We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
SHOCKING!!! Health Screening Vegetarian to Paleo Comparison
Replies
-
I just looked at your food diet. Your "diet" is anything BUT paleo. At all. you're obviously confused as to what "paleo" means. completely. So very wrong. on many levels. chocolate? tortillas? huh?0
-
If you read the thread, you'd see she's invited people to look at her food diary, which has everything logged on both sides. She's also stated that it was largely veggies, whole grains, legumes, and eggs.
Seriously? Who has the time of day to read 6 pages worth of posts in a thread? I read the initial post and I responded based on what I read. And I wasn't dissing how the person is eating. Nor did I say anything about how I am eating. I was pointing out that the post did not indicate what they ate while eating vegetarian, and how poor eating could be in comparison to a cleaner way of eating.0 -
Good to know there's at least one other person that sees what I'm seeing, I hate seeing things alone:laugh:
Indeed.
However, I doubt there has been a "billion dollars" made from paleo yet...that will come once larger food manufacturers start labeling things as "paleo", "paleo approved", etc...and yet, these foods will be nothing like the current interpretation of "paleo". I'm seeing more and more people who formerly identified themselves as "paleo" distancing themselves from the label (but still adhering to the "lifestyle"), so perhaps that day is closer than I think.0 -
Our ancestors ate a higher carb (50%,) moderate fat (30%,) moderate protein (20%) diet. Not anything like the supposed "Paleo" diet being pushed by these books lately. The Mediterranean Diet is much closer to how our ancestors ate.
No. The Inuit eat/ate like my ancestors too, and I'm Caucasian.
Admittedly, the Mediterranean diet is better than the Standard American Diet, but it is not close to a human ancestral diet (i'm talking pre-agriculture which was developed very recently in the scope of human development). You can disagree all you want and you have your own facts to go by, just as I base mine on my own research of reputable sources. I suspect that you don't fully understand the Paleo diet because it is NOT necessarily low carb. Some of us choose low carb for the amazing health benefits. Look at my food diary, I eat LOTS of vegetables and I base my diet on fat. But I suppose it's just a coincidence that all of my health problems (there's a huge list) have mysteriously vanished in a very short time after changing my diet.0 -
Good to know there's at least one other person that sees what I'm seeing, I hate seeing things alone:laugh:
Yup, I'm down with this too. I'll use the terms, but I don't completely identify with them. There are aspects of both "paleo" and "primal" diets as presented in recent literature that I don't agree with and I do my own thing. However, if comparing modern eating plans, the premises behind "paleo" and "primal" are better than the alternatives. My goal is to eat the healthiest foods possible, based on fat, protein, and a small amount of carbs from veggies, which is still LOTS of veggies. The human body has not changed since pre-agriculture times. Everything about our modern lifestyle is unhealthy so if we can eat anywhere even close to whole, natural foods, based on healthy fat, protein, carbs we can only be better off. Healthy eating is not a "FAD"!!!0 -
She doesn't explicitly state that it is "B.S." for everyone in all situations, but inferring such doesn't seem like too great a stretch.
http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/78/3/660S.full
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921800905004994
These are two examples of many scholarly works that either explicitly state that a meat based diet is unsustainable, or that stress that we are able to feed far more people by allocating resources to the cultivation of grain, and even in so doing, will need to improve the yields of grain crops to feed a growing world population. This is the evidence upon which I have based my understanding.
You are correct to point out that "paleo diet" is never properly operationalized. For the purposes of this discussion, I was interpeting "paleo diet" to mean a meat based diet in which traditional Western animals, such as cattle, sheep, pigs, fowl, and fish comprised a significant portion of the caloric intake. I would not assume that this premise of unsustainability would stand if animal protein sources are expanded to include insects. I also think that if the process of "vat growing" meat is ever realized, the argument of unsustainability will likely not hold. Both of these are responses to the basic question of reconciling sustainability and the paleo diet that seem valid. I would also accept "I disagree with the scientists who say that a meat based diet is unsustainable," "I don't think about it," and "FU, got mine." I can come up with a number of possible responses that a person who believed in the paleo diet might give; I wanted to know what answer such a person would actually give.
I am unable to provide a source with a specific time frame expressed in numbers of years at this time, and will retract this part of my post.
It also sounds like the population crisis fears of the 1960s and 19790s, perhaps most famously delineated in The Population Bomb by Paul R. Ehrlich, a book which has become the target of much (largely warranted,) derision since its publication. Obviously, those feared events did not come to pass, but it seems to me that much of the reason why the predicted famines did not come to pass was improvements in the cultivation of grains, most notably rice. Since grains are not part of the paleo diet as I understand it, this is part of what led me to ask my question about how paleo diet enthusiasts reconcile sustainability.
<<<< does not dislike the Paleo / Primal paradigm and has a hard time knowing where to find the line between "offering an unsubstantiated argument" and "inundating people with so many words that it can only invoke a response of 'tl;dr'."
This is kind of off topic, but an interesting discussion anyway, so I'd like to respond.
Is attempting to support 7+ billion people (and growing) a good thing to do, anyway?
Additionally, the problem I have with the whole "the world can't support everyone doing X" thing is that it doesn't really matter what X is. If everyone did the same thing, we probably wouldn't be able to sustain everyone, anyway (at the very least, not without destroying pretty much everything else on this planet), due to the sheer amount of total resources it would take to do so.
This site mentions 200 square yards (~.04 acres) to feed one person on just grain - http://www.quora.com/How-much-farmland-would-be-required-to-sustain-10-000-people-on-a-balanced-vegetarian-diet
It's oversimplified, but let's assume it's true. At an estimated 7 billion people (source: Google "current world population"), that's 1.4x10^12 square yards, or roughly 289,256,198 acres, required to feed everyone on grain.
According to this site, there are 7.68 billion acres of arable land, and arable land is being lost at a rate of 24.7 million acres per year, due to things like global warming (rising water levels due to glacial melting), local climate changes (turning moist areas dry, etc), and urban sprawl, and in 300 years be depleted entirely - http://one-simple-idea.com/Environment1.htm
In other words, if everyone were to go vegetarian (and nothing else changed), it would buy us a couple of centuries, at best. And I'm not even sure whether that assumes the farming practices are actually sustainable (which is a completely different issue, regardless of whether the crop is plants or animals). The problem, in my opinion, isn't so much that farming practices of diet X are unsustainable and therefore diet X won't support everyone eating it, but rather that our population, and its growth, as a whole are (or are becoming, depending on who you ask) unsustainable, regardless of food sources.
That said, there's also the fact that we got to this level of population in part precisely because everyone didn't eat exactly the same way. The fact that we are omnivores has allowed our population to grow outside of the tropical areas where plants are abundant year-round and into the arctic regions where plants aren't available at all. It also allowed us to do things like start growing grains. In other words, the Inuit and northern Scandinavians have a vastly different diet from the Africans and Amazonians when living off of their local foods, and both are vastly different than the SAD.
Regarding the sustainability of meat - I agree that when one's meat choices are as narrow as fish, beef, pork, sheep, and chicken, it's not going to be very sustainable on the large scale or in the long run. Personally, I try to expand my options to things like game (venison, rabbit, small game) and bison, both of which are local and abundant where I live (not to mention that raising bison and buffalo are actually beneficial to US soil, due to this being their ancestral land, and therefore the land is adapted to the animal and vice-versa), whenever I can, which makes the sustainability of meat quite a bit more realistic (it's amazing what you can do when you work with the land, instead of against it).
But again, it comes back to sheer volume of population. Just like with every other creature, when the population expands beyond what the environment can hold, resources become scarce and famine starts to set in. High population densities also support the rise of disease, and war among the species that do it. These factors usually reduce the population back down to a sustainable level, resulting in an overall equilibrium, but we've artificially short-circuited that with a number of things, including medicine, global food transportation, housing, agriculture, and the various other technological advances unique to our species. Eventually, something's got to give, and our population on this planet will get decimated by something.0 -
Seriously? Who has the time of day to read 6 pages worth of posts in a thread? I read the initial post and I responded based on what I read. And I wasn't dissing how the person is eating. Nor did I say anything about how I am eating. I was pointing out that the post did not indicate what they ate while eating vegetarian, and how poor eating could be in comparison to a cleaner way of eating.
Who said you were "dissing" anything? Or said anything about how you are eating?
6 pages isn't that much to at least skim and see if anyone already said what you want to say (hint - at more than a page or two, someone probably has).0 -
<<it's all right there ^^^ and it's huge. I'm not quoting all of it.>>
But again, it comes back to sheer volume of population. Just like with every other creature, when the population expands beyond what the environment can hold, resources become scarce and famine starts to set in. High population densities also support the rise of disease, and war among the species that do it. These factors usually reduce the population back down to a sustainable level, resulting in an overall equilibrium, but we've artificially short-circuited that with a number of things, including medicine, global food transportation, housing, agriculture, and the various other technological advances unique to our species. Eventually, something's got to give, and our population on this planet will get decimated by something.
Thank you for giving a serious and well-reasoned response. Any discussion of paleo diet (whatever that actually means,) always makes me wonder how other people see all the pieces of this nutritional system fitting together. I really appreciate you explaining your perspective.
(I just want to reiterate that I was not asking as some misguided rhetorical attempt to lead others to some particular conclusion. I was just trying to explain what I saw in considering paleo and sustainability, and wanted to know how others thought about it.)0 -
Seriously? Who has the time of day to read 6 pages worth of posts in a thread? I read the initial post and I responded based on what I read. And I wasn't dissing how the person is eating. Nor did I say anything about how I am eating. I was pointing out that the post did not indicate what they ate while eating vegetarian, and how poor eating could be in comparison to a cleaner way of eating.
She's eating ham, salami, all sorts of very very NON paleo foods. No wonder she didn't lose much weight over a year.0 -
The Paleo diet has been found to be healthier on every parameter of blood chemistry. The key is that it reduces blood sugar and thus excessive insulin, high triglycerides, and other things as a consequence--such as reducing high levels of cortisol, bad LDL cholesterol and raising good HDL cholesterol. I'm surprised that your fasting blood sugar went up---most people find that theirs' go down. You could have it tested again just to make sure that there was no lab error.
I have lost 14 pounds since I went on Paleo and have been able to nearly get off my blood pressure medications. I was taking two medications at the maximum dose for each and now I take a quarter dose of one I am confident that I will be able to get off of that when I lose a bit more weight and become even more active. My arthritis is better than it has been in a long time and I feel so much more energetic! I will never go back to eating sugar and grains! It is fairly certain that high consumption of sugar and grains, combined with sedentary lifestyles, is responsible for the obesity and Type II diabetes epidemic that Western nations are currently experiencing.
Good post! I know several people who have done Paleo and also South Beach as a remedy to blood chemistry issues and their numbers have all greatly improved.
Congrats to anyone and everyone who finds something that works for them! Being healthy, eating right and exercising is a real struggle for a lot of people, so stick to what works for you, as long as you're healthy doing it.0 -
She's not eating a paleo diet; these are in her food diary from various days; (I'm not trying to be b!tchy, just honest)
boar's head meat
fajitas
butter
choc ship cookie dough bar
caramel macchiato coffee
asian meatballs
more boards head
Sea Cuisine - Salmon Honey Chipotle Crusted
more choco
kiolbassa
Skordalia - Greek Garlic Sauce
Bakalava,
Chocolate Milk Shake
Creamy Chicken Enchilada,
boar's head
Sweet Potato Fries
Homemade - Velveeta and Rotel Dip With Ground Beef,
Sausage - Polish
Jimmy Dean Ground Sausage
Daisy - Sour Cream,
I saw that she had only lost 6 pounds in a year so I decided to look at her diary "well, everyone has an off day" I checked a variety of days, I didn't see one day that was actually paleo.0 -
Very cool!0
-
She's eating ham, salami, all sorts of very very NON paleo foods. No wonder she didn't lose much weight over a year.
Ham is Paleo, Salami not so much, but it's OK within reason. There is an 80/20 rule, just because there is a cheat here and there doesn't mean she gets drummed out of the Paleo Core.0 -
She's not eating a paleo diet; these are in her food diary from various days; (I'm not trying to be b!tchy, just honest)
boar's head meat
fajitas
butter
choc ship cookie dough bar
caramel macchiato coffee
asian meatballs
more boards head
Sea Cuisine - Salmon Honey Chipotle Crusted
more choco
kiolbassa
Skordalia - Greek Garlic Sauce
Bakalava,
Chocolate Milk Shake
Creamy Chicken Enchilada,
boar's head
Sweet Potato Fries
Homemade - Velveeta and Rotel Dip With Ground Beef,
Sausage - Polish
Jimmy Dean Ground Sausage
Daisy - Sour Cream,
I saw that she had only lost 6 pounds in a year so I decided to look at her diary "well, everyone has an off day" I checked a variety of days, I didn't see one day that was actually paleo.
are you the paleo police? 80/20 is what most people strive for and full fat dairy is allowed on some variations of the paleo diet since there is not one "paleo" diet. Its an n=1 thing, meaning if it works for you, do it. Also, have you looked at her pictures, a 6 pound weight loss is huge on someone her size. You are rude.0 -
We all have different goals. And if you're not willing to keep an open diary, the you really shouldn't comment on anyone else's. Just sayin'.She's not eating a paleo diet; these are in her food diary from various days; (I'm not trying to be b!tchy, just honest)
boar's head meat
fajitas
butter
choc ship cookie dough bar
caramel macchiato coffee
asian meatballs
more boards head
Sea Cuisine - Salmon Honey Chipotle Crusted
more choco
kiolbassa
Skordalia - Greek Garlic Sauce
Bakalava,
Chocolate Milk Shake
Creamy Chicken Enchilada,
boar's head
Sweet Potato Fries
Homemade - Velveeta and Rotel Dip With Ground Beef,
Sausage - Polish
Jimmy Dean Ground Sausage
Daisy - Sour Cream,
I saw that she had only lost 6 pounds in a year so I decided to look at her diary "well, everyone has an off day" I checked a variety of days, I didn't see one day that was actually paleo.0 -
boar's head meat Paleo
fajitas Paleo
butter Paleo
choc ship cookie dough bar
caramel macchiato coffee
asian meatballs Paleo
more boards head Paleo
Sea Cuisine - Salmon Honey Chipotle Crusted Paleo
more choco Paleo
kiolbassa Paleo
Skordalia - Greek Garlic Sauce Paleo
Bakalava,
Chocolate Milk Shake
Creamy Chicken Enchilada,
boar's head Paleo
Sweet Potato Fries paleo
Homemade - Velveeta and Rotel Dip With Ground Beef, primal
Sausage - Polish paleo
Jimmy Dean Ground Sausage paleo
Daisy - Sour Cream, primal
I'm not sure you know what paleo is...0 -
You lost 6 pounds in a year? Uhm...sorry, that's .5 pounds a month. Not all that impressive. Even 1 pound a month isn't that impressive at your weight. The more you have to lose, the easier it is to initially lose weight. It's that last 20lbs that's a b!tch.
The difference is, you're probably eating a LOT more animal based protein than before.
If you bothered to read her post, rather than just trying to be judgmental, you would have noticed that it wasn't about the weight loss. She said she wasn't trying to lose weight. She was trying to be healthy and she did that.0 -
We all have different goals. And if you're not willing to keep an open diary, the you really shouldn't comment on anyone else's. Just sayin'.
she's claiming she's doing well on a paleo diet. I never claimed I'm doing a great diet. I have changed a lot of things, such as eating healthier protein more often and stocked my cabinet with wild alaskan salmon to beef up my D. I'm eating better portions
and more often. I've also been sick 4 times since I joined and on round 2 of anti-biotics and still lost 2 pounds in 4 weeks. Getting my tonsil yanked will help with my health and hopefully I'll be able to get to the gym more often.
My husband leaves town for a week and I'm going to try and clean up my menu, so check back in a week!0 -
She's not trying to lose weight. Are you intentionally ignorant or...?
she's claiming she's doing well on a paleo diet. I never claimed I'm doing a great diet. I have changed a lot of things, such as eating healthier protein more often and stocked my cabinet with wild alaskan salmon to beef up my D. I'm eating better portions
and more often. I've also been sick 4 times since I joined and on round 2 of anti-biotics and still lost 2 pounds in 4 weeks. Getting my tonsil yanked will help with my health and hopefully I'll be able to get to the gym more often.
My husband leaves town for a week and I'm going to try and clean up my menu, so check back in a week!0 -
are you the paleo police? 80/20 is what most people strive for and full fat dairy is allowed on some variations of the paleo diet since there is not one "paleo" diet. Its an n=1 thing, meaning if it works for you, do it. Also, have you looked at her pictures, a 6 pound weight loss is huge on someone her size. You are rude.
Thank you! Geez, remind me to NEVER post on here how well I think I'm doing or what I view as a diet that works for me. Unless you're prepared to be completely analyzed by your peers (who, by the way, I THOUGHT were on here to be encouraging and supportive) keep your success to yourself!
BTW, OP, I think it's great what you're doing and keep up the good work!0 -
I'm sure losing weight didn't do anything for better results, it's all the Paleo diet
lol0 -
BUMPPPPPPP
0 -
Every night before I go to bed I eat 4 girl scout thin mints and I consistantly lose about 2lbs a week, thank you thin mints!
how can you stop at 4? i have a box of those *kitten* in my freezer and i swear if i eat one i'll eat them all. pout!0 -
This doesn't mean anything, really.
We don't know exactly what you were eating as a vegetarian to meet your nutritional requirements. Some vegetarians are incredibly unhealthy and obese, after all! I highly doubt you were eating a diet HIGH in veg, fruit, legumes, nuts, seeds with some wholegrains & whole, sugar-free dairy + eggs...
This.
I'm sure if they'd done all of that on me a couple of years ago, as opposed to now, it'd be similar. I've been vegetarian for 18 years, but until a couple of years ago ALL I ate was carbs and sugars and didn't exercise.0 -
she's claiming she's doing well on a paleo diet. I never claimed I'm doing a great diet. I have changed a lot of things, such as eating healthier protein more often and stocked my cabinet with wild alaskan salmon to beef up my D. I'm eating better portions
and more often. I've also been sick 4 times since I joined and on round 2 of anti-biotics and still lost 2 pounds in 4 weeks. Getting my tonsil yanked will help with my health and hopefully I'll be able to get to the gym more often.
My husband leaves town for a week and I'm going to try and clean up my menu, so check back in a week!She's not trying to lose weight. Are you intentionally ignorant or...?
I looked at the topic title "SHOCKING!!! Health Screening Vegetarian to Paleo Comparison"
I looked at her "paleo diet" it is not a paleo diet. So before you sit there and question my ignorance, you might want to question her claim on how healthy it is. If someone claims "oh, I have been eating unprocessed foods for a year and am so much healthier" and see the person isn't eating a diet they claim, how can you take the statement seriously?0 -
This.
I'm sure if they'd done all of that on me a couple of years ago, as opposed to now, it'd be similar. I've been vegetarian for 18 years, but until a couple of years ago ALL I ate was carbs and sugars and didn't exercise.
Geez, people learn to read before you post.0 -
Where did she say it was? She shared what worked for her, her preferences and her individual circumstances - nothing more.
This is a general point (not directed at you specifically) but if a person is so emotionally invested in a certain way of eating that they feel defensive when someone else merely shows success with a different approach they must ask themselves if that is in fact a healthy mindset
"WOW is all I can say!!! Changing from a Vegetarian diet to a Paleo diet CLEARLY changed ALL my paramenters (except glucose, see * above) in the positive direction! So all that B.S. about eating eggs, bacon, fatty foods, red meat, and other things with lots of cholesterol is A TOTAL CROCK!!! "
Just because something worked for her doesn't mean everything else is a crock and her number changes were quite small. She's acting like he lost 50lbs and significantly lower all her points, which she didn't. And as others pointed out, she wasn't really even paleo.0 -
Thank you! Geez, remind me to NEVER post on here how well I think I'm doing or what I view as a diet that works for me. Unless you're prepared to be completely analyzed by your peers (who, by the way, I THOUGHT were on here to be encouraging and supportive) keep your success to yourself!
BTW, OP, I think it's great what you're doing and keep up the good work!
So if you were doing something you thought was correct and you weren't, and you could see better results. and spewing misinformation, would you want a pat on the head and congratulatory praises?
It's great that she is health(ier) but the diet she is doing simply isn't paleo. If I was doing something wrong, I would hope someone would correct me. obviously I am doing something wrong here by being honest.0 -
She's not trying to lose weight. Are you intentionally ignorant or...?
I looked at the topic title "SHOCKING!!! Health Screening Vegetarian to Paleo Comparison"
I looked at her "paleo diet" it is not a paleo diet. So before you sit there and question my ignorance, you might want to question her claim on how healthy it is. If someone claims "oh, I have been eating unprocessed foods for a year and am so much healthier" and see the person isn't eating a diet they claim, how can you take the statement seriously?
[/quote]'
Take a deep breath. It's all going to be okay. First, you aren't entirely aware of what is and is not Paleo. Second, your judgmental attitude is not making you any friends. The OP was simply expressing happiness that after being a vegetarian, she found a diet that she liked better and kept her healthy. No where did she say she was trying to lose weight. Instead, she said she was trying to maintain. Really, if you're not here to be supportive, you can go somewhere else.0 -
Weight isn't the gauge of health she was using, which is my point.
I looked at the topic title "SHOCKING!!! Health Screening Vegetarian to Paleo Comparison"
I looked at her "paleo diet" it is not a paleo diet. So before you sit there and question my ignorance, you might want to question her claim on how healthy it is. If someone claims "oh, I have been eating unprocessed foods for a year and am so much healthier" and see the person isn't eating a diet they claim, how can you take the statement seriously?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.6K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 260.5K Health and Weight Loss
- 176.1K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.7K Fitness and Exercise
- 444 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 4.1K MyFitnessPal Information
- 16 News and Announcements
- 1.3K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.8K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions