Ice Bucket Challenge, Ribbons, Wrist Bands, etc....

jenilla1

...I don't mean to sound preachy; I'm aware this is my perspective and most people posting here don't share it. I just wish more people had a broader focus and maybe a broader understanding of what "helping people" or "supporting a cause" means...

And who gets to decide who's doing it "right"? If you think you have a better cause or a better way, then do it. Each individual should be able to decide what cause to support and how they want to support it. They don't need your blessing.

Capt_Inzane

Ya know what really upsets me...

I was charged 71 cents for my banana instead of 69 cents..I mean seriously 2 cents what the hell..

Ya'll *****ing over some 40 million dollars. I just want my 2 cents back.

ninerbuff

Eh, it's not different than people wearing pink ribbons that "support" breast cancer, but don't donate money or volunteer time to help. Some people are doing it because it's just fun.
It's fun and it's raising awareness and it's raised money. Don't see the issue here.

We should be more concerned that our retired congress people get full pay and medical benefits for doing absolutely nothing rather than a bunch of fun loving people having good time, creating awareness and/or donating money to help with finding a cure to a disease.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

ironmonkeystyle

It's cool to leverage our collective narcissism as a form of activism. Nothing wrong with that. We are a narcissistic nation. At least some good comes of it, right?

history_grrrl

Eh, it's not different than people wearing pink ribbons that "support" breast cancer, but don't donate money or volunteer time to help. Some people are doing it because it's just fun.
It's fun and it's raising awareness and it's raised money. Don't see the issue here.

Hopefully nobody is wearing a pink ribbon to "support breast cancer." But actually, some of us do think the "fun!" hype around breast cancer is harmful, not helpful: http://thinkbeforeyoupink.org/

ninerbuff

Eh, it's not different than people wearing pink ribbons that "support" breast cancer, but don't donate money or volunteer time to help. Some people are doing it because it's just fun.
It's fun and it's raising awareness and it's raised money. Don't see the issue here.

Hopefully nobody is wearing a pink ribbon to "support breast cancer." But actually, some of us do think the "fun!" hype around breast cancer is harmful, not helpful: http://thinkbeforeyoupink.org/

Sorry meant to say "support against breast cancer".
And by "fun", I meant doing something physical. Like running for breast cancer.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

rowlandsw

The icebucket challenge is an idiotic fad that's going to end up killing someone. Just donate the damned money already and stop feeding the internet stupidity monster.

MelsAuntie

Wait, do people not realize that when you dump water on yourself, you also donate? Accepting the challenge means you do the water thing AND GIVE MONEY.

What if you give the money and DON'T dump the water? Win/win.

ninerbuff

The icebucket challenge is an idiotic fad that's going to end up killing someone. Just donate the damned money already and stop feeding the internet stupidity monster.

It's only idiotic for the ones trying to attempt idiotic ways of doing it. And I've seen them. But for those who are doing it sincerely and more than sure they are donating too, it may be the ONE thing they actually will do something about. I personally plan to donate and and just use a CUP of ice water since we're in a drought in California!:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

Clovermoth

It's slactivism. It makes people feel like they're doing something good for the world and they're really not. I can understand buying things that contribute directly to an organization that you would like to support, I have several HRC stickers on the back of my car right now. But the ice bucket challenge seems like a cop-out. I respect the fact that it brings awareness to the issue, but I think it should be coupled with a donation to the charity not just doing the "challenge."

ALS has seen like 400% increase in donations over last year, it is hard to believe that the ice bucket challenge isn't having an impact whether you like or not. While I agree a lot of people are just doing the challenge and not donating it has brought a lot of awareness to a great cause

I acknowledged that it is bringing awareness to the cause and I understand that many people are doing both the challenge and donating to a charity. My problem with it is that the rules are to do the challenge when somebody nominates you and if you fail you have to give money to the organization. I don't like seeing the donation as a punishment for failing to pour ice over your head.

You actually donate whether you do the challenge or not. That is in the rules. And it does bring awareness to ALS. For example I was just nominated by my Uncle today and had no idea what ALS was....I went and researched it and now I do and I am also donating as well as doing the challenge. I'm not saying I'm superwoman, I'm just saying I'm glad that I was made aware and it's not hurting anyone. Where is YOUR donation.

MelsAuntie

Not sure how the whole thing works. If you are called out, you have to donate or get drenched?

I know lots of people, including my own family, that are challenging each other to the Ice Bucket Challenge, but not donating a cent.

I think it's just a "hey! Look at me" game to them.

You are supposed to donate either way. You're "allowed" to donate less if you do the ice water.

WTF....!!! what do you mean "allowed"? You have the right to donate or not, however much you want to donate ( or not), and if somebody pours ice water over your head when you don't want it, it's assault!! I'd just like to see somebody try to tell me how much, or if, I had to donate, and if they tried to pour ice water on me they'd be wearintg the bucket up their sphincter.

Alluminati

Not sure how the whole thing works. If you are called out, you have to donate or get drenched?

I know lots of people, including my own family, that are challenging each other to the Ice Bucket Challenge, but not donating a cent.

I think it's just a "hey! Look at me" game to them.

You are supposed to donate either way. You're "allowed" to donate less if you do the ice water.

WTF....!!! what do you mean "allowed"? You have the right to donate or not, however much you want to donate ( or not), and if somebody pours ice water over your head when you don't want it, it's assault!! I'd just like to see somebody try to tell me how much, or if, I had to donate, and if they tried to pour ice water on me they'd be wearintg the bucket up their sphincter.

Chill out, Mike Tyson.

rml_16

Not sure how the whole thing works. If you are called out, you have to donate or get drenched?

I know lots of people, including my own family, that are challenging each other to the Ice Bucket Challenge, but not donating a cent.

I think it's just a "hey! Look at me" game to them.

You are supposed to donate either way. You're "allowed" to donate less if you do the ice water.

WTF....!!! what do you mean "allowed"? You have the right to donate or not, however much you want to donate ( or not), and if somebody pours ice water over your head when you don't want it, it's assault!! I'd just like to see somebody try to tell me how much, or if, I had to donate, and if they tried to pour ice water on me they'd be wearintg the bucket up their sphincter.

Oh, honey.

Do you understand what quotation marks mean in this context? Do I really have to explain that to you?

rml_16

The icebucket challenge is an idiotic fad that's going to end up killing someone. Just donate the damned money already and stop feeding the internet stupidity monster.

If someone dies doing this, I'm pretty sure that person made a choice to do something really dumb and I call Darwinism at its best.

rml_16

I can attest to fundraising not being an easy thing, I work for a charity trying to put together ways to 'encourage' people to donate. We are a worthy cause, but there are so many of them.

Speaking of the ALS challenge, how do people feel about other charities 'hijacking' the tag on social media and using it for their own charity campaigns? That is currently what is happening with this particular campaign.

Edited: due to stray '?'

There's a video being passed around explaining how it got started and initially, it was to donate to a charity of one's choice. It didn't have to be ALS. But the men who started it did it in honor of their friend who had ALS, so that kind of stuck.

I have seen a few people donate to other charities and I think that's fine. It's all in fun and it all goes to one good cause or another.

And, speaking of, I have taken this as inspiration to be more charitable in general. I started a FB page where members can suggest charities and "stunts" like the ice bucket challenge (anything that won't kill or wound me and doesn't involve nudity!) and I will film and post a stunt, post a link to the charity's website to encourage others to donate and I will donate a set amount every month to a different charity.

Anyone here is welcome to come "like" it and participate: https://www.facebook.com/reneegivesback

stephanieluvspb

Watch this commercial -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0Q4kIx95aU

Now tell me how much you hate that people are donating to find a cure for ALS.

I'm literally crying now. I hope everybody watches this and I hope everybody helps as much as they can

stephanieluvspb

Not sure how the whole thing works. If you are called out, you have to donate or get drenched?

I know lots of people, including my own family, that are challenging each other to the Ice Bucket Challenge, but not donating a cent.

I think it's just a "hey! Look at me" game to them.

You are supposed to donate either way. You're "allowed" to donate less if you do the ice water.

WTF....!!! what do you mean "allowed"? You have the right to donate or not, however much you want to donate ( or not), and if somebody pours ice water over your head when you don't want it, it's assault!! I'd just like to see somebody try to tell me how much, or if, I had to donate, and if they tried to pour ice water on me they'd be wearintg the bucket up their sphincter.

Chill out, Mike Tyson.

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: seriously!!

SwashBlogger

According to the Washington Post, the Catholic church instructed it's members NOT to participate as ALS research includes stem cell research. Anyone else read that? oh those do-gooders.....

rml_16

According to the Washington Post, the Catholic church instructed it's members NOT to participate as ALS research includes stem cell research. Anyone else read that? oh those do-gooders.....

It's because of the stem cell research.

ninerbuff

According to the Washington Post, the Catholic church instructed it's members NOT to participate as ALS research includes stem cell research. Anyone else read that? oh those do-gooders.....

Being born and raised Catholic, I'm glad I don't follow what the church says anymore. But just don't put it on the Catholics. I'm sure just about any hard core Christian organization would deter it to if stem cell research is included.

A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition