Beware: Peanut Butter

MityMax96

I must be the only person that doesn't like PB2. :ohwell:

I love the Smuckers Organic or All Natural, but the Target and Kroger brand all-natural versions are also really good. I LOVE peanut butter!!!!

You're not. I think it's disgusting. It's like eating chalk paste.

I don't hate it, but it is NOT replacement for peanut butter. I'd use it in smoothies to add flavor if I purchased again, but I would rather add a spoon of real actual peanut butter. I did last night and really 1 T of real PB made me "ice cream shake" super.

I use chocolate PB in my smoothies so I bought the chocolate PB2 to save some calories, figuring it was just flavoring, anyway.

My smoothie was inedible.

I will take it :laugh: :laugh:

Put in extra protein first plz.

SeptemberLondon

I LOVE PB, all kinds - even PB2 (but only in protein shakes). And now I know why this thread is titled "Beware" - because I just retrieved the jar from my desk and now I'm in search of a SPOON!! :bigsmile:

rml_16

I must be the only person that doesn't like PB2. :ohwell:

I love the Smuckers Organic or All Natural, but the Target and Kroger brand all-natural versions are also really good. I LOVE peanut butter!!!!

You're not. I think it's disgusting. It's like eating chalk paste.

I don't hate it, but it is NOT replacement for peanut butter. I'd use it in smoothies to add flavor if I purchased again, but I would rather add a spoon of real actual peanut butter. I did last night and really 1 T of real PB made me "ice cream shake" super.

I use chocolate PB in my smoothies so I bought the chocolate PB2 to save some calories, figuring it was just flavoring, anyway.

My smoothie was inedible.

I will take it :laugh: :laugh:

Put in extra protein first plz.

You're welcome to it. I used about a tablespoon and still have the entire container. It's expensive so I'm having a hard time tossing it. lol

But I don't think you live near me. :-)

willrun4bagels

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

MityMax96

I must be the only person that doesn't like PB2. :ohwell:

I love the Smuckers Organic or All Natural, but the Target and Kroger brand all-natural versions are also really good. I LOVE peanut butter!!!!

You're not. I think it's disgusting. It's like eating chalk paste.

I don't hate it, but it is NOT replacement for peanut butter. I'd use it in smoothies to add flavor if I purchased again, but I would rather add a spoon of real actual peanut butter. I did last night and really 1 T of real PB made me "ice cream shake" super.

I use chocolate PB in my smoothies so I bought the chocolate PB2 to save some calories, figuring it was just flavoring, anyway.

My smoothie was inedible.

I will take it :laugh: :laugh:

Put in extra protein first plz.

You're welcome to it. I used about a tablespoon and still have the entire container. It's expensive so I'm having a hard time tossing it. lol

But I don't think you live near me. :-)

:sad: :sad: :sad:
Don't toss it.....

Where are you??

rml_16

I must be the only person that doesn't like PB2. :ohwell:

I love the Smuckers Organic or All Natural, but the Target and Kroger brand all-natural versions are also really good. I LOVE peanut butter!!!!

You're not. I think it's disgusting. It's like eating chalk paste.

I don't hate it, but it is NOT replacement for peanut butter. I'd use it in smoothies to add flavor if I purchased again, but I would rather add a spoon of real actual peanut butter. I did last night and really 1 T of real PB made me "ice cream shake" super.

I use chocolate PB in my smoothies so I bought the chocolate PB2 to save some calories, figuring it was just flavoring, anyway.

My smoothie was inedible.

I will take it :laugh: :laugh:

Put in extra protein first plz.

You're welcome to it. I used about a tablespoon and still have the entire container. It's expensive so I'm having a hard time tossing it. lol

But I don't think you live near me. :-)

:sad: :sad: :sad:
Don't toss it.....

Where are you??

Florida.

PikaKnight

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

^THIS!

MityMax96

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

FatFreeFrolicking

I buy whatever organic, all-natural PB. Usually it is Nature's Promise brand.

Joannah700

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

This is why I buy the jif to go packs - instant portion control. It is not the healthy peanut butter. I tried the healthy stuff, and frankly, there are some things I am willing to give up - but my sugar and salt laden peanut butter is not one of them.

jasonmh630

Publix has fresh deli ground PB that's pretty good.

mank32

i don't think it really matters much (which brand you select) but I like adams all natural.

skullshank

the thread title scared me! i ate 6TBS of peanut butter last night.

i like teddy, but am currently rocking the hannaford generic natural organic one. i think its called natures place. now that i think about it, im not sure its organic. def natural though. i love that stuff.

seltzermint555

We prefer the generic/store brand PB that only includes peanuts & salt. Good stuff!!

However, I'm a PB fan and will eat any of it...creamy, crunchy, Jif, whatever...I like it all.

PB2 however, I was not impressed with at all. To me, it's an expensive, low calorie substance that you can either mix up to a weird consistency or stick in a smoothie and kind of vaguely *maybe* taste a peanut buttery flavor. Tastes like disappointment ;-) No thanks.

willrun4bagels

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

I usually eat more than 1 serving. I must be doing this all wrong. :sad:

MityMax96

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

I usually eat more than 1 serving. I must be doing this all wrong. :sad:

I think I only stop when the jar is empty.

PikaKnight

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

This is why I buy the jif to go packs - instant portion control. It is not the healthy peanut butter. I tried the healthy stuff, and frankly, there are some things I am willing to give up - but my sugar and salt laden peanut butter is not one of them.

Agreed!

I like Jif's Natural PB but I just got some PB2 (the regular and chocolate kind) and going to give that a go. Don't expect it to be anything as good as real peanut butter, but real peanut butter triggers my migraines sometimes. I'm hoping with PB2 I can have more peanut butter-like stuff without the risk.

PikaKnight

Your title is confusing me OP. Why do we have to beware of PB? :huh:

Cause you can't stop at one serving....
no way, no how:noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:

I usually eat more than 1 serving. I must be doing this all wrong. :sad:

I think I only stop when the jar is empty.

Well, if you do, just realize that if you end up with some stomach issues, that doesn't automatically mean you are intolerant. It means you ate a whole jar of peanut butter. :laugh:

dpwellman

But a peanut isn't a nut. . .!

MityMax96

But a peanut isn't a nut. . .!

Still sounds better than peabean or pealegume :laugh: :laugh: