What's the skinny on squats?
Replies
-
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
QFTouchie...DAT hurt my feelings..0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
This isn't going to be rude. It is not likely that you gain muscle quickly. It is fairly difficult for men to gain muscle and they have a lot more testosterone than women do. Sometimes when you are new to lifting it seems like you are gaining quickly because of water retention, but it will not stick around. Just something to think about if that is what is keeping you from lifting.0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Sweetheart I think you are confused. Stating facts are way different than being rude. Lifting heavy doesn't make women become bulky..sheesh.0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.
0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
QFTouchie...DAT hurt my feelings..
THAT* fixed it for you.
0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.
I am not being rude. I am attacked for sharing what works for me.0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
QFTouchie...DAT hurt my feelings..
THAT* fixed it for you.
Actually...no0 -
It is impossible to argue with those legs.Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.
I am not being rude. I am attacked for sharing what works for me.
No. People are disagreeing with you. Big difference. Just stop already. You had your thread..stop trying to hijack someone else's.0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.
[img]http://i1048.photobucket.com/albums/s379/Jules2Be/IMGP3680-3.jpg[/im [/quot You look awesome.[/img]0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.
I am not being rude. I am attacked for sharing what works for me.
No. People are disagreeing with you. Big difference. Just stop already. You had your thread..stop trying to hijack someone else's.
I will provide what works for me and you guys can disagree with me0 -
I've lifted weights 'seriously' for at least the past 6 years. I've been squatting through most of it. I used to be scared to do any weight. I currently do around 150 lbs for reps. If anything, my legs have gotten smaller over the years as i've put on LBM as opposed to fat. My legs are naturally big, but unless you're trying (eating surplus and training like a beast) squats aren't going to put on mass (if you are in a surplus and training like a beast then mass is exactly what HEAVY squats will do though).
With weight training, muscle size doesn't happen by accident unless you're a genetic (amazing) freak. Who i would be very envious of, by the way.
But if you're still scared to do weighted squats try something like jump squats, those will help "lean" legs out but keep them nice and strong, while giving you some good cardio.
Hey thanks a lot. I could give it a try0 -
I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.
I am not being rude. I am attacked for sharing what works for me.
No. People are disagreeing with you. Big difference. Just stop already. You had your thread..stop trying to hijack someone else's.
I will provide what works for me and you guys can disagree with me
And that's what we are doing. So stop saying we are attacking you or telling others that differing views are going to be rude. -.-
Anyways. BACK to the topic and the OP -
As I said and several others have - you won't get bulky from heavy lifting. And I know that I love lifting just as much as cardio. Both have their benefits and definitely you should have both in your weekly exercise routine 0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.]
You look awesome.
thank you.
ok I am not trying to attack you...I am sure what you do DOES work for you, but it is disheartening when we are trying to break so many myths about weight training and you come in and start saying things that are basically not correct concerning weight training.0 -
1) It is nearly impossible to add muscle mass while in a caloric deficit (aside from slight noob gains).Honestly. Going through these forums drives me crazy, how true is it that squats bulk up/make your thighs larger? I always thought muscle build was dependent on the diet we eat, I'm already eating at a deficit. The squats/lunges I do are part of JM. I have 25/24.5 inch thighs and 38''hips. (I know, humongous). I don't expect to reduce more than 2 inches on them because even if I lose weight all over it's very difficult for me to lose there.
But I love the squats and lunges. I'm more used to cardio so the strength training seems like a challenge. Is it okay for me to continue with this or am I really at a risk of growing larger thighs? I'm a pear.
Thanks in advance!
2) Women have about 1/10 the testosterone of men, which makes adding mass even more difficult without "supplementation" (anabolic/androgenic steroids). Even under optimal diet/training conditions (caloric surplus, adequate protein intake and a heavy lifting routine), women can put on about 1/2 pound of muscle per month. A half-pound a month. Getting hyooge overnight by accident isn't going to happen.
3) You don't gain muscle mass without progressive overload - pushing weights progressively heavier and causing your muscles to have to grow in response to the increased load. Doing squats and lunges to a Jillian exercise video doesn't constitute the kind of strength training routine necessary for hypertrophy (gain in muscle size).
The most likely scenario is a decrease in the size of your thighs due to fat loss (assuming a caloric deficit) and an increase in strength due to neuromuscular adaptation (your nervous system adapting to the stress being placed on it and causing your existing muscle mass to work more efficiently to handle it).
^^this needs to be emphasized.
In addition, squats have a very good metabolic impact and can 'encourage' mobilization of fat from the belly area (no, not spot reduction). Also, strength training in general and specifically compound lifts are a very beneficial to bone density, which is particularly important to women.
What people may see when they start to exercise, and moreso with lifting, is a slight increase in size initially due to glycogen/water retention in the muscle as it repairs itself. It is temporary water weight.0 -
I'm still pretty fat and have been on here eating at a deficit and exercising 5-7 days a week for the past 3 1/2 mths. I have done 5-6 sets of 10 squats with and without weights everyday in that time. My *kitten* and thighs are getting smaller and more toned. I have probably lost the most amount off them.0
-
1) It is nearly impossible to add muscle mass while in a caloric deficit (aside from slight noob gains).Honestly. Going through these forums drives me crazy, how true is it that squats bulk up/make your thighs larger? I always thought muscle build was dependent on the diet we eat, I'm already eating at a deficit. The squats/lunges I do are part of JM. I have 25/24.5 inch thighs and 38''hips. (I know, humongous). I don't expect to reduce more than 2 inches on them because even if I lose weight all over it's very difficult for me to lose there.
But I love the squats and lunges. I'm more used to cardio so the strength training seems like a challenge. Is it okay for me to continue with this or am I really at a risk of growing larger thighs? I'm a pear.
Thanks in advance!
2) Women have about 1/10 the testosterone of men, which makes adding mass even more difficult without "supplementation" (anabolic/androgenic steroids). Even under optimal diet/training conditions (caloric surplus, adequate protein intake and a heavy lifting routine), women can put on about 1/2 pound of muscle per month. A half-pound a month. Getting hyooge overnight by accident isn't going to happen.
3) You don't gain muscle mass without progressive overload - pushing weights progressively heavier and causing your muscles to have to grow in response to the increased load. Doing squats and lunges to a Jillian exercise video doesn't constitute the kind of strength training routine necessary for hypertrophy (gain in muscle size).
The most likely scenario is a decrease in the size of your thighs due to fat loss (assuming a caloric deficit) and an increase in strength due to neuromuscular adaptation (your nervous system adapting to the stress being placed on it and causing your existing muscle mass to work more efficiently to handle it).
^^this needs to be emphasized.
In addition, squats have a very good metabolic impact and can 'encourage' mobilization of fat from the belly area (no, not spot reduction). Also, strength training in general and specifically compound lifts are a very beneficial to bone density, which is particularly important to women.
What people may see when they start to exercise, and moreso with lifting, is a slight increase in size initially due to glycogen/water retention in the muscle as it repairs itself. It is temporary water weight.
^ This is all fantastic information. OP please take the time to read this and ask questions if you need to understand it.
Squatting heavy with a small but reasonable calorie deficit made my butt, hips, and thighs leaner and made me feel amazing. It's good stuff!0 -
I'm still pretty fat and have been on here eating at a deficit and exercising 5-7 days a week for the past 3 1/2 mths. I have done 5-6 sets of 10 squats with and without weights everyday in that time. My *kitten* and thighs are getting smaller and more toned. I have probably lost the most amount off them.
Keep it up!0 -
0 -
Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.]
You look awesome.
thank you.
ok I am not trying to attack you...I am sure what you do DOES work for you, but it is disheartening when we are trying to break so many myths about weight training and you come in and start saying things that are basically not correct concerning weight training.
Truce :-)
Women who lift heavy are awesome to watch.0 -
I'm still pretty fat and have been on here eating at a deficit and exercising 5-7 days a week for the past 3 1/2 mths. I have done 5-6 sets of 10 squats with and without weights everyday in that time. My *kitten* and thighs are getting smaller and more toned. I have probably lost the most amount off them.
Keep it up!
Thanks! Don't worry I will! No turning back I LOVE SQUATS. The improvement in size and strength of my thighs and butt has been incredible. :P 0 -
1) It is nearly impossible to add muscle mass while in a caloric deficit (aside from slight noob gains).Honestly. Going through these forums drives me crazy, how true is it that squats bulk up/make your thighs larger? I always thought muscle build was dependent on the diet we eat, I'm already eating at a deficit. The squats/lunges I do are part of JM. I have 25/24.5 inch thighs and 38''hips. (I know, humongous). I don't expect to reduce more than 2 inches on them because even if I lose weight all over it's very difficult for me to lose there.
But I love the squats and lunges. I'm more used to cardio so the strength training seems like a challenge. Is it okay for me to continue with this or am I really at a risk of growing larger thighs? I'm a pear.
Thanks in advance!
2) Women have about 1/10 the testosterone of men, which makes adding mass even more difficult without "supplementation" (anabolic/androgenic steroids). Even under optimal diet/training conditions (caloric surplus, adequate protein intake and a heavy lifting routine), women can put on about 1/2 pound of muscle per month. A half-pound a month. Getting hyooge overnight by accident isn't going to happen.
3) You don't gain muscle mass without progressive overload - pushing weights progressively heavier and causing your muscles to have to grow in response to the increased load. Doing squats and lunges to a Jillian exercise video doesn't constitute the kind of strength training routine necessary for hypertrophy (gain in muscle size).
The most likely scenario is a decrease in the size of your thighs due to fat loss (assuming a caloric deficit) and an increase in strength due to neuromuscular adaptation (your nervous system adapting to the stress being placed on it and causing your existing muscle mass to work more efficiently to handle it).
^^this needs to be emphasized.
In addition, squats have a very good metabolic impact and can 'encourage' mobilization of fat from the belly area (no, not spot reduction). Also, strength training in general and specifically compound lifts are a very beneficial to bone density, which is particularly important to women.
What people may see when they start to exercise, and moreso with lifting, is a slight increase in size initially due to glycogen/water retention in the muscle as it repairs itself. It is temporary water weight.
^ This is all fantastic information. OP please take the time to read this and ask questions if you need to understand it.
Squatting heavy with a small but reasonable calorie deficit made my butt, hips, and thighs leaner and made me feel amazing. It's good stuff!
Spot on.0 -
/0
-
Bahaha, so because I lift heavy I'm not a busy mother? I think my kids would beg to differ.Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
I just enjoy my workouts.0 -
And I enjoy mine. I LOVE to lift.
Bahaha, so because I lift heavy I'm not a busy mother? I think my kids would beg to differ.Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
I just enjoy my workouts.0 -
I am having Azackery déjà Vu. How much does your purse weigh?I think it depends on a lot of different factors - I tend to gain muscle quickly, so I personally avoid squats, I do variations occasionally, but I too have heard that they bulk you up - best of luck to you!!
I agree with you. You might get some rude remarks. Watch out :-)
Here is a remark and it isn't rude.
As some in previous posts have said - women don't get bulky from heavy lifting.
@Serapi - please stop trying to push negativity into the conversation. It isn't appreciated. Trying to say that whatever remarks to a comment is going to be rude is just rude and sets the wrong mindframe for anyone else that posts. Stop it please.
I am not being rude. I am attacked for sharing what works for me.
No. People are disagreeing with you. Big difference. Just stop already. You had your thread..stop trying to hijack someone else's.
I will provide what works for me and you guys can disagree with me0 -
Pilates have helped in the past. I don't do them everyday, because I'm doing 30DS and BFBM. Pardon if I sound ignorant, I just didn't want to take chances. I love the high I get from strength training and kickboxing, since pilates is more slow and it doesn't give that adrenaline rush you get--- though it has given results (slow ones) in the past.
Are most of the compound movements in 30 DS good for fast results? I'm on Day 13, just lost 2.2 pounds and no inches.0 -
It is impossible to argue with those legs.Workout to be fit. Your gains in muscle size (or lack thereof) isn't determined by reps, weight, etc as much as it is by genetics. For instance, tall slender people will never get bulky muscles through weights. Women with bulky muscles are extremely rare, due to their estrogen levels.
Feel free to hit the weights hard! I'm betting you will love the results.
If someone is happy not lifting heavy, that is all that matters. Some of us are busy mothers and we work out for mental happiness.
Is your mental happiness what's keeping you at your cpu, spewing misinformation left and right? I certainly hope it's helping you, because it's not helping anyone else here
I wish she would stop as well. It is hard enough encouraging people to squat among other things when misinformation is being given,
My legs have continuously gotten smaller and more shapely as I have lost weight an increased the amount of weight I use...I am not bulky...I am eating in a calorie deficit, so am not worried.
feel free to look at some of my before and after pictures...they are a work in progress...If I could post butt pictures here I would.
Lady, I'm coming 'round to attack you for those !0 -
who cares if you bulk up? It wont be much, especially when your legs and BUTT will look FANTASTIC. It'll be worth it.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions