If I make a protein shake with water
Options
Replies
-
No.No.
I am so tired of having to explain this over and over and over, but I graduated with honors from college with a degree in chemistry and I can tell you for absolute certain that when you put that protein powder in the water, the molecular structure changes and they merge and a bunch of other sciency stuff you just wouldn't understand and the water ceases to be water anymore.
In fact, you're risking dangerous dehydration by ingesting that.
That new liquid then gets reprocessed through the body and gets turned back to water again so that the kidney can use it to filter out waste and excess nutrients which the body does not need.0 -
Oh no, not again0
-
No.No.
I am so tired of having to explain this over and over and over, but I graduated with honors from college with a degree in chemistry and I can tell you for absolute certain that when you put that protein powder in the water, the molecular structure changes and they merge and a bunch of other sciency stuff you just wouldn't understand and the water ceases to be water anymore.
In fact, you're risking dangerous dehydration by ingesting that.
That new liquid then gets reprocessed through the body and gets turned back to water again so that the kidney can use it to filter out waste and excess nutrients which the body does not need.
Then please enlighten us that without evaporation into thin air (outside of the body), how does the water or liquid content magically disappear to cause dehydration.0 -
Does that count towards my daily water intake?
No, you have to drink it
As opposed to chewing your shake made with water ????
chewing it denatures the protein0 -
Troll?
0 -
Only water counts as water
?
It is water that he added. Why is this being asked? If I eat a low calorie snack, does that count towards my daily calorie intake? See how that sounds?
Water does not have calories but protein shakes do0 -
As a Yukoner, I can tell you with certainty that only melted snow counts as water!
Don't you southerners know anything??0 -
It counts as water, but you're supposed to make it with milk, so your protein shake is voided.0
-
It is water that he added. Why is this being asked? If I eat a low calorie snack, does that count towards my daily calorie intake? See how that sounds?
Depends on whether it was processed or not0 -
I'm sorry, but if you didn't understand my previous explanation, you just are never going to understand.
No.No.
I am so tired of having to explain this over and over and over, but I graduated with honors from college with a degree in chemistry and I can tell you for absolute certain that when you put that protein powder in the water, the molecular structure changes and they merge and a bunch of other sciency stuff you just wouldn't understand and the water ceases to be water anymore.
In fact, you're risking dangerous dehydration by ingesting that.
That new liquid then gets reprocessed through the body and gets turned back to water again so that the kidney can use it to filter out waste and excess nutrients which the body does not need.
Then please enlighten us that without evaporation into thin air (outside of the body), how does the water or liquid content magically disappear to cause dehydration.
Clearly, you do not have the sciency-type brain that I have. You're simply a plebe and I have no time for this.0 -
It counts as water, but you're supposed to make it with milk, so your protein shake is voided.
milk makes you fat0 -
Only water counts as water
?
It is water that he added. Why is this being asked? If I eat a low calorie snack, does that count towards my daily calorie intake? See how that sounds?
Water does not have calories but protein shakes do
It's also ridiculously hard to get fat off of protein powders unless you're using a weight gainer which has at least 1.5 x's more carbs than there is protein in it (as it's the carbs which will put on the mass).0 -
Troll?
Yep0 -
No.No.
I am so tired of having to explain this over and over and over, but I graduated with honors from college with a degree in chemistry and I can tell you for absolute certain that when you put that protein powder in the water, the molecular structure changes and they merge and a bunch of other sciency stuff you just wouldn't understand and the water ceases to be water anymore.
In fact, you're risking dangerous dehydration by ingesting that.
That new liquid then gets reprocessed through the body and gets turned back to water again so that the kidney can use it to filter out waste and excess nutrients which the body does not need.
Then please enlighten us that without evaporation into thin air (outside of the body), how does the water or liquid content magically disappear to cause dehydration.
WHOOOOOOOSH!0 -
no :noway:Troll?
Yep0 -
Haven't we seen this topic about 100 times this week?0
-
Only if you use natural rainwater. Tap water is processed and isn't clean drinking. Cavemen didn't have tap water so it's not paleo either. Double fail.0
-
WHOOOOOOOSH!
Yes, too much water will make you do that...0 -
I'm sorry, but if you didn't understand my previous explanation, you just are never going to understand.
No.No.
I am so tired of having to explain this over and over and over, but I graduated with honors from college with a degree in chemistry and I can tell you for absolute certain that when you put that protein powder in the water, the molecular structure changes and they merge and a bunch of other sciency stuff you just wouldn't understand and the water ceases to be water anymore.
In fact, you're risking dangerous dehydration by ingesting that.
That new liquid then gets reprocessed through the body and gets turned back to water again so that the kidney can use it to filter out waste and excess nutrients which the body does not need.
Then please enlighten us that without evaporation into thin air (outside of the body), how does the water or liquid content magically disappear to cause dehydration.
Clearly, you do not have the sciency-type brain that I have. You're simply a plebe and I have no time for this.
Your previous explanation makes absolutely ZERO sense. Dehydration is the removal or absence of liquids. For that to happen, the liquid has to literally evaporate into the atmosphere. The other way is to freeze it in which it solidifies but unless your body is operating at your freezer temps, there's no way for that liquid content to solidify in your body. Now, it does leave the body through your number 1's and a little bit of number 2's, but that also shows that the water has entered your body and your body has used the water for what it usually uses water for (transport of nutrients and used to filter waste and unused nutrients).
So, either you were joking or you just don't know what you are talking about?0 -
Does that count towards my daily water intake?
No, you have to drink it
As opposed to chewing your shake made with water ????
chewing it denatures the protein
Oh of course lol :noway:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.8K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 395 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 960 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions