"You can lose weight without working out". YES. But...
Options
Replies
-
I don't like lifting weights. I would rather run a 10k in an hour than to lift for an hour. But I know lifting conserves muscle and I've noticed a huge difference in my ballet technique since I started lifting.1
-
Loving the doggy pics
I wanted to add something to my answer. Previously I said losing the weight came first (50lbs, without formal exercise... And note I say "formal" as in deliberate... Doesn't mean I was bedridden, lol. Yes, I would clean my house, take my kids to the park, walk the dog, garden, etc, but none of that ever got my heart rate up or worked up a sweat, and I would not then, nor do I now, count it as "exercise". Those sort of activities are why I can have my activity level at "lightly active" rather than "sedentary", that's all.). As I lost weight, I felt better, found more energy, and gained more confidence, so I started doing more in the way of "formal" exercise (not only the gym, but sports and activities that actually do get the heart rate up and work up a sweat). I noticed straight away that formal exercise (especially cardio) makes me h.u.n.g.r.y.
If I had started with formal exercise it would have been a lot harder for me to keep my calories under control. Even now I have to consciously eat less on non-gym days to "save up" calories for the days that I engage in formal exercise because I know I'm going to be extra hungry. If I had started with simply exercising to lose weight, I would have gained weight. Right now I'm maintaining. If I ever decide I want to lose more weight, I'll need to (temporarily) reduce (or in the case or cardio, eliminate) my formal exercise. Otherwise there is no way I could endure dropping my calories. For me, hunger wins. Every time. (I suspect that's why I had so much success with LCHF. It's the only "diet" I ever tried that didn't leave me feeling hungry constantly).6 -
CorneliusPhoton wrote: »Tacklewasher wrote: »janejellyroll wrote: »GottaBurnEmAll wrote: »ThatUserNameIsAllReadyTaken wrote: »trigden1991 wrote: »I dont exercize, iv lost 54lbs. I walk to the shops and walk the dog, look after my toddler and work....I.dont really stop all day. So theres no chance in hell im getting up at 4am to do a run or wasting precious evenings at the gym when I dont need to. U dont need exercize to lose weight or to be healthy.
"I don't exercize"
but
"I walk to the shops and walk the dog"
So you do exercise...............
There is a difference in exercise for the purpose of exercise, calorie burn, gaining physical stamina, strength and endurance and traveling somewhere on foot for an entirely different purpose. Purposeful exercise will likely come with an effort which is directed at improvement of many physical and mental factors. You know that though.
What is different between a walk with the dog and a walk without the dog?
Well, for one, when I walk alone I pick up poop absolutely never.
And the dogs are always wanting to stop and sniff stuff. Without them I just walk solid without stopping.
This is my biggest issue with my dog. I usually have to take 2 separate walks -- one purposeful brisk walk sans dog and then one foot-dragging, poop picking up, stop and sniff everything stroll. But that's just the way my dog is -- all dogs are different!
I have 2 dogs of the same breed and even they don't walk the same. One I think I could graduate to running with, the other, not a hope in hell.3 -
As my handle suggests, I have been attempting to lose weight for a long time. On this last go-around (and I do hope it is my last), I decided I needed to try and make sustainable lifestyle changes. In the past, I've tried to do way too much and it stops being sustainable. I set myself a few goals and that's worked. I do try to walk 10k steps a day, but that's been it. I am at a point now where I am ready to try to incorporate more exercise into my regimen, but I think that if I had done that initially, that I would have failed.6
-
This is my walking buddy. She doesn't do hills any more and is deaf (getting old!) but can still go a couple of miles if we don't move too fast.
8 -
Darn after this thread I hope I don't have to get a dog ..
Merry Christmas every one2 -
If you look at the studies of long term weight loss, most of those who successfully kept the weight off did exercise on a regular basis. It helps.
As a daily walker and runner I can eat pretty much what I want most of the time and keep my weight stable. I have problems only when I do a lot of travel and can't get my daily exercise. Losing the weight I gained while on a three month road trip this summer, I know I wouldn't have been able to lose weight without the exercise. Being able to eat 1700 or more keeps me on the diet whereas if I could only eat 1200 a day I wouldn't last a week.1 -
Nothing wrong with walking for exercise. With dogs, if they are off leash, they can tootle along as they see fit and catch up when they are ready. Just watch to see if they stop to do something you need to pick up. Other times they may need to find a nice cool place to rest for a minute:
ETA: Later in the season as the puddle was drying up, it became a thick pasty mud. Of course it was still the ideal place to cool off. My poor car.10 -
red99ryder wrote: »Darn after this thread I hope I don't have to get a dog ..
Merry Christmas every one
I was thinking the same thing! Such great puppies, I want one. (But I can't.)1 -
I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?9
-
snowflake954 wrote: »I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?
Do you have a leash on him?6 -
nutmegoreo wrote: »snowflake954 wrote: »I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?
Do you have a leash on him?
Maybe I should.3 -
snowflake954 wrote: »I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?
My husband has a me. I play Pokemon Go while I walk, so he comes with me and makes sure I keep moving, that I don't walk into things or get run over... I feel like it's not all that different from walking a dog, minus the poop-scooping.8 -
-
snowflake954 wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »snowflake954 wrote: »I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?
Do you have a leash on him?
Maybe I should.
If you have a leash on him its not exercise, but if there is no leash then you're good, you're exercising .5 -
leanjogreen18 wrote: »snowflake954 wrote: »nutmegoreo wrote: »snowflake954 wrote: »I don't have a dog--but I have a husband, and walk alot with him. Does that count?
Do you have a leash on him?
Maybe I should.
If you have a leash on him its not exercise, but if there is no leash then you're good, you're exercising .
I never thought to put a leash on my husband outside the bedroom.7 -
Asher_Ethan wrote: »I don't like lifting weights. I would rather run a 10k in an hour than to lift for an hour. But I know lifting conserves muscle and I've noticed a huge difference in my ballet technique since I started lifting.
Ya, I got back into lifting to help me with yoga and swimming.
But now that I am doing low reps and high weight I'm enjoying it much more and liking it for its own sake. (Thanks MFP forums and my coworkers.)3 -
-
spiriteagle99 wrote: »If you look at the studies of long term weight loss, most of those who successfully kept the weight off did exercise on a regular basis. It helps.
As a daily walker and runner I can eat pretty much what I want most of the time and keep my weight stable. I have problems only when I do a lot of travel and can't get my daily exercise. Losing the weight I gained while on a three month road trip this summer, I know I wouldn't have been able to lose weight without the exercise. Being able to eat 1700 or more keeps me on the diet whereas if I could only eat 1200 a day I wouldn't last a week.
I'm a daily walker and runner, but I sure can't eat pretty much what I want.
That's because I'm old and short and down to losing vanity weight.
I find blank statements about things of this nature are rarely universally true.6 -
spiriteagle99 wrote: »If you look at the studies of long term weight loss, most of those who successfully kept the weight off did exercise on a regular basis. It helps.
As a daily walker and runner I can eat pretty much what I want most of the time and keep my weight stable. I have problems only when I do a lot of travel and can't get my daily exercise. Losing the weight I gained while on a three month road trip this summer, I know I wouldn't have been able to lose weight without the exercise. Being able to eat 1700 or more keeps me on the diet whereas if I could only eat 1200 a day I wouldn't last a week.
Whereas I had no problems losing the extra weight with no exercise factored in. Everyone needs to find what works for them, and that's going to be different than what works for someone else.
3
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 936 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions