How do you report a group?
SuperSexyDork
Posts: 1,669 Member
I have a small group on here that I started for hypoglycemia. Yesterday when I went to check on it, I noticed a new group called "Very Low Calorie Dieting." By very low, it seems to mean the most anyone eats on there is 1100 calories.
I know this sort of thing is against MFP's guidelines but how do I report it?
Unfortunately I do feel like I'm sticking my nose in the business of other people but as a person who was once anorexic and currently struggles with ensuring that I eat enough, this is a major thing for me. It's not healthy and no one should be encouraging this. NO ONE.
I know this sort of thing is against MFP's guidelines but how do I report it?
Unfortunately I do feel like I'm sticking my nose in the business of other people but as a person who was once anorexic and currently struggles with ensuring that I eat enough, this is a major thing for me. It's not healthy and no one should be encouraging this. NO ONE.
0
Replies
-
Your concern is understandable based on your personal history, but I cannot see where this would be against any site rules.
??0 -
I would imagine there are a select number of people on the planet with very low BMR's and high weight loss goals that probably put them in this range.
Not every person fits into every single doctor's chart for what they need and what they should do.
Just my two cents.0 -
Under the MFP community guidlines...
"3. No Promotion of Unsafe Weight-Loss Techniques or Eating Disorders
a) Posts intended to promote potentially unsafe or controversial weight loss products or procedures, including non-medically prescribed supplements or MLM products will be removed without warning.
b) No pro-anorexia or pro-bulimia posts, groups, profile names, or profile bylines. Photos intended to promote or glamorize extreme thinness are also not permitted."
I sincerely believe this is promoting an unsafe weight-loss technique.0 -
not sure where to report it, just check the people in that group are not small and have sedentary life, i.e. under 5ft with a desk job, as an 1100 calorie goal would be normal for a calorie deficit for that type of person.
I'm 5'4", with a desk job, working from home, so I dont even walk to a coffee shop in the day, which means for my height/weight/lifestyle I maintain at 15-1600 calories and need 1200 to create a deficit for dieting.
A low calorie group for concern would be below 1000 cals.0 -
dont know how to report a group but like you do feel concern.0
-
not sure where to report it, just check the people in that group are not small and have sedentary life, i.e. under 5ft with a desk job, as an 1100 calorie goal would be normal for a calorie deficit for that type of person.
I'm 5'4", with a desk job, working from home, so I dont even walk to a coffee shop in the day, which means for my height/weight/lifestyle I maintain at 15-1600 calories and need 1200 to create a deficit for dieting.
A low calorie group for concern would be below 1000 cals.
Some are as low as 800.0 -
I would imagine there are a select number of people on the planet with very low BMR's and high weight loss goals that probably put them in this range.
Not every person fits into every single doctor's chart for what they need and what they should do.
Just my two cents.
The OP is correct.. even in Groups, they must follow all of MFP's guidelines....0 -
Well, if you look at the very bottom of this page you'll see a "Contact Us" link. That would be a good place to start.
You can also message this guy as he is listed as a forum moderator & MFP employee
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/steven0 -
Not everyone who eats 800-110 calories/day is going to develop an eating disorder. I believe your opinion is tainted by your own history. You can report it, but I doubt MFP will make it go away.0
-
Not everyone who eats 800-110 calories/day is going to develop an eating disorder. I believe your opinion is tainted by your own history. You can report it, but I doubt MFP will make it go away.
^^^THIS!!! If you don't like it, don't join the group!!!0 -
Are you sure they aren't using something like HCG? with that you have to eat a very small amount of calories.0
-
It's a group and they don't go on the regular forums promoting this, they are doing the right thing and minding their own business...0
-
It's a group and they don't go on the regular forums promoting this, they are doing the right thing and minding their own business...
Groups are still subject to the same MFP rules that are in place:
Groups
In addition to the Main Forums, MyFitnessPal also offers Groups which contain their own message forums. Group forums are self-moderated. Each group appoints it’s own moderators who are responsible for ensuring the group’s (and MyFitnessPal’s) guidelines are followed. The guidelines below are in two sections: those that apply site-wide, including Groups, and those that apply only to the Main Forums.
Group-Specific Guidelines
21. Groups Can Establish Additional Group-Specific Guidelines
Group Administrators may establish additional guidelines for their Groups as long as they do not interfere with MyFitnessPal’s sitewide guidelines. Members of the group must adhere to these group-specific rules.
22. Group Moderators Must Uphold Site-wide Guidelines
All group moderators are required to uphold the MyFitnessPal site-wide guidelines to the best of their abilities. Failure to do so will result in the loss of their moderator privileges and possibly the shutdown of the group.0 -
It's a group and they don't go on the regular forums promoting this, they are doing the right thing and minding their own business...
Groups are still subject to the same MFP rules that are in place:
Groups
In addition to the Main Forums, MyFitnessPal also offers Groups which contain their own message forums. Group forums are self-moderated. Each group appoints it’s own moderators who are responsible for ensuring the group’s (and MyFitnessPal’s) guidelines are followed. The guidelines below are in two sections: those that apply site-wide, including Groups, and those that apply only to the Main Forums.
Group-Specific Guidelines
21. Groups Can Establish Additional Group-Specific Guidelines
Group Administrators may establish additional guidelines for their Groups as long as they do not interfere with MyFitnessPal’s sitewide guidelines. Members of the group must adhere to these group-specific rules.
22. Group Moderators Must Uphold Site-wide Guidelines
All group moderators are required to uphold the MyFitnessPal site-wide guidelines to the best of their abilities. Failure to do so will result in the loss of their moderator privileges and possibly the shutdown of the group.
Are you part of the group or go in there? If not why do you care? leave them be! they aren't bothering anyone!
Video games made me fat and promote sitting down and watching tv, we should close those groups too while were at it!0 -
1000-1200 is in the normal range for a lot of people.0
-
Unfortunately I do feel like I'm sticking my nose in the business of other people
You could take your nose out of their business.
The group will probably end up getting taken down but a new one will be back up soon, guaranteed. Waste of time reporting it.0 -
I think it's best to leave the decisions up to the people making them. It's nobody's business but their own. You may be alarmed but it's not your choice. Don't make decisions for others. The government gets jealous.0
-
Are they drinking pregnant lady pee? If they are, that's an HCG group so that makes it ok. However, a group promoting annorexia without the pee is against site rules.0
-
Not everyone who eats 800-110 calories/day is going to develop an eating disorder. I believe your opinion is tainted by your own history. You can report it, but I doubt MFP will make it go away.0
-
I agree it is unhealthy. I went and checked it out and most of the people that have posted are eating 800-900 calories a day. Just seems too low to me. But the creator of the group said that if anyone posts in the group disagreeing or trying to argue that it is unhealthy, she will ban them. Not sure if you can report a group.. Or even if they would take it down.0
-
I think it's best to leave the decisions up to the people making them. It's nobody's business but their own. You may be alarmed but it's not your choice. Don't make decisions for others. The government gets jealous.
So true.0 -
Your concern is understandable based on your personal history, but I cannot see where this would be against any site rules.
??
From the guidelines page:
3. No Promotion of Unsafe Weight-Loss Techniques or Eating Disorders
a) Posts intended to promote potentially unsafe or controversial weight loss products or procedures, including non-medically prescribed supplements or MLM products will be removed without warning.
b) No pro-anorexia or pro-bulimia posts, groups, profile names, or profile bylines. Photos intended to promote or glamorize extreme thinness are also not permitted.0 -
There are people who are very restriced for their intake. We don't always k now what their medical history is. My intake was modified because of health reasons. I hate to think I would be bloced for doing what the dr request from the dietitian. Sometimes it's best not to judge others. I understand because of your problem. They are hurting no one if it's a medical condition. Just my two cents worth. It doesn't concern me cause it doesn't affect me. It's their life.0
-
Not everyone who eats 800-110 calories/day is going to develop an eating disorder. I believe your opinion is tainted by your own history. You can report it, but I doubt MFP will make it go away.
I concur. There are also those who are under physicians care.
According to the same logic - I'm leading to anorexia because I never consume more than 900 calories.
Guess what? I'm not. But my private medical history isn't your business.0 -
Are you the Internet police?0
-
Are you the Internet police?
^^0 -
I've reported this to a site moderator.
I inadvertently reported it initially to the moderator of the group itself, and didn't get very far. But I did get a *charming* pm from the group host. A lovely lady. Very warm.0 -
It's a valid concern. I'm sure the mods check up on things like this, and I'm sure pro-ana groups pop up all the time, whether this is one of them or not...
You never know what the situation is, though, and some people may be on their way to surgery and told by the doctor to eat 800-1200. For most people it's not recommended, but some may be on HCG, as stated, or some may be under doctor's orders....
I can understand why you would be worried and trying to look out for other people so they don't have to go through the same thing you have. Ignore the snarks, we have a bunch of know it alls here who don't like to see from anyone else's point of view. :P
We can all be like that from time to time, though. I'm glad you're concerned but I don't think there's anything we can really do about it.0 -
Maybe there "Little people".
0 -
Are you the Internet police?
^^0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions