BREAKFAST - what is the truth?

So over the years I have heard everyone chime in on whether you need to eat breakfast or it's better to skip it.

Intermittent fasters will say to skip it - that it helps get your body to start burning your fat rather than your breakfast.

Other people say it's the most important meal of the day - that it kickstarts your metabolism to start burning fat and takes your body out of starvation mode (storing fat just in case).

What is the truth?
I am not hungry in the mornings but want to be doing what is right.
«1

Replies

  • nanastaci2020
    nanastaci2020 Posts: 1,072 Member
    Do what works for you.
  • Rannoch3908
    Rannoch3908 Posts: 177 Member
    edited September 2020
    There has to be some science to when and how fat stores burn fastest.

    I doubt the science behind Intermittent Fasting and why you fast is total BS right? I've read it helps you burn fat instead of the food your eating.

    And I don't really know which works for me - both of them I guess.

  • AlannaWulf
    AlannaWulf Posts: 25 Member
    I overeat if I skip breakfast or have foods that don't keep me full. Due to this almost every morning I have two eggs and oatmeal. Keeps me full until lunch!
  • Diatonic12
    Diatonic12 Posts: 32,344 Member
    The truth. Our mileage will always vary.

    Somesayers say that if you don't eat breakfast it's indicative of a hormone imbalance. Others say there's no such thing as a need to eat within an hour of waking. If you've ever been to Greece, Italy or France, they don't eat a big breakfast. Just a few tiddlywinks here and there. Espresso and one piece of bread with butter.

    If you've ever been to Ireland, Scotland or England, Wales...they eat a larger breakfast. Climate, longer winters, hard outdoor work all has something to do with it. If you're working in a coal mine loading 16 tons you'll eat more than someone who has a desk job.
  • Mellouk89
    Mellouk89 Posts: 469 Member
    Other than body composition, I heard that eating breakfast is good for blood sugar control, or something along those lines. I just know that I feel better when I have a good breakfast, i'm in a better mood, i'm more productive.
  • AshHeartsJesus
    AshHeartsJesus Posts: 460 Member
    You do you

    For me breakfast is so important and keeps me from over eating. I eat breakcfst every day now. Some are bigger then others. Lunch is always light for me though because I like to eat at night.

    CICO matters to me st the end of the day. I do keep in mind water or waste could factor in if I wrigh the next morning and have eaten dertain things
  • sarahbetherck
    sarahbetherck Posts: 270 Member
    For me, intermittent fasting (16:8 so it's basically just skipping breakfast) makes it easier for me to stay within my calorie limit. No idea about any of the science behind IF, but I've adapted to it and I'm not hungry until noon so it works for me.
  • CrazyMermaid1
    CrazyMermaid1 Posts: 356 Member
    After reading that a high protein breakfast helps some people stay full longer I tried it and stay full until dinner
  • frankiesgirlie
    frankiesgirlie Posts: 669 Member
    I’ve read all the theories and studies about fasting, but only after I had been doing it for many, many years. It didn’t have an official name for it back in the 70s, when as a teenager I didn’t like eating breakfast or lunch because I couldn’t stay awake in class. I ate dinner and that was it, sometimes a pre-bed snack.
    It doesn’t necessarily keep my weight down, on its own. It just makes it easier to get a deficit when I have limited time devoted to eating.
    It just makes me feel better and healthier. And younger.
  • Dogmom1978
    Dogmom1978 Posts: 1,580 Member
    lgfrie wrote: »
    There is no truth. There's very little truth in dieting besides "try to eat healthy foods most of the time, and if you wanna lose weight, eat less of them". Best not to even seek the hidden truth; there's only what works, and that's person-specific.

    When it comes to breakfast, some people find eating it is beneficial for dieting, some don't. I've been doing IF for 15 months, so breakfast has not been part of the plan. I find it helpful to free up those calories to put into two larger meals (lunch and dinner). For other people, that doesn't work. I went on diet hiatus last week and find I still don't actually want breakfast even though I am now eating at maintenance and free to have it. Just not used to eating breakfast anymore and it does nothing for me.

    I agree with the above posters about two things: one, you do adjust to not eating breakfast when you do IF and then you're just not hungry until lunch. Some kind of adaptation takes place, which is probably entirely psychological, but when you don't just "skip" breakfast now and then but have a time before which you never or very rarely eat, you do sort of get past the hunger pangs and fixation on food in the morning.

    Two, while I love carbs and make no effort not to eat them, I'd have to admit that lower carb meals as the first meal tend to leave me less hungry later on. By which I mean higher protein, since I'm not going to eat a pailful of lard. Higher protein first-meals do seem to stave off the hunger longer. Why, I don't really know. If I know I have a high calorie dinner coming up such that there needs to be NO snacking between lunch and dinner, I will eat a high protein (aka lower carb) lunch so that I won't be hungry during the day.

    The healthy foods isn’t even the truth. Eat what you like so you can stick to your diet. If that’s TV dinners, simply choose ones that let you remain within your calorie goals.

    A calorie deficit is all that matters for losing weight, not healthy foods.
  • Dogmom1978
    Dogmom1978 Posts: 1,580 Member
    You can lose 100 lbs eating cupcakes. All you have to do is eat fewer calories than you need...

    CICO is king for weight loss. You might feel like crap if you live off of cupcakes, but you will still lose weight
  • TonyB0588
    TonyB0588 Posts: 9,520 Member
    cwolfman13 wrote: »
    So over the years I have heard everyone chime in on whether you need to eat breakfast or it's better to skip it.

    Intermittent fasters will say to skip it - that it helps get your body to start burning your fat rather than your breakfast.

    Other people say it's the most important meal of the day - that it kickstarts your metabolism to start burning fat and takes your body out of starvation mode (storing fat just in case).

    What is the truth?
    I am not hungry in the mornings but want to be doing what is right.

    Neither is the truth.

    "most important meal of the day" stems from a marketing campaign by Kelloggs way back when to get people to buy cereal.

    There is also no magical fat burning happening with IF other than that produced by a calorie deficit. I'm not typically hungry most mornings so I don't usually eat until noon or 1...I'm in maintenance and I'm maintaining because I'm overall eating maintenance calories...so me doing IF has had no bearing on that.

    Not sure if the Kellogg's campaign worked. I almost always eat cereal for breakfast, but it's almost never Kellogg's.
  • glassyo
    glassyo Posts: 7,732 Member
    TonyB0588 wrote: »
    cwolfman13 wrote: »
    So over the years I have heard everyone chime in on whether you need to eat breakfast or it's better to skip it.

    Intermittent fasters will say to skip it - that it helps get your body to start burning your fat rather than your breakfast.

    Other people say it's the most important meal of the day - that it kickstarts your metabolism to start burning fat and takes your body out of starvation mode (storing fat just in case).

    What is the truth?
    I am not hungry in the mornings but want to be doing what is right.

    Neither is the truth.

    "most important meal of the day" stems from a marketing campaign by Kelloggs way back when to get people to buy cereal.

    There is also no magical fat burning happening with IF other than that produced by a calorie deficit. I'm not typically hungry most mornings so I don't usually eat until noon or 1...I'm in maintenance and I'm maintaining because I'm overall eating maintenance calories...so me doing IF has had no bearing on that.

    Not sure if the Kellogg's campaign worked. I almost always eat cereal for breakfast, but it's almost never Kellogg's.

    And I eat cereal (sometimes Kellogg's) but never for breakfast. :)