Am I seriously obese? 41% Body Fat
Replies
-
There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.0
-
There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.
This is a zombie thread :P1 -
Everything is rubbish & everyone has a differing opinion...haven't you noticed that? Lol...i am currently 238 pounds and guess what? I'm 43% body fat! And there is quite a big difference between our physiques! So don't worry about anything luv...you're ok as long as you feel you are! If you want to make improvements than by all means do it. But don't worry so much about #s or opinions.
You're new to the forums, so I'll try to be nice about this -- don't necromance threads. This thread died 2 years ago. For the general forums, the limit is generally just a couple of weeks (no more than a month, but even longer than about 2 weeks is questionable and you should really consider the response you're making). The groups are more forgiving, since they're not usually as active. A good rule of thumb could be that the more active a forum is, the shorter the expiration time for threads.
You'll "try" to be nice about this? Lol if someone responding to an old thread made you "try to be nice" in your response then you should re-examine your priorities perhaps. It happens all the time and it's really not that serious. Thread police :laugh:7 -
Based on the limited pics in your profile, I'd peg you around 30-32% BF, not 41.
Although I use a similar device to measure my BF, I use it more to see a trend than the actual number. Although I did compare my device to a DEXA back in DEcember, and the DEXA indicated 2% BF lower than my scale, so the scale wasn't far off.0 -
I feel the sam way. I am 5'9 weigh 215 lbs and I am considered obese based on my BMI. I dont think I "look" obese but I guess that term is relative. someone who has been of a healthy weight their whole life might look at me an say I am obese but to me I was never "obese". oh well, I have to lose 16 more lbs to be considered "overweight" and not obese.
0 -
Everything is rubbish & everyone has a differing opinion...haven't you noticed that? Lol...i am currently 238 pounds and guess what? I'm 43% body fat! And there is quite a big difference between our physiques! So don't worry about anything luv...you're ok as long as you feel you are! If you want to make improvements than by all means do it. But don't worry so much about #s or opinions.
You're new to the forums, so I'll try to be nice about this -- don't necromance threads. This thread died 2 years ago. For the general forums, the limit is generally just a couple of weeks (no more than a month, but even longer than about 2 weeks is questionable and you should really consider the response you're making). The groups are more forgiving, since they're not usually as active. A good rule of thumb could be that the more active a forum is, the shorter the expiration time for threads.
You'll "try" to be nice about this? Lol if someone responding to an old thread made you "try to be nice" in your response then you should re-examine your priorities perhaps. It happens all the time and it's really not that serious. Thread police :laugh:
Considering my initial response was "holy thread necromancy, Batman!" and I decided to be nice by not teasing and instead be straightforward, yes, it was me being nice. Normally, I don't care if people respond to older threads, even ones that are a month old or three old, but 2 years dead is a "bit" much by anyone's standards. You have to really dig to get to a thread that old, especially on a forum as active as MFP's General Diet and Weight Loss Help section.2 -
I am just now 41% down from 67%. Im also shocked but in a different way! Ill take the 41 Alex! 😂 I almost had a heart attack when the Dr. Told me I was at 67% and if I didnt lose weight I probably really would have a heart attack! Hope you get a 2nd opinion. That trainer sounds unethical! Ive worked with two diffrent trainers and neither has pushed pills or supplements on me. Only suggestions and they were not the sellers.2
-
There is NO WAY youre at 41%. Just saw your pics! Im 41% and our pics are No where in the same ballpark! Just saying! If youre obese them Im still Morbidly Obese! 😂🤷🏼♀️😏 But headed in the right direction! Thats what matters💪hang in there.2
-
15 -
LaMujerMasBonitaDelMundo wrote: »Don't listen to that trainer, he obviously is just trying to sell you something. Also as far as I know, they're not supposed to sell supplements or something, that is against the practice. About the 41% body fat, I suggest that you get a second opinion using either calipers or if you have money, do the gold standard such as hydrostatic weigh-in or DEXA scan. Handheld devices are one of the least accurate methods although as the above poster said, all body fat analysis are inaccurate & they just give you estimates.
This exactly^^^2 -
palmerig88 wrote: »TrTry putting your measurements into the military body fat % calculator on fat2fitradio.com and try again in a month or two
This is also a good idea2 -
shaynak112 wrote: »First, that's ridiculous.
Second, you have a gorgeous body. I want to look like that! Seriously though, you're about 10 lbs lighter than I am and I'd love to get rid of 10 lbs
I agree2 -
shaynak112 wrote: »First, that's ridiculous.
Second, you have a gorgeous body. I want to look like that! Seriously though, you're about 10 lbs lighter than I am and I'd love to get rid of 10 lbs
I agree
It's been 7 years since they posted, I don't think they care if you agree or not...5 -
How are all these zombie threads getting dug up? I'm seeing a lot lately.0
-
-
sassyjae21 wrote: »There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.
This is a zombie thread :P
Haha, it was a zombie in 2014. Now it is ULTIMATE ZOMBIE!!!!!
4 -
born_of_fire74 wrote: »sassyjae21 wrote: »There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.
This is a zombie thread :P
Haha, it was a zombie in 2014. Now it is ULTIMATE ZOMBIE!!!!!
Zombie squared
1 -
And I sent someone a Hug before I realised. Grrr!1
-
shaynak112 wrote: »First, that's ridiculous.
Second, you have a gorgeous body. I want to look like that! Seriously though, you're about 10 lbs lighter than I am and I'd love to get rid of 10 lbs
I agree
It's been 7 years since they posted, I don't think they care if you agree or not...
Wow how rude are u. Excuse me for agreeing9 -
Overweight maybe, obese at those numbers doubtful. Based on height you prob should at optimal be 125-135.1
-
shaynak112 wrote: »First, that's ridiculous.
Second, you have a gorgeous body. I want to look like that! Seriously though, you're about 10 lbs lighter than I am and I'd love to get rid of 10 lbs
I agree
It's been 7 years since they posted, I don't think they care if you agree or not...
Wow how rude are u. Excuse me for agreeing
It is not rude to point out this is an old thread and OP is long gone.
There isn't really much point agreeing now.
2 -
That means if you work out the fat you would be left with 98 lbs... so unless you are 4' 5 then the guy is trying to sell you something, or just doing it wrong.
She would have to keep 14-20% BF as an ideal amount to be ideally lean.
41%-20%=21% to get rid of. Which of 162 lbs is 34lbs. 162-34 is 128lbs, assuming she kept all current muscle. That is within a healthy weight because its a 22 BMI.3 -
paperpudding wrote: »shaynak112 wrote: »First, that's ridiculous.
Second, you have a gorgeous body. I want to look like that! Seriously though, you're about 10 lbs lighter than I am and I'd love to get rid of 10 lbs
I agree
It's been 7 years since they posted, I don't think they care if you agree or not...
Wow how rude are u. Excuse me for agreeing
It is not rude to point out this is an old thread and OP is long gone.
There isn't really much point agreeing now.
Precisely.1 -
born_of_fire74 wrote: »sassyjae21 wrote: »There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.
This is a zombie thread :P
Haha, it was a zombie in 2014. Now it is ULTIMATE ZOMBIE!!!!!
I wonder what the thread about if cigarettes had calories would be? That was a bumped thread from 2008.0 -
I hate pushy trainers I had one point out that my arms are flabby like gtfo I didn’t come here to leave feeling worse about myself1
-
OP last logged in November 2018. Maybe @half_moon will come back and update us.0
-
kellyjellybellyjelly wrote: »born_of_fire74 wrote: »sassyjae21 wrote: »There is no way you're at 41% body fat... I was ALOT bigger than you and I was at like 34-35% when I started.
This is a zombie thread :P
Haha, it was a zombie in 2014. Now it is ULTIMATE ZOMBIE!!!!!
I wonder what the thread about if cigarettes had calories would be? That was a bumped thread from 2008.
MEGA ZOMBIE!!!!!!!1 -
that doesn't sound right. I'm 5'4 155 and 27% body fat0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions