Eat before a workout?
Replies
-
It depends on the person. I personally train fasted and do great. I have worked out a few times after eating and it's just not the same. I've read the body is busy sending blood to your stomach to digest food that the rest of your body decreases some in performance.0
-
If you don't want to you don't have to m8.0
-
if you want to burn storage fat, you have to do your workout with empty stomach. so the body will burn the storage fat not the meal you have eating. another secret if you want your body to burn storage fat while sleeping, you have to eat 3 hours before sleeping , so your stomach will empty and your body will not burn the meal but the storage fat. try keeping on these rules and you will see fantastic results as me. good luck.0
-
i have eaten before worked out-and when i do core i almost feel sick-so for me-i eat 1 hour before i am going to workout and i will eat some protein after-i prefer an empty stomach been doing that for 5 years and that's what works for me-i think everyone is different-so prefer not to eat before i work out-i feel it slows me down-0
-
Quoting this again for anyone who missed it - absolutely wonderful article from two of the smartest fitness people you will ever come across.0 -
I cannot eat before a workout without wanting to throw up. But I will eat after for sure.0
-
I usually eat a little something before and about 1 hour after. I just finished a Chobani plain greek yogurt, raisins and 1/2 handful Special K cereal on top to give it that crunch that I have to have.0
-
does not matter..
I personally do not eat before I workout bc I do not like to work out on full stomach ...0 -
There's no right or wrong answer (despite what some of the posts would have you believe). Personally I can't eat before as it makes me feel bleugh when working out but I always eat within 60mins of finishing. You can see my weight loss and I've gone from not able to walk a flight of stairs to running around 15 miles a week so wouldn't describe my workouts as 'a bust' despite not eating before hand. I've got fitter and lost weight (calorie deficit helped by exercise but the xercise is for fitness, extra food is a bonus) not eating before any of my workouts. But that's what works for me. The same may or may not work for you.0
-
if you want to burn storage fat, you have to do your workout with empty stomach. so the body will burn the storage fat not the meal you have eating. another secret if you want your body to burn storage fat while sleeping, you have to eat 3 hours before sleeping , so your stomach will empty and your body will not burn the meal but the storage fat. try keeping on these rules and you will see fantastic results as me. good luck.
yea, this whole post is a big no ..
I do exactly the opposite and have no problem losing weight, burning fat etc…
op ignore this.0 -
You totally posted this at just the right time because I just got done with a nutrition class on pre and post workout fuel.
The gist of the whole thing is that if you aren't fueling (and with the proper things) before and after workouts (ANNNND in a correct tie frame) then your workout is considered a bust.
Oh no! All my workouts for the past 6 months have been a bust!0 -
You totally posted this at just the right time because I just got done with a nutrition class on pre and post workout fuel.
The gist of the whole thing is that if you aren't fueling (and with the proper things) before and after workouts (ANNNND in a correct tie frame) then your workout is considered a bust.
Oh no! All my workouts for the past 6 months have been a bust!
sounds like we are both screwed...0 -
It's going to be up to you. Try both. You'll know. I cannot lift a feather without eating something an hour or an hour and a half before working out. I have guys on my list that do it in a fasted state and look amazing. Bottom line, it's your call.0
-
You totally posted this at just the right time because I just got done with a nutrition class on pre and post workout fuel.
The gist of the whole thing is that if you aren't fueling (and with the proper things) before and after workouts (ANNNND in a correct tie frame) then your workout is considered a bust.
pre and post workout nutrition is apparently EXTREMELY important and I myself witnessed the help the proper foods/timing provides to my own workouts tonight.
Since you are working out in the early morning like I usually do, you will want to eat something lower in fiber and quickly processed about 30 minutes before your workout. I.e. 1/2 a banana or 1/2 scoop protein in water.
post workout your window to replenish your glycogen is about 30-45 minutes and some top choices here would be 2 rice cakes, 4 oz sweet potato or 1/2 an apple.
Of course these are not your meals, but simply fuel. Today was my first day following this 100% and OMG did it make a HUGE difference in my workout. Hope it works well for you too
what school do you go to? University of Broscience? geez….lolz0 -
eat when you're hungry, whenever that is0
-
You have to eat something before working out. It's the most important meal of the day: Post and pre-workout,.0
-
Is does not matter if you eat before a workout or not. As long as your daily caloric intake and macro intake is correct, it is mostly up to you what you prefer. Personally i like to have a coffee and 2 slices of bread with some chocolate spread before lifting. On the other hand a gym buddy/friend of mine always prefer to go the gym fasted. He likes to eat a bigger post workout meal and does not like breakfast anyways. We are both making progress on our lifts in the gym.0
-
reliable references on this information???
LOL I'd ask the same of you and the false information you put out.0 -
You have to eat something before working out. It's the most important meal of the day: Post and pre-workout,.
the broscience in this thread is amazing...0 -
Quoting this again for anyone who missed it - absolutely wonderful article from two of the smartest fitness people you will ever come across.
And the POINT of this peer-reviewed journal article (which reviews many other peer-reviewed studies) is essentially: No conclusive evidence. Do what works best for YOU.
At most, there *may* be a *small* advantage to post-workout refueling for those trying to gain muscle mass. Small, and again, a theoretical advantage.0 -
I'm hypo-glycemic, so I have to be mindful of that, but I haven't carb cycled or scared myself about protein before or after a workout. So far, so good.
I eat when I'm hungry, drink when I'm thirsty, workout when it fits my schedule, and have recomped fairly well.
That isn't to say that if I get a hankering for a protein bar mid-workout that I won't stop what I'm doing and eat it.
There's science out there. There's bro-science out there. I'm a fan of science, but the "just get to the gym and work out and eat when I'm hungry" approach seems to just.....work.0 -
There's science out there. There's bro-science out there. I'm a fan of science, but the "just get to the gym and work out and eat when I'm hungry" approach seems to just.....work.
And the science backs you on that!
(ETA: although eating when hungry doesn't work for everyone - it's YMMV)0 -
Can a car run without gas? No it cannot, so why do you expect this fromI normally wake up and then do my work out then grab something to eat after a shower, is that right or should I be eating before my work out?
your poor body ?0 -
I prefer doing my LISS first thing in the morning on an empty stomach. anything else (weights, HIIT and sports training/matches) i always make sure i've eaten properly beforehand else i find that i don't have enough energy and struggle to complete my workout.
This is just what works for me though. Don't know about anyone else0 -
If you feel weak, tired or like you could do your workout better, think about grabbing a snack beforehand. Otherwise, carry on with what works for you; the timing of your meals won't affect your weight loss.0
-
Unless you've just run a marathon, your body has plenty of readily available energy stores.
Can a car run without gas? No it cannot, so why do you expect this fromI normally wake up and then do my work out then grab something to eat after a shower, is that right or should I be eating before my work out?
your poor body ?0 -
I normally wake up and then do my work out then grab something to eat after a shower, is that right or should I be eating before my work out?
I guess it's all personal preference. I never could hit the weights first thing in the AM. I always felt I needed some calories in me in the AM. I'm sure I may be stronger if I trained later in the day. BUT, all I do now is take my pre-workout drink and I'm fine. Plus they say training on an empty stomach really jack's up the fatt burning metabolism. As soon as I'm done though, I have a protein drink consisting of at least 40 grams of fast absorbing whey protein. then an hour or so later, I'll have some egg whites and Quinoa.0 -
Unnecessary.You should eat within 30-60 minutes before and after. Combing a protein source with a carbohydrate source.
Nope. Eating is personal preference.You totally posted this at just the right time because I just got done with a nutrition class on pre and post workout fuel.
The gist of the whole thing is that if you aren't fueling (and with the proper things) before and after workouts (ANNNND in a correct tie frame) then your workout is considered a bust.
pre and post workout nutrition is apparently EXTREMELY important and I myself witnessed the help the proper foods/timing provides to my own workouts tonight.
Since you are working out in the early morning like I usually do, you will want to eat something lower in fiber and quickly processed about 30 minutes before your workout. I.e. 1/2 a banana or 1/2 scoop protein in water.
post workout your window to replenish your glycogen is about 30-45 minutes and some top choices here would be 2 rice cakes, 4 oz sweet potato or 1/2 an apple.
Of course these are not your meals, but simply fuel. Today was my first day following this 100% and OMG did it make a HUGE difference in my workout. Hope it works well for you too
http://www.jissn.com/content/10/1/50 -
Whatever works for you, I can't eat before an early morning workout but that is just me. If it is in the evening it doesn't bother me so I always eat prior.0
-
im a wimp and struggle if im hungry... i feel tired and drained...so i try to eat something before i workout. but i know its different for everyone. some people love working on an empty stomach. my empty stomach makes me feel sad inside! saying that since dieting hungry is the norm for me! so i guess maybe that might change now... i'l try a workout without eating and let you know! haha0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions