Eat your carbs
Lovelyveggie
Posts: 3 Member
I’ve come across a lot of people who absolutely avoid carbs at all cost, why? Im pretty sure carbs will not turn into fat. —Carbohydrates turn into glucose, which your body burns immediately or converts to glycogen to be stored in the muscles and liver for between meals. If you eat more calories from carbs or other sources than your body can use, the cells store the excess as fat.
I understand the benefits of GOOD fats and whole fats via flax, avo, chia, and many more but this whole keto diet is insane.... Other than needed for medical conditions.... which that’s how the keto diet was created through dr trying to help patients with seizures...
I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
I understand the benefits of GOOD fats and whole fats via flax, avo, chia, and many more but this whole keto diet is insane.... Other than needed for medical conditions.... which that’s how the keto diet was created through dr trying to help patients with seizures...
I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
39
Replies
-
I'll agree that most of the keto stuff you hear is just hype.
It's not a magical weight loss solution and still works the same way any other diet would. You'd still have to create a calorie deficit in order to lose weight. There's nothing magical about it for weight loss. Carbs don't instantly turn to fat. There's a lot more to it than your alluding in your post.
I'd disagree about the endomorph stuff but that's a different thread for a different time. They've been debunked and are meaningless.6 -
riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight....
strong first post....6 -
As with most things... there's a time and a place for both. The trick is knowing the difference, and knowing how to apply them to your needs/goals/preferences.1
-
I keep my carbs to less than 50g a day mostly due to higher blood sugar levels. Diabetes run in my family and even though I am not obese 6'3/215, I have to watch all carbs. Keto is nt hype if you stick to it, Thats the whole key is sticking to it. I find I eat way less per day not being able to grab carbs easily. (Yes of course that is a calorie deficit) But I also try to keep lean meats and plenty of veggies in my diet, along with healthy fats.7
-
Lovelyveggie wrote: »I’ve come across a lot of people who absolutely avoid carbs at all cost, why?
If you mean why do people do low carb, some find they are less hungry or more able to be satisfied on their calories doing that. Others find they control calories without counting, which they like, or control blood sugar issues (IR), or just tend to eat better as it gives them a reason they accept for cutting way down on foods they tend to overeat or which provoke cravings.Im pretty sure carbs will not turn into fat.
They can, but it makes no difference. Excess calories lead to added fat, whatever the macro mix. So if they control calories better on low carb, they may have an easier time losing or not gaining.Carbohydrates turn into glucose, which your body burns immediately or converts to glycogen to be stored in the muscles and liver for between meals. If you eat more calories from carbs or other sources than your body can use, the cells store the excess as fat.
Yes, exactly.I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I don't think people have a "high metabolism" or not, and lots of people who do well on keto were quite overweight, probably because it can be helpful for people with IR. (Endomorphs is not a real thing.)I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
Sounds like it didn't work for you and maybe like you could have implemented it better, but no need to, no one needs to do it.
I tried it and didn't experience any great benefits, but I thought it was fine, and I certainly did not experience excessive oil in my pores or such oil smelling. Some have a weird breath thing, but I did not.
I like many higher carb foods, though, so without benefits did not see the point for me, but I understand why others might think it is a good approach for them.3 -
I love my carbs but I’m just trying to get lean that’s why I cut my carbs for now.7
-
Carbs aren't really needed, so if you're going to get rid of anything, carbs are usually a pretty good place to start for most people. Protein and fat, on the other hand, are both necessary. Certainly you don't have to get rid of carbs, and there's nothing wrong with them, but there's nothing wrong with stocking to a low carb diet either (provided you're getting sufficient micronutrients).
I personally tend to be fairly high carb, but different people prefer different things.2 -
Each to their own at the end of the day and if it works then do it, but I always strive for sustainability and enjoyment. I tried Keto/atkins/paleo and I honestly didn't enjoy it. I've seen lots of videos, articles and studies on low carb and there definitely is evidence of increased fat burning potential as this is what a lot of bodybuilders use a few weeks before competition.
1 -
Yes, I have noticed that I don’t lift as heavy. Also, I get tired so quickly. What I meant about cutting carbs. I meant heavy carbs like rice & bread. Thank you Sardelsa for info.
3 -
Yes, I have noticed that I don’t lift as heavy. Also, I get tired so quickly. What I meant about cutting carbs. I meant heavy carbs like rice & bread. Thank you Sardelsa for info.
Try timing your carbs around your workouts to see if that helps.1 -
17 -
?0
-
Yes, I have noticed that I don’t lift as heavy. Also, I get tired so quickly. What I meant about cutting carbs. I meant heavy carbs like rice & bread. Thank you Sardelsa for info.
Try timing your carbs around your workouts to see if that helps.
Yes, I have noticed that I don’t lift as heavy. Also, I get tired so quickly. What I meant about cutting carbs. I meant heavy carbs like rice & bread. Thank you Sardelsa for info.
Try timing your carbs around your workouts to see if that helps.
I guess it makes sense to have carbs b4 workout. I’ll try that after this keto diet thing. Do you compete or something?0 -
I guess it makes sense to have carbs b4 workout. I’ll try that after this keto diet thing. Do you compete or something?
Yea on keto that would even be difficult because your carbs are so low, but it is possible. Again up to you.. depends on your goals and all that.
I compete with myself
but no not in bodybuilding 1 -
I guess it makes sense to have carbs b4 workout. I’ll try that after this keto diet thing. Do you compete or something?
Yea on keto that would even be difficult because your carbs are so low, but it is possible. Again up to you.. depends on your goals and all that.
I compete with myself but no not in bodybuilding
You should. Seem like you know what you’re taking about. Just saying.
0 -
I find that I “run” better on a moderately high carb diet- 65/20/15. The days I eat more protein, I feel heavy and bloated. But I am active and eat around 23-2500 to maintain at 125lbs.2
-
Ebony_Kitty wrote: »I find that I “run” better on a moderately high carb diet- 65/20/15. The days I eat more protein, I feel heavy and bloated. But I am active and eat around 23-2500 to maintain at 125lbs.
I also "run" better on a moderate to high carb diet.
I tried keto for 4 months last year (mostly out of curiosity) and was very strict. I constantly felt heavy and bloated and frequently nauseous. I never experienced the increased energy. Nothing I tried to help with my problems doing keto ever worked. I slowly started working carbs back in and all my issues disappeared practically immediately. I also experience bloating and heaviness with high protein, so really my only option is moderate to high carbs with moderate protein and moderate to low fat. Works well for me.
I don't knock keto because it didn't work for me, and it has been the only thing that controls my godson's seizures. But it is very trendy right now and I've seen it constantly touted as some sort of miracle. In reality, for the purposes of weight loss, it works like every other diet (aka CICO). And just like every other diet, it works great for some and not so great for others. To each his own.4 -
Lovelyveggie wrote: »I’ve come across a lot of people who absolutely avoid carbs at all cost, why? Im pretty sure carbs will not turn into fat. —Carbohydrates turn into glucose, which your body burns immediately or converts to glycogen to be stored in the muscles and liver for between meals. If you eat more calories from carbs or other sources than your body can use, the cells store the excess as fat.
I understand the benefits of GOOD fats and whole fats via flax, avo, chia, and many more but this whole keto diet is insane.... Other than needed for medical conditions.... which that’s how the keto diet was created through dr trying to help patients with seizures...
I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
I wouldn't quite go so far as to say the keto diet is INSANE. I agree it's excess calories that cause fat storage and those can come from any source. However when I eat low carb I naturally eat less calories. I am less hungry. I feel better and have fewer cravings. Everyone is unique. This diet suits me best. Moderate to high carb leaves me bloated and constantly hungry. Also keto seems to help control my rheumatoid arthritis. Just because I don't typically eat many carbs doesn't mean I think high carb diets are INSANE. I think everyone needs to find what works for them without judgment.
0 -
Lovelyveggie wrote: »I’ve come across a lot of people who absolutely avoid carbs at all cost, why? Im pretty sure carbs will not turn into fat. —Carbohydrates turn into glucose, which your body burns immediately or converts to glycogen to be stored in the muscles and liver for between meals. If you eat more calories from carbs or other sources than your body can use, the cells store the excess as fat.
I understand the benefits of GOOD fats and whole fats via flax, avo, chia, and many more but this whole keto diet is insane.... Other than needed for medical conditions.... which that’s how the keto diet was created through dr trying to help patients with seizures...
I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
The keto diet isn't a good fit for me, but it is for many dieters.
It's not "insane" when done healthfully.
Somatypes are a myth.
Keep your eyes on your own plate.
Let people try what works for them.
Just because it didn't work for you or me doesn't mean we need to run around telling people what to do with their diets.12 -
If I eat high carb food, I am hungry after 1 hour. If I eat high fat/protein, I am hungry after 5 hours. Helps me saving calories.2
-
Each to their own at the end of the day and if it works then do it, but I always strive for sustainability and enjoyment. I tried Keto/atkins/paleo and I honestly didn't enjoy it. I've seen lots of videos, articles and studies on low carb and there definitely is evidence of increased fat burning potential as this is what a lot of bodybuilders use a few weeks before competition.
That's because it cuts water so they shred.
If you look at actual studies and not videos and articles, you will find that a low carb or keto diet have no advantage over any other weight loss diet keeping calories constant.9 -
Never mind.
*Don't be snarky, jj... don't be snarky.*5 -
Lovelyveggie wrote: »I’ve come across a lot of people who absolutely avoid carbs at all cost, why? Im pretty sure carbs will not turn into fat. —Carbohydrates turn into glucose, which your body burns immediately or converts to glycogen to be stored in the muscles and liver for between meals. If you eat more calories from carbs or other sources than your body can use, the cells store the excess as fat.
I understand the benefits of GOOD fats and whole fats via flax, avo, chia, and many more but this whole keto diet is insane.... Other than needed for medical conditions.... which that’s how the keto diet was created through dr trying to help patients with seizures...
I’ve also realized people with a high metabolism can better handle a keto diet.... so all you endomorphs beware....
I tried the keto diet for one month and I put on weight while also having excessive oil secretion from my pours so I smelled
I think you got it right. Keto was designed with certain conditions in mind. CICO ultimately works. Metabolism can play a factor, but it will still go back to that. It's not always easy. 290 lbs later, I've learned that.1 -
Regardless of the original purpose of a keto diet it quickly became clear that it is one of many ways to effectively reduce weight. It clearly will not be effective or desired by all people. I think people can become fixated on the weight loss to the point of thinking that is the only purpose. It can help people with insulin resistance and T2D. It can reduce inflammation and cholesterol levels. All that aside I find it a satisfying WOE and it is serving me well.3
-
The theory is that when you're in ketosis your body is in an optimal state for using body fat for energy. It doesn't avoid the requirement of a caloric deficit but it's supposed to make it easier to stay in that deficit because your body can get more calories from body fat instead of your plate.
I can't claim it works for everyone but it worked for me. I tried both low-carb, high-fat and low-fat, high-carb and I found that I had to eat more calories on low-fat than on low-carb to avoid going hungry. In fact, when I did strict keto this summer I had a few extreme days when I barely ate 800 calories and still had lots of energy without feeling hungry. I didn't force myself to do it, I just wasn't hungry so I didn't eat much. I'd never recommend deliberately going that low in calories on a regular basis but it does show how efficient your body can get at using your body fat when in ketosis.
CICO will always be the bottom line, going low carb is just supposed to help control the "CI" part of it.
4 -
To the exercise crowd if you do try keto and have an experienced anything like me you will not be happy with workouts for months. I am a runner and felt devoid of energy when running as if I had lead in my legs. After about two months my energy came back and runs feel good now, I think this is fat adaption. So if you think going keto for one month is going to let you decide from a workout standpoint if it is right you may want to reconsider.1
-
Just an FYI to future posters, the entire 1st page happened in January and the OP hasn't been here since February, so arguing with them is futile
coderdan82 wrote: »The theory is that when you're in ketosis your body is in an optimal state for using body fat for energy. It doesn't avoid the requirement of a caloric deficit but it's supposed to make it easier to stay in that deficit because your body can get more calories from body fat instead of your plate.
I can't claim it works for everyone but it worked for me. I tried both low-carb, high-fat and low-fat, high-carb and I found that I had to eat more calories on low-fat than on low-carb to avoid going hungry. In fact, when I did strict keto this summer I had a few extreme days when I barely ate 800 calories and still had lots of energy without feeling hungry. I didn't force myself to do it, I just wasn't hungry so I didn't eat much. I'd never recommend deliberately going that low in calories on a regular basis but it does show how efficient your body can get at using your body fat when in ketosis.
CICO will always be the bottom line, going low carb is just supposed to help control the "CI" part of it.
Yep, that's the key! Figuring out how to eat so hitting that calorie goal is easier. Glad you found your way
1 -
I always forget to check the date, Thanks0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions