Which one is the most attractive to you?

tubbyelmo

25%

EatClenTrenHard

15-17
15-17
15-17
15-17

GabyG69

20-25

RhonndaJ

30%, but anything between 20 - 35 looks good.

And I'm going to stress that I'm just talking about the pictures posted, age and attitude can change things.

lovelyrose11

30%

ColoD2013

15 - 35. All those look healthy

JenKillough

I like 15-22% and possibly a little higher for some frames...

Chameleone

30!!

JustJennie1

15-17%

michelle850

Anywhere between 20-30 looks good to me!

Meg_78

I like a girl 15-22% It's where I like to be too.

ferrahcn

15

KickassAugust

30% ...dang.

Lisseth03

15-17

elprincipito

15 to 35%!!!

ZoeLifts

I like 15-17%, but I also agree that the 10-12% is an extreme representation.

Just for fun, though, here is a comparison of two different body types at 15%, with the first woman obviously involved in fitness competition and looking very different even from the 15-17% choice given in the original post at a normal state of "rest". Also, you see two different goals, obviously, in the pic below for their to be two different body types.:

ReesesPuffs

Attractiveness goes alot deeper then how much water you can displace in the bath.

Taneil27

25%

Robin_Bin

From these pictures, I'd say 15-35% all look like they're in a healthy range - with 25 and 30% looking the best.

RhonndaJ

And for those who wanted the male version