Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Pop tarts vs. Toaster Strudel

    Posts: 12,589 Member
    edited January 19 in Food and Nutrition
    TartVStrudelDebate_zpsb8dd2f09.jpg

    There clearly is only one answer. Let it begin!


    poptartVSStrudel_zpsa673fb6d.jpg

    PopTartGang_zps256b03a2.jpg

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register
    «134567…10

    Replies

    • Posts: 125 Member
      They are both delicious.

      But I think toaster strudel wins by photo finish in taste.
    • Posts: 3,306 Member
      meh, i can grab and go with pop tarts.

      ain't everybody got time for toaster strudels.
    • Posts: 5,320 Member
      I have never had a toaster strudel.

      A pop tart is a pop tart, it seems a toaster strudel would make me want a fruit filled croissant or other fresh pastry.
    • Posts: 562 Member
      Pop tarts.
    • Posts: 352 Member
      Bith please. Do I really have to answer??

      24, ppl!
    • Posts: 28,072 Member
      Cinnamon Toaster Strudel > Pop Tarts without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any other Toaster Strudel without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any Toaster Strudel (including cinammon) with ice cream


      Clear?
    • Posts: 218 Member
      Dry cardboard vs flaky yummy with frosting you put on? Strudels all the way.
    • Posts: 2,848 Member
      POP TART - brown sugar cinnamon unfrosted - don't need plastic icing.
    • Posts: 2,276 Member
      Cinnamon Toaster Strudel > Pop Tarts without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any other Toaster Strudel without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any Toaster Strudel (including cinammon) with ice cream


      Clear?

      thank jeebus I've won someone over! =)
    • Posts: 458
      Not even close! Pop Tarts all the way! MMMMM is so miss those! LOL
    • Posts: 4,733 Member
      meh, i can grab and go with pop tarts.

      ain't everybody got time for toaster strudels.

      this.
    • Posts: 6,420 Member
      Both are disgusting. Get some real, fresh bakery!
    • Posts: 8,927 Member
      I haven't seen cinnamon toaster strudels around here. I just see raspberry, strawberry, mixed berry, blueberry and apple. One of my daughters likes them, so I get them for her (and I have one once in a while, among those options I like the raspberry).
    • Posts: 6,897 Member
      toaster strudels are the bomb!
    • Posts: 2,525 Member
      TOASTER SCRAMBLES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • Posts: 15,357 Member
      Cinnamon Toaster Strudel > Pop Tarts without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any other Toaster Strudel without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any Toaster Strudel (including cinammon) with ice cream


      Clear?

      Wait, ice cream makes Toaster Strudel worse?
    • Posts: 22,834 Member
      Pop tart iz Teh Shizzle.
    • Posts: 6,897 Member
      Cinnamon Toaster Strudel > Pop Tarts without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any other Toaster Strudel without ice cream
      Pop Tarts > any Toaster Strudel (including cinammon) with ice cream


      Clear?

      Clear but wrong. Love you girl but you're oh so wrong. Ice cream cannot be factored into the pop tart vs toaster strudel debate. That's cheating.

      strawberry frosted pop tart > any other poptart flavor
      strawberry cream cheese toaster strudel > strawberry frosted poptart

      therefore...

      strawberry cream cheese toaster strudel > any pop tart
    • Posts: 1,344 Member
      This debate is invalid. How are they comparable? It's like comparing pancakes to an omelette. You eat them both for different reasons. Pop Tarts are good for your soul. Toaster Strudels are for when you feel fancy.
    • Posts: 1,296 Member
      Pop-tarts, brown sugar cinnamon
    • Posts: 419 Member
      If I have to have one I will choose the Pop Tart but I would much rather have a bagel or a croissant *drool*
    • Posts: 263 Member
      cake confetti pop tarts
    • Posts: 2,197 Member
      Can I suggest baklava? Basically the otherside of the world's version of a strudel.
    • Posts: 396 Member
      Toaster Strudel
    • Posts: 94 Member
      Cherry Pop Tarts are in line with bacon on my top things I LOVE to eat. Toaster Strudel are ok, but Pop Tarts will always have my heart.
    • Posts: 418 Member
      Pop Tarts...Frosted Cherry! Yum!
    • Posts: 6,897 Member
      This debate is invalid. How are they comparable? It's like comparing pancakes to an omelette. You eat them both for different reasons. Pop Tarts are good for your soul. Toaster Strudels are for when you feel fancy.

      nah nah nah. The comparison is likened to that of french toast vs pancakes or waffles vs pancakes.
    • Posts: 1,344 Member
      show previous quotes

      nah nah nah. The comparison is likened to that of french toast vs pancakes or waffles vs pancakes.
      Fine. Then I choose Pop Tarts...but with my pinkies out when I eat them.
    • Posts: 479 Member
      Poptarts for shelf life and the fact that you can eat them if your electricity goes out...but really Toaster Strdel is my favorite!!!
    • Posts: 4,733 Member
      show previous quotes
      Fine. Then I choose Pop Tarts...but with my pinkies out when I eat them.

      don't forget to put a doily down on the table, under your plate, when eating the toaster strudel.
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories