Does anyone feel the same? (Lost weight but still feel fat?)

24

Replies

  • Sabresgal63
    Sabresgal63 Posts: 641 Member
    This is called body dismorphia. It's common. And it can cause you to give up. DON'T!

    Do something, put something one, hear someone and realize HOW FAR YOU HAVE COME and REFUSE to GO BACK!

    It's much harder the second time around.

    I agree and also dig deep to find that "Good something" that is different............like how you can walk farther, breathe easier, you don't jiggle so much when you walk........stuff like that
  • Alysgrma
    Alysgrma Posts: 365 Member
    I dont see the difference in myself either....but I FEEL the difference. When I started walking I couldn't walk around the block...Today at lunch I walked over 1 mile in just @ 23 min. That may not be to fast but for me....it was!!! I see it in little things
    like that each and every day...like keeping up with my 6yr old granddaughter dancing...before I would sit and watch her...now she will sit after awhile and watch ME!!!

    Dig Deep!!

    Mary
  • waldenfam2
    waldenfam2 Posts: 203 Member
    Absolutely! I was trying to explain it to someone who was calling me "skinny girl" the other night and when I was stumbling through an explanation of how I still feel like the fat girl she used the word anorexic which made me cringe. I'm afraid to talk about it because I feel like people think I'm fishing for compliments, but it's there...

    Makes me think maybe I should have kept just one pair of the size 26 jeans around to try on when I can't escape the feeling that I haven't really changed.

    Same here, lol. I had someone call me skinny minnie last weekend, and I'm like what?? I'm still a size 14 (my biggest was also size 26) I tried explaining to her how I don't see myself as different. Sure I'm more active, blah, blah, blah, but I still see myself as the fat girl. She instantly started looking at me weird, lol. Guess only people that have been there can truly understand.
  • scthomas01
    scthomas01 Posts: 17 Member
    i so feel u on this!! i had somebody call me "skinny minny" the other day and tell me that i don't need to lose anymore weight, i told her that i was trying to lose 17 more pounds and she was like "why, u look good like u are." but of course i don't see it like that. i got in to a size 12 the other day and i haven't been in a size 12 since 1997!!! i know going from a size 18-20 to a 12 is a big accomplishment but sometimes i still see the old me when i look in the mirror. i think as women we will never be satisfied with how we look no matter how small we get!!
  • ocylott
    ocylott Posts: 31
    when I was big, I always thought I looked better than I did...until I saw pics and realized I looked like hell.
    This works in reverse, too. Take pictures. We look at ourselves in the mirror every day, so we're used to ignoring the image we see there and replacing it with our mental image. But when you see a photograph, you're much more likely to see yourself as you really are.
  • ChristineNicole81
    ChristineNicole81 Posts: 31
    Yes, I now feel like instead of fat, I am "skinny fat". I have been working so hard to tone and it just isn't getting anywhere quick. I know toning takes more time, but the fact that my thighs still rub together after losing 30 lbs makes me feel nasty. Not to mention now my butt and thighs REALLY jiggle when I walk now, so no shorts, skirts or bikini for me! Nasty...
  • mamamc03
    mamamc03 Posts: 1,067 Member
    Constantly! I have lost 66lbs and I still hate my body. Some pics I can tell, some I cant. But I felt this way when I was in high school. At 180lbs I felt the same way I felt at 361lbs at my heaviest as I feel now at 295. It's frustrating. I'm wearing smaller everything, but I still see the same fatty in the mirror and hate her for making me miserable....I feel a blog coming on.
  • TheHerbGarden
    TheHerbGarden Posts: 48
    I really didn't think many, if any at all, people would feel the same. I've read every single post and agree with everyone of you. You're right this is going to take time to adjust to. Thanks to all that have posted and its good to know we are not alone in our thinking. We will get there :flowerforyou:
  • Vyshness8699
    Vyshness8699 Posts: 390 Member
    Yes I feel exactly the same way... I've lost 37lbs and I feel my body still looks the same:frown: Im hoping once i get to 125lbs i wnt feel this way
  • anacapenados
    anacapenados Posts: 13 Member
    Oh! my God I thought I was the only one felt that way, reading your comments made me realize that at least I'm not going crazy, I've lost 25pounds everybody says I look "skinny" I think they are lying, I am using old cloth that didn't fit anymore (4 sizes less) but everybody tells me that they look big and that I have to start buying new outfits. I'm afraid to go shopping, I'm afraid that I'll still be size 16 ... or that I have only lost 1 size and everybody is just lying to encourage me... I have a weird feeling I never had befor or in other times I've lost weight.

    I still have to lose 20 pounds, maybe when I lose them I'll feel ok.
  • albayin
    albayin Posts: 2,524 Member
    I know I am still fat because I haven't lost all I want to lose yet.
  • AnexRavensong
    AnexRavensong Posts: 262 Member
    That's me right now. Albeit I haven't lost as much weight as a lot of people here.. I lose weight, I gain it, but generally my non-scale measurements all move down. Should be a good thing, right?

    Well I was feeling pretty good last week when I finally got to 33% body fat (max high end of healthy for my age), but then as the days went on and I kept seeing my reflection, I felt like nothing has changed.

    I'm still fat. It doesn't help that my clothes are not consistent. I have a pair of size 46 jeans that I out grew ages ago, a pair of size 44s that don't cover my butt, a pair of size 42 that fit perfectly and start to get loose, and another pair of 46s that are a little loose but otherwise fit.

    So did I lose weight or not? I don't know. I mean, my measurements say I did, but I feel like nothing has changed. I hate it, and I'm in this depressed funk which only makes me wonder why I even bother.
  • mazdauk
    mazdauk Posts: 1,380 Member
    Me too! Someone said the other day "there's nothing of you" when I was trying to turn down a cookie (OK, I failed to turn it down because of that!) and I nearly came out with the "you've not seen me naked line" - but not really appropriat at work:blushing: . I see the loose bits, the wobbly bits, stretch marks etc. And I remember I was only 9st 3 when I got married. And I feel huge.

    But then I wore a size 14 suit last week (a big 14, but still....) and I put on a skirt that's too loose now (bummer in a way because I like it, but good its too loose). And I managed to zip up some size 14 trousers - they still looked like a bag of potatoes but last year I couldn't even make the buttons come close.......

    I think about all the time in my early 20s when I was a 12 and wouldn't wear things because of big legs etc. - now as soon as I can fit into stuff I'll wear it anyway. I know I'm not perfect and never will be, but there's plenty bigger than me (although younger) so I 'm going to live for me not what others think.

    Watch out world, the hotpants are coming out of the wardrobe!
  • RonandDi
    RonandDi Posts: 120 Member
    I won't say I feel fat, or think I look much different, but like was mentioned above, I can do a hell of a lot more now than I did 6 months ago. I still weigh myself every day, but don't worry too much about what it says. I get up every morning and run 3 miles, and every morning it gets easier. I can do more push-ups every day...add to the pull-ups every few days. When I look in the mirror I don't look at how fat or skinny I am, but I try and look at the more fit person I've become. Little progress each day keeps me going.

    BTW...this morning it was pulling my belt to the next loop. Small victories.
  • lacroyx
    lacroyx Posts: 5,754 Member
    I used to feel this way almost everyday. Not as much now.
  • superbabe612
    superbabe612 Posts: 5 Member
    I can soooooo see where you're coming from on this one! And I thought it was just me!
    I've lost 4 stone in a year (56lbs) and I know I am thinner but I don't feel it. I'm still trying to hide behind dull colours, or baggy clothes that hide my curves/bulges.
    So now I have the problem of not knowing what suits me, what fits best, what looks right… I want to look good but the last time I felt like I looked good, I was 20! Now I'm 41!
    When I look back at really old photos from when I thought I was fat, I see a slim person in the photo. When I look at not so old photos when I really WAS fat but in self-denial, I see a slob. Now I look at myself in the mirror and it's like my head is on someone else's body! But since I still tend to avoid mirrors I don't SEE the slimmer me!
    All I know is, I'm never going back to the heavier person I used to be!
  • RikkiErin
    RikkiErin Posts: 2
    Dude, I totally fee that way! Since september I have lost 40 lbs! Went from 195 to 155. I went from a size 15 in jeans to a size 9. I still feel massively fat though. Like I was looking at my thighs today and I was like good God they're huge. I just feel obese and I know I am still overweight, but I am a lot smaller than I use to be. However, I don't actually feel smaller… I feel like I just have heaps and heaps of fat. I still need to lose about thirty pounds to get to my goal weight and I am starting to think I should lose 40. :/ 'healthy' for my height is like 110-140. Ugh I just want to look good naked. :/ It sounds weird…but if you look good naked… you'll look good in anything you wear.
  • legreyfoxx
    legreyfoxx Posts: 2
    I'm guilty to this. The most I've ever weighed was 240, and I am now currently 155 (fluctuates between 155-159) but still feel like I weigh 240 especially after every meal I feel 240 again...ugh!
  • garciabnm
    garciabnm Posts: 138
    I feel this way all the time. Sometimes i look in the mirror and cant believe that its me looking back. Having lost 165 lbs you would think I'm crazy,but being over weight,fat and out of shape for most of my life,i for some reason always feel that way. Dont get me wrong, I'm much happier now,but somehow I always feel like I need that extra 20 minutes in the gym,or i need to ride that extra 5 miles. I've gone from hearing fat jokes.to hearing skinny jokes, usually from the same people. Somehow, I just feel like nothing has changed, even though I know it has. Good to know, im not the only one with these feelings.
  • becky6m
    becky6m Posts: 108 Member
    Oh, YES!!!! I have lost almost 100 pounds and its like I forgot what I used to look like. I look at pictures and see that my side by side is an amazing accomplishment. But, then I look in the mirror and still see the things I am not happy with. I am in maintenance mode of my weight loss but I see my thighs (which I lost a total of 6 inches of each thigh) has tons of cellulite, and I am so self conscious wearing shorts. I love my new body my abs are amazing. But I wish I wasn't so hard on myself. Maybe it comes with time. I have no fixes, no comforting words. I just wanted to share my view to let you know you are not alone.
  • ficklesoul
    ficklesoul Posts: 54 Member
    Yeap yeap. I've lost about 150+ pounds and some days I still feel fat. I bet one of these days even when I reached my ultimate goal I'll still think I'm fat. It's really annoying! I think some part of me thinks that if I keep telling myself I'm fat, it would prevent me from getting fatter hehe.
  • camtosh
    camtosh Posts: 898 Member
    I feel that way often when I get overly bloated and when I plateau. I'll stop losing weight for 7-10 days and feel like I'm a total screw up instead of feeling like I've accomplished so much. Seems that the negative feelings concerning my weight are 10 times stronger than the positive ones. I've really been in a funk lately since I'm between sizes. I'm between 18 & 16 and I got totally obsessed with the scale and with underfeeding myself to try to lose more. I've taken 2 weeks off to get myself straightened out and feel like a person again instead of that constant obsession with what to eat, when to eat, how to eat... eat, eat, eat, eat. Bah! I'm real... I'm doing more real stuff for myself. If I have a snack, then so be it. I don't have to beat myself up over it as much as I have been. I've lost nearly 100 lbs. and still feel like a fat girl. :(
    What she said! I lost weight about 10 years ago, and found out that the thinner me was still -- ME! and no one seemed to care whether I was Fat Me or Skinny Me. Life just treated me the same. I was pretty depressed about that for awhile, and eventually gained it all back. So here I am, trying again, but this time I want to be stronger. I think we need to be the ones who treat ourselves better, instead of beating ourselves up for not being perfect. Everyone else is too busy worrying about themselves to give a crap about what I look like....
  • Babeskeez
    Babeskeez Posts: 606 Member
    Me. I have lost some weight (not a lot) and my body has changed from lifting but I still suffer from major self esteem issues and still see myself as gross.
  • piratesaregrand
    piratesaregrand Posts: 356 Member
    its really weird.

    in my head i look the same as i did nearly 40kg ago, and everytime someone tells me ive done really well, look awesome blah blah blah i assume its a joke :/
  • katiekakess
    katiekakess Posts: 1
    I feel the same way! I'm 17 years old, and have lost 100 pounds. (still going) I'm now 130, planning to get to 115. I'm obsessed with my weight, and it has become a big issue for me. I'm constantly counting calories, barley eating enough, i look in the mirror all the time, and still see a fat blob. :/
  • emmalouc93
    emmalouc93 Posts: 328 Member
    Yes! I sometimes feel worse now than I did when I had a lot more weight...

    There are days where I'm like hmm I can't wear that I think I look fat in it...and my boyfriend is just like 'you wore it all the time before you lost weight and didn't think you looked fat, why do you think that now?'


    It's all in the mind...!
  • spider_mark51959
    spider_mark51959 Posts: 2,870 Member
    Hello. Just thought I'd offer a guys perspective. I'm nearly half way to my stated goal, and yet at times feel as though I'm just starting out
  • Bonny619
    Bonny619 Posts: 311 Member
    Not so much when I'm alone but more so when I'm around other women who are either my size or smaller than me. I always feel like the fat girl in those situations.
  • taso42
    taso42 Posts: 8,980 Member
    That's one of the problems with diets
  • ShaniWulffe
    ShaniWulffe Posts: 458 Member
    I know exactly what you mean. I've lost roughly 48lbs (long story, don't feel like typing it out right now), and I know I'm thinner and can feel that I'm thinner and see it in the mirror... But I'm nowhere near how I thought I would feel at this weight. I'm sitting around 15% body fat, and that should feel awesome! Long story short... It doesn't. I still feel too big. It's just so frustrating
This discussion has been closed.

Categories