Gym teacher makes 9th Graders do Insanity Workout
Replies
-
I don't think they meant literally taking a nap, I think it was more of a comment about the P.E. teacher not teaching but letting Shawn T. do the teaching.0
-
When my son is that age, I'd have no problem with him doing Insanity. He may actually get better grades in school after the "workout" because then he may actually focus.0
-
THIS. IS. CRAZY!!! Kids muscles aren't developed enough to do intense workouts like this. I hear this can cause serious permanent damage. My teen sister is my best workout partner. We do Zumba, SHORT sessions of Insanity, and Rockin' Body but this is one or two times/wk, not every day and we switch up the workouts. I would never make her do a full Insanity session as I can't do it myself, yet. Being required to do this without the parent's consent is WRONG. When I was in high school, we did Sweatin To The Oldies. I think that, or Tae Bo, maybe a good option, but Insanity is WAY TOO MUCH. Also, what is the gym teacher doing while the kids are watching a video. How lazy is that?!
Are you kidding me? This is the perfect time to get them started on programs such as this, when their muscles are developing. Why? Because exercising causes blood to be pumped to that part of the body which means more nutrients and oxygen to build stronger better bodies. You yourself said your sister is DOING Insanity. And notice the OP did not say the teacher had them doing it EVERY DAY. Also, just because YOU can't do the full DVD that doesn't mean your sister isn't capable of it. Never judge your capabilities to that of others.
Besides, the PARENTS DO GIVE CONCENT. They do it when for one they have to sign wavers (permission slips) at the begining of the year, and two when the child is sent home with the next year's schedule of classes and you have to approve of it before you turn it in. What part of physical education do you think wouldn't be physical? What? You think they would stand around twiddling their thumbs the whole class period?
Finally, Insanity is a DVD program that you go at YOUR pace. Same as Zumba, same as Sweating to the Oldies. You go at YOUR pace. So it doesn't matter if the teacher put the DVD in, if the kids only put forth a 25% effort they won't hardly be getting any of the intensity anway.
I did some research and found that there are new studies showing that strength training can be beneficial and not harmful to children. Again, this is new evidence. People used to think that it could be harmful. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. and YES, they can go at their own pace, but if you're amongst peers, you may push yourself harder, maybe too hard... and oftentimes, in my own experience, gym teachers push you even harder.
Exercise is good for kids. Pushing yourself too hard is bad for everybody, including kids. The only problem I would have is if the gym teacher popped in the DVD and took a nap when the kids exercised.
http://www.childrenscolorado.org/wellness/info/teens/20486.aspx
Who said he/she took a nap? That is jumping to a huge conclusion.
And it wasn't said whether this was a daily plan or once a week in P.E. this is what they're doing.
If I was a P.E. teacher and doing this once or twice a week to add variety, I would be watching closely and offereing help or support, whatever
I think it's a great idea and being younger, they should be able to handle the workout BETTER than adults even. Look at the energy kids have! Maybe fewer kids would be on pills for being hyper if they had other means of dispersing that excess energy0 -
lazy teaching. it's easier to switch on a dvd than it is to engage with the kids and find a way to make them see that exercise can be something to look forward to.
torturing kids in gym class puts a lot of kids off exercise for years or for life.0 -
Just found out that my friend's daughter who is 14 years old had to do an Insanity workout at school this past Friday. Apparently the gym teacher made all the students do this very demanding workout. This is crazy especially since this is a workout program for people 18 years or older. The teacher didn't even ask the parents permission to teach this workout program!!
As you can imagine the kids were struggling after 2 minutes of doing Insanity. Also the teacher plans to do more programs.
Don't get me wrong kids needs physical activity but extreme programs are not appropriate for kids.
My friend is going to meet with the principal of the school to discuss this issue.
Are there any parents out there who kids are doing Insanity or P90X in school?
Kids can do extreme exercise just as well as adults, and nobody says the can't stop and take a breath if they need it. Saying that kids can only do little exercise that is light is like saying that kids can only eat kid friendly food, like saying they can only eat fish fingers and not actual fish like salmon fillet.
Many studies has shown that adult that were fit and healthy as children are more likely to be fit and healthier and live longer than those that just were average and did little exercise.0 -
Physical Education should be just that - education. Just having the kids do a video really isn't educating them on how to stay physically fit. It used to be we taught our kids sports, because sports teaches so much more than just the sport. It teaches them to be physical, to be part of a team, to follow rules, etc., etc. We are moving away from that, why I do not know. I have handicapped students so we do low impact aerobics in my class. I am not a PE teacher, but I have them do some kind of physical fitness on the days they do not see the teacher. I also teach them WHY it is important to be fit - in other words why the heck we are working out in the first place. That is what the important thing is! Dodge ball is not a sport, its a way for the stronger kids to pick on the weaker kids. Those that don't agree probably weren't getting the ball thrown at their face. Basketball, soccer, baseball, tennis, running. We also need to keep teaching our students sports along with some workout program.0
-
I know parents who have had their kids do Insanity in gym class and the kids LOVE it. Do parents or any other person who says it's too intense, lazy teaching or any other negative comment bother to ask the kids if they enjoy it? It's not like these kids have to do the workout at Shawn T's level, they can do it at their own. Some kids, of course, will hate it because not everyone enjoys athletics but overall it's a fun workout. It is also change from just playing sports and may engage kids who do not like team sports to do something on their own intensity without having to compete. Kudos to teachers who are finding innovative ways to engage their students!0
-
My son did Insanity workouts in the 6th grade. He complained about it a lot but like someone else said, most teenagers will complain about PE if if they're not doing their favorite activity or what they excel at. If the kids are moving and doing their best I can't find a problem with it. I can't imagine the PE teacher is expecting the kids to all be able to perform at the level of Shaun T. but instead encouraging them to try their best and introduce them to what real physical activity looks like.
Real life is HARD! It's not always about doing what you want to......0 -
I know parents who have had their kids do Insanity in gym class and the kids LOVE it. Do parents or any other person who says it's too intense, lazy teaching or any other negative comment bother to ask the kidsif they enjoy it? It's not like these kids have to do the workout at Shawn T's level, they can do it at their own. Some kids, of course, will hate it because not everyone enjoys athletics but overall it's a fun workout. It is also change from just playing sports and may engage kids who do not like team sports to do something on their own intensity without having to compete. Kudos to teachers who are finding innovative ways to engage their students!
my kid enjoys oreos and chocolate milk. forever.
kids+enjoy=/= a good criteria for choosing things to guide them in my opinion.
we are not talking about whether or not the kids will like it or whine about it, or are we? I though we were talking about what was good for the kids? at least that's how I read OP first concerns.0 -
I know parents who have had their kids do Insanity in gym class and the kids LOVE it. Do parents or any other person who says it's too intense, lazy teaching or any other negative comment bother to ask the kids if they enjoy it? It's not like these kids have to do the workout at Shawn T's level, they can do it at their own. Some kids, of course, will hate it because not everyone enjoys athletics but overall it's a fun workout. It is also change from just playing sports and may engage kids who do not like team sports to do something on their own intensity without having to compete. Kudos to teachers who are finding innovative ways to engage their students!
my kid enjoys oreos and chocolate milk. forever.
kids+enjoy=/= a good criteria for choosing things to guide them in my opinion.
we are not talking about whether or not the kids will like it or whine about it, or are we? I though we were talking about what was good for the kids? at least that's how I read OP first concerns.0 -
For all the people that keep throwing out the - anyone starting a workout program should be cleared by a physician first - as a reason the kids should not be doing Insanity, every school district we have ever been in required a physical yearly before school started, by a physician. Doesn't that cover this requirement? The doctors already note which children have asthma and other issues that can prevent them from fully engaging in certain activities.0
-
Do you really think it's the parents being jealous? Really? Insanity is free on youtube..
Really? All of it? I will have to check it out. I spend enough money on race fees, running shoes, tech shirts.. If I can have it for free I might actually be able to retain some of my allowance instead of buying it.
I'm 43 years old and a parent, why do *** I *** have an allowance anyway? Oh, yeah, bills...0 -
/Snip!
My old high school doesn't have that stuff any more, you have 3 options: HOPE (which is basically health class), ROTC, or weight lifting (beginners, intermediate, advance and you have to go up in that order). And you need 2 credits to graduate and in 9th grade you have to take HOPE (required). No more team sports (No child left behind act blew that), no general fitness (again NCLBA). Guess what they teach in weight lifting, HEAVY LIFTING. If heavy lifting is appropriate then tell me why Insanity or P90X (which is all BW) would be so bad as people are saying.
I went to middle and high school in the 1980s. We were taught strength training (yes, lifting heavy weights) starting in 7th grade (age 12-13) and continued to work on that throughout our high school PE classes. We also worked on sprinting, running distances, chin ups/flexed arm hang, sit ups, shuttle drills for time, etc. All this stuff was usual and expected.
In addition to working on fitness benchmarks and strength building, we also did stuff like floor hockey, volleyball, softball, basketball, soccer, track & field--that would be divided up into teaching us different sorts of events--we even did square dancing (someone else mentioned this; perhaps they are from Oregon too). Boys learned wrestling, while us girls did Jazzercise! Yeah, Jazzercise. A female PE teacher would show up in her leo and tights and play cassette tapes and lead us through what I am assuming were copyrighted Jazzercise routines. My mom did Jazzercise back then, and the routines to the songs were the same as the ones we learned, so I'm guessing they were copyrighted versions. A lot of us girls who were more athletic saw Jazzercise as a huge joke and kind of ridiculous, but we giggled our way through it, enjoyed some of the music, and ultimately we had fun. Doing something like INSANITY would have been similar for us back then--"fashionable" in terms of exercise fads, but different from our typical PE class, and a bit more challenging than Jazzercise!
Not sure why everyone is assuming the PE teacher popped in a DVD and "took a nap". Perhaps he/she spent some time making sure everyone understood how to correctly perform the movements, stretching with the class, and then did the workout along with them? Maybe the teacher led the workout? Maybe it isn't actual Beach Body INSANITY but this teacher's own version of the workout. Nobody really knows, but those are all possibilities as well as the fact that maybe he or she just popped in a video and ignored the class (which I highly doubt).0 -
Nothing wrong. Jeeez0
-
My 13 yr old son is enrolled in a learning academy where only gymnastics and karate are practiced as an elective. He does an hour of Kajukenbo after school everyday. Plus does Insanity with me when he decides to wake up early before school. I see nothing wrong with having the kiddos do Insanity at school.0
-
They have probably banned team sports in most schools because its not fair for the kids that aren't good at them (stupid rules of parents who's kids are nonathletic) ... So they are forced to try to do something new, and because some states have banned physical fitness testing because its not fair, and running because some kids cant and its not fair, i think this teacher is taking a chance on doing something good for these kids, and soon that will get banned to and PE will turn into social hour with one flat dodge ball that isn't allowed to be thrown because some kid might by chance get hit and think they are being targeted by a bully and the school will have to close down. END RANT sorry I am not a parent yet so I cant fully understand the whole making sure everything is fair for your kid, but I think its also important that kids learn lift isn't fair, and just because one kid isn't good at something doesn't mean every other kid has to miss out on it.
hahahaha.... so THIS. And I am a parent who looks at the school system with dismay...0 -
What part of the program do you disagree with?
^^I'm curious too. My 10 year old runs 5K obstacle course mud runs with me 3-5 times a years. Those kind of workout are his bread and butter. Maybe it will be hard in the beginning but imagine the satisfaction they will feel once the master it! Challenge kids...they're up to it. I do agree there should be parental ok first though.0 -
I have three kids in high school --- two seniors and a freshman. I applaud any PE teacher who tries to institute the concept of LIFE SPORTS into teens before it's too late. How many middle-aged adults do you know that play football, basketball, or dodge-ball regularly? Or even volleyball --- that bastion of stand around and do nothing. I salute teaching kids to do Insanity, Zumba, Jazzercize, whatever it takes to get them moving in a manner they can carry with them into the real world.
Our school PE program has deteriorated to the point where they have a police officer supervising co-ed PE because the girls (last year it was the boys) have so much pent up energy that they get into fights == now that is real insanity!
If you don't like your kid actually breaking a sweat and getting active in PE, then sign your kid up for Health Class instead, where he/she can hear all about the THEORY of eat less move more.0 -
I would have loved the option of doing some kind of workout instead of the team sports. The team sports have their place, too, as long as the gym teacher is teaching actual teamwork. My favorite part of gym class was the warm up time. Except for people with particular medical conditions, fitness exercising is accessible to pretty much everyone, and people should be more focused on what they are doing and not what the others are doing, so it doesn't matter how much better or worse people are than each other.
I don't have a problem with the teacher using the DVD. This may actually be safer as the teacher would have more of an opportunity to supervise form and safety.0 -
A great idea. And THEN they should do dodgeball right after.0
-
Whatever I say its great..They don't have to keep up with the full intensity of the workout, but I sure does expose them to a beautiful future..
That Gym teacher should be commended0 -
I don't think that is a big deal, at all. It's good to train younger kids, and make them work hard because nowadays all kids do is sit on the sofa watching t.v. When I was in 8th grade l I had one hour and a 15 minutes of intense cardio five times a week for our P.E. The teachers are simply challenging the students, which is totally acceptable.0
-
I would not have a problem with one of my children doing a cardio workout in P.E?0
-
I think this is a brilliant idea! Most kids are lazy and don't want to do anything in gym class! I think I will make a suggestion to the schools in my area.0
-
Good! I wish they did that at every school. I take my daughters to the park regularly and half the time there are middle schoolers on the playground for p.e.!! Wtf is that?! My toddlers run (half for play, half for practicing the sport) more than those kids. Its ridiculous.0
-
I think it's a great idea. As long as the children are monitored then I see no problem with it. I only wish they had Insanity in P.E when I was a kid.0
-
I think its a good thing, especially in this day and age. It just sounds like PE is PE again. Not "lets play sports."0
-
I agree P.E. teachers should design a workout program that is suitable for kids. Doing Insanity or P90X is ridiculous especially without the parents contest.
This is what I've thought for years...teach kids how to go from the couch to being in shape and include sports in that plan.0 -
Just found out that my friend's daughter who is 14 years old had to do an Insanity workout at school this past Friday. Apparently the gym teacher made all the students do this very demanding workout. This is crazy especially since this is a workout program for people 18 years or older. The teacher didn't even ask the parents permission to teach this workout program!!
As you can imagine the kids were struggling after 2 minutes of doing Insanity. Also the teacher plans to do more programs.
Don't get me wrong kids needs physical activity but extreme programs are not appropriate for kids.
My friend is going to meet with the principal of the school to discuss this issue.
Are there any parents out there who kids are doing Insanity or P90X in school?
This is not an appropriate workout for teenagers. In fact, the only people who should do Insanity are those who are old enough to make that decision on their own. Most school gyms have basketball, volleyball, hockey, along with baseball and track, etc. If one of these kids has a heart condition that is undetected (and that's been known to happen), and he/she falls dead of a heart attack, there's going to be hell to pay. I agree with you. The idea of Insanity for 9th graders is literally INSANE!0 -
For all the people that keep throwing out the - anyone starting a workout program should be cleared by a physician first - as a reason the kids should not be doing Insanity, every school district we have ever been in required a physical yearly before school started, by a physician. Doesn't that cover this requirement? The doctors already note which children have asthma and other issues that can prevent them from fully engaging in certain activities.
Yes, also, 504s/IEPs/the like will cover a lot if the children can not participate.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions