Limiting myself to 1500 calories. Too much sugar though?
Replies
-
Agree with a lot of the information given in this thread...unless it's a good carb bad carb comment.
OP: I started my diet taking in 2875 calories a day and constantly lost 1lbs a week...when ever I would go 2 weeks without losing anything, I'd drop my calories some. Now I'm taking in 2250cals a day and still losing 1lb a week. I don't feel like I'm on a diet at all. I always feel full actually lol. But if the numbers on the scale keep dropping and you can eat more, why not do it? I'd rather be satisfied with my lifestyle than feel starved for a "quick fix" that can do more harm than good.0 -
Try adding in fruit smoothies, or yoghurt, or have another weetabix at around 9pm.
Do not think about it has dieting too much, think of it more has healthy eating and just chanigng eating habits of a lifetime.0 -
Trust me if you have your calories that low you will not be able to keep it up and you will most likely give up. Think about it in the long term. Picture yourself where you want to be in six months or a year. In a year, eating a lot more calories than 1500 you could definitely lose 60 lbs. check out fat2fitradio.com and find out how many calories you need to eat. I was shocked when I lost and continued to lose weight at 2100 feeling no discomfort or hunger. It's a great feeling when you realize there's no rush and you feel like you could do it for a very long time without feeling like you're missing out! Good luck!0
-
Carbs are great when they are good carbs!
This is when any and all of your credibility was lost. A carbohydrate is a carbohydrate. You can paint it, dress it up, call it a different name, or whatever you please but the end result is still the same thing. It's going to become glucose molecules and insulin will spike. Carbs and insulin make you fat and keep you fat. Plain and simple.
Excess calories make you fat. Protein is insulinogenic too. Carbs do not make you fat or keep you fat in the absence of an energy surplus.
Gluconeogenesis only happens to protein when more protein is consumed than fat. If fat is the most plentiful then fat will be utilized.
Yes, they do. Clearly you do not understand how insulin works.0 -
^ brb getting fat in an energy deficit because I am a wizard.0
-
Where should I add extra calories and what?
Almonds, raw. Almond butter with organic celery sticks or carrot sticks.
Boiled eggs try 2 per day.
Protein powder mixed with coconut milk (So delicious brand is good) or dairy if dairy doesn't bother you.
Greek yogurt (if you eat dairy), low sugar or plain type
Larabar (nuts+dates) very good protein bar esp for workouts
You prob should have 2000 cals a day for being a guy and size-wise. Your diet looks good, you can always up the protein and veggies, though.0 -
^ brb getting fat in an energy deficit because I am a wizard.
You're an idiot. Thermodynamics don't even apply to the human body because energy expenditure is impossible to measure firstly. Calories are useless, and counting them is useless. Macronutrients are what matter.
Also, I'll take your ignorant, sarcastic reply as an admission of knowing nothing about the mechanisms of insulin or anything about endocrinology at all.0 -
Your personal attacks do not lend credibility to your misunderstanding of thermodynamics or your rather Taubsian view. But on a more serious note, I'm posting from my phone and I don't have the ability to reply thoroughly, but I can do so later.0
-
I'm very committed to losing the weight and getting healthy. When i have been thinner i have been happier it is that simple.
What i find hard to grasp is the fact that i'm able to eat pretty much what i was before starting the plan. I ate a full fat yoghurt this evening as i still had 500 calories left for the day (basing that on 1930). I'll be adding some nuts into my day from tomorrow too so i should get my calories up.
My nutrient details today are saying i have 34g of carbs left for the day but i am -7 on dietary fibre and -58 on sugars. I also have 30g of fat left with 9g of sat fat left. The only thing i feel i'm missing is some sweet things yet i'm already over on my sugars. Would say a Ryvita cracker and some cheese be a good snack for evening time?
I had Spaghetti bolognase tonight made from lean minced beef, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and a low fat bologanse sauce. Pasta was whole wheat.
Looking at the fat2fitradio.com site they recommend 2478 calories a day!
With still 320 calories remaining today i'm struggling to get them in. Admittedly i could of ate a chocolate bar at some point in the day but surely that isn;t the right choice? Bearing in mind i'm not a big vegetable eater and try to steer away from traditional vegtables such as broccoi, cabbage, cauliflower and the like.
I'm making a home made chili chicken balti tomorrow for dinner.0 -
If you're trying to make a point, I missed it. Once you have a degree in physics or nutrition, your word is credible. Until then, you're just a guy on the internet spreading broscience to people who don't know any better.
Oh please spare me your wikipedia regurgitation. Thanks.0 -
Just worry about your total calories, you will be fine
0 -
In my opinion, people are stressing too many opinions and minor details... everyone is different. Recommended weight loss by medical professionals is 1-2 pounds per week, it is possible to lose faster and slower, but everyone makes it too complicated for people new to losing weight.
Truth is keep your calories under what you burn. If you want to lose faster and can do so without effecting how you feel, then lower more or exercise more... Good Luck! The lifestyle being healthy will grant you will more than pay for the effort it takes to get there 0 -
the fruit choices are high in sugar content, if you want to eat fruit eat non tropical fruits like apples, melons, citris fruits. I know you dont like to eat vegetables but in order to lose the fat you are going to have to eat them to take in enough good healthy calories.0
-
In my opinion, people are stressing too many opinions and minor details... everyone is different. Recommended weight loss by medical professionals is 1-2 pounds per week, it is possible to lose faster and slower, but everyone makes it too complicated for people new to losing weight.
Truth is keep your calories under what you burn. If you want to lose faster and can do so without effecting how you feel, then lower more or exercise more... Good Luck! The lifestyle being healthy will grant you will more than pay for the effort it takes to get there
Okay, I understand you're well intentioned and you just want to help this guy out and I really respect that but seriously calories are just a number, they don't mean anything. If all of his calories are coming from ice cream, don't you think his body would handle that differently than if it came from vegetables or meat?
The energy in/energy out theory has been disproven on several occasions and its more important to look at what drives fat accumulation and lipolysis than it is to consistently be counting calories.0 -
the fruit choices are high in sugar content, if you want to eat fruit eat non tropical fruits like apples, melons, citris fruits. I know you dont like to eat vegetables but in order to lose the fat you are going to have to eat them to take in enough good healthy calories.
This is not true. Hit your macros. end thread.0 -
If you're trying to make a point, I missed it. Once you have a degree in physics or nutrition, your word is credible. Until then, you're just a guy on the internet spreading broscience to people who don't know any better.
Oh please spare me your wikipedia regurgitation. Thanks.
0 -
In my opinion, people are stressing too many opinions and minor details... everyone is different. Recommended weight loss by medical professionals is 1-2 pounds per week, it is possible to lose faster and slower, but everyone makes it too complicated for people new to losing weight.
Truth is keep your calories under what you burn. If you want to lose faster and can do so without effecting how you feel, then lower more or exercise more... Good Luck! The lifestyle being healthy will grant you will more than pay for the effort it takes to get there
Okay, I understand you're well intentioned and you just want to help this guy out and I really respect that but seriously calories are just a number, they don't mean anything. If all of his calories are coming from ice cream, don't you think his body would handle that differently than if it came from vegetables or meat?
The energy in/energy out theory has been disproven on several occasions and its more important to look at what drives fat accumulation and lipolysis than it is to consistently be counting calories.
Can you provide some examples of the energy balance equation being disproven?0 -
Thing is I need to loose a considerably large amount of weight. 60 - 70 pounds at least. If I ate 1930 calories I don't think i'd feel I was on a diet at all. I'm having three meals a day as it is and i'm not hungry
I agree with the other posts - eating too little will not help you. You do not have to feel deprived, and you shouldn't be deprived of food - just eat good stuff!
Big lesson I have learnt - this is NOT A "DIET" - you are learning to eat well as your body needs, not what your head says!! I have lost a lot of weight since Christmas and still eat lots, but I eat better choices - I am on 1200 cals per day (but I am a 60 yo sedentary woman, 5'6 1/2") - you look like a big guy, only 31, so your body needs those calories.
Trust MFP to provide you with the right numbers - as long as you have been truthful and put in all your height / weight etc correctly - I would say eat well within what MFP suggests for at least a month or two, get some exercise - and you don't have to kill yourself, just move more - and see what happens.
Re the sugar - I know if I have two pieces of fruit my sugar is over, and whilst this is a controversial topic, sugar is sugar is sugar - but at least if you get sugar from fruit it comes with vitamins, minerals, fibre. Fruit juice is a way to quickly pile on sugar so in my opinion I would avoid juices. Don't have added sugar if you can avoid it, avoid processed food as much as possible, eat lots of vegies and good protein. Plan your day - put in ahead what you think you will eat, or want to eat, and see what it comes out at - eating good snacks during the day also helps - almonds are a great way to get some healthy nibbling done!
Good luck with your weight loss - I wish my son would join MFP and do this like you are. Looking forward to seeing good results from you 0 -
:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:0 -
What would happen if you ate a diet with over 70% of cals coming from carbs and 43% of your cals came in the form of sucrose, but you were in a caloric deficit?0
-
{~~~ no degree in physics but i do know that I have lost 92 pounds and i did it by COUNTING CALORIES and lifting heavy things...I think if you're trying gain muscle or cut then there are different things to look at but this guy is wanting to drop weight and if he fuels his body with x amount of calories and moves more he WILL LOSE. Now go roid rage somewhere else cumquat0
-
Can you provide some examples of the energy balance equation being disproven?
would like to see this also.0 -
If you're trying to make a point, I missed it. Once you have a degree in physics or nutrition, your word is credible. Until then, you're just a guy on the internet spreading broscience to people who don't know any better.
Oh please spare me your wikipedia regurgitation. Thanks.
LMFOA; I don't think I have ever seen Sidesteal use Wikipedia as a reference source here!0 -
{~~~ no degree in physics but i do know that I have lost 92 pounds and i did it by COUNTING CALORIES and lifting heavy things...I think if you're trying gain muscle or cut then there are different things to look at but this guy is wanting to drop weight and if he fuels his body with x amount of calories and moves more he WILL LOSE. Now go roid rage somewhere else cumquat
I think "and lifting heavy things" should be emphasized instead of the former because that is what matters.
Roid rage? Oh lord. Give me a break *kitten*.
All of you, should try reading a book for once in your life.
Gary Taubes explains why thermodynamics don't apply in both of his books AND all of his presentations. Educate yourselves.0 -
If you're trying to make a point, I missed it. Once you have a degree in physics or nutrition, your word is credible. Until then, you're just a guy on the internet spreading broscience to people who don't know any better.
Oh please spare me your wikipedia regurgitation. Thanks.
LMFOA; I don't think I have ever seen Sidesteal use Wikipedia as a reference source here!
How adorable, your minions are fighting your battles for you.0 -
In my opinion, people are stressing too many opinions and minor details... everyone is different. Recommended weight loss by medical professionals is 1-2 pounds per week, it is possible to lose faster and slower, but everyone makes it too complicated for people new to losing weight.
Truth is keep your calories under what you burn. If you want to lose faster and can do so without effecting how you feel, then lower more or exercise more... Good Luck! The lifestyle being healthy will grant you will more than pay for the effort it takes to get there
Okay, I understand you're well intentioned and you just want to help this guy out and I really respect that but seriously calories are just a number, they don't mean anything. If all of his calories are coming from ice cream, don't you think his body would handle that differently than if it came from vegetables or meat?
The energy in/energy out theory has been disproven on several occasions and its more important to look at what drives fat accumulation and lipolysis than it is to consistently be counting calories.
Why do people such as you always, and I mean always, push things to an idiotic extreme. NO ONE is saying just eat ice cream, but are all, as far as I can see saying a bowl of ice cream is not going to destroy your weight loss as long as your body is in an energy deficit. You are spouting things that really need peer reviewed research papers to back them up, so provide them. I am sure that others you are discounting for not having a degree can do so since I have seen them do it before.0 -
In my opinion, people are stressing too many opinions and minor details... everyone is different. Recommended weight loss by medical professionals is 1-2 pounds per week, it is possible to lose faster and slower, but everyone makes it too complicated for people new to losing weight.
Truth is keep your calories under what you burn. If you want to lose faster and can do so without effecting how you feel, then lower more or exercise more... Good Luck! The lifestyle being healthy will grant you will more than pay for the effort it takes to get there
Okay, I understand you're well intentioned and you just want to help this guy out and I really respect that but seriously calories are just a number, they don't mean anything. If all of his calories are coming from ice cream, don't you think his body would handle that differently than if it came from vegetables or meat?
The energy in/energy out theory has been disproven on several occasions and its more important to look at what drives fat accumulation and lipolysis than it is to consistently be counting calories.
Why do people such as you always, and I mean always, push things to an idiotic extreme. NO ONE is saying just eat ice cream, but are all, as far as I can see saying a bowl of ice cream is not going to destroy your weight loss as long as your body is in an energy deficit. You are spouting things that really need peer reviewed research papers to back them up, so provide them. I am sure that others you are discounting for not having a degree can do so since I have seen them do it before.
Cuz calories is calories bro.
Duh. I mean since calories are the only thing that matter, right?0 -
Agree with a lot of the information given in this thread...unless it's a good carb bad carb comment.
OP: I started my diet taking in 2875 calories a day and constantly lost 1lbs a week...when ever I would go 2 weeks without losing anything, I'd drop my calories some. Now I'm taking in 2250cals a day and still losing 1lb a week. I don't feel like I'm on a diet at all. I always feel full actually lol. But if the numbers on the scale keep dropping and you can eat more, why not do it? I'd rather be satisfied with my lifestyle than feel starved for a "quick fix" that can do more harm than good.
^ This.
Listen to him.0 -
So if I write a book about the likely hood of pigs being able to fly in 2013 would that make it fact? There are lots of different books about health0
-
I'm not a big vegetable eater and also trying to find the time to exercise at the moment is hard. I have a fairly active job and work nearly 6 days most Weeks also have two young kids so time is of the essence!
Good news! You have two built in gyms! Kids are great for helping you get exercise. They make messes that you have to clean up, they are never where they are supposed to be so you have to walk around looking for them, they either are driving you nuts to go outside and run around or they really need for their health to go outside and run around, and they are competitive little boogers. "Who can run faster me or Mom? Let's race around the block. I bet I can do more jumping jacks than you. Push me higher, higher, I said HIGHER." My 4 year is convinced that every time we go up the stairs at home it is a race. I don't super love all veggies either but I found some that I do like and I eat them a lot. I like tomatoes, edamame, cucumbers, Brussels sprouts, and peppers.
I am 5'4, weigh 136.5 lbs and eat nearly 1600 calories a day, consistently losing 0.5-1 lbs per week. It is mind-numbingly simple though I freely admit to eating something chocolate nearly every day.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions