Is it bad my daughter wants to shred?!?
stephx4
Posts: 810
My 6 year old daughter keeps asking if she can do the shred. She's even gone to the extent of you tubing to find it?!?
0
Replies
-
Safety-wise, if you keep an eye on her form she'd be okay.
However, what is her reason? Has she seen you and wants to be like you, or does she think she's fat?
If it's the latter this could be a problem and I would definitely try to get to the bottom of it. Has someone said something to make her think that?0 -
I thinks it's because she's heard me talk about calories and needing to lose weight.
she asked me if she'd lost weight this morning!!
She's also said its fun and she enjoys exercise.0 -
I'd say humor her and let her "shred". It's great that she wants to be like you...Just don't let her get too crazy0
-
I thinks it's because she's heard me talk about calories and needing to lose weight. she asked me if she'd lost weight this morning!!
She's also said its fun and she enjoys exercise.
I commend you on being such an exemplary role model for your child. This is how it should be all across the world! My 12 year old son always asks "are you going to walk today? or workout? We can go around 7:30" I think is is great he wants to do what I am doing. I think he realizes I am doing this to be a better version of me and he appreciates it. Just make sure she gets the exercise part but also the importance of eating! EAT EAT EAT it is good to EAT! But you have to exercise to balance it out. Back when I was her age we did something similar to 30 day shred all the time but it was gym class everyday something that is lacking now lol0 -
If it is just her wanting to be like you I wouldn't worry too much. But I would tell her she's beautiful and doesn't need to lose weight, and explain about the other health benefits of exercise. Maybe try her with some fun dancing exercise. You can get Zumba routines on youtube, or if you type koo koo kangaroo into youtube there are dance routines aimed at kids that my class of 6 and 7 year olds love!0
-
Im confused. Does you daughter need to lose weight? IS she concerned at her weight at 6 years old? IS it even safe for a 6 year old to do the 30 day shred?
Please explain because to me it sounds too extreme for a small child.
I know that my weight issued started at home. My mom was always on a diet.0 -
Im confused. Does you daughter need to lose weight? IS she concerned at her weight at 6 years old? IS it even safe for a 6 year old to do the 30 day shred?
Please explain because to me it sounds too extreme for a small child.
Yes it is extreme for a 6 yr old child to want to exercise and be like mommy lol Plant her in front of the TV with some cookies and candies and go in the other room and hide while you workout in secret to save her from being FIT and HEALTHY lol0 -
You might want to change your language at home, saying that you need to get fit, rather than lose weight. That' what I do to prevent my kids getting unnecessary hang-ups from my attempts to be healthier. You can tell her also that she's welcome to do it (I'd say without weights) but that she gets fit from running around and playing outside, so she doesn't need to do a special routine the way mommy does.0
-
OH OK!!! so the 30 day shred is not about dieting? How stupid of me.
I guess thats why I asked.0 -
Exactly.0
-
Im confused. Does you daughter need to lose weight? IS she concerned at her weight at 6 years old? IS it even safe for a 6 year old to do the 30 day shred?
Please explain because to me it sounds too extreme for a small child.
Yes it is extreme for a 6 yr old child to want to exercise and be like mommy lol Plant her in front of the TV with some cookies and candies and go in the other room and hide while you workout in secret to save her from being FIT and HEALTHY lol
Did I suggest for her to feed her kid cookies instead of promoting a healthy life style?
wow0 -
OH OK!!! so the 30 day shred is not about dieting? How stupid of me.
I guess thats why I asked.
30 day shred is about exercising.....what you consume is about dieting. Two totally separate things but when accompanied together properly will help you reach the best results possible. She just said her little girl wants to do what she is doing exercise wise. She is too young to correlate weight loss with eating and exercise so she needs to be taught that. Starting by allowing her to participate is a great first step to introduce health and nutrition to her. Plus she will be able to eat more if she likes it and exercises with mommy. The goal is to teach them it is okay to eat and that eating can lead to fat loss coupled with exercise. She is setting her daughter up to never have an ED. Very smart mommy!0 -
My 6 year old daughter keeps asking if she can do the shred. She's even gone to the extent of you tubing to find it?!?
it's perfectly ok. she's just excited to be involved in the same thing you're doing. but she'll lose interest eventually and move on to being obsessed with something else. she's a kid. that's what they do.
0 -
I have 3 boys 17, 13, 12 and they ask me about my workouts and my eating. I think its ok to let your child(ren) know why you do what you do. However, I think it is good to let them know/learn that it is good to "get moving". If your child wants to do your shred with you let her try, but explain to her that she needs to take it slow and if she starts to feel sore that it is ok to take a break. Also, you could tell her that the shred is just for mom, but that sometime throughout the day you and her could go for a walk together and maybe throw in a little run. This would be teaching her how to be healthy in activity. I think at her age she just wants to be like you and spend time with you, so make it fun and at the same time let her know that mom needs to have somethings just for you. Good luck! Just don't let her over do or go to extremes and you should be fine0
-
I thinks it's because she's heard me talk about calories and needing to lose weight. she asked me if she'd lost weight this morning!!
She's also said its fun and she enjoys exercise.
I commend you on being such an exemplary role model for your child. This is how it should be all across the world! My 12 year old son always asks "are you going to walk today? or workout? We can go around 7:30" I think is is great he wants to do what I am doing. I think he realizes I am doing this to be a better version of me and he appreciates it. Just make sure she gets the exercise part but also the importance of eating! EAT EAT EAT it is good to EAT! But you have to exercise to balance it out. Back when I was her age we did something similar to 30 day shred all the time but it was gym class everyday something that is lacking now lol
This!
I am sure she is just copying you because she wants to be like you. Kudos for being such an example! :-) Give her a big hug and say yes. Just help her along and make it kid friendly. She will love exercising with you.
I am sure she is just talking about calories and weight loss to have a grown-up-like conversation with you. Just keep and eye on her. You guys are going to have a blast! ♥0 -
OH OK!!! so the 30 day shred is not about dieting? How stupid of me.
I guess thats why I asked.
30 day shred is about exercising.....what you consume is about dieting. Two totally separate things but when accompanied together properly will help you reach the best results possible. She just said her little girl wants to do what she is doing exercise wise. She is too young to correlate weight loss with eating and exercise so she needs to be taught that. Starting by allowing her to participate is a great first step to introduce health and nutrition to her. Plus she will be able to eat more if she likes it and exercises with mommy. The goal is to teach them it is okay to eat and that eating can lead to fat loss coupled with exercise. She is setting her daughter up to never have an ED. Very smart mommy!
I'm not so convinced by your arguments. I don't think it's a problem to let her 6 year old do 30DS, but I don't think she should being led to the idea of needing to exercise to lose fat. At six, she should understand you exercise because it's fun and because it's good for you. If she needs specifics about why it's good, I'd stick with things like it helps your muscles get strong, it helps you sleep better at night and it's good for your brain to make your blood move fast around your body by moving your body fast. I would strongly suggest leaving out all reference to exercise and fat loss at this age.0 -
This is absolutely adorable. It actually makes me wish I had a child, and I have sworn I would have never have any.
I do the 30 Day Shred, and I'm sure that a 6 year old could do those exercises much easier than an adult could - just don't give her any hand weights. Think back to when you were a kid and the stuff you did then that you can't do now. I used to do kart wheels all the time - I haven't attempted one since I was about 11, and I doubt it would be very pretty now
While I agree about keeping looks and vanity out of the conversation, there is nothing wrong with discussing weight management with a child and why you are doing it for yourself.0 -
You might want to change your language at home, saying that you need to get fit, rather than lose weight. That' what I do to prevent my kids getting unnecessary hang-ups from my attempts to be healthier. You can tell her also that she's welcome to do it (I'd say without weights) but that she gets fit from running around and playing outside, so she doesn't need to do a special routine the way mommy does.
Great advice0 -
My almost 17 year old daughter used to take martial arts classes. She was in the best shape and had a knockout body. Then suddenly, she quit the classes. She also likes to go eat fast food every day for lunch, as it is within walking distance of her high school.
Well GUESS WHAT HAPPENED? Yep, suddenly that rocking body of hers has gone soft and pudgy. And, yes, I TOLD her that is what will happen if you live on junk food 5 days a week.
Was I fat shaming her? Was I bullying her? NO, I was stating very clearly that what she eats affects her body, and that what she does for exercise prevents her from becoming fat.
She needed to know, and I love her enough to tell her like it is.0 -
You might want to change your language at home, saying that you need to get fit, rather than lose weight. That' what I do to prevent my kids getting unnecessary hang-ups from my attempts to be healthier. You can tell her also that she's welcome to do it (I'd say without weights) but that she gets fit from running around and playing outside, so she doesn't need to do a special routine the way mommy does.
This is excellent advice
0 -
It's fine, but she shouldn't use weights.0
-
6??????
0 -
OH OK!!! so the 30 day shred is not about dieting? How stupid of me.
I guess thats why I asked.
30 day shred is about exercising.....what you consume is about dieting. Two totally separate things but when accompanied together properly will help you reach the best results possible. She just said her little girl wants to do what she is doing exercise wise. She is too young to correlate weight loss with eating and exercise so she needs to be taught that. Starting by allowing her to participate is a great first step to introduce health and nutrition to her. Plus she will be able to eat more if she likes it and exercises with mommy. The goal is to teach them it is okay to eat and that eating can lead to fat loss coupled with exercise. She is setting her daughter up to never have an ED. Very smart mommy!
I'm not so convinced by your arguments. I don't think it's a problem to let her 6 year old do 30DS, but I don't think she should being led to the idea of needing to exercise to lose fat. At six, she should understand you exercise because it's fun and because it's good for you. If she needs specifics about why it's good, I'd stick with things like it helps your muscles get strong, it helps you sleep better at night and it's good for your brain to make your blood move fast around your body by moving your body fast. I would strongly suggest leaving out all reference to exercise and fat loss at this age.
It is not an argument it is a statement. I am not trying to convince you of anything. My statement....
"The goal is to teach them it is okay to eat and that eating can lead to fat loss coupled with exercise."
is fact. Says nothing about the little girl being worried about being fat. If you choose to teach your children that you exercise because it is fun and helps your muscles get strong that is your choice. I think that leaving out the fact that it prevents you from being fat is just as important as the others. It is not okay to be fat and when ppl stop coddling children about it or hiding it from them we will be a much more healthier world. It is never too early to teach a child that fat is not okay and can lead to many health problems.0 -
My (almost) 3 year old tries to do the workouts with me. Just let her copy you. Don't let her use weights. Its great to be a role model. Don't try and hide the fact that you eat healthy and workout from her... its great for her to learn to be healthy now instead of trying to figure it out when she is older.0
-
There is a big difference between reaching your children to lead a healthy lifestyle and exercise regularly, and teaching them to be careful about calories and be almost scared to eat.
If I were you, talk of being healthy to her but limit talking about calories and weight loss around her.0 -
You might want to change your language at home, saying that you need to get fit, rather than lose weight. That' what I do to prevent my kids getting unnecessary hang-ups from my attempts to be healthier. You can tell her also that she's welcome to do it (I'd say without weights) but that she gets fit from running around and playing outside, so she doesn't need to do a special routine the way mommy does.
This is excellent advice
this
if she want to use weights, give her really light ones or maybe 2 small water botles (empty)0 -
Getting kids into exercise is not a bad thing, but I would be careful about using the words "lose weight". At 6, or any age, it should be about being healthy and eating right. I am a lifelong anorexic and bulimic so I have to watch the words that I say to my impressionable 8 year old daughters. I try to give them a healthy outlook rather than talk diets. They both love to ride bicycles, run and eat right. I don't want them to have a body image problem but I also want them to know that eating right and exercise makes you feel good. That said, my girls love to do the videos with me and I do not let them use weights.0
-
My (almost) 3 year old tries to do the workouts with me. Just let her copy you. Don't let her use weights. Its great to be a role model. Don't try and hide the fact that you eat healthy and workout from her... its great for her to learn to be healthy now instead of trying to figure it out when she is older.
OMG too cute I thought 6 yr old was cute but 3 ahahaha! This thread has made my day there is HOPE!!!! TY all I am going to make sure I exercise today!0 -
Both my 7 year old and my (almost) 3 year old work out with us and I'm working on jogging with both. Yes, the 3 y.o. has a long way to go but if I tickle her she'll run about 2 miles. lol My 7 y.o. is in MMA classes 5 days a week and works out with kettle bells in addition. I think the important part is in how you present it. This is "play," "fun," and "getting strong," and not about losing weight.0
-
My (almost) 3 year old tries to do the workouts with me. Just let her copy you. Don't let her use weights. Its great to be a role model. Don't try and hide the fact that you eat healthy and workout from her... its great for her to learn to be healthy now instead of trying to figure it out when she is older.
This. As long as you're not going around talking about how fat you are and being negative all the time, then it doesn't hurt to instill healthy habits. My DD just turned 4, and she has been joining in with me every once in a while. She also thinks that most food is homemade. I love instilling this healthy mindset into her, without having her form a negative opinion/issues surrounding weight. I also agree with another poster that she'll probably lose interest after a while.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions