How many carbs is too many? Not keto - just realistic
emalemalie
Posts: 1 Member
I’m trying to drop weight and maintain, and I was living a VERY high carb lifestyle prior to making some changes about a month ago. What is a reasonable carb goal daily? I shoot for 1400 calories (because I’m not very active) and I have no idea how many carbs I should strive for daily. HELP
5
Replies
-
MFP gives you 50%. Try that.
If you feel you need more adjust, but do make sure you are getting your nutritional needs met, and enough protein and fats.
Cheers, h.4 -
150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/25 -
150g is the upper limit i should say. Probs aim for 100g.33
-
I like to set my fat to the minimum recommended by the RDA, my protein to much higher (a gram per pound of body weight), and my carbs will fall where they may. I tend to like around 130g of carbs per day. It's different for everyone though. Do you like carbs? Do they keep you full?2
-
emalemalie wrote: »I’m trying to drop weight and maintain, and I was living a VERY high carb lifestyle prior to making some changes about a month ago. What is a reasonable carb goal daily? I shoot for 1400 calories (because I’m not very active) and I have no idea how many carbs I should strive for daily. HELP
If you're eating so many carbs that you can't reach your minimum protein and fat needs or are having a hard time getting certain nutrients in, then that's too many carbs.9 -
emalemalie wrote: »I’m trying to drop weight and maintain, and I was living a VERY high carb lifestyle prior to making some changes about a month ago. What is a reasonable carb goal daily? I shoot for 1400 calories (because I’m not very active) and I have no idea how many carbs I should strive for daily. HELP
However many carbs you want to eat, feel satiated, and stay at your calorie goal.
Macros are personal preference. Some people find that when they eat a lot of carbs they feel constantly hungry and end up over-eating in response. Others (like me) are satiated by carbs and find eating at around 50% carbs (which for me is @ 200g) we feel great at the right calorie level.
My personal strategy (which I learned here) is to look at the MFP default for protein and fat as minimums to exceed, and let carbs fall where they may. I also strive to hit my fiber goal as well.
To lose weight, the most important number to get right is calories. Good luck!6 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:19 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
lol does is say that? So funny. Insidious weight gain.6 -
This content has been removed.
-
diannethegeek wrote: »emalemalie wrote: »I’m trying to drop weight and maintain, and I was living a VERY high carb lifestyle prior to making some changes about a month ago. What is a reasonable carb goal daily? I shoot for 1400 calories (because I’m not very active) and I have no idea how many carbs I should strive for daily. HELP
If you're eating so many carbs that you can't reach your minimum protein and fat needs or are having a hard time getting certain nutrients in, then that's too many carbs.
This!5 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Yeah, whatever works for you, you know so that's fair. It's not my article, but it may (or may not) give the OP some useful information (that's up to her, not us). She asked about carb limits, i provided an article that states these and also gives rationale behind it's conclusions. I provided something, something she requested, and it is open to be refuted by anyone of course. But @bbell1985 snarky comments aren't helpful to anyone- no help to the OP and adds no value to the thread.19 -
I'm a vegetarian. Most of my protein has carbs in it. Typically I'm up around 250-300 grams/day. Still eating healthy and losing weight.13
-
Plan around your minimum protein. You can fit in as many carbs around that. Your calorie deficit is your upper limit.7
-
I eat around 200g on 1400 calories and thats just what works for me and where I feel my best4
-
davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Also, the article states immediately beneath the diagram:
"When I say generally that a chronic intake of over 150 grams of carbs can lead to insidious weight gain over a lifetime, I am factoring in the concept that many people are at the effect of a familial genetic predisposition to storing fat easily under the carb paradigm (the 60+% overweight). I am also factoring in the drop in metabolism that happens naturally with age, as well as the fact that PBers don’t NEED to purge and refill glycogen stores every day via exercise. Yes, there are some people (a small percentage of outliers) who might maintain pretty decent body composition at up to 300 grams a day on little exercise. I would bet that they also are selective about the carb sources and do a better job of controlling overall calories, so there’s little excess to store. For most of the population, that 150 mark remains a good average level for maintaining ideal body composition."
So, yeah, the author agrees it isn't a rule for EVERYONE but a general rule for the majority based on his experience. Again, i agree with you that you eating over 150g carbs might not cause you weight gain- whatever works for you.19 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Yeah, whatever works for you, you know so that's fair. It's not my article, but it may (or may not) give the OP some useful information (that's up to her, not us). She asked about carb limits, i provided an article that states these and also gives rationale behind it's conclusions. I provided something, something she requested, and it is open to be refuted by anyone of course. But @bbell1985 snarky comments aren't helpful to anyone- no help to the OP and adds no value to the thread.
lmao. I didn't make a snarky comment. I internet laughed out loud.
14 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Also, the article states immediately beneath the diagram:
"When I say generally that a chronic intake of over 150 grams of carbs can lead to insidious weight gain over a lifetime, I am factoring in the concept that many people are at the effect of a familial genetic predisposition to storing fat easily under the carb paradigm (the 60+% overweight). I am also factoring in the drop in metabolism that happens naturally with age, as well as the fact that PBers don’t NEED to purge and refill glycogen stores every day via exercise. Yes, there are some people (a small percentage of outliers) who might maintain pretty decent body composition at up to 300 grams a day on little exercise. I would bet that they also are selective about the carb sources and do a better job of controlling overall calories, so there’s little excess to store. For most of the population, that 150 mark remains a good average level for maintaining ideal body composition."
So, yeah, the author agrees it isn't a rule for EVERYONE but a general rule for the majority based on his experience. Again, i agree with you that you eating over 150g carbs might not cause you weight gain- whatever works for you.
Mark Sisson is a former athlete who makes a small fortune selling books and supplements. Not a credible source.
If a person is in a calorie deficit they will lose weight regardless of macro distribution. Despite all the keto popularity, I have yet to see anything near a scientific consensus otherwise.11 -
davidmillar14 wrote: »davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Yeah, whatever works for you, you know so that's fair. It's not my article, but it may (or may not) give the OP some useful information (that's up to her, not us). She asked about carb limits, i provided an article that states these and also gives rationale behind it's conclusions. I provided something, something she requested, and it is open to be refuted by anyone of course. But @bbell1985 snarky comments aren't helpful to anyone- no help to the OP and adds no value to the thread.
lmao. I didn't make a snarky comment. I internet laughed out loud.
You provided nothing useful.
That was a little snarky. Maybe.
You cannot be the judge of what is useful unless you are the OP. Your opinion isn't fact, I'm sorry. It was definitely a snarky comment, it came across very patronising and dismissive despite a lack of evidence to refute the article on your part. I get the article might be against your beliefs and you don't like it but again you cannot speak for the OP. If something isn't inline with your beliefs you don't be an *kitten* about it, or maybe YOU do lol, but I'm all for mixed opinions and exchanges of ideas. Ideologies are dangerous things.
18 -
I worked with a diabetic specialist. If you are looking for HEALTH not just weight loss she recommends 30g of carbs max per meal. Carbs are a major factor to increased A1C.18
-
davidmillar14 wrote: »davidmillar14 wrote: »davidmillar14 wrote: »150g According to this article, see the diagram near the bottom. Interesting article in it's own right.
https://www.marksdailyapple.com/a-metabolic-paradigm-shift-fat-carbs-human-body-metabolism/
That's a blog about eating Primal/Paleo.
As far as the diagram, I can say personally I have not experienced "insidious weight gain" eating over 150g of carbs daily. I lost my weight this way and now have been rather effortlessly maintaining for the last two years :drinker:
Yeah, whatever works for you, you know so that's fair. It's not my article, but it may (or may not) give the OP some useful information (that's up to her, not us). She asked about carb limits, i provided an article that states these and also gives rationale behind it's conclusions. I provided something, something she requested, and it is open to be refuted by anyone of course. But @bbell1985 snarky comments aren't helpful to anyone- no help to the OP and adds no value to the thread.
lmao. I didn't make a snarky comment. I internet laughed out loud.
You provided nothing useful.
That was a little snarky. Maybe.
You cannot be the judge of what is useful unless you are the OP. Your opinion isn't fact, I'm sorry. It was definitely a snarky comment, it came across very patronising and dismissive despite a lack of evidence to refute the article on your part. I get the article might be against your beliefs and you don't like it but again you cannot speak for the OP. If something isn't inline with your beliefs you don't be an *kitten* about it, or maybe YOU do lol, but I'm all for mixed opinions and exchanges of ideas. Ideologies are dangerous things.
Oh relax jack7 -
well I have eaten more than 200g of carbs during most of my weight loss phase and lost weight even with a metabolic disorder and a genetic defect where my body cannot process fats and cholesterol properly,all because I was in a deficit. I didnt store fat and if I eat less than 150g of carbs a day I tend to be under my calories and not wanting to eat at all. on the days I ate 150 or less I came in under 1200 calories which if I did all the time would not be healthy for me. not to mention those days my protein levels were really low.
There were days I ate over 300g and still lost weight,for me sure it was slower but I still lost.now if you have a health issue and carbs exacerbate it or causes your blood sugar to be out of control then sure lower them. but for those with my health condition we cant do high amounts of fats so either protein or carbs have to be higher.3 -
As others said, it depends on your situation. Some can handle and thrive on 250+g of carbs a day - usually the young and active. Others may need to eat lower carb - often older and those with metabolic issues like insulin resistance.
For me, over 30g of carbs is too much because it drives up my BG and appetite. For my husband, over 300g is too much because it means he ate too many mashed potatoes.1 -
As others said, it depends on your situation. Some can handle and thrive on 250+g of carbs a day - usually the young and active. Others may need to eat lower carb - often older and those with metabolic issues like insulin resistance.
For me, over 30g of carbs is too much because it drives up my BG and appetite. For my husband, over 300g is too much because it means he ate too many mashed potatoes.
yeah of course it depends on the situation. I have a metabolic issue(I dont have insulin resistance or diabetes) and Im not young or highly active;I just feel better eating more carbs most days. what seems to drive my appetite I noticed lately is protein. the more I eat the more I want,maybe Im lacking something there?1 -
crystalfporter wrote: »I worked with a diabetic specialist. If you are looking for HEALTH not just weight loss she recommends 30g of carbs max per meal. Carbs are a major factor to increased A1C.
I don't recall OP saying she was diabetic.
Keto is not the universal answer to every diet question.15 -
If a person is in a calorie deficit they will lose weight regardless of macro distribution. Despite all the keto popularity, I have yet to see anything near a scientific consensus otherwise.
There is an overwhelming amount of evidence regarding the effectiveness and health benefits of keto diet as opposed to the typical high-carb American diet. If you "have yet to see" you are sticking with your preconceived ideas and not even making a feeble attempt at doing any research. Mark is not wrong, and there is plenty of hard scientific evidence to back him up, if you can be bothered to look and to read.
Is Time magazine a reliable enough source for you? "ending the war on fat" "Nearly four decades later, the results are in: the experiment was a failure. We cut the fat, but by almost every measure, Americans are sicker than ever."
“The myopic focus on fat has warped our diet and contributed to the biggest health crises facing the country.”
http://time.com/magazine/us/2863200/june-23rd-2014-vol-183-no-24-u-s/
How about WebMD? "Low-Carb Beats Low-Fat for Weight Loss: Study" https://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20140901/low-carb-beats-low-fat-for-weight-loss-heart-health-study#1
So, yes you can lose weight by cutting enough calories and being hungry all the time. However, you asked for a carb goal, and just don't like the answer. I would suggest aiming for less than 100g carbs per day, and focusing on veggies as your primary source of carbs.23 -
catherineg3 wrote: »If a person is in a calorie deficit they will lose weight regardless of macro distribution. Despite all the keto popularity, I have yet to see anything near a scientific consensus otherwise.
There is an overwhelming amount of evidence regarding the effectiveness and health benefits of keto diet as opposed to the typical high-carb American diet. If you "have yet to see" you are sticking with your preconceived ideas and not even making a feeble attempt at doing any research. Mark is not wrong, and there is plenty of hard scientific evidence to back him up, if you can be bothered to look and to read.
Is Time magazine a reliable enough source for you? "ending the war on fat" "Nearly four decades later, the results are in: the experiment was a failure. We cut the fat, but by almost every measure, Americans are sicker than ever."
“The myopic focus on fat has warped our diet and contributed to the biggest health crises facing the country.”
http://time.com/magazine/us/2863200/june-23rd-2014-vol-183-no-24-u-s/
How about WebMD? "Low-Carb Beats Low-Fat for Weight Loss: Study" https://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20140901/low-carb-beats-low-fat-for-weight-loss-heart-health-study#1
So, yes you can lose weight by cutting enough calories and being hungry all the time. However, you asked for a carb goal, and just don't like the answer. I would suggest aiming for less than 100g carbs per day, and focusing on veggies as your primary source of carbs.
Okay, how about a look at some actual peer-reviewed research instead of magazine articles and blog entries? Actually, there's an overwhelming *lack* of evidence regarding the effectiveness and health benefits of the keto diet as opposed to higher carb/protein diets. If you have "yet to see", you are sticking with your preconceived ideas and not even making a feeble attempt at doing any actual research. There is plenty of hard scientific evidence to back this up:
https://bodyrecomposition.com/research-review/ketogenic-low-carbohydrate-diets-have-no-metabolic-advantage-over-nonketogenic-low-carbohydrate-diets-research-review.html/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26278052
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9094871
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18195164
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20141567
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22258266
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27385608
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20679559
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22243943
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22935440
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25007189
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/16685046/
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa0804748
https://www.aworkoutroutine.com/low-carb-diet/16 -
catherineg3 wrote: »If a person is in a calorie deficit they will lose weight regardless of macro distribution. Despite all the keto popularity, I have yet to see anything near a scientific consensus otherwise.
There is an overwhelming amount of evidence regarding the effectiveness and health benefits of keto diet as opposed to the typical high-carb American diet. If you "have yet to see" you are sticking with your preconceived ideas and not even making a feeble attempt at doing any research. Mark is not wrong, and there is plenty of hard scientific evidence to back him up, if you can be bothered to look and to read.
Is Time magazine a reliable enough source for you? "ending the war on fat" "Nearly four decades later, the results are in: the experiment was a failure. We cut the fat, but by almost every measure, Americans are sicker than ever."
“The myopic focus on fat has warped our diet and contributed to the biggest health crises facing the country.”
http://time.com/magazine/us/2863200/june-23rd-2014-vol-183-no-24-u-s/
How about WebMD? "Low-Carb Beats Low-Fat for Weight Loss: Study" https://www.webmd.com/diet/news/20140901/low-carb-beats-low-fat-for-weight-loss-heart-health-study#1
So, yes you can lose weight by cutting enough calories and being hungry all the time. However, you asked for a carb goal, and just don't like the answer. I would suggest aiming for less than 100g carbs per day, and focusing on veggies as your primary source of carbs.
No, Time and WebMD are not credible scientific sources.
Why do keto proponents always assume that the only option other than LCHF is a low fat, ultra-processed SAD diet? There is so much in between! I eat moderate, balanced macros. All the studies that get thrown around to bolster keto compare it to the SAD. I don't eat the SAD diet.
The Blue Zones, areas with an unusually high % of healthy, active centenarians, all eat diets based on veggies, fruits, whole grains, beans, and nuts. I'm not saying keto isn't healthy, BTW, but it surely isn't necessary for health.
You can be healthy eating keto. You can be healthy eating vegetarian. You can be healthy eating lots of other ways in between.19 -
I don't digest fats well and might get reflux from too much protein. Also, both don't keep me as full and full of energy as bread, rice, pasta, potatoes and the likes. I usually eat around 55-60% carbs. Works for me.2
-
This content has been removed.
-
davidmillar14 wrote: »150g is the upper limit i should say. Probs aim for 100g.
No, it's not an upper limit unless you are going for a low carb diet like Mark promotes. There is no science behind this "limit", it's just opinion. The only limit is based on your caloric budget when taking into account your fat and protein requirements. After you have met the minimal requirements in those you can distribute the rest of your calories between fats, proteins and carbs as you see fit.10
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions