I am starting a fast...any stories or tips?
spaceylacey
Posts: 25
I am starting a water fast today and was wondering if anyone has ever tried one....what kid of success anyone has had, or any advice you could give me....anything helps! Thank you 
♥Lacey
♥Lacey
0
Replies
-
I am starting a water fast today and was wondering if anyone has ever tried one....what kid of success anyone has had, or any advice you could give me....anything helps! Thank you
♥Lacey
Advice? Don't do it. Why are you wanting to do it? Religious purposes? Or just because?0 -
For weight loss, and to try to learn some discipline...i have a hard time with yo-yo-ing....i was 27 pounds 3 weeks ago and went on an eating binge and have since gained 15lbs....so i want to get that off fast while teaching myself to deny the urge to eat...i often do it for no real reason....its an addiction i think.0
-
Just keep telling yourself you can do it. Accept the hunger you feel as temporary (it is, you forget about being hungry over time.)
If you're having trouble, just tell yourself
"Just one more hour" or other period of time, and when you make it, say
"Oh, I made it an hour, what's one more?"
Good luck!0 -
Honestly, I think doing stuff ike fasting is probably part of the reason you are yo-yo ing. Starving yourself is probably going to lead you to a binge later. Reducing calories from your TDEE and exercising is going to help you a lot more in the long run. Does it take longer to come off? Absolutely. But it's a lot easier to maintain that type of weight loss.0
-
For weight loss, and to try to learn some discipline...i have a hard time with yo-yo-ing....i was 27 pounds 3 weeks ago and went on an eating binge and have since gained 15lbs....so i want to get that off fast while teaching myself to deny the urge to eat...i often do it for no real reason....its an addiction i think.
You don't need a water fast. If you want to learn discipline, then start by stopping the yo yo crap. Sure, reducing calories to flippin nothing will help that number on the scale go down, but as soon as you start eating again that number will go right back up. And teaching yourself to deny the urge to eat? What? So you can keep up the binging behaviors? And the yo yo? You asked for advice and i stick to my initial response. Don't do it.0 -
Soooooo how is undergoing a fast not a part of yo-yoing again?0
-
My advice.... Dont do it. You can lose weight and learn better eating habits without starving yourself. That is just setting yourself up for failure.0
-
If youre fasting, you should not do it for more than about 5 days. When you come off the fast, start slowly by eating raw veggie and fruits, and slowly adding more things into your diet, otherwise you just gain back what you lost. I would recommend to seek advice from a doctor about fasting to make sure you are doing it safely.0
-
I just collapsed after a few days.
And then got into a mindset that ANY food afterwards made me feel greedy.
My advice is that it's not sustainable.0 -
Instead of fasting, why don't you do the IF 16/8? Basically you skip lunch and you stop eating at 8 (so you have to eat in an 8 hours window). It helps you with the discipline, but it's not as tough as a complete fast. When I started doing the IF I realized two things:
1. I don't die if I don't have breakfast, I actually eat less if I don't eat breakfast
2. I enjoy more my meals, because I'm looking forward to them, instead of just giving them as ready.
There are some groups in here that advocate IF and you'd try it if you want to. Some people are not made for this (like anything, every body is different!).
(I follow IF with 5:2 diet, again, it's working for me so I'm quite happy with this.).0 -
Not the site for water fasting support. But I have done this, and think it is great if you have knowledge and the right motivations. A great book on the subject is written by the doctor Herbert Shelton. Google and get that book! Fasting Can Save Your Life, is the name of it.0
-
My experience with fasting to kick off a weight loss program was not good. I would restrict and feel good about it, scale going down, etc.....then i would crack and have a little treat, then end up bingeing then saying "eff it" and i'm off to the races again of eating whatever and not exercising
later, rinse, repeat over and over again for yearsssssssssssss
now i'm looking at it as a lifestyle change. not doing anything radical, just lowering calorie intake and exercising. this is 6 months of doing this (size 16 to size 10, and i'm 48 and going through menopause)
no drastics necessary. don't deprive yourself, you don't need the headaches (literally)0 -
will power > water fast
if you're talking about intermittent fasting, well thats another story.
do some research on that.0 -
I advise against it. It's a dumb and desperate idea. does your body no good and is not sustainable. you would be much better off sitting down with a good book, like 'Good Calories, Bad Calories' and deciding on a diet approach you can manage for the long term. Make THAT decision today. Any diet that 'demands' discipline that is counter to your body's own intelligence is useless. your body's intelligence will fight you and win. go with what works for your body and that is easy to figure out and demands very little discipline. I've been on my own program for years now. I refine it, I learn, I don't 'count calories'. I eat when i'm hungry. there's still some weight I'd like to lose but my health is excellent. wise up. relax and solve this problem in a REAL way. not some harmful way that only wastes your time and somehow convinces you that you're undisciplined.0
-
A fast for weight loss is the ultimate yo-yo, so by doing that you're embracing the yo-yo diet lifestyle. Nothing good will come long term from water fasting to try and loose weight quickly. The not eating after 8pm and eating a balanced responsible diet during the day is a good idea, that's real discipline. Also working out is discipline. Fasting will probably do more harm than good to your metabolism too which will cause weight gain later on.0
-
If you want to learn discipline, might I suggest taking a martial arts class instead of water fasting.0
-
will power > water fast
if you're talking about intermittent fasting, well thats another story.
do some research on that.
That would be awesome if she was talking about IF0 -
My advice...don't do it. Please. This woman did, and I would not call her results successful.
http://forum.fitnessthroughfasting.com/showthread.php/2093-Michelle-s-40-Day-Water-Fast0 -
I like that advice thank you 0
-
will power > water fast
if you're talking about intermittent fasting, well thats another story.
do some research on that.
That would be awesome if she was talking about IF
lol agreed, but not optimistic.
0 -
A fast for weight loss is the ultimate yo-yo, so by doing that you're embracing the yo-yo diet lifestyle. Nothing good will come long term from water fasting to try and loose weight quickly. The not eating after 8pm and eating a balanced responsible diet during the day is a good idea, that's real discipline. Also working out is discipline. Fasting will probably do more harm than good to your metabolism too which will cause weight gain later on.
Excellent post0 -
My advice...don't do it. Please. This woman did, and I would not call her results successful.
http://forum.fitnessthroughfasting.com/showthread.php/2093-Michelle-s-40-Day-Water-Fast
Was just going to post this.0 -
No.0
-
I do intermittent fasting, normally on a 16/8 split, but I often try to make the fasted state last as long as I can.
First off, coffee. Drink lots of coffee. Depending on how strict you are, you can drink it black, with sweetener, or even a splash of milk. I use skim, and it probably only adds 5 or 10 calories. I probably burn that getting up to make the damn thing.
Sugar-free gum is also good. Lets you chew on something, but without the calories.
Most important, do something! Don't sit around thinking about all the food you could be eating. Go out for a run, read a book, etc, etc.
I find that I'm at my most productive when I'm in my fasted state. Maybe reorganize that closet that's been bugging you.
Have fun, and good luck!0 -
Read up on intermittent fasting there are groups on here, make sure do it properly if you dont do the research and find out if its the right thing for you then its guna be more harmful that helpful !0
-
she lost 42 pounds though, @ a pound a day....i think that is successful...if i do 15 days i should be about where i want to be and then wean myself slowly back to a healthy diet...thats what i am thinking anyway0
-
it is yo-yo-ing....i know....i just cant even fit into my clothes right now and need a fast fix...that is my biggest concern right at the moment0
-
she lost 42 pounds though, @ a pound a day....i think that is successful...if i do 15 days i should be about where i want to be and then wean myself slowly back to a healthy diet...thats what i am thinking anyway
so youre going to take in nothing but water for 15 days?
and there really is no quick fix. if there was, this site wouldnt exist or maybe it would be called My Fasting Place.0 -
She also had painful gout, dizzy spells, icky white film on her tongue, bad breath, dry mouth, headaches...not to mention whatever damage she may have done to her body that we don't know about. It's just not worth it.she lost 42 pounds though, @ a pound a day....i think that is successful...if i do 15 days i should be about where i want to be and then wean myself slowly back to a healthy diet...thats what i am thinking anyway0 -
Let us know how it goes!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions