Healthy milk substitutes?
Replies
-
Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
No it doesn't, if that was true men in countries where soy consumption is high would have bouncing breasts.3 -
Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
It's phyto-estrogen, not "photo estrogen." And your summary of the impact it has on men and women isn't accurate.0 -
I usually drink 1% milk or unsweetened Silk Almond Milk.0
-
Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
Erm.....no it doesn't. I've been to Japan and in didn't see a single man with breasts chowing down on tofu.1 -
janejellyroll wrote: »Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
It's phyto-estrogen, not "photo estrogen." And your summary of the impact it has on men and women isn't accurate.
Yes I did spell it wrong.
0 -
For soy milk, I prefer Silk and So Nice over So Good.
I ALWAYS buy the vanilla soy milk. But I'm not concerned about sugars... and I don't have it every day.
ETA: If I weren't allergic to cow's milk then I'd just stick with that instead of any substitute.0 -
SoDamnHungry wrote: »rileysowner wrote: »What is unhealthy about milk?
So you could try rice milk, soy milk, hemp milk, coconut milk, and the list likely goes on. All of them are just attempts to simulate milk, nothing is intrinsically healthier about them although they tend to be lower calorie.
Some people told me that regular dairy milk is high in fat and calories so if I substitute milk with soy or coconut milk instead they say I'm saving my calories and my fat content
I suggest you look at the nutrition label instead of listening to what "some people" tell you. Compare regular and skim with optional substitutes, and see which fits better into your diet. And take into account what you actually like, because sometimes a few extra calories is worth it.
Is regular milk considered ''unclean''? or processed? I'm trying to go for a clean diet overall
it is processed, so dirty, and should be avoided like the plague...1 -
geneticsteacher wrote: »rileysowner wrote: »SoDamnHungry wrote: »rileysowner wrote: »What is unhealthy about milk?
So you could try rice milk, soy milk, hemp milk, coconut milk, and the list likely goes on. All of them are just attempts to simulate milk, nothing is intrinsically healthier about them although they tend to be lower calorie.
Some people told me that regular dairy milk is high in fat and calories so if I substitute milk with soy or coconut milk instead they say I'm saving my calories and my fat content
I suggest you look at the nutrition label instead of listening to what "some people" tell you. Compare regular and skim with optional substitutes, and see which fits better into your diet. And take into account what you actually like, because sometimes a few extra calories is worth it.
Is regular milk considered ''unclean''? or processed? I'm trying to go for a clean diet overall
It is milk. The only processing is pasteurization and skimming off the cream to get the various fat percentages. I would consider it clean, but then I don't eat clean and have no intention of doing so.
may i ask how do you lose weight without eating clean?? Research I've done from trainers and youtube videos etc. they all say you will not lose weight unless you eat clean.
Most of us lose weight by eating fewer calories than we need to maintain our weight. I don't eat "clean"; I eat the same foods as I have also eaten, but in smaller portions.
but i thought a calories isnt just a calorie? like if you only eat 200 calories in lets say french fries and 200 calories in veggies, you will lose weight witht he veggies cause the calories in the fries are bad and make you gain weight
you are getting information from horrible sources...0 -
the amount of misinformation in this thread is alarming...3
-
-
I'm trying to find a healthy milk substitute but I'm not sure which kind or brand to buy lol.
I can't have almond milk though because of allergies.
But I do love soy and coconut milk but how do I find the healthiest kind? Should I buy the canned or the carton kind? lol What about the vanilla soy is that healthier or is that too much added sugar?
Also if I were to buy regular dairy milk is it better to get whole fat, 2% fat, etc.?
Thanks!
milk1 -
I like to sub my milk for a nice dark Milk Stout. Nothing better over a bowl of Lucky Charms. Magically delicious.1
-
I like the organic soymilk from Trader joes in vanilla!0
-
janejellyroll wrote: »Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
It's phyto-estrogen, not "photo estrogen." And your summary of the impact it has on men and women isn't accurate.
If even actual estrogens or testosterones in food impacted blood estrogen/testosterone in any significant way, people who need hormone therapy would not need hormone therapy.2 -
NaturalNancy wrote: »I like the organic soymilk from Trader joes in vanilla!
But you also like fear mongering.2 -
janejellyroll wrote: »Knightride48 wrote: »Soy milk is good but I heard it can increase dementia chance in females as long as and also increase your estrogen levels as well.
Yes soy has photo estrogen. In women it replaces the estrogen that we naturally produce and lowers our estrogen levels. In men it increases their estrogen so ... man boobs. Not sure about the dementia part though.
I drink unsweetened almond milk but I am lactose intolerant.
It's phyto-estrogen, not "photo estrogen." And your summary of the impact it has on men and women isn't accurate.
Yes I did spell it wrong.
You got everything else wrong too0 -
geneticsteacher wrote: »rileysowner wrote: »SoDamnHungry wrote: »rileysowner wrote: »What is unhealthy about milk?
So you could try rice milk, soy milk, hemp milk, coconut milk, and the list likely goes on. All of them are just attempts to simulate milk, nothing is intrinsically healthier about them although they tend to be lower calorie.
Some people told me that regular dairy milk is high in fat and calories so if I substitute milk with soy or coconut milk instead they say I'm saving my calories and my fat content
I suggest you look at the nutrition label instead of listening to what "some people" tell you. Compare regular and skim with optional substitutes, and see which fits better into your diet. And take into account what you actually like, because sometimes a few extra calories is worth it.
Is regular milk considered ''unclean''? or processed? I'm trying to go for a clean diet overall
It is milk. The only processing is pasteurization and skimming off the cream to get the various fat percentages. I would consider it clean, but then I don't eat clean and have no intention of doing so.
may i ask how do you lose weight without eating clean?? Research I've done from trainers and youtube videos etc. they all say you will not lose weight unless you eat clean.
Most of us lose weight by eating fewer calories than we need to maintain our weight. I don't eat "clean"; I eat the same foods as I have also eaten, but in smaller portions.
but i thought a calories isnt just a calorie? like if you only eat 200 calories in lets say french fries and 200 calories in veggies, you will lose weight witht he veggies cause the calories in the fries are bad and make you gain weight
you are getting information from horrible sources...
can you explain what im misinformed on?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions