Viewing the message boards in:

Tell me again why eating before bed won't make me fat?

1679111214

Replies

  • Posts: 4,698 Member
    Bob gets up in the morning and goes for a power walk. His body doesn't give a crap that the calories came from yesterday rather than today.
  • Posts: 562 Member
    Is there any science to support your claim?

    Absolutely! It's pretty difficult science though.


    nq23iv.jpg
  • Posts: 4,733 Member


    It's ok, I know the science of weight loss can be confounding at times....although I have to say that you are very perceptive because you are right, having soda make *all* your food float to the top is as bad as having it all settling to the bottom...it just means you'll get a fat torso rather than a fat *kitten*.

    So; there are two solutions for you:

    1. Moderate your soda intake. Take a few sips, then a few bites of your food, then a few more sips so that everything is a bit more mixed up.
    2. Invest in my Gyronator 3000; proven to gently mix your food into small, non-fat making particles. This man lost 350lb with a healthy 'low density food diet' and 30 minutes a day on the Gyronator 3000 and he's never looked back!

    188_gyro_shoot_009.jpg

    science for the win!
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    lolz - just noticed that the earlier article I posted was actually posted on the first page...derp.


    Here is a review of the anabolic effects of GH from the British Journal of Sports Medicine for people concerned about GH being suppressed by eating at night.

    http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/37/2/100.full

    Did you cite the wrong article? I read the entire thing and it was basically just speaking to the issue of taking exogenous GH. No one here was advocating any artificial use of rhGH--so why go there? The article actually affirmed that the majority of our natural supply comes during sleep but nothing further was said about it. It did mention that exercise does stimulate natural GH production, but other research has revealed that nighttime secretion is still the most plenteous.
  • Posts: 709 Member
    MsPudding:

    I :heart: you so much right now!!
  • Posts: 4,564 Member
    I really puffy heart this thread
  • Posts: 2,827 Member
    The problem with eating late at night is that when you lay down all the food settles in whatever direction you're laying down and then sinks into your body as fat!! So lay on your back and all that food is going to turn into a fat *kitten*....lay on your side and your late night meal with settle into fat hips....lay on your front and you'll get a bigger belly.

    Eating during the day whilst you're moving around means the food never has a chance to settle and become fat; instead it swiches around and gets broken down into smaller and smaller pieces as you move around until they're too small to even become fat...and then your body expels them.

    FACT.

    Perfect. ;)
  • Posts: 1,689 Member
    i munch all night before i go to bed. i get home from work later, eat dinner and a few snacks and go to bed shortly after. my bmi is in the 17s...
  • Posts: 3,202 Member
    Why are all you people resorting to silliness? I think the OP was trying to track down a subject and the sarcastic tone is really juvenile and mistreating what is, to her, a serious subject. While I agree that the timing of eating is irrelevant to weight loss, there were other issues raised in addition to that one.
  • Posts: 28,072 Member

    Did you cite the wrong article? I read the entire thing and it was basically just speaking to the issue of taking exogenous GH. No one here was advocating any artificial use of rhGH--so why go there? The article actually affirmed that the majority of our natural supply comes during sleep but nothing further was said about it. It did mention that exercise does stimulate natural GH production, but other research has revealed that nighttime secretion is still the most plenteous.

    That was not the reason I posted it.
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    That was not the reason I posted it.

    Then, would you like to reveal your purpose?
  • Hi
    i as an ex SW consultant was always trained that it does not matter what time you eat as long as you stick to the plan your following
    i had many shift workers i.e nurses in my group eating at funny times and they lost weight consistantly
  • Posts: 268 Member
    I eat before bed every night. My lifestyle hasn't allowed me to do it any other way and I've been successful in losing the weight and keeping it off. My personal deduction ... Your body adjusts. Eat less and move more.
  • Posts: 28,072 Member

    Then, would you like to reveal your purpose?

    I though that my post explained that when I said:

    "Here is a review of the anabolic effects of GH from the British Journal of Sports Medicine for people concerned about GH being suppressed by eating at night."
  • Posts: 2,848 Member
    i munch all night before i go to bed. i get home from work later, eat dinner and a few snacks and go to bed shortly after. my bmi is in the 17s...

    Looks like you play Twister too. I also played Twister back in the 60s. I was very thin then. Correlation?
  • Posts: 1,907 Member
    Nevermind
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    I though that my post explained that when I said:

    "Here is a review of the anabolic effects of GH from the British Journal of Sports Medicine for people concerned about GH being suppressed by eating at night."

    But the article did not speak to that.
  • Posts: 3,202 Member
    Hi
    i as an ex SW consultant was always trained that it does not matter what time you eat as long as you stick to the plan your following
    i had many shift workers i.e nurses in my group eating at funny times and they lost weight consistantly

    While I agree with you on the parameter of weight loss or maintenance, there are other health issues. I think we all pretty much accept that meal timing is irrelevant to weight loss, but overall health is, or should be an important concern as well.
  • Posts: 28,072 Member

    But the article did not speak to that.

    Does not speak to what?
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    Does not speak to what?

    The issue of natural GH being suppressed by eating a lot before bed.
  • Posts: 28,072 Member

    The issue of natural GH being suppressed by eating a lot before bed.

    I never said it did
  • I never eat anything after I have finished my last meal which could be anywhere from 6:00 - 7:00 pm. I cant sleep very well going to bed on a full stomach, plus I love the feeling of waking up hungry. It makes sure I dont skip breakfast.
  • Posts: 1,503 Member
    I snack every night around 8:30-9 PM. I go to bed at 10. I'm losing 2-4 pounds per week without fail and from measurements and educated guesses (since we all know BF% calculations outside of the fancy expensive ones aren't exact) my BF is going down.
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    I never said it did

    Then why did you mention it?
  • Posts: 2,037 Member
    Why are all you people resorting to silliness? I think the OP was trying to track down a subject and the sarcastic tone is really juvenile and mistreating what is, to her, a serious subject. While I agree that the timing of eating is irrelevant to weight loss, there were other issues raised in addition to that one.

    Erm, because the subject was well and truly discussed and a conclusion reached by the end of page 2 (i.e. calories in, calories out, time of day does not matter). But we were all having such a lovely time chatting we decided to continue with the thread. I really don't know why this would upset you.

    If the OP disagrees then we will stop, but I haven't heard that she does.
  • Posts: 2,037 Member


    It's ok, I know the science of weight loss can be confounding at times....although I have to say that you are very perceptive because you are right, having soda make *all* your food float to the top is as bad as having it all settling to the bottom...it just means you'll get a fat torso rather than a fat *kitten*.

    So; there are two solutions for you:

    1. Moderate your soda intake. Take a few sips, then a few bites of your food, then a few more sips so that everything is a bit more mixed up.
    2. Invest in my Gyronator 3000; proven to gently mix your food into small, non-fat making particles. This man lost 350lb with a healthy 'low density food diet' and 30 minutes a day on the Gyronator 3000 and he's never looked back!

    188_gyro_shoot_009.jpg

    You are now officially my new MFP hero :heart:
  • Posts: 1,857 Member

    Bolded for the shear genius.

    :heart: :heart: :heart: :heart:
  • Posts: 3,202 Member

    Erm, because the subject was well and truly discussed and a conclusion reached by the end of page 2 (i.e. calories in, calories out, time of day does not matter). But we were all having such a lovely time chatting we decided to continue with the thread. I really don't know why this would upset you.

    If the OP disagrees then we will stop, but I haven't heard that she does.

    It doesn't upset me, but I was concerned that she would feel that others were looking down on her.
  • Posts: 1,089 Member

    I have nothing.

    Can I pre pay for your book, pretty please?
  • Posts: 964 Member

    Then you're not concerned about Bob losing weight. Because those are the key, no, the ONLY relevant points as to if he will lose weight or not.

    She answered her own question.
    :noway:
This discussion has been closed.