Now That I Can Eat...Always Hungry
Replies
-
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »arditarose wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Just for fun I calculated my TDEE w/ the following stats:
Female
39
5'1"
107lbs
Sedentary (because I have an office job)
Workouts per week: 4 x 30mins
Guess what it told me? 1350 are my maintenance calories.
TDEE gives me LESS than MFP! MFP doesn't even include exercise and it still says I can eat more! WTH?!
which calculator did you use? And are you really sedentary? I mean you may have an office job but do you walk a lot/have active hobbies?
http://iifym.com/iifym-calculator/
Yes, I'm sedentary.
Unless I actively pursue exercise, I'm not really doing a whole lot.
Unless you just count every day life like running errands or doing household chores.
My hobbies are all "sit-down" hobbies.
iifym calculator is low for me too. I use something between that and scooby's0 -
Well I guess I'll start at 1350...and work my way up if I keep losing weight.
But this truly upsets me.
Again, food is not that important to me... but it sucks knowing that if I really want to eat, I can't or I can, but I need to exercise a whole lot more and/or bank some of those calories and save them for the days I know I'm going to eat more.
0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Well I guess I'll start at 1350...and work my way up if I keep losing weight.
But this truly upsets me.
Again, food is not that important to me... but it sucks knowing that if I really want to eat, I can't or I can, but I need to exercise a whole lot more and/or bank some of those calories and save them for the days I know I'm going to eat more.
Start there, logging meticulously, and add 100 calories per week.0 -
I'm starting to think being fat was better, LOL! But since I bought so many new clothes... I guess I'll stay skinny for a while...
0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm starting to think being fat was better, LOL! But since I bought so many new clothes... I guess I'll stay skinny for a while...
yep! This year it is my goal to find an activity/hobby that gets me moving a lot more so I can be a bit more comfortable food wise
0 -
My new theme song... "I wish I was a little bit taller, I wish I was a baller..."
http://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=I+wish+I+was+a+little+bit+taller+site:youtube.com&FORM=VIRE2#view=detail&mid=82CB2ABF462D105EAD5082CB2ABF462D105EAD50
Hahahahahahahahahahaha!
0 -
oh the 90s! Had that gem of a single on cassette.0
-
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »carliekitty wrote: »I weigh less then 132 lbs and loose on 1900 Calas a day. I'm extremely active though. I workout 6 days a week most weeks and am an avid runner. I aim to just walk 50 miles a week w my hubby and or the dogs or even alone listening to podcasts in addition to my other workouts. I think weight liftings great but you need to move more for a higher metabolism! It's an appetite suppressant for me.
@carliekitty - how tall and old are you?
Not making excuses but, height and age reduce your allowable calories...
5"3 44 yrs old. I'm also a hypothyroid girl ❤️0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Well I guess I'll start at 1350...and work my way up if I keep losing weight.
But this truly upsets me.
Again, food is not that important to me... but it sucks knowing that if I really want to eat, I can't or I can, but I need to exercise a whole lot more and/or bank some of those calories and save them for the days I know I'm going to eat more.
Welcome to maintenance.
If i didn't do the exercise i do - at 49 yrs old and 5,3" (just found out i've shrunk an inch
), there's no way i could eat the amount i eat now! And Food IS very important to me.
Have you thought of doing some kind of exercise or activity you'll enjoy [and most importantly, stick with]. Maybe dancing or something?
The other day when it was pelting down with Rain, i didn't go for a Run but stayed at home and danced for 40 mins to my favourite old skool tunes.
I may have looked like an idiot
, but it did burn quite a few calories.....and it was FUN. 0 -
It's funny that you mention this because I have always found maintenance to be harder for me than losing!! And the older I get the harder it is. I have also never trusted calorie burn so I don't eat back exercise calories either. In fact when I had a bodymedia device which is what you wear on your arm and it calculates your calorie burn for the day I actually gained weight! I am sort of maintaining right now and I still try to stay a hundred or so cals under maintenance just as a cushion but I am also much taller than you and I work out every day so I have alot more calories each day.
I would say if you are hungry add a snack in for a few days and see how that effects your weight. It may take you a few weeks to figure out what maintenance is for you!
Good luck!0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Basically what my title says....
I'm at maintenance, new to it...just started a few days ago, and now that I can eat more I'm always hungry!
The sad thing is my maintenance calories aren't much more than my deficit calories since I'm only 5'1" 107ish pounds.
(deficit = 1200 maintenance= 1370 per MFP)
Anyway...anyone else experiencing this?
If you aren't now but have before, how long did it take for it to go away?
I'm still staying w/in my calories/slightly below so weight gain is not really a concern (I worked way too hard to go back!) but the hunger is driving me crazy! Ugh!
TIA for your responses!
Back to the original question, I experienced this very thing when I first went to maintenance. Hungry ALL THE TIME. Then I started lifting heavier weight and it got worse. It has slowly tapered off, though I still go from not hungry to starving in what feels like a very short time. (My completely unproven theory is that it's from having lower body fat.) Somewhere on these boards, someone else shared advice from a nutritionist that I thought was helpful: Think of hunger on a scale from 1 (stuffed) to 10 (starving) and don't let yourself get above a 7 or below a 3. It is true that if I let myself be hungry for too long (say I'm out of the house and don't have any snacks on hand), I can't just take the edge off at that point but need to eat a substantial meal and then some to feel okay again.
0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Just for fun I calculated my TDEE w/ the following stats:
Female
39
5'1"
107lbs
Sedentary (because I have an office job)
Workouts per week: 4 x 30mins
Guess what it told me? 1350 are my maintenance calories.
TDEE gives me LESS than MFP! MFP doesn't even include exercise and it still says I can eat more! WTH?!
You're 39?!? No way! If so you look terrific...0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Just for fun I calculated my TDEE w/ the following stats:
Female
39
5'1"
107lbs
Sedentary (because I have an office job)
Workouts per week: 4 x 30mins
Guess what it told me? 1350 are my maintenance calories.
TDEE gives me LESS than MFP! MFP doesn't even include exercise and it still says I can eat more! WTH?!
You're 39?!? No way! If so you look terrific...
@Tremellas Thank you!!!!!!
Yes I'm 39... I'll be 40 in October.0 -
I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!0
-
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »arditarose wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Just for fun I calculated my TDEE w/ the following stats:
Female
39
5'1"
107lbs
Sedentary (because I have an office job)
Workouts per week: 4 x 30mins
Guess what it told me? 1350 are my maintenance calories.
TDEE gives me LESS than MFP! MFP doesn't even include exercise and it still says I can eat more! WTH?!
which calculator did you use? And are you really sedentary? I mean you may have an office job but do you walk a lot/have active hobbies?
http://iifym.com/iifym-calculator/
Yes, I'm sedentary.
Unless I actively pursue exercise, I'm not really doing a whole lot.
Unless you just count every day life like running errands or doing household chores.
My hobbies are all "sit-down" hobbies.
IIFYM underestimates my TDEE by 250, for what it's worth.0 -
I like to walk but other than my normal walking throughout the day I don't have a lot of time to just walk. Looks like I will have to make time, though walking really doesn't burn that many calories.I have a step counter on my phone but I don't always have my phone on me, too bulky, so I'm thinking of getting a FitBit Zip as someone earlier suggested, this way I can clip it to myself and have it on all day. I figure that may help me a little bit as far as being able to see my calories burned throughout the day, before any other scheduled exercise gets added. I also like to play Just Dance...again time is a factor though.
It just boggles my mind that my maintenance calories are just barely above what's considered the lowest calories people (women) can safely survive on! No wonder people become anorexic, some people truly need to starve themselves in order to lose and/or maintain weight!
BTW - I was really upset last night at these revelations so I said "F**k it!" and enjoyed a hot dog, some french fries (5 French fries, lol) and a tall can of Strawberita at the ball game last night. They were all so yummy and I didn't allow myself to feel guilty at all...even though it took me over my daily allotment by about 150cals.
Crossing my fingers that l'll figure this out soon.
Thank you all for your advice and support!0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »arditarose wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »Just for fun I calculated my TDEE w/ the following stats:
Female
39
5'1"
107lbs
Sedentary (because I have an office job)
Workouts per week: 4 x 30mins
Guess what it told me? 1350 are my maintenance calories.
TDEE gives me LESS than MFP! MFP doesn't even include exercise and it still says I can eat more! WTH?!
which calculator did you use? And are you really sedentary? I mean you may have an office job but do you walk a lot/have active hobbies?
http://iifym.com/iifym-calculator/
Yes, I'm sedentary.
Unless I actively pursue exercise, I'm not really doing a whole lot.
Unless you just count every day life like running errands or doing household chores.
My hobbies are all "sit-down" hobbies.
IIFYM underestimates my TDEE by 250, for what it's worth.
Really? That is worth knowing...
But how do you know that it underestimates it?
0 -
up your protein youll be full longer, loer your carb intake and youll have less cravings0
-
I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!0 -
soldiergrl_101 wrote: »up your protein youll be full longer, loer your carb intake and youll have less cravings
I do eat protein
But...but EVERYTHING has carbs, so as I'm meeting my protein goals I'm still eating carbs...
0 -
The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.0
-
The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lol0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lolDoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!
How do you know you can't eat more than 1370 without gaining weight?
Maybe your maintenance calories/TDEE is 1500 or maybe 1600.
Initially, i thought my TDEE was 1900, then i started eating around 2000-2100 cals (just to test it out). Still stayed the same weight.
Try this calculator and see what it gives you.....out of interest.
http://www.sailrabbit.com/bmr/0 -
ExRelaySprinter wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lolDoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!
How do you know you can't eat more than 1370 without gaining weight?
Maybe your maintenance calories/TDEE is 1500 or maybe 1600.
Initially, i thought my TDEE was 1900, then i started eating around 2000-2100 cals (just to test it out). Still stayed the same weight.
Try this calculator and see what it gives you.....out of interest.
http://www.sailrabbit.com/bmr/
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
I looked at that link you posted... it was too confusing for me! I saw it and thought "yikes!" Sorry!
But thank you!0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »ExRelaySprinter wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lolDoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!
How do you know you can't eat more than 1370 without gaining weight?
Maybe your maintenance calories/TDEE is 1500 or maybe 1600.
Initially, i thought my TDEE was 1900, then i started eating around 2000-2100 cals (just to test it out). Still stayed the same weight.
Try this calculator and see what it gives you.....out of interest.
http://www.sailrabbit.com/bmr/
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
I looked at that link you posted... it was too confusing for me! I saw it and thought "yikes!" Sorry!
But thank you!
Oh wait, I just looked at it again... if I did it correctly... it says my maintenance calories are..... ready for this?
1317.... each calculator I try has me eating less and less.... I need to stop! I'm just depressing myself all over again!0 -
DoreenaV1975 wrote: »
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.DoreenaV1975 wrote: »ExRelaySprinter wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lolDoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!
How do you know you can't eat more than 1370 without gaining weight?
Maybe your maintenance calories/TDEE is 1500 or maybe 1600.
Initially, i thought my TDEE was 1900, then i started eating around 2000-2100 cals (just to test it out). Still stayed the same weight.
Try this calculator and see what it gives you.....out of interest.
http://www.sailrabbit.com/bmr/
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
I looked at that link you posted... it was too confusing for me! I saw it and thought "yikes!" Sorry!
But thank you!
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
Oh wait, I just looked at it again... if I did it correctly... it says my maintenance calories are..... ready for this?
1317.... each calculator I try has me eating less and less.... I need to stop! I'm just depressing myself all over again!
Oh no! That IS with some exercise yes?
The thing is, you shouldn't be afraid to gain a pound or so.....especially if it's to find out what your true TDEE is.
I wouldn't think you would gain that much anyway, jumping from 1370 to 1500.
I would've been p'eed off if i was eating 1900 only to fnd out waaay down the line that i could in fact eat 2100.
If it were me, i'd take the leap and try 1500 and see what happens for a few weeks.
You may just be surprised!0 -
ExRelaySprinter wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.DoreenaV1975 wrote: »ExRelaySprinter wrote: »DoreenaV1975 wrote: »The calorie calculators are just a starting point. Each day I plug my numbers into a spreadsheet which I have been keeping up with for well over a year now. I average out my calories over a month's span and as long as my average is under 1900, I lose. If you begin a new exercise routine or even eat a bit too much salt it can make the scale rise because of water retention. It does not mean that you have gained any fat. These fluctuations used to drive me crazy because I would eat well all week and then suddenly "gain" 2 or 3 pounds. Then again sometimes I would party all weekend consuming 2000-3000 calories and the scale never moved. The spreadsheet helps me to keep up with the fluctuations and sometimes I never know what causes them but it helps me see the overall trends.
I have a spreadsheet too! I'm a statistics nerd, lolDoreenaV1975 wrote: »I'm 5'2" 121. Still losing slowly. I average about 1700 total calories a day. I would eat someone's face off if I was only allowed 1370. I started using the TDEE method since I wasn't losing eating back all the exercise calories mfp was giving me. During the process I learned that my maintenance calories were around 1900. I have a very sedentary job and don't do much cardio at all. Lifting heavy makes me super hungry but I absolutely love the results! That calculator you used gave me 1468 TDEE. No way is that right for me!
So...we can't trust exercise burn calculations or calorie calculators?! Ughhh...so frustrating!
How do you know you can't eat more than 1370 without gaining weight?
Maybe your maintenance calories/TDEE is 1500 or maybe 1600.
Initially, i thought my TDEE was 1900, then i started eating around 2000-2100 cals (just to test it out). Still stayed the same weight.
Try this calculator and see what it gives you.....out of interest.
http://www.sailrabbit.com/bmr/
Technically I don't know... but I'm afdriad to find out. I reallydon't want to gain back what I worked so hard to lose.
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
I looked at that link you posted... it was too confusing for me! I saw it and thought "yikes!" Sorry!
But thank you!
Last night i indulged (a bit) but that's not something I plan to keep up... other than the rare occassion...
Oh wait, I just looked at it again... if I did it correctly... it says my maintenance calories are..... ready for this?
1317.... each calculator I try has me eating less and less.... I need to stop! I'm just depressing myself all over again!
Oh no! That IS with some exercise yes?
The thing is, you shouldn't be afraid to gain a pound or so.....especially if it's to find out what your true TDEE is.
I wouldn't think you would gain that much anyway, jumping from 1370 to 1500.
I would've been p'eed off if i was eating 1900 only to fnd out waaay down the line that i could in fact eat 2100.
If it were me, i'd take the leap and try 1500 and see what happens for a few weeks.
You may just be surprised!
Oops forgot about the exercise... Okay I did it wrong... Thank goodness...for once im happy to be wrong! LOL Told you I found it confusing! I don't have time now...so l'll try again later.
And what your saying about going from 1370 to 1500 sounds grea, makes srns in theory but the practice of it scares me!0 -
I am 4' 10.5 " and 30 years older than you and have discovered that being hungry for me is partly ( and sometimes a BIG part) psychological, which means that I get " hungry " just because I can have more calories.
A more important point for me is; and I have known this for 25-30 years, that if I eat simple carbs, I usually get hungry. So I avoid them and since because of height and age within a deficit that allows me a .5 pounds loss a week, I only eat 1200 calories, I eat 95% complex carbs of the carbs I eat. I only eat two large meals a day and no snacks ( personal preference and the fact that I am from a no-snack culture ) and am never hungry....at least not so hungry that I have to eat. Feeling hungry before a meal imo is how it is supposed to be.0 -
PattiWalling wrote: »I have a Polar FT4 which has a strap I attach around my chest during workouts. It communicates my heart rate to my polar watch which I wear on my wrist (input all your basic user information into the watch when you get it). It constantly tells me my heart rate, number of calories burned and a time counter for each workout session. It's counting calories burned no matter what I'm doing whether it's cardio or lifting weights. It cost my $89 from Academy but I'm sure it can purchased just about anywhere. No more guessing on calorie burns for any workout or using MFP's overly exaggerated calorie burn for activities.
And surprise - it ain't as accurate as you think.
The cheap Polars make some assumptions based on your BMI (weight/height) to figure fitness level (gender/age) to decide a key stat - VO2max.
It then calculates another key stat - HRmax by 220-age.
Sadly both of those are huge assumptions. Women especially have more chance of being more than 10 bpm from that HRmax then in that range.
Which is why even with nicer Polar's using self-test and available stats, and even with lab entered stats, accuracy can be off by decent amount. Is 30% inflated as much as database entries? How would one know?
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/459580-polar-hrm-calorie-burn-estimate-accuracy-study
And just FYI.
The formulas that even get a calorie burn from HR are ONLY valid for steady-state aerobic exercise zone, that's the only time your heart beating supplying more oxygen has any bearing on calories being burned.
If lifting is done right, along with intervals, it's opposite of steady-state same HR 2-4 minutes - and anaerobic.
Totally wrong usage of HRM.
So no - while it may be applying the formula to the wrong workout - it's giving inflated calorie burn for lifting.
Better to manually log as Strength Training or Circuit Training depending on what you are doing. May seem like little calorie burn compared to cardio - but that is true.0 -
My suggestion for always feeling hungry is upping vegetables maybe with "I cant believe its not butter spray" or some low/no calorie flavor spray. There are a lot of veggies that burn more calories to digest than they actually contain. "Carrots, celery, cauliflower, broccoli, cucumbers, iceburg lettuce, leafy greens, grapefruit, watermelon", you can add the veggies to broths and make a healthy lunch or dinner side. Any fruit or veggie that is 50 - 60% or more water is usually less calories than what is it is to metabolize it because of all the fiber. Add these to your snacks to feel full throughout the day and you have the added benefits of vitamins. If you still feel hungry reduce your carbs from breads and pastas and add more lean protien. Good luck I hope this helps.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions