We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Running or Elliptical

13»

Replies

  • muddyventures
    muddyventures Posts: 360 Member
    Why just choose one? I prefer running but a hip injury has forced me to add to my exercise. Do both!
  • BrunetteRunner87
    BrunetteRunner87 Posts: 591 Member
    Started out only doing the elliptical, that's how I lost the bulk of my weight, but I can't stand it anymore. The only cardio I can do now is running outside!
  • MzMandi1025
    MzMandi1025 Posts: 78 Member
    I used to love the eliptical, but my trainer told me that running is much better for you. So I started power walking/jogging on the treadmill & I noticed a huge difference. I've found that I burn more calories in 20 minuets on the treadmill than I do 30 min on the elpitical.
    Just curious, why wait until you're under the 200 mark?

    Good question! I think it's more of a mental thing. Because I am seeing such good results on the elliptical I wanna keep that up until I reach a certain goal. And maybe those 6-7 lbs wouldn't be as hard on my knees lol

    I do the "hills" intervals on the ellitpical so it's not just one setting/level the full 20-30 minutes that I'm on there. I sweat like crazy on that thing. It's actually quite embarassing some days :blushing:

    Ok, I see. I have a friend that uses the eliptical because she has bad knees, it makes it hard for her to run. Maybe start out at a half mile. I'm 214 right now & I really hate running, but I can't deny the benefits, especially since I've noticed such a change in my endurance. I was an eliptical buff until my trainer said that I really needed to start jogging. At first, I couldn't get past a half mile & even then, I did more walking than jogging. Then, just to get myself started, I remembered something they had us do in Junior High/High school when we had to run the mile for PE. I would use the track setting on the eliptical, then walk the curves, & jog the straights. That's really helped a lot. I'm hoping that soon, I'll be able to jog an entire lap without stopping & just work my way up from there.
  • mandeiko
    mandeiko Posts: 1,657 Member
    I used to only do elliptical, until I could literally go an hour without breaking a sweat. I wasn't losing weight, either...never really did with the elliptical.

    Then, at 270 pounds I started running. I could only run a minute at a time, if even that.

    Now, I weigh 189 and I can run 3+ miles at a time without stopping.

    No question...running was better for me.

    That's a heck of an accomplishment!! Congrats!! You ROCK! :drinker:
  • msgunder
    msgunder Posts: 65 Member
    I tried it! I jogged off and on at the gym today. I warmed up for 5 mins by walking and then I would jog for 60 secs and then walk for 90 secs until I got to only 4 minutes left. Then I walked to cool down. I was a bag of sweat by the time I got done! It about killed me and I could barely make my minute jogs sometimes but I'll keep pushing.

    Thanks for everyone's advice/opinions!!

    :drinker:
  • SparkleHorse224
    SparkleHorse224 Posts: 98 Member
    Personally, my philosophy is...why run unless you are being chased by A BEAR??

    That said...someone pointed out to me that on programs like The Biggest Loser, people who take up running lose more weight and do better.

    I do the Couch to 5K program (I think it's now 'Ease into 5K' or some such).
This discussion has been closed.

Categories