Favorite 'Strange' Sandwich
Replies
-
I use to have mushy pea sandwiches in my early twenties and loved them, I love just lettuce sandwiches
One of my sister's ex's use to buy a greggs sandwich and a pie and put the pie in with the sandwich, he had it all the time.0 -
hmmmm..not sure that its weird....we have a sandwich joint in town that has "lowrider" black beans, avocado, turkey, cream cheese, salsa, sprouts, and lettuce, tomato onion, on wheat. SOOOO good! I will say though that my addiction to avocado is bordering on weird. I eat it every day.0
-
Peanut butter and banana!
one day I want to try chocolate silk peanut butter on my PB&B!
Peanut butter and banana is not strange its EPIC! especially on seeded bread mm mmmmm mmmmmmmmm0 -
Peanut butter, bananas, and honey on white bread OR ham, swiss cheese, and mustard with potato chips on top. Yum! Neither of these I eat anymore because both are pretty unhealthy, but boy were they good!!! Oh and I forgot about peanut butter and marshmallow fluff!0
-
Two slices of toasted bread with bacon and LOTS of mustard. Mmmm! I haven't had one in years, which is probably a good thing!
I also love potato salad sandwiches. Carbs...nom nom nom!0 -
this is grossing me out.0
-
I love a good grilled peanut butter sandwich dunked in ketchup! Delish! I also like cucumber/mayo sanwiches or lettuce/mayo sandwiches, tomato/mayo sandwiches, pickels and either mayo or butter (though I haven't eaten on in years), peanut butter and chocolate chips sandwiches, peanut butter and maple syrup sandwiches, peanut butter, marshmallow cream, and chocolate syrup sancdwiches, I could go on......0
-
i don't eat this now because of my diet... but i would make a pb&j sandwich and put pretzels on it... than i would dip it like a cookie into milk.. best thing in life!!0
-
Once upon a time, it was PB, Bologna and Wavy Lays!0
-
Mayo and radish sandwich!0
-
french fries on my cheesburgers
roast beef, onion (diced sweet) and cheetos0 -
One time when I was young (8 or 10?), I was complaining about being hungry. My dad offered to make me lunch, but I couldn't decide what to eat. Frustrated, he said, I'll make you a sandwich and you are going to eat it.
He made me the following:
Wheat bread
Bologna
Peanut butter & jelly
Raw onion
Mustard
It was one of the most horrendous things I've ever tasted. Definitely strange!0 -
i used to love , after Thanksgiving, leftover stuffing and cranberry sauce sandwiches. Mmmm! Also peanut butter and alfalfa sprouts sandwich. Sounds weird, but very tasty.0
-
When I was a kid, my mother made us butter and sugar sammiches....no wonder I got fat!!!! :grumble:0
-
I like ham, crushed pineapple, bbq sauce, and swiss cheese on sourdough!
sounds like a hawaiian pizza:)0 -
fig butter (trader joes)
cream cheese
OM NOM NOM0 -
Wonder Bread, butter, cucumbers, white vinegar, salt & pepper. Peanut Butter & Lettuce. Nutella & Bacon.0
-
not really a sandwich but, onion bagel with cream cheese and cheddar pringles smashed on top! Good on Cinn Raisin too!
I love chips/cheese curls on my sandwiches, gotta have that crunch!0 -
Yes...I used to eat Peanut Butter and Mayo sandwiches!
And mayo and tomato is num too!
My husband used to eat his pizza slices between 2 slices of buttered bread back in the day.....holy carbs!0 -
Mashed avocado with ranch dressing & lettuce on toast. Yum!
Also at Quiznos (haven't been in a while though) Wheat with turkey, lettuce, swiss cheese, pickles, and garlic powder (none of the oregano mix), and EXTRA Chipotle Mayo. Super spicy but ssssooooo good!0 -
I have always been made fun of for my love of "strange" food concoctions. Some of my favorites are:
-Salami, mustard, cheese and pickles on a hot dog bun
-Grilled cheeses with ketchup
-Cheese and mayo sandwich dunked into salsa and then dunked into sour cream
-Cheese sandwich with mayo stuffed with sour cream and onion chips
Strangely, I never craved this food when I was pregnant. When I was pregnant it was hash brown patties with cheese, salsa, and sour cream. These were just my "I'm an adolescent who can eat this crap without gaining a ton of weight" foods. My current weight may make more sense after reviewing these food choices, lol0 -
A toasted bacon and strawberry jam sandwich is a favorite of mine. I learned that from my mother though, it was one of her faves while I was growing up.0
-
well years ago I ate bread and butter pickles and cheese as a sandwich and used to eat lettuce and mayo sandwiches. STill love a good fluffenutter (PB and Fluff) now the strange thing I eat is liverwurst and mustard on white bread. omg so good I could eat them everyday! but I don't lol
my dad used to eat PB and mayo. my mom used to eat tomato and mayo. and my sister used to eat raw onion and mayo sandwiches.0 -
Growing up we used to eat peanut butter, miracle whip and lettuce. Or if we had leftover baked beans, we'd have them cold on bread spread with margarine.
I love peanut butter on dill pickles, I've never made a sandwich out of it (will have to try it).
I also eat my tuna prepared with low fat miracle whip in a slice of bread spread with peanut butter. My whole family thinks it is disgusting I'd NEVER put pickles in my tuna though, that would be crossing the line!0 -
I love me a Peanut Butter and Pickle Sandwich, and no, I'm not pregnant
The peanut but has to be smooth and the pickle has to be dill, no garlic...... SO GOOD!
Anyone else like the Peanut Butter Pickle? Or any thing else that might be considered strange?
Totally!! I have to eat them in secret or my husband thinks I am a crazy person! I also love marmite and cucumber sandwiches0 -
Butter, strawberry jam, dill pickle, on sourdough. It's life changing.0
-
Peanut butter and bologna.0
-
Peanut Butter & Banana on Wheat. Sometimes I toast the bread and the peanut but is all melty, YUM!
Tomato & Mustard.
Cheese & Pickles. (American cheese & Sweet Pickles)
What kind of pickles do you put on the Peanut butter sandwiches? sweet?0 -
Toasted blueberry bagel, cream cheese, and ham!!! NOMTASTICALLY DELICIOUS!!!0
-
My wife always makes me eat them in a room far far away from her, but I've always liked peanut butter on my hot dogs instead of mayo, mustard, or ketchup.
She didn't talk to me for a few hours after I let my son try one and he loved it. Now both of us have to eat them in a separate room.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions