Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Miracle Whip or Mayo?

    24

    Replies

    • Posts: 498 Member
      show previous quotes

      I knew this was going to drive a wedge between us.

      I'm with Rae.
    • Posts: 217
      show previous quotes

      I hate you.

      Miracle Whip is yummy. Mayo is flavorless gloupy fat.

      Amen sister...Amen...
    • Posts: 2,724 Member
      Miracle Whip is just mayo with the most disgusting spices added in (is it even less calories??)


      The best use for it is a trash can filler.

      We could have had something beautiful, but then you post this. Shortest stay on a friends list ever.
    • Posts: 899 Member
      Low fat Helmans is really good (I have found). Try that. I too do not like Miracle whip.

      This.


      BTW Miracle Whip is NOT a mayonnaise.. the regular Miracle Whip is a salad dressing. Then they made Miracle Whip MAYO.. which is better... yet not as good as Hellmann's.
      Note that Hellmann's 1/2 the fat is as good as the regular one. With only 40 cal per TBSP, I often use it for a creamy salad dressing (I add spices of course) And I get something delicious for more than half the calories of another creamy salad dressing.
    • Posts: 7,166 Member
      show previous quotes

      I'm with Rae.
      show previous quotes

      I thought we had a good thing going and now I find this out. I used to love you...


      SEEE!? All the REAL Colorado chick are on my side.
    • Posts: 6,033 Member
      I SEE THAT MOST OF MY FRIENDS ARE AGAINST ME. THAT'S FINE. SUSIE STILL LOVES ME AND HER LOVE IS ALL I NEED.


      As for the rest of you, I'm doing five shots of tequila and coming to your house.
    • Posts: 2,964 Member
      mayovsmw_zpsb4cb801b.jpg
    • Posts: 3,927 Member
      show previous quotes
      Well, that certainly helps things, doesn't it? Putting a silly picture up? Very mature. Please stop derailing the thread.

      eliotdundundun.gif
    • Posts: 5,044 Member
      Miracle Whip......mayo just doesn't have flavor to me.
    • Posts: 300 Member
      show previous quotes
      a) Well considering the OP ASKED opinions about Mayo vs Miracle Whip, I'm pretty sure it isn't ME that is derailing the thread.
      2) Discussing our opinions of sandwich spread is FAR from "tearing each other down". If someone gets offended b/c I don't like their choice of condiments, they have much bigger issues to deal with
      Z) The Joker is NOT silly, especially when played by Heath Ledger.
      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?
    • Posts: 8,646 Member
      show previous quotes
      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?

      Okay, now you just gave yourself away.
    • Posts: 300 Member
      show previous quotes
      Okay, now you just gave yourself away.
      I got greedy.
    • Posts: 2,964 Member

      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?

      confused.jpg
    • Posts: 7,166 Member
      Troll is trolling.
    • Posts: 8,646 Member
      show previous quotes
      I got greedy.

      UEV9Dqb.jpg
    • Posts: 3,189 Member
      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?

      0ee.jpg
    • Posts: 4,564 Member
      show previous quotes
      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?

      Woa why so serious?
    • Posts: 1,265 Member
      If you want some seriously good mayo then make it at home! You can tweak the recipe till it tastes right for you and then go with it.

      Also to use up the remainder of the mayo you already have i hear you can use it in on chicken in the oven... or just use it sparingly in sandwiches. Another option is give it to a relative or friend who doesn't need to watch their weight and likes using it :)
    • Posts: 4,555 Member
      I eat full fats so mayo
    • Posts: 498 Member
      show previous quotes
      Calling a food I like "disgusting" is rude and uncalled for. It's tantamount to BULLYING and I will not stand for it. What if someone that really like Miracle Whip was contemplating hurting themselves and then read this thread?! You didn't think about that when you attacked me with that violent Joker picture, did you?

      You're getting in a tizzy over Miracle Whip??

      Whackadoo FTW!!!
    • Posts: 108 Member
      I like a good olive oil mayo.
      ^^this for sure
    • Posts: 242 Member
      Ewwwwwwwww Miracle Whip ::sick:
      For the love of food.... TONE IT DOWN ALREADY!

      it is one of the few foods that will totally ruin other foods it touches... not just gross alone... grosses up anything it comes in contact with.
      & What's with the sweet weird flavour? Why does anybody want sweet potato salad or tuna?? It seriously boggles my mind.
    • Posts: 5 Member
      The Olive Oil Mayo is my Absolute Favorite Too!!
    • Posts: 139 Member
      I'm a Miracle Whip girl, but I would make some cheese dip if I were you :)
    • Posts: 363 Member
      This thread has been so much fun I had to go back to see what the question really was.....So, I would take the Miracle Whip back the store and tell them it doesn't taste right...which it doesn't because IT"S MIRACLE WHIP ..retch....thy will take it back because they for sure aren't going to taste it!!!
      No receipt?...Save it for a Yankee Swap??
    • Posts: 149 Member
      Veganaise! My husband even prefers it, and he's not vegan. I've even heard that high end chefs use it instead of mayo. Much healthier,too.
    • Posts: 32 Member
      I use the olive oil mayonnaise and just use less of it. (Reduced fat)
    • Posts: 32 Member
      It's hard for me to throw out food, but getting better at it if need be since I had the sleeve done.
    • Posts: 716 Member
      I have a weird, and relevant fact. It's also something you could use your leftover miracle whip for, if you wanted to.

      **DISCLAIMER: I do not recommend reading further if you are eating.**










      Enzymes in miracle whip will digest dead skin. I read it in a magazine in the 90s. I'm slightly embarrassed to say I've tried it. It works. The last time I used it was ages ago, so I don't remember how long you leave it on (maybe 10-15), but dead skin will roll off afterward. It's gag-worthy, but there it is.
    • Posts: 63
      i am a mayo girl for 30 years. dating and living with a guy that likes miracle whip. i have tasted whip. my opinion is i like it only in small doses.
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories