A doc told me something no one else has....
raelynne629
Posts: 24 Member
Losing weight sucks and you'll feel hungry for a while as your body resets.
No one has every told me that during the weight loss process that I'll be hungry. It's something we've always known but no one has ever said it to me and I found it to be a very frank comment and I thanked him for it! It's all about 85/15 or 90/10 making the best choices you can for the situation.
There are a lot of hormonal issues with weight, weight loss and feeling hungry, but do any of us truly know what hunger is? The hunger I'm talking about is discomfort... I'll be uncomfortable for a little while (maybe a year or more..) as I lose this weight and my body resets to be "normal" again!
What's more uncomfortable... being heavy forever or being a little hungry for a while??.
No one has every told me that during the weight loss process that I'll be hungry. It's something we've always known but no one has ever said it to me and I found it to be a very frank comment and I thanked him for it! It's all about 85/15 or 90/10 making the best choices you can for the situation.
There are a lot of hormonal issues with weight, weight loss and feeling hungry, but do any of us truly know what hunger is? The hunger I'm talking about is discomfort... I'll be uncomfortable for a little while (maybe a year or more..) as I lose this weight and my body resets to be "normal" again!
What's more uncomfortable... being heavy forever or being a little hungry for a while??.
0
Replies
-
You said a mouth full. I'll take the discomfort!0
-
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".0
-
Losing weight sucks and you'll feel hungry for a while as your body resets.
No one has every told me that during the weight loss process that I'll be hungry. It's something we've always known but no one has ever said it to me and I found it to be a very frank comment and I thanked him for it! It's all about 85/15 or 90/10 making the best choices you can for the situation.
There are a lot of hormonal issues with weight, weight loss and feeling hungry, but do any of us truly know what hunger is? The hunger I'm talking about is discomfort... I'll be uncomfortable for a little while (maybe a year or more..) as I lose this weight and my body resets to be "normal" again!
What's more uncomfortable... being heavy forever or being a little hungry for a while??.
hungry for a YEAR?! i did 1200 cals for 12 weeks, and was hungry all that time! that was plenty for me!
yes, you may feel hungry for a few weeks while you get used to eating less, but just plain hungry all the time? you're not eating enough!0 -
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".
I've lost most of my weight on keto, but I've had to put it on hold for a few weeks due to a couple of money issues (most of my money is going towards paying off debt so I can get rid of it quicker). I'm losing weight without it, but hunger is always quick to return after a meal.0 -
I think there was a short time when that was true. Here are a few tips for not being hungry.
- Eat foods that fill you up. A good combination of high-quality carbs and protein will help. IE: 0% Greek yogurt with a sliced apple etc. Junk doesn't fill you up, so get rid of it.
- Spread out your calories. Make sure you eat smaller meals, and eat snacks.
- People are different, some are hungrier in the morning and other at night. Have your larger meal at that time.
- Dink water, sometimes that will take away the huger and help us to feel more full. I suggest drinking a large glass 15 minutes before you eat.
- Exercise takes away the cravings.
And yes, there will be some times when you are hungry, so?
I was almost 100 pounds overweight laying in the ICU - I'll take life and hunger any day.0 -
That's a good point. Yes, there is discomfort sometimes in being hungry and denying yourself food you'd like to eat. But lately, I have lost weight around my middle that was TORTURING me. I felt it every minute of the day, keeping me from moving, in my way when I want to bend, jiggling when I walked to let me know it was always there. So now, the COMFORT of losing that spare tire feels wonderful and the trade-off of feeling a bit of hunger sometimes is totally worth it.0
-
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".
low carb diets are gimmicks. unless you plan to live that way for the rest of your life, they don't really help you learn how to have a healthy relationship with food. it's better to learn how to eat all foods in moderation, because that best equips you to maintain your loss 5 years, 10 years, and 20 years down the road.
i suggest an "If It Fits Your Macros" (IIFYM) approach. unless you have a medical condition that requires you to limit carbs, carbs and fiber are useful nutrients.0 -
There are tricks and tips you will learn along the way to combat feeling hungry....without cutting out all of a particular food group.....reservist a great word ....while your body resets as you put it you will also reset your way of thinking and your relationship with food......Best of luck on your journey and find some supportive friends! (Open diaries are a great way to get ideas on menu planning and to find different brands of things we love that are healthier options )
reservist? Haha should have been reset lol 0 -
I went through a couple of weeks of "cravings" and "eating way too much" while trying to figure out proportions and healthy choices. This is week 3 and I am feeling balanced...finally. Able to stick to things much easier and keep it reasonable. Drink extra water. Have extra veggies around when you are starving. Yesterday I made homemade Taco Soup with lots of fiber that worked wonders for filling me up without a lot of calories or consumption.0
-
I hate being hungry. There is no need to starve to lose weight, you can still do it and be satisfied by good food. Cut out the processed food products and eat more natural foods, and you will keep within your calories easily and not be hungry.0
-
I think there was a short time when that was true. Here are a few tips for not being hungry.
- Eat foods that fill you up. A good combination of high-quality carbs and protein will help. IE: 0% Greek yogurt with a sliced apple etc. Junk doesn't fill you up, so get rid of it.
- Spread out your calories. Make sure you eat smaller meals, and eat snacks.
- People are different, some are hungrier in the morning and other at night. Have your larger meal at that time.
- Dink water, sometimes that will take away the huger and help us to feel more full. I suggest drinking a large glass 15 minutes before you eat.
- Exercise takes away the cravings.
And yes, there will be some times when you are hungry, so?
I was almost 100 pounds overweight laying in the ICU - I'll take life and hunger any day.
SOUND ADVICE HERE^^^^ :drinker:0 -
Thanks for saying that.
We are so use to instant gratification that mild hunger is considered something we need to instantly eliminate, when it should be responsibly dealt with.0 -
I think it's important to define WHEN it's 'OK' to feel hungry. Such as up to an hour before your next scheduled meal - as it means your body has efficiently burned the fuel you gave it last meal and is now ready for more. If you are genuinely hungry an hour after eating then you need to look at what you eat and how much. This is a lesson that I have only just learned - you CAN feel hungry while cooking your evening meal and you don't have to eat whilst doing it!
x0 -
I'm never hungry. I eat between 1600-1850 cals per day. Fuel your body, don't deprive it.
Doctors are not necessarily nutritional experts. Trust me, I'm a former nurse. I've seen how many of them live.0 -
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".
low carb diets are gimmicks. unless you plan to live that way for the rest of your life, they don't really help you learn how to have a healthy relationship with food. it's better to learn how to eat all foods in moderation, because that best equips you to maintain your loss 5 years, 10 years, and 20 years down the road.
i suggest an "If It Fits Your Macros" (IIFYM) approach. unless you have a medical condition that requires you to limit carbs, carbs and fiber are useful nutrients.
This definitely! I've been doing well for the past 13 months. I don't feel hungry or deprived. I never think about stopping what I am doing b/c it is now part of my life.0 -
Yes, losing weight does suck. If it didn't, we wouldn't have all these people out there looking for that no-diet-no-exercise-eat-all-the-junk-food-you-want magic pill (and the con artists out there saying they've found it). But, in the end, when that doctor looks at you with a smile and says, "Good job. You're at a healthy weight and you don't have to take your blood pressure/cholesterol/insulin/etc. medications anymore," it makes that little bit of discomfort worth it.0
-
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".
low carb diets are gimmicks. unless you plan to live that way for the rest of your life, they don't really help you learn how to have a healthy relationship with food. it's better to learn how to eat all foods in moderation, because that best equips you to maintain your loss 5 years, 10 years, and 20 years down the road.
i suggest an "If It Fits Your Macros" (IIFYM) approach. unless you have a medical condition that requires you to limit carbs, carbs and fiber are useful nutrients.
I have to disagree. I agree that its not practical to eat low carb for life, at least in the strictest sense but to call it a gimmick ... in the nicest possible way ... shows ignorance.0 -
I don't personally find that hunger is necessary. I've never gone hungry and I haven't had any trouble. I eat filling foods and I eat enough calories. I make sure I get enough protein and fat. That's really all there is to it for me. If you're constantly uncomfortable then I'd start looking for things to tweak.0
-
I don't personally find that hunger is necessary. I've never gone hungry and I haven't had any trouble. I eat filling foods and I eat enough calories. I make sure I get enough protein and fat. That's really all there is to it for me. If you're constantly uncomfortable then I'd start looking for things to tweak.
+ 1.0 -
I'm never hungry. I eat between 1600-1850 cals per day. Fuel your body, don't deprive it.
Doctors are not necessarily nutritional experts. Trust me, I'm a former nurse. I've seen how many of them live.
^ this.
you can survive on a low carb diet, but you may end up feeling mentally and physically sluggish as a result. carbs are a useful and quick source of energy.0 -
Keep your deficit smallish and eat plenty of fats and protein. I was hungry my first couple of weeks, but that ended when I figured out my macros and the right calorie deficit.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets0 -
I have yet to be hungry while losing weight. I eat easily 4x as much now as I did before, but I'm eating good, healthy, nutritious foods so I get to eat a lot more of them for a lot less calories (I'm losing 2lbs a week).0
-
Hunger is mistaken for thirst a lot........Try drinking more!!!0
-
Your totally correct and I thought the same thing
Is what I am feeling TRUE hunger or is it boredom hunger or is it irritation hunger u know the hunger you feel because your irritated because you want to eat what you want to eat
I have had to make sure my will power is strong and there was several times I almost fell for it but my will power stepped in and said hey you dont need that get a glass of sugar free lemonade and you will be fine
Now the other day I was on the way to the gym and we did have to stop at 7-11 and I had to get some hard boiled eggs because I was getting headache from not eating (we were going at our normal dinner time) - I can see a change now instead of grabbing a bag of chips like I normally would have done not to mention my husband and my 2 kids would have also got junk food I got a sensible protein0 -
I eat on a schedule most days and i'm honestly never hungry0
-
Have you considered a low carb or ketogenic approach? Eat as much as you like within reason. The loss of refined carbs means you never feel hunger pains. I dont want to preach too much but I highly recommend looking into it as it completely changed my perspective on "diets".
low carb diets are gimmicks. unless you plan to live that way for the rest of your life, they don't really help you learn how to have a healthy relationship with food. it's better to learn how to eat all foods in moderation, because that best equips you to maintain your loss 5 years, 10 years, and 20 years down the road.
i suggest an "If It Fits Your Macros" (IIFYM) approach. unless you have a medical condition that requires you to limit carbs, carbs and fiber are useful nutrients.
I have to disagree. I agree that its not practical to eat low carb for life, at least in the strictest sense but to call it a gimmick ... in the nicest possible way ... shows ignorance.
the ignorance is on your part, not mine. low carb is very much a gimmick diet. you will lose water weight as a result of cutting your carbs drastically, but this is not sustainable. professional bodybuilders do that in the days leading up to a competition in order to get their "leanest" look, but you can't sustain it. atkins is also a well recognized gimmick diet that cuts carbs down to minimal levels. again, this is not something you can sustain for long periods of time without facing possible health risks.
http://www.atkinsexposed.org/printer-friendly.html0 -
I think there was a short time when that was true. Here are a few tips for not being hungry.
- Eat foods that fill you up. A good combination of high-quality carbs and protein will help. IE: 0% Greek yogurt with a sliced apple etc. Junk doesn't fill you up, so get rid of it.
- Spread out your calories. Make sure you eat smaller meals, and eat snacks.
- People are different, some are hungrier in the morning and other at night. Have your larger meal at that time.
- Dink water, sometimes that will take away the huger and help us to feel more full. I suggest drinking a large glass 15 minutes before you eat.
- Exercise takes away the cravings.
And yes, there will be some times when you are hungry, so?
I was almost 100 pounds overweight laying in the ICU - I'll take life and hunger any day.
I think this right about sums it up. There is no "one size fits all" approach to retraining your mind and body to act together when it comes to sustainable weight loss. There is no magic diet, magic pill or cleanse that will make the weight disappear. It takes dedication to exercise, and paying attention to the cues that our body gives us as to what real actual hunger is. Logging has been an eye opening experience as to my own personal eating patterns.0 -
Some of us have to eat "low Carb" because of being diabetic...if we don't want to end up taking huge amounts of insulin and turning into obese people. I have found that I can eat low carb by eliminating processed foods and gluten , limiting fruit juices and fruit, and eating plenty of fresh vegetables. it takes a little more effort buying fresh vegetables and preparing them but I am not hungry and i wake up each day with blood sugars in the 80's without having to take huge doses of insulin . So far I have lost 56 lbs and have 22 more lbs to lose to get to my goal of 120 . I'm 5'6 and 62 years old0
-
that is something non low carbers say yes.
edit - ah forget it I cannot be bothered
) 0 -
I only eat about 1600 calories a day well below my bmr of about 1900 and I hardly ever feel hungry. I eat breakfast everyday. I space my meals evenly and never skip a meal. I also make sure I get some protein and fat with every meal. I think your selection of food makes a much bigger difference in whether or not you will feel hungry.
For example, if I have 3 eggs for breakfast cooked in a little EVOO I will not be hungry at all. Breakfast is at 8am and lunch is at 1pm, so I go 5 hours without hunger. 3 eggs cooked in a tsp of EVOO is only 280 calories. But if I have a big bowl of cereal for breakfast with a cup of milk, I will be hungry a couple of hours later. The big bowl of cereal has closer to 400 calories.
So, if I am concerned about getting the least hunger and the least amount of calories it makes more sense for me to have eggs for breakfast which is what I have most days.
I definitely think your food choices will dictate your hunger more than anything else. We all joke about being hungry right after eating chineese food and there are a TON of calories in chineese food.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions