Eating "junk" and losing weight?
Replies
-
The correlation is convenience and price, not the content of the food.
Has this been demonstrated? Is this opinion or do you have a source?0 -
The correlation is convenience and price, not the content of the food.
Has this been demonstrated? Is this opinion or do you have a source?
The fact that excess caloric intake is what causes weight gain.0 -
For me it's about baby steps I'm not going to go from a lover of pizza to craving broccoli over night, but I do say to each their own I am working on it and I do love that people leave their diaries open so I can get good ideas from them. I don't want to come across as rude but I do think its post like these that's why people leave theirs private.0
-
I eat what I want as long as it fits into my calorie goal. It's not like I'm never going to eat cake again in my life. It needs to be sustainable. I eat cake, chips, and ice cream. Just in moderation. Eating nothing but junk isn't the best idea, but having it once in a while isn't bad. I had a McChicken yesterday and I'm still losing weight.0
-
The fact that excess caloric intake is what causes weight gain.
This is a different statement. You are saying people are overeating because it is cheap and easy.
I have seen the hypothesis that, because fast foods are poor in micronutrients, they fail to satiate and cause overeating.
We don't know for sure what the relationship is. We just know that there is one.0 -
The fact that excess caloric intake is what causes weight gain.
This is a different statement. You are saying people are overeating because it is cheap and easy.
Well that part is a supposition, but it's a pretty obvious one.
It's not the fact that the food is processed that is making them gain weight. It's the fact that they're consuming more calories, for whatever reason.0 -
i eat what i like. there is no such thing as "healthy" or "unhealthy" foods. there is only such thing as too much or too little.
"If It Fits Your Macros" and you want to eat it, you can eat it.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/833026-important-posts-to-read
this is a much more satisfying and sustainable way to live the rest of your life. you should be able to enjoy your food. there's no reason you have to be miserable on carrots and celery every day for the rest of your life.
chocolate covered cheesecake squares.
OMG I want.... *wiping drool off computer screen*0 -
Well that part is a supposition, but it's a pretty obvious one.
It's not the fact that the food is processed that is making them gain weight. It's the fact that they're consuming more calories, for whatever reason.
I was talking about whether or not there is a correlation between obesity and processed foods. There is. It's pretty predictable.
I will not chase you down another rabbit hole.0 -
If a person goes from eating 3 Big Macs at lunch to 1 Big Mac at lunch, they are most likely going to lose weight. If they replace those 2 Big Macs with a salad or some fresh veggies or fruit, all the better for them. For me, it is more important that I am able to sustain this "diet" and I will not be able to do that if I don't still "get to" eat the things I enjoy. And yep, this is why my diary is private.0
-
And that factor may be sugar consumption. Researchers are focusing on the eating of sugar (and specifically the metabolizing of the fructose in sucrose) as the underlying factor in "food addiction". http://www.foodaddictionsummit.org/index.htm0
-
Well that part is a supposition, but it's a pretty obvious one.
It's not the fact that the food is processed that is making them gain weight. It's the fact that they're consuming more calories, for whatever reason.
I was talking about whether or not there is a correlation between obesity and processed foods. There is. It's pretty predictable.
I will not chase you down another rabbit hole.
Yep, and one of the main problems with processed foods is their sugar content. Ketchup, for example, has more sugar in it than soda pop does.0 -
Well that part is a supposition, but it's a pretty obvious one.
It's not the fact that the food is processed that is making them gain weight. It's the fact that they're consuming more calories, for whatever reason.
I was talking about whether or not there is a correlation between obesity and processed foods. There is. It's pretty predictable.
I will not chase you down another rabbit hole.
A rabbit hole that you are digging. The correlation is not that it is "processed" but that it is high in calories. Too many calories causes the weight gain not the "processing".0 -
This is the way I see it: It's the calorie deficit that makes you lose weight. That being said, a healthy diet is more fulfilling, more satisfying, and you won't have as many cravings. Also preservatives and chemicals in food react differently in different people. Think of it like an allergy, some people can all the junk they want and have no side effects, others are extremely senstive to them, so some people will get tired, sluggish, sick, rashes, headaches, retain water, get acne, and have trouble losing weight amongst many other symptoms. Every person is different. To each their own. Im on here for a healthy life not just to lose weight so I try to eat as clean as I can. Add me if you want.0
-
haha this ^^^^^No. It doesn't make any difference at all. I get sufficient vitamins and minerals, make sure my macros are met, and my calories are within my allotment. That is all and it works.
I'm a junk food junky too. I guess i'd be 'healthier' per se if i were eating better quality foods but the fact is i have proven you CAN lose weight if you stay under your calories and/or macros. Its all about balance andmoderation.
I admit however that the best way to eat is 80/20. 80 % healthy foods, 20 % cheats to enjoy life a little. It also makes you 'feel' better by eating what is right.
but that doesnt stop me from eating what i want most of the time or on weeks im craving it constantly.0 -
A rabbit hole that you are digging. The correlation is not that it is "processed" but that it is high in calories. Too many calories causes the weight gain not the "processing".
Like I said, there are hypotheses about how the "processing" might lead to excess calorie ingestion which then would lead to weight gain. I mentioned the lack of micronutrients. aroundthemulberry bush is talking about high refined sugar content leading to food addiction.
We do not know exactly what the relationship it. But it does exist.0 -
I'm not willing to cut out anything that I won't cut out for the rest of my life. It's not sustainable. I eat my fair share of fruit & veg and other healthy foods, but I eat junk too.
^^^ THIS. If I completely deprive myself of everything I want all I do is want it more. To make this a lifestyle you have to know one day you will eat a cookie again, or cake. Just not everyday.0 -
This is the way I see it: It's the calorie deficit that makes you lose weight. That being said, a healthy diet is more fulfilling, more satisfying, and you won't have as many cravings. Also preservatives and chemicals in food react differently in different people. Think of it like an allergy, some people can all the junk they want and have no side effects, others are extremely senstive to them, so some people will get tired, sluggish, sick, rashes, headaches, retain water, get acne, and have trouble losing weight amongst many other symptoms. Every person is different. To each their own. Im on here for a healthy life not just to lose weight so I try to eat as clean as I can. Add me if you want.
Yep.0 -
A rabbit hole that you are digging. The correlation is not that it is "processed" but that it is high in calories. Too many calories causes the weight gain not the "processing".
Like I said, there are hypotheses about how the "processing" might lead to excess calorie ingestion which then would lead to weight gain. I mentioned the lack of micronutrients. aroundthemulberry bush is talking about high refined sugar content leading to food addiction.
We do not know exactly what the relationship it. But it does exist.
So we all agree that calories cause weight gain and weight gain causes health risks. Overeating "healthy" or "unprocessed" foods is still overeating and causes weight gain. Micro nutrients content has little to do with satiation.0 -
You will be better for getting your tastes used to fresh and healthy foods. I was just reading a thread where someone is addicted to ruby red grapefruits and has to eat one every day! Now isn't that a better option for your body than NEEDING chocolate every day?
If you can eat fresh and still enjoy your food, DO IT! I personally would need something "bad" at PMS time, but I don't think it's good for your health to have it all the time. For me, it's not about fat:thin, but rather do I want to be healthy or would I like to increase my chances of cancer by eating all kinds of carcinogens and preservatives and refined sugars?0 -
Disagree. Processed foods have long been available in Asia. Their population seems to do just fine. What they are lacking is a population of 60% overweight and obese people.
No medical organization will dispute that WEIGHT is the number one predictor of health risk.
Obesity is rising in China alongside fast food market growth.
There does seem to be some relationship between processed foods and weight.
Easily accessible calorie dense food. "Processed food" (whatever that means) is not the what is causing obesity. Obesity is causing the health risks.
You "know" that, do you?0 -
I see SO many people on here who have their diaries open and eat more than half of their calories from what's considered "junk" food. What's the deal with this?! I realize I'm the one with 150 pounds left to lose, but wouldn't these people be losing more if they would eat fruits and vegetables at every meal? I'm striving for 75% fresh food. Is that maybe unrealistic? And there are people losing .5 pounds per week but eating candy, chips, etc. Would it not make a difference if they'd eat real food instead? Maybe I'm just confused!
I know what you mean...I used to have my diary open for my friends to view because I wanted them to say something to be about the things that I was eating as long as it was in an encouraging way. I will say this, in the beginning, I ate whatever I wanted and I still put in the MFP journal even though most days I went over my calorie goal. But being able to see what I was doing and notice how much fat and cholesterol I was putting into my body helped me to make better choices. Over time, I have adjusted my eating and learned to make better choices. Maybe they are having a similar experience? Idk hard to say but it's possible.0 -
Disagree. Processed foods have long been available in Asia. Their population seems to do just fine. What they are lacking is a population of 60% overweight and obese people.
No medical organization will dispute that WEIGHT is the number one predictor of health risk.
Obesity is rising in China alongside fast food market growth.
There does seem to be some relationship between processed foods and weight.
Easily accessible calorie dense food. "Processed food" (whatever that means) is not the what is causing obesity. Obesity is causing the health risks.
You "know" that, do you?
Well if you eat nothing but processed food and keep the calories down, you don't gain weight. So yeah we all know it.0 -
You will be better for getting your tastes used to fresh and healthy foods. I was just reading a thread where someone is addicted to ruby red grapefruits and has to eat one every day! Now isn't that a better option for your body than NEEDING chocolate every day?
If you can eat fresh and still enjoy your food, DO IT! I personally would need something "bad" at PMS time, but I don't think it's good for your health to have it all the time. For me, it's not about fat:thin, but rather do I want to be healthy or would I like to increase my chances of cancer by eating all kinds of carcinogens and preservatives and refined sugars?
Yes.0 -
Disagree. Processed foods have long been available in Asia. Their population seems to do just fine. What they are lacking is a population of 60% overweight and obese people.
No medical organization will dispute that WEIGHT is the number one predictor of health risk.
Obesity is rising in China alongside fast food market growth.
There does seem to be some relationship between processed foods and weight.
Easily accessible calorie dense food. "Processed food" (whatever that means) is not the what is causing obesity. Obesity is causing the health risks.
You "know" that, do you?
Well if you eat nothing but processed food and keep the calories down, you don't gain weight. So yeah we all know it.
It has also been shown MANY times over that health markers can improve with weight loss alone despite continued eating of so-called "unhealthy/bad/prcessed foods. So yeah I can say I know that.0 -
So we all agree that calories cause weight gain and weight gain causes health risks.
I can agree to this. I don't think I said otherwise.Micro nutrients content has little to do with satiation.
I won't agree to this. As far as I know, if your body is sorely lacking in micronutrients, it might strive to cause you to eat more food.0 -
I eat 50/50 Half junk or what possibly people think are junk you could call any food junk or any food healthy, food is food a calorie is a calorie, and thats it, i eat half Whatever i want, If thats chips so be it , than the rest i eat heathy salads lean meats But i can eat healthy 100 percent on some days the 5-/50 is optional, this is a lifestyle change and i know i can do this for the rest of my life,!!0
-
Disagree. Processed foods have long been available in Asia. Their population seems to do just fine. What they are lacking is a population of 60% overweight and obese people.
No medical organization will dispute that WEIGHT is the number one predictor of health risk.
Obesity is rising in China alongside fast food market growth.
There does seem to be some relationship between processed foods and weight.
Easily accessible calorie dense food. "Processed food" (whatever that means) is not the what is causing obesity. Obesity is causing the health risks.
You "know" that, do you?
Well if you eat nothing but processed food and keep the calories down, you don't gain weight. So yeah we all know it.
You know that obesity, in itself, is the cause of illness? Or is it the same habits that cause obesity, causing illness? You do not know which one is true. You may think you do, but you do not.0 -
Disagree. Processed foods have long been available in Asia. Their population seems to do just fine. What they are lacking is a population of 60% overweight and obese people.
No medical organization will dispute that WEIGHT is the number one predictor of health risk.
Obesity is rising in China alongside fast food market growth.
There does seem to be some relationship between processed foods and weight.
Easily accessible calorie dense food. "Processed food" (whatever that means) is not the what is causing obesity. Obesity is causing the health risks.
You "know" that, do you?
Well if you eat nothing but processed food and keep the calories down, you don't gain weight. So yeah we all know it.
You know that obesity, in itself, is the cause of illness? Or is it the same habits that cause obesity, causing illness? You do not know which one is true. You may think you do, but you do not.
Too many calories is what causes obesity.0 -
::raising hand:: That would be me. I love food and that's never going to change. I wanted to lose weight but not give up what I love and guess what? I did it. Last night I had pizza and a big piece of chocolate cake. I was a little over on calories (hey, it's my birthday, I'm allowed) but I will compensate the rest of the week by eating under.
There are days my husband and I do lunch or go on dates and I refuse to worry about what's going in my mouth because I still want to enjoy myself and, yes, I enjoy food. It's one of my pleasures. For other people it might not be. On the days I don't go out to lunch or dinner, I make sure I eat under calories so it all balances out at the end of the week.
I've lost a pound a week and have now upped my calories to lose .5 pounds a week and its working.
If I had to eat only vegetables (yuck, I HATE vegetables) and fruit and lean meat and chicken for the rest of my life I would totally rebel and go in the other direction.
I've a found a good balance that works well for me. :drinker:0 -
I strongly believe in all things in moderation. I know that I can't realistically eat mostly just fruits and veggies, not do I want to.
I have followed this principle all of my life, including eating "junk" food, and have never been more than a tiny bit overweight.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions