Free Weights Vs Machines? Holy crap!
LorinaLynn
Posts: 13,247 Member
I've been strength training fairly heavy for one year and two months. But the first year was using machines at the gym. I belonged to Planet Fitness, and the locations closest to me didn't have free weights, so I did machines. And I was really happy with the results, because it was a HUGE improvement over doing nothing but cardio, body weight and 5# dumbbell stuff, which was a HUGE improvement over not exercising at all.
But I hated going TO the gym. It took almost a half hour just to get there, another half hour back, so I didn't want to spend more time driving to and from than I spent working out, so ... boom, there's two hours out of my day. It just felt like a waste of time and gas. I decided to spend about 5 months worth of membership fees on a cheap barbell and bench set from Sears.
I've been lifting at home little over 2 months now. I'm eating around 2000 calories a day, running 3x a week and lifting 3x a week, usually a half hour to 45 minutes, sometimes an hour. I'm lifting "lighter" than I was using the machines, because the machines did half the work for me, and I don't have a squat rack or spotter and would rather err on the side of caution than risk hurting myself.
But I'm getting a MUCH more thorough workout and the results speak for themselves.
Also a good example for anyone concerned about getting bulky or losing curves from lifting. :happy: And I know it's not a hugely dramatic change, but I'm still gobsmacked because the scale has barely moved and I don't see changes in the mirror.
I'm not following a particular routine. Just the basics like bench press, overhead press, rows, squats, deadlifts, standing calf raises, leg curls and extensions, usually split into an upper body day and lower body day, and if I'm feeling really spunky and not going to run the next day, I might do both.
But I hated going TO the gym. It took almost a half hour just to get there, another half hour back, so I didn't want to spend more time driving to and from than I spent working out, so ... boom, there's two hours out of my day. It just felt like a waste of time and gas. I decided to spend about 5 months worth of membership fees on a cheap barbell and bench set from Sears.
I've been lifting at home little over 2 months now. I'm eating around 2000 calories a day, running 3x a week and lifting 3x a week, usually a half hour to 45 minutes, sometimes an hour. I'm lifting "lighter" than I was using the machines, because the machines did half the work for me, and I don't have a squat rack or spotter and would rather err on the side of caution than risk hurting myself.
But I'm getting a MUCH more thorough workout and the results speak for themselves.
Also a good example for anyone concerned about getting bulky or losing curves from lifting. :happy: And I know it's not a hugely dramatic change, but I'm still gobsmacked because the scale has barely moved and I don't see changes in the mirror.
I'm not following a particular routine. Just the basics like bench press, overhead press, rows, squats, deadlifts, standing calf raises, leg curls and extensions, usually split into an upper body day and lower body day, and if I'm feeling really spunky and not going to run the next day, I might do both.
0
Replies
-
I have always been of the opinion that every lady on this site needs to listen to you. You are living proof of how great weight training is for a body.0
-
Ummmm...you've lost inches EVERYWHERE! Perfect proof that women don't get bulky!!!0
-
Awesome results! Keep up the hard work!0
-
Even though I've only just started ST - I can most certainly appreciate going off the machines - you use so much more muscle control to control the weights, rather than having the machines work it for you.
♥ your progress stories OP - maybe one day I'll have one of my own!0 -
I like how you have heels on in the second set of pics! =D0
-
0
-
You look awesome, girl!
It's just too bad more people don't jump on the free weights bandwagon. It IS sooooo much more effective than using machines.0 -
And THIS is why I added you as friend.
I love lifting heavy and I'm going to continue to push myself. You're an inspiration.0 -
You look amazing!!! Can definitely tell a difference in your shape!0
-
Well obviously it is not working since you do not look like a men yet0
-
First thing I've gotta say is .. AWESOME job. You look tight and fit and ready to rock it.
Second thing...is it bad that when I saw the first "after" picture...I could hear you saying "BAM" the moment you flexed?0 -
You look awesome! What do you mean it's not a big difference?!?! I can see a difference in your body!0
-
EVERYONE, bookmark this post, and put it in every other post asking about weight lifting and free weights.
Unless you have a medical reason to not use free weights, you should ALWAYS use free weights over machines.0 -
I don't want to sound creepy or anything, but you have a very nice bum!
Well, you have a nice everything, actually! It's very motivating, especially for a person like me that sucks at weights training.0 -
You can really see the difference! I almost bought a bench set after you got yours, but it's not in my budget, so I'm sticking with dumbbells and a stability ball for now. You are such a huge inspiration, Lorina! I'm going to have to put this link on my profile with the other one. :flowerforyou:0
-
So are you the one on the right and the one on the left is your sister, or the other way around?0
-
i love being the only "girl" in the free weight section of my YMCA's fitness center....i do my own thing but i do think i get the "admiration" of the men doing their workouts around me....Just because i'm there....i love free weights and only use the lat pulldown machine.....i am going to push harder and work towards a rocking body just like yours lorina as soon as i'm recovered from my tummy tuck surgery....
denise0 -
WOW!!!! AMAZING!! You really are an inspiration!!0
-
You can really see the difference! I almost bought a bench set after you got yours, but it's not in my budget, so I'm sticking with dumbbells and a stability ball for now. You are such a huge inspiration, Lorina! I'm going to have to put this link on my profile with the other one. :flowerforyou:
CallMeCupcake,
A bench is just an accessory for the most part unless you are trying to bulk up, in my opinion. Barbells (Dumbbells) and a kettle ball is really all the free wieght you need to work the major muscle groups.0 -
I have always been of the opinion that every lady on this site needs to listen to you. You are living proof of how great weight training is for a body.
^Exactly! I love seeing your pics and story! Kudos to you on your hard work :happy:0 -
This is definitely inspiration for me as I'm entering into the strength training world and learning different exercises to use.0
-
I am loving lifting heavy...I also have noticed..that doing compound movements..engages my abs..and they are actually getting flatter. HUGE for me since I have PCOS, IR, and hypothyroid. I am thinking in a year..it will be reasonably flat..CANT WAIT!0
-
Wow. I can't believe you don't think that's much of a difference. 2 MONTHS??? Really??? Amazing and inspirational to those of us that are still beginning. I just started weights a couple weeks ago (NROLFW) and love it. Coming from doing Insanity and love the controlled pace of lifting. Thanks for giving me something to shoot for! :flowerforyou:0
-
You look awesome....I much prefer free weights over the machines as well ....I like some of the leg machines at the gym but free weights for everything else.0
-
I would like to start using free weights. I bought a bench for my sons and they never use it. I was thinking I could use it. But I am not sure of what size weights I should start with. I have never used weights before and I don't want to hurt myself. Anyone have any suggestions on how I should start off?0
-
I would like to start using free weights. I bought a bench for my sons and they never use it. I was thinking I could use it. But I am not sure of what size weights I should start with. I have never used weights before and I don't want to hurt myself. Anyone have any suggestions on how I should start off?
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/686963-large-collection-of-info-for-beginners0 -
I would like to start using free weights. I bought a bench for my sons and they never use it. I was thinking I could use it. But I am not sure of what size weights I should start with. I have never used weights before and I don't want to hurt myself. Anyone have any suggestions on how I should start off?
Start where you can... where you're challenged but can still keep good form. I typically do three sets of 8, and it usually goes like this... first three reps "I got this!" next three reps "This is getting heavy!" and last two reps "Holy F, this is heavy!" Then rest for a minute or two and repeat. When the entire set is "I got this," I need to go heavier.0 -
amazing! and THIS is why women should LIFT!0
-
Wow! I hadn't realized you were using machines before, and always knew from your previous before/afters that weight lifting made a huge difference...
But seeing the difference from machine to free weights is AMAZING. I always hear about the benefits of free weights over machines, so I've been doing free weights. I'm even MORE inspired now to keep it up!0 -
You look great.
I'm inspired to give free weights a try. Hubbie's got a bench, barbell and weights so may give it a try. Maybe that will get him lifting too. Thanks for the pictures and the motivation to try!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions