Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to.
sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to. Known to have meth in them? I'd have to see evidence of that. Seems like a rather extreme claim. Yes, supplements are not regulated like medications, but that by no means says they can be laced with illegal drugs. Sure, make sure you don't purchase from sketchy sources, just like anything.
Xellercin wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to. Known to have meth in them? I'd have to see evidence of that. Seems like a rather extreme claim. Yes, supplements are not regulated like medications, but that by no means says they can be laced with illegal drugs. Sure, make sure you don't purchase from sketchy sources, just like anything. It's not hard to find this information. It's a well known fact that supplements are often found to have severe contamination. How do you define a "sketchy" source? How do you define a "safe" source? Most supplement companies have very questionable supply chains, and because they are unregulated, they can have their products made from literally anywhere. Supplements are rarely tested, so it's horrifying that when they are, it's not unusual for the testers to find black market drugs in them, like synthesizes hormones in "herbal" supplements for men and women, Chinese basement lab versions of Viagra, Propecia, various amphetamines. Not to mention the myriad unintentional contaminants. But why listen to me? I'm only someone who has been hired by small health supplement companies to help them navigate what they can legally have on their labels in terms of safety claims. What do I know? ETA: a quick Google tells me that not one, but two supplements that claimed to be "all natural" were tested and found to contain meth/meth-like drugs in them. And not just meth, but an unknown synthetic meth that they don't even know how it affects organs.
sollyn23l2 wrote: » No offense, but I really doubt you are. And even if you are, that doesn't mean you know anything about the ingredients put into them. That's called an appeal to authority fallacy, and in no ways proves your point. Also, you made the claim, it's on you to provide the evidence, not the other way around. But I do agree with the basic concept that supplements are not always safe.
sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to. Known to have meth in them? I'd have to see evidence of that. Seems like a rather extreme claim. Yes, supplements are not regulated like medications, but that by no means says they can be laced with illegal drugs. Sure, make sure you don't purchase from sketchy sources, just like anything. It's not hard to find this information. It's a well known fact that supplements are often found to have severe contamination. How do you define a "sketchy" source? How do you define a "safe" source? Most supplement companies have very questionable supply chains, and because they are unregulated, they can have their products made from literally anywhere. Supplements are rarely tested, so it's horrifying that when they are, it's not unusual for the testers to find black market drugs in them, like synthesizes hormones in "herbal" supplements for men and women, Chinese basement lab versions of Viagra, Propecia, various amphetamines. Not to mention the myriad unintentional contaminants. But why listen to me? I'm only someone who has been hired by small health supplement companies to help them navigate what they can legally have on their labels in terms of safety claims. What do I know? ETA: a quick Google tells me that not one, but two supplements that claimed to be "all natural" were tested and found to contain meth/meth-like drugs in them. And not just meth, but an unknown synthetic meth that they don't even know how it affects organs. No offense, but I really doubt you are. And even if you are, that doesn't mean you know anything about the ingredients put into them. That's called an appeal to authority fallacy, and in no ways proves your point. Also, you made the claim, it's on you to provide the evidence, not the other way around. But I do agree with the basic concept that supplements are not always safe.
AnnPT77 wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to. Known to have meth in them? I'd have to see evidence of that. Seems like a rather extreme claim. Yes, supplements are not regulated like medications, but that by no means says they can be laced with illegal drugs. Sure, make sure you don't purchase from sketchy sources, just like anything. It's not hard to find this information. It's a well known fact that supplements are often found to have severe contamination. How do you define a "sketchy" source? How do you define a "safe" source? Most supplement companies have very questionable supply chains, and because they are unregulated, they can have their products made from literally anywhere. Supplements are rarely tested, so it's horrifying that when they are, it's not unusual for the testers to find black market drugs in them, like synthesizes hormones in "herbal" supplements for men and women, Chinese basement lab versions of Viagra, Propecia, various amphetamines. Not to mention the myriad unintentional contaminants. But why listen to me? I'm only someone who has been hired by small health supplement companies to help them navigate what they can legally have on their labels in terms of safety claims. What do I know? ETA: a quick Google tells me that not one, but two supplements that claimed to be "all natural" were tested and found to contain meth/meth-like drugs in them. And not just meth, but an unknown synthetic meth that they don't even know how it affects organs. No offense, but I really doubt you are. And even if you are, that doesn't mean you know anything about the ingredients put into them. That's called an appeal to authority fallacy, and in no ways proves your point. Also, you made the claim, it's on you to provide the evidence, not the other way around. But I do agree with the basic concept that supplements are not always safe. Are you in the US? It's common knowledge that supplements are very lightly regulated, if at all, and that finding terrible things in them is a recurring event. Sometimes, they're contaminants, not intended to be present, but there through inadequate care in sourcing/manufacturing. Sometimes, they're put there quite deliberately, because dangerous substances can be "effective" in some other sense. Sure, many/most supplements are made by reputable firms, with good manufacturing practices, because some people have ethics. With profit in the picture, sadly some lack such ethics. When it comes to the meth issue, here's one example:https://analyticalsciencejournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/dta.1578 Here's a popular press article about that incident a few years back, with some context about the supplement's producer and the overall supplement market.https://www.bostonmagazine.com/health/2013/10/15/methamphetamine-found-in-supplements/ Xellercin posts regularly around here, doesn't normally flag-wave about her credentials, but reading a number of her posts suggests to me that she has relevant expertise on topics like this. I can't prove it, of course; but I usually tend to assume people aren't lying when there's literally no evidence that they are. Most people here have jobs/professions; it's inevitable that some rare few will be medical professionals, scientists, exercise-science academics, dietitians, etc.
sollyn23l2 wrote: » AnnPT77 wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » sollyn23l2 wrote: » Xellercin wrote: » Even prescription drugs developed by pharmaceutical companies that dump billions into making them don't work. What makes you think a supplement made by a company that has no regulations will magically work better? Also, look into contamination of supplements. You can't even trust that what they say is in them is even what's in them. Workout supplements have been known to have meth in them. So yeah. I'm sure they work! You just don't necessarily want them to. Known to have meth in them? I'd have to see evidence of that. Seems like a rather extreme claim. Yes, supplements are not regulated like medications, but that by no means says they can be laced with illegal drugs. Sure, make sure you don't purchase from sketchy sources, just like anything. It's not hard to find this information. It's a well known fact that supplements are often found to have severe contamination. How do you define a "sketchy" source? How do you define a "safe" source? Most supplement companies have very questionable supply chains, and because they are unregulated, they can have their products made from literally anywhere. Supplements are rarely tested, so it's horrifying that when they are, it's not unusual for the testers to find black market drugs in them, like synthesizes hormones in "herbal" supplements for men and women, Chinese basement lab versions of Viagra, Propecia, various amphetamines. Not to mention the myriad unintentional contaminants. But why listen to me? I'm only someone who has been hired by small health supplement companies to help them navigate what they can legally have on their labels in terms of safety claims. What do I know? ETA: a quick Google tells me that not one, but two supplements that claimed to be "all natural" were tested and found to contain meth/meth-like drugs in them. And not just meth, but an unknown synthetic meth that they don't even know how it affects organs. No offense, but I really doubt you are. And even if you are, that doesn't mean you know anything about the ingredients put into them. That's called an appeal to authority fallacy, and in no ways proves your point. Also, you made the claim, it's on you to provide the evidence, not the other way around. But I do agree with the basic concept that supplements are not always safe. Are you in the US? It's common knowledge that supplements are very lightly regulated, if at all, and that finding terrible things in them is a recurring event. Sometimes, they're contaminants, not intended to be present, but there through inadequate care in sourcing/manufacturing. Sometimes, they're put there quite deliberately, because dangerous substances can be "effective" in some other sense. Sure, many/most supplements are made by reputable firms, with good manufacturing practices, because some people have ethics. With profit in the picture, sadly some lack such ethics. When it comes to the meth issue, here's one example:https://analyticalsciencejournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/dta.1578 Here's a popular press article about that incident a few years back, with some context about the supplement's producer and the overall supplement market.https://www.bostonmagazine.com/health/2013/10/15/methamphetamine-found-in-supplements/ Xellercin posts regularly around here, doesn't normally flag-wave about her credentials, but reading a number of her posts suggests to me that she has relevant expertise on topics like this. I can't prove it, of course; but I usually tend to assume people aren't lying when there's literally no evidence that they are. Most people here have jobs/professions; it's inevitable that some rare few will be medical professionals, scientists, exercise-science academics, dietitians, etc. According to the article, it was not meth. This is why I question things. I absolutely agree with the basic idea that supplements are not as heavily regulated as prescription medications. This goes for vitamins and all supplements.
Sinisterbarbie1 wrote: » These sorts of questions with screen shots of advertisements from people who never before posted and don’t post again, followed up by someone who personally attacks members who disagree with the value of the supplement and caution against its use strike me as an orchestrated campaign by a very lame PR company. I hope they see that instead of generating interest and positive buzz the results are instead lengthy posts explaining the questionable value and very high potential risk of unregulated, internet marketed supplements that promise weight loss benefits. Or maybe all attention is good attention, like with a toddler. Of course if someone is looking for alternate sources of street drugs, MFP might be the new go to source for information