Edward or Jacob...and why?

SemperAnticus1643

Who would you prefer? And why?

skinnyme125

Jacob he is cute, I think Edward is creapy ugly. Sorry. I like darker skinned indian males. My ex husband was darker skinned and indian and now so is my son. I find that very sexy. My skin used to be like that when i was younger but over the years i have gotten lighter.

lilac01

Edward. He's so charming.

jenhenning219

combine them both and you have the perfect guy, i cant choose sides

cdngirl71

Ewwww I wouldn't pick either of them.

FearAnLoathing

Both are ICK

arodriguez2

based on the movies- Jacob, based on the books- it's a tie, after reading the beginning of midnight sun though- kinda liking Edward. lol.

jend114

Jacob, #1 I love wolves & he's a wolf #2 he's just super hot

IamOnMywayNow

Jacob....he is hot and besides, i would rather have baby wolf pups, instead of blood sucking babies:-D

cassiex10

I'm Team Edward for the most part...but in a perfect world, I'd go with both and say Team Threesome :laugh:

HotSouthernMess

edward for sure. he is just so sweet and romantic. he "lives" for bella and loves her so much.

crazymama2two

theyre both icky to me in my own way of thinking for different reasons, BUT if i had to choose, id pick edward - something about skinny scrawny tall pale boys makes me weak in the knees...

that and nerds with glasses

that and semi-dirty hippies with dreds

that and my man; a clean hippy with a job!

i babbled. sorry.

crazymama2two

I'm Team Edward for the most part...but in a perfect world, I'd go with both and say Team Threesome :laugh:

i meant to say THIS

heathersmilez

Edward; better facial bone structure, completion, height, weight. Jacob looks like a cabbage patch w/ muscles.

poesch77

combine them both and you have the perfect guy, i cant choose sides

I agree with this.....Edward's head on Jacob's tan sexy bod!!!!

binary_jester

Making note of anyone who picks side to immediately remove them from my friends list.

ladybug1620

I'm Team Edward for the most part...but in a perfect world, I'd go with both and say Team Threesome :laugh:

i meant to say THIS

Ahahahah me too! If I had to choose, I choose Edward. I'm in love with the way he loves so intensely.

LuckyLeprechaun

Both are ICK

this!

my brother took me to see the first Twilight movie, and told me "it's about vampires" I was imagining cool movies such as Blade, Underworld, Interview, etc. Afterwards I told him, "You owe me a drink!"

Sparkling, vegetarian vampires? :noway: :sick: :indifferent:

LuckyLeprechaun

Making note of anyone who picks side to immediately remove them from my friends list.

LOL YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

mishelnkiki

I PERSONALLY PREFER THE SMOKING HOT BROTHER OF EDWARD. CANT THINK OF HIS NAME BUT I THINK IT MIGHT BE EMITT, MAYBE. OR HELL PUT ME ON TEAM BELLA! LOL. NO NO SERIOULSY THO, THE ONLY MOVIE EDWARD IS HOT IN IS THAT ONE. EVERY OTHER MOVIE IVE SEEN HIM HE ISNT ATTRACTIVE. JACOB HOWEVER... SMOKIN HOT NO MATTER WHAT! EVEN AS SHARK BOY HE WAS A LIL CUTIE! LOL.

skinnyme125

Both are ICK

this!

my brother took me to see the first Twilight movie, and told me "it's about vampires" I was imagining cool movies such as Blade, Underworld, Interview, etc. Afterwards I told him, "You owe me a drink!"

Sparkling, vegetarian vampires? :noway: :sick: :indifferent:

The first movie was real bad but they actually get better as they go. I didn't want to watch any more after the first but got suckered into it and the second is a little better and the third is even better than that.

Ashley_Panda

Edward.

But I'm Team Jasper! :]

skinnyme125

I PERSONALLY PREFER THE SMOKING HOT BROTHER OF EDWARD. CANT THINK OF HIS NAME BUT I THINK IT MIGHT BE EMITT, MAYBE. OR HELL PUT ME ON TEAM BELLA! LOL. NO NO SERIOULSY THO, THE ONLY MOVIE EDWARD IS HOT IN IS THAT ONE. EVERY OTHER MOVIE IVE SEEN HIM HE ISNT ATTRACTIVE. JACOB HOWEVER... SMOKIN HOT NO MATTER WHAT! EVEN AS SHARK BOY HE WAS A LIL CUTIE! LOL.

I love how you mentioned Shark Boy. He was a cutie in that one.

louell33

I have no idea who they are.....I will crawl back under my stone...

sbwood888

My 14 year old daughter has been obsessed with Edward for the past 2 years. She even has an Edward pillow case on her bed. I guess I would have to choose Jacob--only because I am sick of hearing about Edward. :laugh:

deeharley

Team Charlie here.

Cori615

Jacob! Not only for the hot tan body but because he would be more fun to be around with. Edward blah

dawnw30

I'd have to say Jacob because I bet he loves to be rubbed and pet....Edward is a dead, cold dude - ewww....LOL! :laugh:

LorinaLynn

At the risk of being a creepy old lady, as well as ruining my cred for having read the books... Jacob.

I like the kind of guy I can be completely 100% myself around, a guy who's a buddy, a peer. She worships Edward too much. She thinks he's too good for her. I wouldn't want a relationship with that kind of imbalance... I don't think either person should put the other on a pedestal.

And... Edward may be forever in the body of a 17 year old, but emotionally, he should be far too mature for a flighty overemotional teenage girl.

I like Emmett best. Great big funny lunk of a guy. That's my type. :happy: How he puts up with a priss like Rosalie is beyond me.

But honestly... Gimme Eric Northman from the Sookie Stackhouse series. A vampire AND a viking. Can't trump that unless you get Scottish vamp in a kilt.

red01angel

Both are one dimensional doucherockets. No thanks sister.

I'd rather do Blade...THAT'S a vampire I could work with.

amerr

theyre both icky to me in my own way of thinking for different reasons, BUT if i had to choose, id pick edward - something about skinny scrawny tall pale boys makes me weak in the knees...

that and nerds with glasses

that and semi-dirty hippies with dreds

that and my man; a clean hippy with a job!

i babbled. sorry.

This for me too! I have odd taste in men. lol