Diary open am I eating right? I am not losing anymore!!
Replies
-
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
I will concede that for a typical human attempting to create a calorie deficit to lose weight with no outside factors, this would be true (even though how many calories burned by nursing has been pretty well established by the medical community).
However, no breastfeeding mother should take this advice and risk the nutrition of their infant child by doing this. It's a completely different situation when your body is nourishing two human beings. Additionally, the OP may find that (contrary to popular wisdom) it's just going to be difficult to lose weight until she stops nursing, simply due to the way that hormones are reacting in her body. Sometimes it just happens that way, and it can even be different from baby to baby for the same individual. But there's no way to know this without some trial and error, and with the OP currently eating so few calories it's clear that the next step is to try to increase them.
So, basically, it's possible that you're a little right, but you're still mostly wrong and in no position to be advising this woman on this topic.0 -
Eat Woman! Feed your baby and your body. Dont worry about the scale especially when you are breastfeeding and you know those things can fill up pretty fast.
Focus on something else like getting more calcium in, walking a bit further, fitting into a smaller pant, lifting more weights..whatever you want. Just only use the scale as a reference now.
Breastfeeding is so much more important to the health and overall being of your child than a stuck scale.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
She is already under estimating that. At 7 months with no supplemental food, it could be as high as 800 calories a day.
The "average" is 20 calories per ounce of milk. I'm sure she can figure out how many ounces she is producing and adjust accordingly. You feed 2.5 oz of milk per 1 lb of baby weight, A 7 month old is about 16 lbs. 16x2.5x20=800 calories. Of course, this is assuming the baby is only eating breast milk.
If you use MFP for how many calories you burn running, you are also getting an estimate. It's not an accurate tool, to be honest.
I'm not understanding why you are so caught up on this, other than you enjoy being the center of attention.
OP: It seems to me like you are doing everything right, except it seems like you are nursing, working out, and some days only eating 1200 cals. I'm not sure why you would do that intentionally. I agree with those who think you should up your cals. The reason I think this is because you are doing some body weight resistance training and I think that changes the game some. Worse case scenario, you try it and it doesn't work. Maybe you could do a refeed and see how that goes.
Also, you could try using an HRM to see what you are really burning on your activities and adjust accordingly (of course, an HRM won't tell you what you burn Nursing, naturally).
If I were you, I'd try doing some HIIT for the hecks of it.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
She is already under estimating that.
That, too.0 -
how long has it been since a loss?
what exercise do you do, have you had any "days off" and ate something different? what are you stats, height weight ?
I looked at your diary, it looks good, but I think that mfp over estimates exercise calories, so when I went to tdee method -20% I started losing again:)
Louise
5 ' 7 Starting Weight: 184
Current weight: 174
Started diet exercising: May 20th, 2013 approx 2 months and a couple days
Mon-Fri 10 am : 150 squats
12 pm: Walking 30 mins briskly
3:00 pm: 50 squats
6:00pm-7:00pm: 30 Day Shred Jillian Michaels
Wednesday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Friday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Saturday & Sunday: Rest
eat more protein, less sugar. do more cardio - intense - not walking. the weight routine is weird that you do. i would recommend logging onto body building.com and signing up for the jamie eason live fit 12 week workout plans. they are emailed to you weekly and you just do whats on the menu. easy... works!0 -
how long has it been since a loss?
what exercise do you do, have you had any "days off" and ate something different? what are you stats, height weight ?
I looked at your diary, it looks good, but I think that mfp over estimates exercise calories, so when I went to tdee method -20% I started losing again:)
Louise
And how are they wierd? I have been pregnant back to back for the last 2 years and came from doing ZERO activity? I do this routine on my break schedule as I work Full Time Mon-Fri! so its really not wierd at all.
5 ' 7 Starting Weight: 184
Current weight: 174
Started diet exercising: May 20th, 2013 approx 2 months and a couple days
Mon-Fri 10 am : 150 squats
12 pm: Walking 30 mins briskly
3:00 pm: 50 squats
6:00pm-7:00pm: 30 Day Shred Jillian Michaels
Wednesday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Friday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Saturday & Sunday: Rest
eat more protein, less sugar. do more cardio - intense - not walking. the weight routine is weird that you do. i would recommend logging onto body building.com and signing up for the jamie eason live fit 12 week workout plans. they are emailed to you weekly and you just do whats on the menu. easy... works!
And how are they wierd? I have been pregnant back to back for the last 2 years and came from doing ZERO activity? I do this routine on my break schedule as I work Full Time Mon-Fri! so its really not wierd at all. Thanks for the advice0 -
Jen, I think you should check out this web page, go to tdee-20%how long has it been since a loss?
what exercise do you do, have you had any "days off" and ate something different? what are you stats, height weight ?
I looked at your diary, it looks good, but I think that mfp over estimates exercise calories, so when I went to tdee method -20% I started losing again:)
Louise
5 ' 7 Starting Weight: 184
Current weight: 174
Started diet exercising: May 20th, 2013 approx 2 months and a couple days
Mon-Fri 10 am : 150 squats
12 pm: Walking 30 mins briskly
3:00 pm: 50 squats
6:00pm-7:00pm: 30 Day Shred Jillian Michaels
Wednesday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Friday: Weights 10 lbs (20) mins
Saturday & Sunday: Rest
http://www.drlisawatson.com/weight-loss-plateau0 -
Take a look at your exercise, I see a number of days with over 750+ exercise calories. That seems like an awful lot, I burn ~550 in during most of the month 1 Insanity videos and I'm a 5'10" 200lb man. Don't count daily activities like cleaning, work or casual walking around the home or office as exercise, just your actual workouts.
Not an awful lot at all, I regularly burn 700 +, using Polar FT4 HRM, doing my cycling(80 minutes for around 730), elliptical (660 per hour) or running. In fact, I can burn up to 700 in an hour running and I am 140Ibs. It depends on the intensity of the workout, among other factors.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
She is already under estimating that. At 7 months with no supplemental food, it could be as high as 800 calories a day.
The "average" is 20 calories per ounce of milk. I'm sure she can figure out how many ounces she is producing and adjust accordingly. You feed 2.5 oz of milk per 1 lb of baby weight, A 7 month old is about 16 lbs. 16x2.5x20=800 calories. Of course, this is assuming the baby is only eating breast milk.
If you use MFP for how many calories you burn running, you are also getting an estimate. It's not an accurate tool, to be honest.
I'm not understanding why you are so caught up on this, other than you enjoy being the center of attention.
OP: It seems to me like you are doing everything right, except it seems like you are nursing, working out, and some days only eating 1200 cals. I'm not sure why you would do that intentionally. I agree with those who think you should up your cals. The reason I think this is because you are doing some body weight resistance training and I think that changes the game some. Worse case scenario, you try it and it doesn't work. Maybe you could do a refeed and see how that goes.
Also, you could try using an HRM to see what you are really burning on your activities and adjust accordingly (of course, an HRM won't tell you what you burn Nursing, naturally).
If I were you, I'd try doing some HIIT for the hecks of it.
My little one just turned 6 months she is 21 lbs
chubby one.... Which I pride myself in since all that is BREASTMILK... Thank I might just try that. I pump/nurse 30 oz + daily.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
She is already under estimating that. At 7 months with no supplemental food, it could be as high as 800 calories a day.
The "average" is 20 calories per ounce of milk. I'm sure she can figure out how many ounces she is producing and adjust accordingly. You feed 2.5 oz of milk per 1 lb of baby weight, A 7 month old is about 16 lbs. 16x2.5x20=800 calories. Of course, this is assuming the baby is only eating breast milk.
If you use MFP for how many calories you burn running, you are also getting an estimate. It's not an accurate tool, to be honest.
I'm not understanding why you are so caught up on this, other than you enjoy being the center of attention.
OP: It seems to me like you are doing everything right, except it seems like you are nursing, working out, and some days only eating 1200 cals. I'm not sure why you would do that intentionally. I agree with those who think you should up your cals. The reason I think this is because you are doing some body weight resistance training and I think that changes the game some. Worse case scenario, you try it and it doesn't work. Maybe you could do a refeed and see how that goes.
Also, you could try using an HRM to see what you are really burning on your activities and adjust accordingly (of course, an HRM won't tell you what you burn Nursing, naturally).
If I were you, I'd try doing some HIIT for the hecks of it.
My little one just turned 6 months she is 21 lbs chubby one.... Which I pride myself in since all that is BREASTMILK... Thank I might just try that. I pump/nurse 30 oz + daily.
My little one just turned 6 months she is 21 lbs chubby one.... Which I pride myself in since all that is BREASTMILK... Thank I might just try that. I pump/nurse 30 oz + daily. 0 -
If you use MFP for how many calories you burn running, you are also getting an estimate. It's not an accurate tool, to be honest.
I'm not understanding why you are so caught up on this, other than you enjoy being the center of attention.
Agreed. I always over-estimate food, under-estimate exercise (more calories counted/ less minutes running).
You also bring up another excellent point of attention. How do I get out of the center of attention? Should I change my profile picture to me in a bikini? That should probably draw attention away.0 -
In fact, I can burn up to 700 in an hour running and I am 140Ibs. It depends on the intensity of the workout, among other factors.
Yeah no.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
Logging at 300 is underestimating since the range is 300 - 500 cals per day. She just put 9 minutes to put something. Tons of people here constantly put 1 calorie for insanely intense workouts. It's a number to put there to be able to factor those cals in that's all. It's the cal number that's important for her uses.0 -
My point is someone cannot accurately gauge the calories 'burnt' breast feeding. If someone is unable to do so, at the very least they need to underestimate the calories 'burnt'.
With food you can be almost entirely accurate if you eat the foods you can absolutely measure. Exercise a little less. Arbitrary bodily functions, even less so.
You need to stop beating this dead horse. She needs to add calories for breast feeding. Whether or not she calls it "calories burned" or not is irrelevant. So get off it, okay?0 -
I'm glad I'm joining this thread when all the info is clearer. So, OP, your baby is 6 months and breastfeeding has been a great success so far. I think that deserves a huge
:flowerforyou: 
:smooched: :drinker:
Your supply has been good and your little one is about to get into solids and you feel ready to lose some weight again. One thing to consider, regarding the scales, is milk weight! I know it sounds silly, but as baby's needs must be starting to change, the amount of milk your body expects to produce may not yet have altered to the change in demand. It's like water weight in non-lactating people, and of course that can be going on too.
When I was BFing I was scared to lose weight rapidly as I'd read that this could release toxins into the breast milk. The following touches on this and seems to have calm and reasonable advice (though I must admit I didn't read it all):
http://kellymom.com/nutrition/mothers-diet/mom-weightloss/
I wish you all the best. Xxx0 -
Hey Guys,
I need some help on this topic because I'm this close to losing my mind over this. I started myfitnesspal over a month ago, it set my calorie intake to 1200 (losing 2lbs a week), I am 138 5'3. I used to be 115 but over years I've slowly gained alot of weight. Before I started this diet, I was easily eating over 2000 calories a day with no exercise (office job so my activity level was zero). Now, I've been eating 1200 and actually alot of times under 1200 and exercising around 4 times a week for atleast an hour. I have literally lost NO weight at all. I dont understand this, I have been working so hard and I see no results I am so frustrated and I just want need advice. I don't have enough time in the day to the whole 4-5 meals a day, I eat breakfast, lunch, snack and dinner. I have totally cut out sodas besides casual happy hour drinks. I dont always eat back exercise calories. My calorie intake varies everyday, I just feel so upset because I'm working so hard and havent seen any results. Please please help me!!!
My diary is open too!!0 -
In fact, I can burn up to 700 in an hour running and I am 140Ibs. It depends on the intensity of the workout, among other factors.
Yeah no.
I still stand by you being an asshat. How do you know what someone else burns? I'm smaller than the poster and burn about 300 calories per half hour of running. I realize your mental disorder allows you to think you're a super hero but seriously give up on the stupid comments. You're only making yourself look more and more ridiculous.
And who cares how the OP adds her 300 calories for breastfeeding? Does it really make a difference in the way the world revolves if she adds it as exercise or just makes her daily budget 300 calories higher to allow for lactation? You're knit picking a point that is irrelevant.
Thank You! you are right all around.0 -
I have lost 40,45,51 on 3 different occasions & currently 42 (gonna keep off this time). I purchased a heart rate monitor that I wear around my chest that's paired with watch(Polar). That way heart rate & calories are more accurate & even then I take 100 calories off every 30 minutes of exercise performed so just in case it's not accurate, I won't eat those calories back. You can cut grass and wash car & add those calories(1500 the other day washing 3 cars for approximately 4 hours even after using method mentioned above).0
-
I have lost 40,45,51 on 3 different occasions & currently 42 (gonna keep off this time). I purchased a heart rate monitor that I wear around my chest that's paired with watch(Polar). That way heart rate & calories are more accurate & even then I take 100 calories off every 30 minutes of exercise performed so just in case it's not accurate, I won't eat those calories back. You can cut grass and wash car & add those calories(1500 the other day washing 3 cars for approximately 4 hours even after using method mentioned above).
HRM's are only accurate for steady state cardio activity which washing a car isn't. You need to be maintaining a significantly increased heart rate over an extended period of time to get a proper reading. Something like running, biking, aerobics, swimming, etc. Wearing it for activities like cutting grass and car washing are give you high false readings. Also a HRM is taking into account your total calorie burn for the time, not deducting your BMR which you would have burned during that time anyway.0 -
In fact, I can burn up to 700 in an hour running and I am 140Ibs. It depends on the intensity of the workout, among other factors.
Yeah no.
I still stand by you being an asshat. How do you know what someone else burns? I'm smaller than the poster and burn about 300 calories per half hour of running. I realize your mental disorder allows you to think you're a super hero but seriously give up on the stupid comments. You're only making yourself look more and more ridiculous.
And who cares how the OP adds her 300 calories for breastfeeding? Does it really make a difference in the way the world revolves if she adds it as exercise or just makes her daily budget 300 calories higher to allow for lactation? You're knit picking a point that is irrelevant.
I just used the "ignore" feature on him. It's so much prettier around here all of a sudden!0 -
Hey Guys,
I need some help on this topic because I'm this close to losing my mind over this. I started myfitnesspal over a month ago, it set my calorie intake to 1200 (losing 2lbs a week), I am 138 5'3. I used to be 115 but over years I've slowly gained alot of weight. Before I started this diet, I was easily eating over 2000 calories a day with no exercise (office job so my activity level was zero). Now, I've been eating 1200 and actually alot of times under 1200 and exercising around 4 times a week for atleast an hour. I have literally lost NO weight at all. I dont understand this, I have been working so hard and I see no results I am so frustrated and I just want need advice. I don't have enough time in the day to the whole 4-5 meals a day, I eat breakfast, lunch, snack and dinner. I have totally cut out sodas besides casual happy hour drinks. I dont always eat back exercise calories. My calorie intake varies everyday, I just feel so upset because I'm working so hard and havent seen any results. Please please help me!!!
My diary is open too!!
You are pretty consistently under eating. That is not good. Try eating back your exercise calories.
Also, when you say "strength training" what exactly are you doing?
Also, consider the fact that you might not need to be back to 115 again. Check this lady out- I think she weighs 170 in both of these pics:
0 -
I just used the "ignore" feature on him. It's so much prettier around here all of a sudden!
It's really not nice to comment about people's pictures on here. I thought this site was a no judgement zone?0 -
Ah, I just am so afraid to eat now haha. Yeah I mean I've lost 2 inches off my waist so thats a plus sign, I see a difference in my overall body just not on the scale so I dont know if that means anything! My goal is to drop to 120s range so I have some leeway to gain 5 pounds here n there. I dont want to 115 again specifically. I dont know if me doing elliptical at the gym is not enough cardio? Should I mix it up? I've been doing like body pump classes sometimes i do treadmill but i dread running. I do squats with 30lbs about 40 each or so each time I do go to gym. But there isnt really any variation in my diet or exercise I dont know if thats the reason the scale isnt moving.0
-
I see a difference in my overall body just not on the scale so I dont know if that means anything!
It means you're on the right track because the scale lies but your body doesn't.0 -
Can u read? Read the post again! 100 calories off every 30 min of exercise. Washing the car still left about 800 calories on the table that I didn't eat. Regardless of what I'm doing its not that far off!!!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions