Dukan it out !!! - The Dukan Diet
Replies
-
just wanted to ask others on dukan, how many grams of carbs are u having on pp and pv days?? on a protein only day i have carbs in the form of fat free dairy, and a little onion or garlic in food. obviously pv days automatically include veg, but there doesnt seem to be any guidelines in the book.
so i just wondered what u guys were doing?0 -
Energy drain on low carb. I like that the weight loss is quick and easy on the dukan plan but I don't like the lack of energy. If I am only going to walk 20-30 minutes per day it is fine, but I am used to doing a lot more than that and after almost vomiting on one of my bike rides last week, I have decided to add a carb serving before work outs. My attack days I will limit my activity to the walk and on pv days I will add one carb serving before my workout. After improving my cardio so much in the last several months I don't want to lose my fitness level and I really like the feeling of accomplishment taking on challenging activities. I ride by bike 25 km home from work 3 days per week much of it up hill, cuz I live on a little mountain, and one gym day to work my upper body. That leaves 3 attack days and 4 pv + low glycemic carb days.
Do any of you work out? How are you handling the energy drain?0 -
I had a really successful attack phase last week. I am on cruise this week (PV) and then PP next. The thing is, I lost weight on attack that I have not gained back so that is great. About four pounds in ten days (I stuck it out for 10 because I was hoping to lose more). This week, I did protein and veggies except for three days in which all I wanted was carbs (apples, brown rice, w/e). I checked it out today and I gained half a pound back. I resume PP next week (alternating weeks). I do work out a lot though, and I just feel like I need it! Any tips for not failing the PV? I did fine without any carbs, but give me some and then all I want is more! :huh: the mind and body are curiously behaving. will do better tomorrow and this week (turkey for thanksgiving anyone?) but it is more of a question WHEN I will need more carbs then I am taking in than IF I will need more carbs than I am taking in before I reach my goal weight...
I should also add that I haven't been doing the oat bran. This may be my downfall, but I did not find the specific stuff he talked about. And I didn't understand why I needed it so just forgot about it.0 -
And about carbs, I try to limit dairy while on PP because they do add up. I stay well under 50g on PP days and around/under 100g on PV days (some of the vegetables say they have a lot of carbs on myfitnesspal that he approved. I wonder if the entries are correct?).0
-
Not to be a "debbie downer" (what a dorky saying LOL), but the reason these fad diets keep selling is because people have little patience to work hard and get the weight to come off in the most healthy way possible...
Good luck - but fads are fads - watching calories, eating healthily and exercising is the only life plan that works in my opinion...0 -
I should also add that I haven't been doing the oat bran. This may be my downfall, but I did not find the specific stuff he talked about. And I didn't understand why I needed it so just forgot about it.
[/quote]
It took me a few grocery stores before I found it, but now I have it (usually in the cereal aisle, but you you should ask at your store).
the bran helps keeps you full and makes your bowels work properly, quite an important thing.
I mix it in with my yogurt and it tastes fine. i am going to try and make crab cakes for dinner with it tonight. I hope it works.
You said you work out, how are you coping with energy levels on protein days?0 -
Not to be a "debbie downer" (what a dorky saying LOL), but the reason these fad diets keep selling is because people have little patience to work hard and get the weight to come off in the most healthy way possible...
Good luck - but fads are fads - watching calories, eating healthily and exercising is the only life plan that works in my opinion...
Gee I wish I had thought of that, oh wait I did and so did every one else who is heavier than they want to be.
I am not trying this because I am lazy and afraid of hard work, (I work out 7-10 hours per week) I have been stuck for months and need something to get my weight loss started again.
So yes, you are a debbie downer!0 -
you know, i have heard the skeptics too and I know there's no such thing as a "miracle" diet. Everyone knows that if you fall back into bad habits, yes you will gain the weight back that you have lost. I love the Dukan Diet- I have never tried low carb before and it has done things that nothing else ever has, like flatten my belly and curb my cravings for the junk food and "white" carbs.
Let's please support one another- that's the reason for this thread. You don't have to agree with what we are doing, but then again- why would you even comment on the thread. For a lot of people, the Dukan gives just the right result in the beginning for people that have tried everything and it encourages them to move on. I admit, the Attack phase is extreme, but the PV days are nice and I am starting consolidation now- it is a lifestyle change. I'm curious to see how it all pans out, but right now- I am a total supporter of the difference it has made for me.0 -
Not to be a "debbie downer" (what a dorky saying LOL), but the reason these fad diets keep selling is because people have little patience to work hard and get the weight to come off in the most healthy way possible...
Good luck - but fads are fads - watching calories, eating healthily and exercising is the only life plan that works in my opinion...
i work hard, count calories and eat healthily on the dukan diet. not quite sure why you would comment on this thread at all.0 -
I had a really successful attack phase last week. I am on cruise this week (PV) and then PP next. The thing is, I lost weight on attack that I have not gained back so that is great. About four pounds in ten days (I stuck it out for 10 because I was hoping to lose more). This week, I did protein and veggies except for three days in which all I wanted was carbs (apples, brown rice, w/e). I checked it out today and I gained half a pound back. I resume PP next week (alternating weeks). I do work out a lot though, and I just feel like I need it! Any tips for not failing the PV? I did fine without any carbs, but give me some and then all I want is more! :huh: the mind and body are curiously behaving. will do better tomorrow and this week (turkey for thanksgiving anyone?) but it is more of a question WHEN I will need more carbs then I am taking in than IF I will need more carbs than I am taking in before I reach my goal weight...
I should also add that I haven't been doing the oat bran. This may be my downfall, but I did not find the specific stuff he talked about. And I didn't understand why I needed it so just forgot about it.
i alternate my pp and pv days i wonder if this may help so that you wont have such a break between carbs and crave them less?
also i just use 100% oat bran from the supermarket, as long as its 100% i think that should be ok. the specific oat bran the diet talks about can only be purchased through the dukan website and im not willing to spend that much on it (im a poor student lol)0 -
Well after the 2nd time of the attack phase I have now come to the conclusion that this diet is no good if you are a busy person
I really crash with no energy
Back to sensible foods I think0 -
Well after the 2nd time of the attack phase I have now come to the conclusion that this diet is no good if you are a busy person
I really crash with no energy
Back to sensible foods I think
sorry to hear uv had a bad time, this diet isnt for everyone. i worried about crashing but i have more energy than i have done for a while- maybe we approached things differently, i definetly didnt spend long in attack phase!! good luck with your journey.0 -
Hi there my fellow Dukaners, what is everyone doing for Thanksgiving? Are you allowing yourself the treat of a regular meal or trying to stick to Dukan, I'm struggling with what to do. I love cornbread dressing and pumpkin pie more than anything but don't want to get off track- it is a special day though :flowerforyou:0
-
Hi there hows everyone doing, hope everyone is dong really well!!
Ive just started exercising (a 3000 calories burned a week challenge) which has actually sent my body into complete shock as its so used to me being so lazy, lol!! so, after a week of loads of energy i have completley run out of fuel this week and today ive struggled to stand, never mind exercise. for this reason im 'leaving' dukan for a while and eating more carbs to accomodate for the fuel i need to exercise. i could have reduced my exercise to the walking dr dukan prescribes but i felt it wouldnt help my endurance levels as i want to be able to go running.
although i will be sticking to some dukan principles, my dukan diet will be missed!!! if eating differently doesnt help my energy levels, i will be back!!!!!!0 -
to each their own, let us know how you do!
low carbs are said to trigger cravings- body wants glucose! so it is hard
i am used to working out (kickboxing is my favorite) so it really just takes a lot more motivation
i lost weight with dukan- no bran- alternating PP and PV weeks- but i break it once a week unintentionally. i need to get it together!0 -
Hey y'all,
I'm going to try Dukan again. I've been working for years and years to shed pounds, having some success from time to time and stuff, but I've been in major stall mode. I attempted Dukan about three months ago but didn't really put any effort in. This time, I'm going to give it real focus and hope for the best.
I'm getting married at the end of March, and yes, I want to look good in my wedding dress (we're eloping, though, so it's not like it'll be a huge show or anything) but I also want to look good in pictures in PARIS, and not have to lug all this weight around while trying to sightsee on my honeymoon. Plus, I'm just sick and tired of being overweight!
So, share any tips or advice you have, please. And good luck to us all!0 -
Hello, it's great to find other people on the dukan diet to talk to
Just finished attack yesterday and so far I'm down 7 lbs... HAPPY! Thats better than I ever managed on my first week of weight watchers. Now I must just add in some excersise... Good luck everyone! 0 -
Just checking in to say hi, how's everyone doing?0
-
hi!
so i tried higher carbs, energy level did raise a little but so did weight. gained 4 lbs. needless to say i went back to attack and ive lost 5 pounds in five days. clearly my body likes this diet. so i plan to eat more veg and dairy on pv days to increase my carbs, maybe even a little more oatbran and use these days as workout days. im approaching my last stone now, cant wait to get to my true weight!!!0 -
Hi everyone! I tried the Attack phase a few weeks ago and got down 5 pounds in 2 days!!! But on day 3, the hubby and I went to my inlaws for dinner and they ordered pizza and kept making me feel guilty for turning it down, so I caved and ate some to keep them quiet..and then life just got hectic! I am ready to give it my all now though, because I KNOW it works! I've seen it work twice now.
Starting tomorrow is Day 1 of Attack for me. I know I can do this...I did it for over a month back in July and it worked out great. I just need to stay focussed and go through the phases correctly instead of getting impatient.0 -
I am going to give Dukan one more try.
I have ordered Chris Powell's book (extreme makeover; weightloss edition trainer) I saw a preview of his plan on Dr OZ awhile ago and it looks like he incorporates low carb days. The book comes out just after Xmas but I want to lose some poundage before then.
:happy:0 -
Day 5 of attack phase, down 6 lbs! I am doing the happy dance as I have been on a stupid plateau since July of this year. I recently had BR surgery and they took off alot of boobs and guess what when I came out and after the swelling had gone down the doctor said I should be a few pounds lighter. NOT! I was at my same weight before I had the surgery!! And I remained the same weight! I eat nothing but veggies and lean meats all day long. I exercise times a day/45 mins each and nothing. Not even weight gain! I had my thyroid checked and its fine. So then I was told to up my calories (I was at 1200, then 1000) then went to 1400 and still nothing!! So I got desperate and I have always wanted to try this diet and whola! It worked! I am going to do 15 days of this. At this rate if I am doing 6lbs per week and at 15 days I might just get a little over 15 lbs off! good enough for me as I have 30-40 lbs to shed. Good luck everyone!0
-
I've tried it.
I do something kinda similar but a bit more healthy, with lower calories and a specific amount of protein to reach my goals.
If anyone wants to know message me as its too complicated to explain on here.
Theres loads of ways to skin a cat.
I recommend reading it, and if anyone wants to buy my copy of the book i'll gladly sell it to them.
its ok but not amazing.
I lose more more on m y diet.
Good luck to you all and this site is excellent.0 -
I' m down 36 pounds in 16 weeks of Dukan diet. I probably do a few more days of protein and vegetable than days of pure protein, but overall it works well for me. I'm rarely ever hungery and have lots of energy. Have about 12 pounds to go to hit what Dr Dukan says is my true weight, but would like to lose about 10 pounds more than that. There is a facebook page (dukan facebook US) that is very encouraging to follow. I plan to try to stay off the grains even once I go to Consolidation or at least stick with gluten free grains. I think the Consolidation and Stabilization phases are the most important part of the diet. Almost anyone can lose weight, but keeping it off long term is very hard. I would never have started this plan if it wasn't for the step by step instructions in those two phases.0
-
WEBMD REVIEW:
There is no question this very restrictive diet will lead to weight loss, if you can actually follow it. But the elimination of healthy food groups, and the unpleasant side effects, makes The Dukan Diet an unlikely choice for the long haul.
Protein is an essential part of a healthy diet, but it cannot stand alone. A truly healthy diet includes all the food groups -- vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and low-fat dairy and healthy fats along with lean protein. Your body needs the nutrients these foods provide.
Skip this fad diet. Instead, choose a calorie-controlled eating plan that you can stick with for the long term.0 -
Well done. Bought the book. Too harsh for me. Go for it if its working for you.
And if anyone wants my Dukan book let me know.0 -
WEBMD REVIEW:
There is no question this very restrictive diet will lead to weight loss, if you can actually follow it. But the elimination of healthy food groups, and the unpleasant side effects, makes The Dukan Diet an unlikely choice for the long haul.
Protein is an essential part of a healthy diet, but it cannot stand alone. A truly healthy diet includes all the food groups -- vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and low-fat dairy and healthy fats along with lean protein. Your body needs the nutrients these foods provide.
Skip this fad diet. Instead, choose a calorie-controlled eating plan that you can stick with for the long term.
i read this review, it seems to be written by someone who has never followed or even read the diet book. every other day i eat plenty of veg, i eat low fat dairy every day and i also eat healthy fats in the form of oily fish and extra virgin olive oil, all allowed on the dukan diet. i also eat goji berries so i get my fruit intake with those, as well as the tomatoes i eat. this in addition to the lean protein doesnt end up excluding much but starchy carbs, which, are reintroduced. calorie controlled eating plans work really well for some people, but dukan works equally as well for others. random web reviews dont tell the whole story.0 -
bump0
-
I really want to try this diet. I have PCOS and think it would really help me!
BUT I have a BAD addiction to pop. I've been drinking diet just fine, but I'm worried about just lean meats and water on the attack phase.
Would the Crystal Light green tea raspberry on the go hurt to put in my water bottles during the attack phase?0 -
I really want to try this diet. I have PCOS and think it would really help me!
BUT I have a BAD addiction to pop. I've been drinking diet just fine, but I'm worried about just lean meats and water on the attack phase.
Would the Crystal Light green tea raspberry on the go hurt to put in my water bottles during the attack phase?
on attack phase you can have fat free dairy as well, skimmed milk, you have to have oat bran every day, and you can have a couple cans of diet pop. i did an it didnt harm me. i know some people are very strict on the diet but id suggest trying things out to see what works for you. for example, i shouldnt drink atall during cruise phase, but i do have a vodka diet coke or three when i want to and im still losing!!
o yes- MAKE sure you drink your water- it really helps0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 421 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions