Welcome to Debate Club! Please be aware that this is a space for respectful debate, and that your ideas will be challenged here. Please remember to critique the argument, not the author.
Essential Oils
WeepingAngel81
Posts: 2,232 Member
in Debate Club
I am new to the E.O. world, and came into not really having no opinion about them either way. I do use oils, but I do not believe that modern medicine should be tossed out the window. I just took a trip to the doctor a couple of weeks ago, in fact, for a nasty cough I had going on. However, the more I learn, the more I realize there is a lot of opinions that tend to either fall under full out belief in using them to support your body OR total skeptics believing them to be just another craze. I am curious about what others think about taking a more holistic approach to their health.
What do you think? Are they just another craze, or do believe their is real science behind them and why? Are they something you have ever incorporated into your life, or do you have no use for them?
What do you think? Are they just another craze, or do believe their is real science behind them and why? Are they something you have ever incorporated into your life, or do you have no use for them?
0
Replies
-
I have the ones that smell nice. Holistic health is a bit of a buzzword and is usually a good indicator of pseudoscience to me. I personally think that health involves a "holistic" approach in that diet and exercise are important but who doesn't?4
-
I have and use EO's! Love them!! I use them for anxiety and depression and also if my muscles are sore!
2 -
Listerine is my favorite, it really makes my breath fresh7
-
I'm very skeptical and think it runs more along the lines of placebo effect - if you think it's going to work, then it will.
That said, occasionally when I visit the massage therapist she uses a mint oil on the scalp which is very soothing. But I don't believe that it's actually doing anything other than what it's meant for, which is to just be a refreshing scrub. I don't get into magical thinking myself.3 -
i use lavendar and some of them for cleaning as well.
i have panaway for sore joints too.1 -
There are some that beneficial like Eucalyptus. It's used in all kinda of things and helps with inflammation like a sunburn or in Vicks Vapor Rub. Thus the grandma's always telling you to use Noxzema on your sunburns to help with the swelling. Personally I just like the smells and if you are going to use them do your research especially if you move into tinctures. A lot of EO and tinctures affect medications and diseases0
-
I'm very skeptical and think it runs more along the lines of placebo effect - if you think it's going to work, then it will.
That said, occasionally when I visit the massage therapist she uses a mint oil on the scalp which is very soothing. But I don't believe that it's actually doing anything other than what it's meant for, which is to just be a refreshing scrub. I don't get into magical thinking myself.
Can you expand on the magical thinking part? From my understanding, E.O.'s are volatile compounds found within a plant. It has been proven that plants when we eat them are good for us. Is it a stretch to believe that the oils found within these plants could be good for our bodies as well? For example, currently, there is a lot of research being done on Frankincense and it's effects on cancer. I wouldn't go out and slather myself in the oil, nor would I use that as my sole treatment if I had cancer, but if you were told you had cancer and told that this in conjunction with your ongoing medical treatment, could help you, would your skepticism hold you back from trying it?1 -
There are some that beneficial like Eucalyptus. It's used in all kinda of things and helps with inflammation like a sunburn or in Vicks Vapor Rub. Thus the grandma's always telling you to use Noxzema on your sunburns to help with the swelling. Personally I just like the smells and if you are going to use them do your research especially if you move into tinctures. A lot of EO and tinctures affect medications and diseases
Do you think it's the Eucalyptus alone or the other ingredients working with it in the products you mentioned that help soothe?0 -
Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.1
-
Tea tree oil (for me) worked more effectively on chronic athletes foot than even prescription cream. Would I use holistic for every medical problem.....nope I'd rather not live in the dark ages. Both have their place in my world.4
-
There isn't enough empirical evidence for me to consider using them as an alternative medicine. I do think there is a place for aromatherapy and have used oils for that purpose, but it's simply a therapeutic effect. Scents often have an effect on the brain and can make us feel good (or bad, depending on the memory it produces.) A good example is smelling something from your childhood: perhaps your grandmother's house, or the smell of your mother's signature dish.2
-
I have lavender, vanilla, orange& grapefruit oils for a refreshing smell. For me, they just smell nice, i don't expect them to have any use beyond that.1
-
ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.5 -
I do not subscribe to the magic oils. It seems like such a white suburban craze.3
-
ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
I've not heard of peppermint to help with digestion, but I have heard of star anise helping. I have heard peppermint may help with an upset stomach though. My mom used to always rub my stomach in a counter clockwise motion when I was a child and my stomach was upset, and I do recall her telling me to eat a peppermint if I felt nauseated, but I don't like peppermint taste so that didn't happen!1 -
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
0 -
ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?5 -
ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
6 -
ColonEvgeniZyntx wrote: »ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?
http://www.aafp.org/afp/2007/0401/p1027.html
0 -
ForecasterJason wrote: »
ColonEvgeniZyntx wrote: »ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?
http://www.aafp.org/afp/2007/0401/p1027.html
That article says:peppermint oil given via enema has been modestly effective for relief of colonic spasm in patients undergoing barium enemas.
Rubbing it on your belly isn't the same as shooting it up your rectum.13 -
It also says, "there seems to be a trend indicating mild effectiveness in the reduction of some IBS symptoms, especially flatulence and abdominal pain and distension."ForecasterJason wrote: »
ColonEvgeniZyntx wrote: »ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?
http://www.aafp.org/afp/2007/0401/p1027.html
That article says:peppermint oil given via enema has been modestly effective for relief of colonic spasm in patients undergoing barium enemas.
Rubbing it on your belly isn't the same as shooting it up your rectum.
BTW, I should also note I didn't get the idea to use the oil from the Internet, but rather a hard-copy book on essential oils.
0 -
ForecasterJason wrote: »
ColonEvgeniZyntx wrote: »ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?
http://www.aafp.org/afp/2007/0401/p1027.html
So enema?0 -
ForecasterJason wrote: »
It also says, "there seems to be a trend indicating mild effectiveness in the reduction of some IBS symptoms, especially flatulence and abdominal pain and distension."ForecasterJason wrote: »
ColonEvgeniZyntx wrote: »ForecasterJason wrote: »
Since it can be used to relax the muscles in the abdominal area, controlling intestinal gut motility would be a benefit. Some other sources say that it has antibacterial properties as well. Granted, these effects are limited to only a component of the GI tract.ForecasterJason wrote: »Months ago I tried using peppermint oil to help with my digestion, but the effects I noticed were minimal. However, I know others who have used essential oils for other conditions and have had success. I don't think they necessarily have magical properties, but I do think they can be useful for certain things if used properly.
If I recall correctly, you were rubbing the oil on your stomach with the hopes that it would improve digestion.
I still don't understand the biological mechanism to which it would affect digestion whatsoever.
:huh:
What part of the gut do you think you are affecting by rubbing oil on your belly?
http://www.aafp.org/afp/2007/0401/p1027.html
That article says:peppermint oil given via enema has been modestly effective for relief of colonic spasm in patients undergoing barium enemas.
Rubbing it on your belly isn't the same as shooting it up your rectum.
BTW, I should also note I didn't get the idea to use the oil from the Internet, but rather a hard-copy book on essential oils.
Yes, but it's talking about taking it orally. The only reference to applying it topically was used for the reduction of headaches. It clearly says at the top of this study:Dosage
Adults: 0.2 to 0.4 mL of oil three times daily in enteric-coated capsules
I don't think they intend for your to rub capsules on your belly. They also cite having coated capsules that bypass the upper GI tract and get absorbed in the lower intestines. This is 100% about taking oral doses of peppermint oil.
3 -
Anecdotal, I've always found peppermint tea good for cramps, but I'd rather not have it up my rear.4
-
This is an image of a colon (see the arrow.)
As you can see, it isn't really near the abdominal surface (skin, muscles, fat, fascia, etc...)
Surface oils are not going to reach the colon, not unless you bath in them 24/7.
0 -
From magical oil to peppermint enemas. Never change MFP...never, ever, change.12
-
paulgads82 wrote: »Anecdotal, I've always found peppermint tea good for cramps, but I'd rather not have it up my rear.
Coffee enema or GTFO!
2 -
When used with a carrier oil, they can get absorbed deep into the skin, however. There was a particular instance that I rubbed too much on my skin and felt nauseous within a few minutes.EvgeniZyntx wrote: »This is an image of a colon (see the arrow.)
As you can see, it isn't really near the abdominal surface (skin, muscles, fat, fascia, etc...)
Surface oils are not going to reach the colon, not unless you bath in them 24/7.
1 -
EvgeniZyntx wrote: »paulgads82 wrote: »Anecdotal, I've always found peppermint tea good for cramps, but I'd rather not have it up my rear.
Coffee enema or GTFO!
You don't want to know how many people have advised this to cure my chronic illness. Ok its 3 but that's 3 too many.2 -
EvgeniZyntx wrote: »This is an image of a colon (see the arrow.)
As you can see, it isn't really near the abdominal surface (skin, muscles, fat, fascia, etc...)
Surface oils are not going to reach the colon, not unless you bath in them 24/7.
I'm following what you're saying here. However, in theory (I say this because I haven't found scientific studies on this, so if anyone knows of any, let me know) E.O.'s are absorbed into the blood stream when applied topically and your body "carries" it to where it needs to go. Just as if you were to take an advil it would help your back pain. Now, if that theory were proven, I could understand how rubbing it on the skin anywhere would help. Maybe that is what Forecaster is trying to get at?
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions