your input please gentlemen...

newfielover
newfielover Posts: 104 Member
edited September 29 in Health and Weight Loss
So this is incredibly dumb and I feel stupid asking this! But a friend and I were having a discussion about this and I am interested to see what you all have to say!! (Even though I think that no girl should judge her body on what guys think lol)
So the stereotype is that guys love the super skinny hollywood/airbrushed models. Is this true? Or is that starting to go "out of style"? What do you think is beautiful in a woman?
Thanks so much for adding to this discussion for us!!!!
Hugs and best of luck to everyone!!!!!
«1345678

Replies

  • AZTrailRunner
    AZTrailRunner Posts: 1,199 Member
    Hardly. I am attracted to women of varying statures (athletic, healthy curves, etc.). Put a barbie doll in front of me with a bad attitude and suddenly she becomes repulsive. So attitude plays a big part too.

    not sure if that helped or not.
  • tigersword
    tigersword Posts: 8,059 Member
    Curves, please. Not a fan of super skinny, give me a strong athletic looking girl any day.
  • newfielover
    newfielover Posts: 104 Member
    It most definately did! Thank you so much! Now Im winning my "discussion" with my friend :)
  • crisanderson27
    crisanderson27 Posts: 5,343 Member
    Hardly. I am attracted to women of varying statures (athletic, healthy curves, etc.). Put a barbie doll in front of me with a bad attitude and suddenly she becomes repulsive. So attitude plays a big part too.

    not sure if that helped or not.

    This.

    Seriously...that.

    There's not much else to say to it.
  • Fayve
    Fayve Posts: 406 Member
    Actually, if I can ransack this thread a bit. I was curious myself after coming across this picture.

    http://i54.tinypic.com/iwivbn.jpg

    Not sure if it's offensive - at least I don't think it is, but what I found interesting was to find what I see myself as, and what my goal would look like.

    My boyfriend said that he thinks 2 and 3 are what the media deems 'beautiful' - and he wishes that women like 8,9, and 11 would replace that. I see myself as a 9, and I want to be a 3 or 5 ;)
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    So this is incredibly dumb and I feel stupid asking this! But a friend and I were having a discussion about this and I am interested to see what you all have to say!! (Even though I think that no girl should judge her body on what guys think lol)
    So the stereotype is that guys love the super skinny hollywood/airbrushed models. Is this true? Or is that starting to go "out of style"? What do you think is beautiful in a woman?
    Thanks so much for adding to this discussion for us!!!!
    Hugs and best of luck to everyone!!!!!

    I enjoy having a bit of insight into what men really like because I think, as women, we think they all want Barbie dolls. Perhaps if we knew what REAL men want in a woman we wouldn't be so hard on ourselves?
  • How do I say this and not sound like a perv...ok I like it when a woman has curves, when we have "fun" time I don't wanna worry about braking her lol
  • 4KidFather
    4KidFather Posts: 134
    Strengthy curves please. Gwyneth paltrow and the catwal chicks look like they'd break if they lived in my house.
    Interestingly, I think most guys pick up on a healthy vibe from women. I've noticed how many of us men I know can agree that a certain women is attractive of not even although they may not be cover page material. Strange but in person I think smells and hormones kick in :)
    I will also add that I think the strength stature thing is huge as a lot of guys (inc me) pick up on poise, walks and energy.
    Look at all those crossfit beauties, jamaican sprinters etc. THOSE get guys excited, not catwalk skeletons.
    Soooo.... what about girls :) ha ha ha
  • dan323
    dan323 Posts: 271 Member
    What an interesting question. I would have to say that each man has his own like and dislike,just as women do. I myself don't think airbrushed supper models are interesting at all. They are just to skinny for my taste. That being said my wife is 5'4" and 110 lbs. But that is her build.In fact she is actually trying to gain weight. When she was 120 she was just as lovely. I think most men want a woman they can hold on to and not worry that we might break her if we hold her to tight. If you stay trim and fit you will be fine. Those women on America's Top Model that my daughter's watch are way to skinny. They need some meat on there bones. What you see in magazines and on TV is not accurate to what most men would want. Some men also think that's what a women should look like and IMHO they are just shallow in what they think of Women in general. I say BE YOURSELF and not whats in magazines and on tv.
  • Jamazurunner
    Jamazurunner Posts: 132
    A big thanks to the original poster for this- its refreshing to hear that guys like girls who do not starve themselves or lose weight in an unhealthy way. Sometimes us normal gals need this reassurance!

    Jam
  • aa1440
    aa1440 Posts: 956 Member
    Don't like super skinny. Must have a few curves.

    Now don't get me wrong. There are some women with a little extra that still look good.
  • norcalrv
    norcalrv Posts: 20 Member
    The supper skinny twiggy is not for me, and never has been. Curves, and some meat on the bones is much more attractive and desirable.
  • SeanC86
    SeanC86 Posts: 88
    Hardly. I am attracted to women of varying statures (athletic, healthy curves, etc.). Put a barbie doll in front of me with a bad attitude and suddenly she becomes repulsive. So attitude plays a big part too.

    not sure if that helped or not.

    This.

    Seriously...that.

    There's not much else to say to it.

    I third this thought process...

    I'm attracted to different women for different reasons. Personally, I don't look at just what a woman looks like to figure out if I'm attracted to her. It's a lot about how she carries herself too. If she's super skinny and has that, as they say, "barbie girl" attitude to her... It's not my thing. I'd rather be with someone who is healthy, confident, but not conceited, and an overall joy to be around. I won't say I haven't seen attractive "skinny" women, or dated them, but I've found that those who look healthier, or have "a little meat on the bones" (personally hate that saying, but no know how else to put it) are genuinely nicer people and a lot more fun to be around.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    A big thanks to the original poster for this- its refreshing to hear that guys like girls who do not starve themselves or lose weight in an unhealthy way. Sometimes us normal gals need this reassurance!

    Jam

    This thread makes us "real women" feel so much better. :)
  • fastbelly
    fastbelly Posts: 727 Member
    Curves vs Skinny? Curves all day long!
  • crisanderson27
    crisanderson27 Posts: 5,343 Member
    Actually, if I can ransack this thread a bit. I was curious myself after coming across this picture.

    iwivbn.jpg

    Not sure if it's offensive - at least I don't think it is, but what I found interesting was to find what I see myself as, and what my goal would look like.

    My boyfriend said that he thinks 2 and 3 are what the media deems 'beautiful' - and he wishes that women like 8,9, and 11 would replace that. I see myself as a 9, and I want to be a 3 or 5 ;)

    I'm not a fan of 8 and 9...11 is definitely ok. 3 caught my attention first, but it may have been the suit and pose (serious curves). Thinking about it, in descending order from favorite to least, would be 5 and 3 tied, 11 and 4 tied (if 4 had smaller breasts...Lord), and then 2 and 1. I didn't notice 14 until just now...but that 'average' body type could fit anywhere in the above list, depending on her face.

    As a disclaimer...NO PERSONALITY IS IMPLIED in this post. Personality can modify ANY of them to be first on the list. Seriously. A pretty face and an incredible personality will get you much farther with me than a smokin body. The smokin body can come and go...from either direction (gaining it or losing it).
  • wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...
  • Hearts_2015
    Hearts_2015 Posts: 12,031 Member
    bump
  • kappyd
    kappyd Posts: 199 Member
    I think you would have a hard time finding two guys that like the exact same type.
  • crisanderson27
    crisanderson27 Posts: 5,343 Member
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    Elaborate lol =D.
  • Jamazurunner
    Jamazurunner Posts: 132
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    I know! I keep hitting the refresh button!
  • RollinDawg
    RollinDawg Posts: 235 Member
    These anorexic looking Hollywood women that some people say are so beautiful just really don't do a thing for me, except make me want to take them a sandwich or two. I can't remember her name, but the lady in the Pirates of the Carribean movies doesn't even look healthy at all.

    First thing I notice usually is a woman's smile and her attitude...or at least that's the first thing that I notice that will hold my attention for more than a few seconds. If she seems to be enjoying herself and laughing, then in my mind I think "Hey, I can make her laugh...I got a shot." I may notice something else at a glance, but that's just cuz I'm a guy...it's what we do...sorry ladies, no offense meant at all.
  • Jamazurunner
    Jamazurunner Posts: 132
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    Elaborate lol =D.


    Well personally I don't think many women have realized that this is what some men prefer! Many of us gals are conditioned to thinking that we need to physically look a certain way. I think hearing all these comments are good for us in realizing that:

    1. Its not always about looks!
    2. Guys like us, regardless of our body shape and type (weight is not the "dealbreaker"
    3. Confidence is key
  • crisanderson27
    crisanderson27 Posts: 5,343 Member
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    I know! I keep hitting the refresh button!

    Elaborate lol!!

    Seriously...I as a male who 'voted'...would like you guys input as well. Tell us what you're thinking! =p

    And don't get me wrong...a smokin hot body is a big plus...but it's not a deal breaker is my point.
  • crisanderson27
    crisanderson27 Posts: 5,343 Member
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    Elaborate lol =D.


    Well personally I don't think many women have realized that this is what some men prefer! Many of us gals are conditioned to thinking that we need to physically look a certain way. I think hearing all these comments are good for us in realizing that:

    1. Its not always about looks!
    2. Guys like us, regardless of our body shape and type

    Thank you hun =D.

    And yes...yes, we do.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    I think Jam hit the nail on the head.

    This thread is like an open door into the way men see women. It's refreshing to hear that not all men want a size 0 Barbie doll.
  • James_1954
    James_1954 Posts: 187 Member
    Actually, if I can ransack this thread a bit. I was curious myself after coming across this picture.

    http://i54.tinypic.com/iwivbn.jpg

    ...

    Hey, if they're wiggling in my direction, there's not a single one of them that doesn't look completely fine. Seriously.
  • omid990
    omid990 Posts: 785 Member
    bump
  • Avalonis
    Avalonis Posts: 1,540 Member
    Actually, if I can ransack this thread a bit. I was curious myself after coming across this picture.

    http://i54.tinypic.com/iwivbn.jpg

    Not sure if it's offensive - at least I don't think it is, but what I found interesting was to find what I see myself as, and what my goal would look like.

    My boyfriend said that he thinks 2 and 3 are what the media deems 'beautiful' - and he wishes that women like 8,9, and 11 would replace that. I see myself as a 9, and I want to be a 3 or 5 ;)

    I like 12 and 13. 11 is ok, but bordering on too skinny.
  • SeanC86
    SeanC86 Posts: 88
    wow. this post's answers are an eye opener... Interesting...

    Elaborate lol =D.


    Well personally I don't think many women have realized that this is what some men prefer! Many of us gals are conditioned to thinking that we need to physically look a certain way. I think hearing all these comments are good for us in realizing that:

    1. Its not always about looks!
    2. Guys like us, regardless of our body shape and type (weight is not the "dealbreaker"
    3. Confidence is key

    I think on both sides of the coin, it comes down to confidence and personality that attracts us to one another in the long run. That first initial attraction is purely based on physical attraction. As this post is geared towards that, you have most of our answers... I've found (even when I was overweight) that any girl COULD find me attractive if they got to know me... because I like to flirt, say nice things, and genuinely be a nice guy. I've had close women friends call me a "genuine charmer" before, because I don't just say something to you to "get in your pants" or anything stupid... I say it cause I mean it. If someone is confident, there's not much that can stand in their way.
This discussion has been closed.