OPINION ON ATKINS
Replies
-
If you have no medical reason to cut carbs, I wouldn't recommend Atkins.
My personal opinion is diets like Atkins are fads. You lose weight on them, but once you transition into normal eating habits, you can gain weight back. It's a cycle. The same with products like Advocare, Herbalife, ect.
Calorie deficit and exercise is the motto I go by, and it's worked for me and many others on the websites. Losing weight should be a lifestyle change, and to learn habits to lose weight, and keep it off when you transition to maintenance. Unless you plan on eating Atkins forever, I'd recommend learning moderation, and how to eat the foods you want while reaching your goals.
That's true of ANY DIET. If you go back to eating too many calories for your height you'll gain weight end of story. there are benefits to atkins. it curbs your carb cravings and hunger levels. You have to count your calories still and when you get off the diet you STILL have to maintain your calories.
I'm aware.
She asked about Atkins. I answered in regards to Atkins.
not really, because it's not an atkins thing. you don't gain weight when going off atkins unless you eat too much after going off atkins. it isn't a correlation
I never said you "would" gain weight going off Atkins. I said you "can" gain weight back transitioning into normal eating habits.
I also stated that it's the same with other products.0 -
Back in 2004 my health teacher said she and her husband went on Atkins, lost a lot of weight and then gained it all back after a good Thanksgiving meal. Normally one might gain a pound or two on a splurge like that so uh yeah.0
-
0 -
I love Atkins, and would reccomend it if you have a lot of weight to lose, but I would say read the book cover to cover and go through all the phases.
The goal is to reintroduce carbs slowly back into your diet, not to give up carbs for the rest of your life.
I lost my first 70 lbs through Atkins and walking my dog
It is a tool I know how to use if I start putting on lbs again.
Move through the program, it fails most people because the first stage is very restrictive, but people stay on the first stage longer than they are supposed to because you do drop weight pretty quickly.
Then they get bored, start eating again and then the diet is a "failure", when really the indiviual fails the diet.
So again, I love the diet, lost a lot of weight on it, read the book cover to cover, do all the phases, dont skip, give yourself a year to do the whole program.
lost 70 lbs on Atkins, the last 26 i lost calorie counting
you mean there's more to it than the induction diet? NO WAI0 -
I did it. Lost 75 lbs doing it. However, it proved to be an unstainable diet that I couldn't hold to for life and didn't provide me with the knowledge I needed to maintain my weight, regardless of the food I was eating.
I would recommend a more moderate approach that comes free on the internet.0 -
Atkins - soooo 10 years ago.0
-
My sister has done Atkins...multiple times. She refuses to listen that there are other ways to lose weight. The most recent time, this past month, she ended up going to the ER with intense stomach pains. I wasn't there so obviously I don't know the doctor's exact words, but she told me that the doctor said to stop doing Atkins, as it will continue to give her digestive issues. Luckily she wasn't in danger of any serious harm at that moment, but it is something to keep in mind.0
-
I did the new Atkins and followed it as the book tells you to. I had success on it and didnt feel like crap, I still watch my carb intake, lower carbs and higher protien works for me, but everyone is different. Find what works for you in a healthy way!0
-
I used the '02 version for a six month stint, and then a two month follow up (couldn't do it during the holidays.) I lost 60 lbs before I reached my goal and gave ketosis up.
When it came down to it, Atkins provided a natural appetite suppression and its rules helped me not to sneak junk food, ever. So, the "miracle" turned out to be that I was eating fewer calories than I was burning.
I don't use Atkins any more, but I'm glad to have tried. And boy did that pizza look surprised when I gave up keto!0 -
He died of an heart attack when he was quite young. - not a good advert0
-
Atkins was never intended to be used long term. It was designed for heart patients to drop weight quickly for surgery. You can get the same (and healthier) results simply by counting and cutting calories while exercising. Its a tried and true method that has been around for ages. Carbs are not the enemy. Well placed, nutritious carbs are your friend.0
-
He died of an heart attack when he was quite young. - not a good advert
Admittedly I'm told it was other health issues than his diet but yeah not good publicity.0 -
I'm on the Insulin Resistance diet for my well...Insulin Resistance. It is also a lower carb diet (15 protein for ever 30 carb) and what it essentially taught me was how to properly portion control. I've maintained it for over a year now.
Because I'm on a lower carb diet too, Akins comes up a lot in my research, grocery list, and conversations. I agree with everyone in this forum that it's a fad diet, you shouldn't cut out carbs unless you're medically suppose to, and it's not sustainable. Plus, atkins food stuff is CRAZY expensive.
My advice? Eat clean (nothing processed) and move. Limit those carbs but do not cut them out completely!0 -
I would say just follow the guidelines set forth here on MFP.
Tweek them to fit you of course.
Eat at a deficit and move more.....lots of success stories on here.
It's really that simple....
0 -
I did a Atkins light verison for a little over 1 year under the supervision of my doctor. At the time I had type II diabetes and it helped in getting my blood sugars under control. Once I was no longer diabetic I stopped it.0
-
Be prepared for the low carb haters. They always come in here and de-rail an otherwise good discussion with their ridicule and childish mockings.
With that said, I do keto, which is similar to Atkins, but unlike Atkins, you don't add carbs back in post-induction. So everyday I try to keep my net carbs under 30, 20 if I can help it. It helped me budge a stubborn 30 lbs. Plus I LOVE being able to eat full-fat EVERYTHING and this eating plan has encouraged me to experiment in the kitchen, so that's a definite plus!0 -
He died of an heart attack when he was quite young. - not a good advert
Actually he died of a head injury. It helps to research, rather than spout misinformation to try to scare people out of an eating plan you don't understand.0 -
Be prepared for the low carb haters. They always come in here and de-rail an otherwise good discussion with their ridicule and childish mockings.
Lol lady...lol0 -
I'm assuming this is a troll post just to get bickering started, but I have to say some of the replies in this thread are a bit disconcerting. People seem to genuinely believe that a "sustainable diet" leads to long-term success and that you can't cut weight in a different way than you maintain weight, but that's simply nonsense. If you find it helpful to eat the same foods on a cut as you do on a bulk, more power to you, but that's not good advise for everyone and I really don't see why doing this gives some people such a false sense of security about their long-term success. At the end of the day, how you cut weight has nothing to do with how you will maintain your weight loss, and plenty of people choose to cut weight with different macros and even food restrictions, relative to when they're eating at maintenance or bulking. Finally, the notion that "Atkins didn't teach me what I needed for maintenance" is a complete cop-out. If you didn't have the knowledge to avoid regaining weight (which if you're honest with yourself, you probably did), that's still on you for failing to educate yourself about what causes weight gain. If you revert to your old habits after ANY weight loss, Atkins or otherwise, you shouldn't be surprised when you regain the weight, and blaming that on Atkins rather than yourself is just failing to accept responsibility for your own actions (or inaction).
But, all that said, the Atkins diet definitely isn't for everyone.0 -
I wasn't aware that giving dissenting opinions backed by personal experience was derailing a topic asking for opinions but okay.0
-
I'm assuming this is a troll post just to get bickering started, but I have to say some of the replies in this thread are a bit disconcerting. People seem to genuinely believe that a "sustainable diet" leads to long-term success and that you can't cut weight in a different way than you maintain weight, but that's simply nonsense. If you find it helpful to eat the same foods on a cut as you do on a bulk, more power to you, but that's not good advise for everyone and I really don't see why doing this gives some people such a false sense of security about their long-term success. At the end of the day, how you cut weight has nothing to do with how you will maintain your weight loss, and plenty of people choose to cut weight with different macros and even food restrictions, relative to when they're eating at maintenance or bulking. Finally, the notion that "Atkins didn't teach me what I needed for maintenance" is a complete cop-out. If you didn't have the knowledge to avoid regaining weight (which if you're honest with yourself, you probably did), that's still on you for failing to educate yourself about what causes weight gain. If you revert to your old habits after ANY weight loss, Atkins or otherwise, you shouldn't be surprised when you regain the weight, and blaming that on Atkins rather than yourself is just failing to accept responsibility for your own actions (or inaction).
But, all that said, the Atkins diet definitely isn't for everyone.
If i chose to educate myself with the atkins diet I would have learned to key is to not go over your magic carb threshold and you will be fine. With Atkins mine was like 70 when I did the diet. Turns out if I control my total caloric intake (a topic hardly discussed in his book) I can eat 200-300 grams of carbs daily and be just fine.
And let me ask you..Is it the lack of carbs specifically that causes the fat loss (outside of glycogen depletion and water loss that is a direct result of low carb) or is it the food restriction, appetite suppression that causes one to eat less calories and drop weight? And how is it explained in atkins?
Thats my problems with it. Its not the diet I have a problem with, but the WHY is not accurate in general0 -
He died of an heart attack when he was quite young. - not a good advert
Actually he died of a head injury. It helps to research, rather than spout misinformation to try to scare people out of an eating plan you don't understand.
Yep. And he wasn't 'quite young' either. My how the myths spread like wildfire. Google is your friend.0 -
Potentially both in the case of someone who is insulin resistant, as many obese people are, but always the latter. Nothing says Atkins book is ALL you can read when following his diet though, and it never claims to be a treatise on nutrition or general fitness. It's simply a structured system for weight loss. I do agree though that people need to educate themselves beyond simply reading his book though. But if upon learning the basics about nutrition and weight loss someone chooses the Atkins diet, I personally don't see a problem nor do I believe they're any less likely to succeed in the long run.0
-
Working for me0
-
Gym and food can get expensive!! : P
You don't need to go to the gym to work out. I have lost 30 pounds without ever stepping foot in a gym. I work out at home with DVDs, or I take walks or go jogging. Recently I started adding free weights at home to my routine.
As for food, well, you have to eat food even on Atkins. And it can be more expensive on Atkins, with meat costing what it does these days. Just eat less of what you're used to eating, and you'll spend less money on food. Boom, done.0 -
He died of an heart attack when he was quite young. - not a good advert
No he didn't. He died from kidney failure that damaged his heart.0 -
Ignore opinions and read the science.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23372809
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11108325
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11108325
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22850317
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22905670
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10959514
High protein diets will only help you fit into a smaller casket.0 -
Does anyone remember before Atkins got really cool there was an infomercial for it? I remember seeing that as a pudgy kid and thinking wow, this looks great! You get to eat bacon, steak, fried eggs, cheese. I kept looking for actual desserts (aside from the berries and cream that were pictured) and when I didn't see any cheesecake I was, like, "This is not for me." From that point on I stuck to watching Richard Simmons infomercials. Much more entertaining.0
-
Ignore opinions and read the science.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23372809
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11108325
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11108325
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22850317
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22905670
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10959514
High protein diets will only help you fit into a smaller casket.
Funny because protein intake on the Atkins diet is as low and most likely lower than many of the protein recommendations given for weight lifters on these forums - and yet this sort of fearmongering only tends to pop-up in Atkins threads.0 -
Does anyone remember before Atkins got really cool there was an infomercial for it? I remember seeing that as a pudgy kid and thinking wow, this looks great! You get to eat bacon, steak, fried eggs, cheese. I kept looking for actual desserts (aside from the berries and cream that were pictured) and when I didn't see any cheesecake I was, like, "This is not for me." From that point on I stuck to watching Richard Simmons infomercials. Much more entertaining.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XIscLaYnECs&feature=kp 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions