Negative feedback on my food diary

13

Replies

  • CrazyTrackLady
    CrazyTrackLady Posts: 1,337 Member
    Some people need more motivation than others. Some people actually do NEED to have someone make them feel guilty so they don't do it again! If you are not one of those people, and you do not need help with your Food Diary then go ahead and make it private. To have it public is an open invite for criticizing & congratulating. I doubt that member was trying to be rude, they were just trying to motivate you to think twice before eating that way. One Cheat Day can X out 5 Good days. So I have been told. But if you have the calories from running, I say go for it. Others think differently. If you don't want the hardcore No junk food, no rest days etc etc. Friends then remove them. Hehe. No need to feel bad if you are ok with Cheat Days. Hope this gives you a little bit of a different perspective on those kind of members. Most people on here are just trying to help & that's what I tell myself. Then again, I don't add many people as friends. Hehe But I do have one of those hardcore friends that kick my *kitten* on things here and there. Some things are helpful others make me grumble in her direction but hey, she's just trying to help. <333

    I disagree. One 250 cal food item is NOT going to undue the hard work done over the course of several days and months. There is a huge difference between being supportive and being obnoxious. The commenter was being way too petty.
  • randomtai
    randomtai Posts: 9,003 Member
    Just delete that person from your friends list.

    This!!! I WISH someone would comment something negative on my food diary. No one knows what any one person goes through on a single day to make up their food choices. What kind of loser sits around commenting on other people's food choices???
  • randomtai
    randomtai Posts: 9,003 Member
    Some people need more motivation than others. Some people actually do NEED to have someone make them feel guilty so they don't do it again! If you are not one of those people, and you do not need help with your Food Diary then go ahead and make it private. To have it public is an open invite for criticizing & congratulating. I doubt that member was trying to be rude, they were just trying to motivate you to think twice before eating that way. One Cheat Day can X out 5 Good days. So I have been told. But if you have the calories from running, I say go for it. Others think differently. If you don't want the hardcore No junk food, no rest days etc etc. Friends then remove them. Hehe. No need to feel bad if you are ok with Cheat Days. Hope this gives you a little bit of a different perspective on those kind of members. Most people on here are just trying to help & that's what I tell myself. Then again, I don't add many people as friends. Hehe But I do have one of those hardcore friends that kick my *kitten* on things here and there. Some things are helpful others make me grumble in her direction but hey, she's just trying to help. <333

    WOW! :noway:
  • cruzcrzyMarie
    cruzcrzyMarie Posts: 251 Member
    That's part of why I kept my diary private when I was logging calories. I know what I'm doing with my diet, and I refuse to feel guilty about my indulging. I don't find it helpful to have people, without any training or real knowledge, scrutinizing my food choices and offering feedback.

    Everyone is here to use different tools that the site offers. The public food diary function isn't one I need.

    SAME HERE. My food diary is for my own accountability. I've been maintaining my weight loss for over a year now.
  • suz155
    suz155 Posts: 326 Member
    I'm just the opposite. For me, just like, in the real world, I want the upbeat, as well as the constructive criticism. I am one of these people who is addicted to food. I can very easily b.s. myself, that's why I got so heavy to begin with. I want the truth from people, not just the bubbles and sunshine. That being said, before, I give constructive criticism, I ask the people, do you want my feedback?
  • cwilliams080676
    cwilliams080676 Posts: 118 Member
    There's always that one person who has to say stuff. I have them on my list too. You are doing super Friend request me, I don't do that.
  • annaldora
    annaldora Posts: 19 Member
    I'm sure the person who made the negative comment has NEVER had a cheat or off day! Ummmmm......Yea, right!! Yep, just delete them......Have a wonderful weekend!!
  • cwolfman13
    cwolfman13 Posts: 41,865 Member
    Just break up...i.e. delete.
  • SlowlyLosingLolita
    SlowlyLosingLolita Posts: 93 Member
    I always keep mine private just for that reason-I always got horrible messages.
    When I would get busy I simply forget to log lunches. Or if I was out and about all day or gone for the weekend I would go back and log what I remembered eating and I would always get awful messages from people screaming at me.
    I got called anorexic, I got accused of LYING once which was just weird, and I got tons of messages telling me the exact calories I should have eaten. I just got sick of it and made everything private.
    I deleted the few that were really mean about it but if someone wrote me with good intentions I felt bad deleting them.
    They were just worried I guess but it made me feel really self conscious about my diary.
  • BeachGingerOnTheRocks
    BeachGingerOnTheRocks Posts: 3,927 Member
    'Watch your fat young lady' is the best one I've had! I was a bit miffed and thought about deleting the offender but I decided against it. I was still under cals and I'd been eating out a lot as we had family staying with us. I decided against it but I was annoyed I felt like I had to explain myself. But that's what you get for having a public diary. I wouldn't make a comment like that but that doesn't stop others. I look at diarys just for ideas so I like to think I'm returning the favour by keeping mine public.

    If you are under on your calories and someone thinks you've had too much fat, that person probably doesn't know a whole lot about nutrition and the feedback is mostly useless.

    I only ever comment on someone's diary in a critiquing way when they post in the forums seeking help. My friends generally aren't asking for my input simply by completing their diaries.

    Everyone is entitled to eat what they want, except my husband, who gets plenty of feedback in the form of the meals I make for him. (kidding, kind of)
  • mel3491
    mel3491 Posts: 31
    You go girl! You are more likely not to track it if you fear someone will comment and make you feel bad. We have worked hard to get where we are at and you certainly don't need someone you barely know responsible for derailing you!
  • Jessica_D_Shadow
    Jessica_D_Shadow Posts: 138 Member
    Some people need more motivation than others. Some people actually do NEED to have someone make them feel guilty so they don't do it again! If you are not one of those people, and you do not need help with your Food Diary then go ahead and make it private. To have it public is an open invite for criticizing & congratulating. I doubt that member was trying to be rude, they were just trying to motivate you to think twice before eating that way. One Cheat Day can X out 5 Good days. So I have been told. But if you have the calories from running, I say go for it. Others think differently. If you don't want the hardcore No junk food, no rest days etc etc. Friends then remove them. Hehe. No need to feel bad if you are ok with Cheat Days. Hope this gives you a little bit of a different perspective on those kind of members. Most people on here are just trying to help & that's what I tell myself. Then again, I don't add many people as friends. Hehe But I do have one of those hardcore friends that kick my *kitten* on things here and there. Some things are helpful others make me grumble in her direction but hey, she's just trying to help. <333

    WOW! :noway:

    <3 Just trying to show a different perspective.
  • mumtoonegirl
    mumtoonegirl Posts: 586 Member
    yeah delete someone who is not going to be there, you typically eat healthy so why is it anyone's business if you want to have the occassional treat, this is a life change, you do not have the occasional treat you won't have lifelong success. I am for having friends who give honest feedback but going at someone for one treat in an otherwise healthy plan - screw them.

    I do always put a note in my diary on days that are my 'treat' days or days where things have been upside down and my numbers are not what they are normally.
  • Iron_Lotus
    Iron_Lotus Posts: 2,295 Member
    Some people need more motivation than others. Some people actually do NEED to have someone make them feel guilty so they don't do it again! If you are not one of those people, and you do not need help with your Food Diary then go ahead and make it private. To have it public is an open invite for criticizing & congratulating. I doubt that member was trying to be rude, they were just trying to motivate you to think twice before eating that way. One Cheat Day can X out 5 Good days. So I have been told. But if you have the calories from running, I say go for it. Others think differently. If you don't want the hardcore No junk food, no rest days etc etc. Friends then remove them. Hehe. No need to feel bad if you are ok with Cheat Days. Hope this gives you a little bit of a different perspective on those kind of members. Most people on here are just trying to help & that's what I tell myself. Then again, I don't add many people as friends. Hehe But I do have one of those hardcore friends that kick my *kitten* on things here and there. Some things are helpful others make me grumble in her direction but hey, she's just trying to help. <333



    Wow.
  • HappyElizabeth
    HappyElizabeth Posts: 231 Member
    Delete that holier-than-thou "friend". It's My Fitness *Pal*, not the Food Police.
  • pholbert
    pholbert Posts: 575 Member
    I just came from denny's. IT is Fathers Day. I had breakfast with my husband and 2 son's and 1 4 yr old grandson.I loved it. I don't feel bad about it at all!. I am a lucky girl.
  • Jessica_D_Shadow
    Jessica_D_Shadow Posts: 138 Member
    I'm just the opposite. For me, just like, in the real world, I want the upbeat, as well as the constructive criticism. I am one of these people who is addicted to food. I can very easily b.s. myself, that's why I got so heavy to begin with. I want the truth from people, not just the bubbles and sunshine. That being said, before, I give constructive criticism, I ask the people, do you want my feedback?


    To all the "Wow"-zers. Here is someone that is the opposite & needs the motivation. Hehe. Everyone gets motivation to lose weight differently. Everyone takes thier OWN journey to weight loss & getting healthy.

    OP- Do it how YOU want to do it. Because in the end it's YOUR journey to make! =) You can do this girl! Take it one day @ a time! <33
  • Rockstar_JILL
    Rockstar_JILL Posts: 514 Member
    I keep my food diary private as it is only MY business what I eat and how I manage my food intake. I eat enough and I exercise lots. I have lost almost 90 lbs. doing it MY WAY and I will continue to do it that way. I won't feel guilty for having had beer and nachos yesterday...I don't think everyone needs to know what I eat everyday anyway. This is MY journey and I love having great supporters to help me along and I love to support others. I don't even have time to look at everyone's journals everyday. I will only peek in once and awhile to see what other's are eating. Just do what you need to do to make this happen for you. :)
  • randomtai
    randomtai Posts: 9,003 Member
    I'm just the opposite. For me, just like, in the real world, I want the upbeat, as well as the constructive criticism. I am one of these people who is addicted to food. I can very easily b.s. myself, that's why I got so heavy to begin with. I want the truth from people, not just the bubbles and sunshine. That being said, before, I give constructive criticism, I ask the people, do you want my feedback?


    To all the "Wow"-zers. Here is someone that is the opposite & needs the motivation. Hehe. Everyone gets motivation to lose weight differently. Everyone takes thier OWN journey to weight loss & getting healthy.

    OP- Do it how YOU want to do it. Because in the end it's YOUR journey to make! =) You can do this girl! Take it one day @ a time! <33

    There is a difference between constructive criticism that is asked for, and sticking your nose in someone else's business. The latter is what the thread is about. :smile: :flowerforyou:
  • TarHeelChick64
    TarHeelChick64 Posts: 25 Member
    You have nothing to feel guilty about. This entire week has been a cheat day for me. I just didn't feel like eating healthy. I start out eating sensibly but by the time the afternoon came around I wanted something sugary sweet (pop-tarts, Hershey Kisses, etc.) Luckily, I haven't gained any weight and I know today I will eat healthier and do better.
    Congratulations on losing the 23 pounds, that is fantastic!
  • Jessica_D_Shadow
    Jessica_D_Shadow Posts: 138 Member
    I'm just the opposite. For me, just like, in the real world, I want the upbeat, as well as the constructive criticism. I am one of these people who is addicted to food. I can very easily b.s. myself, that's why I got so heavy to begin with. I want the truth from people, not just the bubbles and sunshine. That being said, before, I give constructive criticism, I ask the people, do you want my feedback?


    To all the "Wow"-zers. Here is someone that is the opposite & needs the motivation. Hehe. Everyone gets motivation to lose weight differently. Everyone takes thier OWN journey to weight loss & getting healthy.

    OP- Do it how YOU want to do it. Because in the end it's YOUR journey to make! =) You can do this girl! Take it one day @ a time! <33

    There is a difference between constructive criticism that is asked for, and sticking your nose in someone else's business. The latter is what the thread is about. :smile: :flowerforyou:

    In respect of the OP, I will take heed to the nipping at my ankles & head out of the conversation here. <3 Good luck with your journey OMGitzj3551k4. Take things one day @ a time & don't let others bring you down. You can do this! & Don't let anyone tell you differently! Take care!
  • MelsAuntie
    MelsAuntie Posts: 2,833 Member
    Well, how rude is that? Nobody has the right to chastise you about what you eat except your doctor, for medical reasons.
  • laserturkey
    laserturkey Posts: 1,680 Member
    Yeah, I'm pretty sure if someone made an idiotic comment like that to me, they would be right OFF my friends list.
  • katemcon
    katemcon Posts: 9
    I think people only make negative comments about other people when they feel bad about themselves. Don't worry about one person's comment, you have done so well, be proud of that.
  • Timmmy40
    Timmmy40 Posts: 152 Member
    A good day is logging everything you eat, and keeping a healthy conscious mind with food intake and exercise. Just getting off the couch and going for a walk makes it a good day. It doesn't matter if you were over on your calories. You logged it. Make today a better day than yesterday. You are allowed to eat off of your calorie plan. I do it more often than I want, and I hold myself accountable by logging it in my diary.

    A year and a half ago before I started this new chapter in my life I ate everything. I ate 3 times the portions I should have. I ate a big snack while waiting for dinner to finish cooking. I probably ate 5000 -6000 calories a day, and that was probably a light day. Now, I eat around 2200 and I burn off 1000 – 1500 calories on average with exercise. So, for me anything under 5000 calorie intake a day is a great day.

    You are logging your food and exercise. That makes it a good day. You make healthy choices every day. You are allowed to splurge. If I don't splurge every now and then I know I would have fallen off the wagon as they say a year ago. Keep doing what you are doing and delete that friend. There are plenty of good motivating people on this site that help instead of making discouraging comments. If you need a friend like that feel free to add me.
    Keep Punching! All Is Possible! It Is A Choice! No Excuses! Never Quit!!
  • Maano79
    Maano79 Posts: 4 Member
    Firstly, congratulations on loosing so much weight and healthy eating. Secondly, whoever gives negative comments on your food diary or anything else then ignore and delete. So what if you had a rest day and ate a whole bunch of calories? No big deal, you're not doing it all the time and it was a once in a while treat. The best thing is that you have balance. All the best.
  • DianeLyn56
    DianeLyn56 Posts: 5
    My food diary is private because I refuse to eat diet food. lol I would rather have smaller portions of foods I enjoy and I eat three pieces of dark chocolate Doves a day. :D I don't criticize anyone because we are all in this together and we all have the right to eat what we want, and if we gain, we gain. Enjoy what you eat and continue on your path, you are doing great!
  • VpinkLotus
    VpinkLotus Posts: 849 Member
    Don't worry about it. Honesty in your diary is important so you can have an accurate idea of what you are consuming. Good job for being honest and for a good run! If people on your list feel the need to make you feel crudy DELETE THEM.
  • NoeHead
    NoeHead Posts: 516 Member
    I'm sorry you had that kind of experience! far from constructive criticism and there is no need to that kind of "friend" for that kind of crappy support. good job on your weight loss so far!
  • Crochetluvr
    Crochetluvr Posts: 3,321 Member
    Yeah, I'm pretty sure if someone made an idiotic comment like that to me, they would be right OFF my friends list.

    ^^^This.

    I have never had ANY of my friends criticize anything I have eaten since I have been here. Guess I just have great friends. :)

Categories