are for the correct item in question.

    Also, a lot of negative early reviews often come from people with Android devices, who had and may still have trouble syncing with their device. There are a lot of different flavors of Android, unlike iPhone, which is the mainstay for Polar.

    There are also some people who have had defective sensors. That can happen with any product. There are also people complaining about what they believe is a bad device, when they probably didn't take care of the sensor or watch like they should every day.

    And last but not least, you have to be careful about the phony reviews. There are literally thousands of them on Amazon.

    I read Amazon reviews when researching a product. However, I don't put a lot of weight with them either. I go to as many sources as I can.
  • Posts: 6,124 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    I am wanting to use it for running as well as a new weight training/hiit program in starting soon. I need to know what my heart rate is at certain points of the work outs. I also want a more accurate calorie count. :)

    Beyond the irony of you asking online for opinions on HRMs to clarify/counter online reviews ....

    HRMs are not going to give you an accurate caloric estimate for lifting or HIIT.

    Are you looking for one that connects to your phone? To gym equipment? That comes with its own watch display?
  • Posts: 499 Member

    My strap has been through the washer several times and no problem the only time I've had faulty reading is from faulty cardio equipment, but my monitor didn't miss a beat. Most of the problem is with the strap not being wet, and not sticking to your skin. I've found soaking it and applying a little electro gel, or KY jelly fixes that problem.

    The one thing I have noticed, which is not a problem for me. I have the H7 sensor that uses both bluetooth, and the old technology to sync with cardio equipment, is if I sweat to much and my shirt is soaked, it will switch, but I only know this because I see it on my chart, and notice the HR is faded.
    Good to know! Thank you for your input.
  • Posts: 499 Member

    The problem with Amazon reviews is that what you may be reading may not be for the item you are researching. Amazon does a terrible job with making sure reviews are for the correct item in question.

    Also, a lot of negative early reviews often come from people with Android devices, who had and may still have trouble syncing with their device. There are a lot of different flavors of Android, unlike iPhone, which is the mainstay for Polar.

    There are also some people who have had defective sensors. That can happen with any product. There are also people complaining about what they believe is a bad device, when they probably didn't take care of the sensor or watch like they should every day.

    And last but not least, you have to be careful about the phony reviews. There are literally thousands of them on Amazon.

    I read Amazon reviews when researching a product. However, I don't put a lot of weight with them either. I go to as many sources as I can.
    Very true. I've never purchased or owned a HRM so I really don't know a whole lot. Thank you!
  • Posts: 499 Member

    Beyond the irony of you asking online for opinions on HRMs to clarify/counter online reviews ....

    HRMs are not going to give you an accurate caloric estimate for lifting or HIIT.

    Are you looking for one that connects to your phone? To gym equipment? That comes with its own watch display?
    Haha true... If it connects to my iPhone I would be happy! lol I don't really care for it connecting to gym equipment.
  • Posts: 609 Member
    edited July 2015
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    Haha true... If it connects to my iPhone I would be happy! lol I don't really care for it connecting to gym equipment.

    The H7 sensor will connect to your phone, don't know if that's the one you were looking at. you don't need the watch for it.

  • Posts: 857 Member
    edited July 2015
    If you get the H7 monitor, you can use the free Polar Beat app with your iPhone (which is very good). It will automatically upload your daily workout figures to polarpersonaltrainer.com (once you set up a free Polar account). Very good tool for tracking progress.
  • Posts: 6,124 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    Haha true... If it connects to my iPhone I would be happy! lol I don't really care for it connecting to gym equipment.

    OK ... for the ones that read the electrical impulses from your heart (chest strap required) that leaves the Polar H6 and H7, 4iiii Viiiiva, and Wahoo Tickr line of straps. There are also the optical sensors such as the Scosche Rhythm + and Mio's arm mounted straps.

    All of those get good reviews for accurately tracking HR and work with Bluetooth devices such as an iPhone or Android.
  • Posts: 2,445 Member
    Another H7 recommendation. This is by far the best one I've ever had. The previous Polar bluetooth HRM was crap. Very erratic and unreliable. But they fixed all these issues with the H7.

    I also purchased 2 extra straps (very cheap) since I run 4-5 days per week and the straps tend to smell bad. I know you are not supposed to, but I throw mine in the washer and it comes out smelling (and working) good as new.
  • Posts: 7 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    A lot of the reviews I've read were saying that the strap wasn't picking up the heart rates well and that the device would go to crap within a short time. I know things happen. I really just want more suggestions to make the "best" purchase. I don't want to have to fiddle with the dang chest strap while trying to work out because it's being a pain. It seems as though a lot of people were having issues with it.

  • Posts: 7 Member
    My polar chest strap is always messing up! My boyfriend has one also and his is also messed up. It stops picking up the heart rate mid workout soo annoying! Kills the vibe big time!
  • Posts: 857 Member
    edited August 2015
    My polar chest strap is always messing up! My boyfriend has one also and his is also messed up. It stops picking up the heart rate mid workout soo annoying! Kills the vibe big time!

    If it is under warranty, you and he need to contact Polar. If it isn't under warranty, he probably should get a new Polar strap for $20.00 as they don't last forever.

    Have the both of you been maintaining the strap properly after every workout?
  • Posts: 12,294 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    I am wanting to use it for running as well as a new weight training/hiit program in starting soon. I need to know what my heart rate is at certain points of the work outs. I also want a more accurate calorie count. :)

    Just an FYI but HRMs will not be at all accurate for HIIT, and even worse so for strength training. The calculation embedded in the HRM assumes steady state cardio, the further away you get from that activity the more inaccurate it will become.
  • Posts: 140 Member
    edited August 2015
    I love my Zephyr HxM because the battery is rechargeable. Don't wind up using it much anymore, though. Do make sure the contacts are wet. If you are sweating, that will help.
  • Posts: 1,155 Member
    jensquish1 wrote: »
    i was set on getting a polar HRM but have heard awful things about the cheat strap not working right. I am looking for some other suggestions!

    Don't get one, they are just the closest estimate ... might as well as use the free estimate... unless your loaded then just buy whatever....
  • Posts: 499 Member
    I'm probably not going to get one. It's almost pointless I suppose. And I'm messing around with technology while working out I'm going to flip out lol
  • Posts: 857 Member
    edited August 2015

    Don't get one, they are just the closest estimate ... might as well as use the free estimate... unless your loaded then just buy whatever....

    In my opinion, a heart rate monitor (which not 100% all the time) can really assist one in training, depending on the type of training. And if one takes the time to find his or her max rate, the monitor can help one be more specific in zone training. The willy nilly method is not very advantageous, in my opinion.
This discussion has been closed.