How would your dog protect you?
Replies
-
my lab often barks at men, or people approaching us in the dark (unless I order him not too and/or distract him) but, like someone else has said, this is fear on his part and if the barking did not scare someone off he would likely run!!! (He is rescue and was badly treated in the past)
My other dog is a rottie cross black lab and is built pretty big so most people would think twice about approaching anyway but she is very loving with new people as well as family however I am sure that out of the two dogs, she would also be the one to protect as fully as she could. Even now, if I play fight with my husband she reacts with warning barks if one of us squeals (though in no way any sort of attack form) Her nature is to guard anyway and remain loyal and I would trust her to do that fully though I hope that she is never called upon to do this. It is a pretty safe place where we live but things can happen anywhere.0 -
I have a miniature poodle. He is just too small to really do anything but he would totally bark if someone was trying to break in0
-
I have the same thoughts.
My dog is a 3 year old golden, he's the soppiest dog I've ever met and the only time he'd hurt anyone is if he accidently stood on your foot or something when he was going bonkers with excitement over you being there (has happened many a time to me) I've said to my bf before, "would he protect if he had to?" and he seems convinced that yes he would, that it's an instinct in every dog to protect their pack (and this guy has been brought up with dogs) I just can't imagine it yet, I'd have to see it to believe it, and obviously I don't want that!
Although tbf he has done a protective sort of bark and growled / shown teeth when the door has gone and we're both home on a few occaisions, and he is always on high alert if he hears anything, so I don't think he wouldn't. I just have never experienced it. I think they go by how you are feeling, if you seem nervous or scared they will react differently to if you seem happy and open to the stranger.0 -
my cross rottie does that too however our first rottie never realised she was one lol and I expect she would have run rather than fought to protect meI have always owned rotweillers and they are prtective by nature.
Although he is a kind and gentle pup, loves kids and people in general.
He will always get between me, my wife or son and whoever is walking up if he doesn't know them.
He looks scary if you don;t know him too.0 -
My dog Willy was the sweetest most loving german shepard/ husky cross, but when I walk walking him and another dog got too close to me for his liking I had to use all of my strength to hold him back. Also we were at the lakeshore watching fireworks some random guy comes running and jumps over my legs, my dog pinned him to a tree, until we told him it was ok.0
-
When I was little we had lab mix, my brothers and I were playing in the backyard and a man came in our yard for god knows what, as soon as he got into the back our dog attacked him, protecting us. For the dogs I have now, one is a sweetheart and too nice, but out other dog, an American foxhound, is super protective if I'm alone with him. I'll be out walking him, and he doesn't care if he sees people, but if a man walks up to me he absolutely loses it, and acts like he is going to rip their face off. He's given a couple people warning snips when the come inside, just to let them no what's up if they try anything sketchy.
Do you really think it ok that your dog gives people "warning nips" for no reason? Or goes crazy for no other reason than ther person approaching is a male? He is not protective, he is fearful.
Do you really think your being a fun member of this forum? Butthurt much? Sorry to overwhelm you with questions I love meeting new people~!
I
non-sequiturs 0 -
Unless your dog is specifically trained in protection work, chances are nothing.
Dogs have two reactions - fight or flight. They'll try one and resort to the other if needed. When they are growling at a stranger in the bushes, that would be fight. If the threat continues, and your dog has the option, there's a good chance they'll opt for flight.
What people view as a dog being "protective" is often more of a weak temperament or possessiveness than it is protection.
Not sure about this. I have had 3 German Shepherds, none trained in protection. Two of which stepped in to protect myself and family members. They had sound temperaments and no resource guarding tendencies.
Some dogs/breeds are more naturally protective than others.
I agree with this guy.
Dogs don't have to be trained to be protective in order to be protective. My German Shepherd had never been trained to protect and typically if other dogs were fighting or something was going on, she was usually between my legs (when she was a puppy) as she got older, she would put herself between me and anyone walking towards us, if other dogs came running at us she wanted to protect me. She liked other dogs, just didn't like them charging us.0 -
I have a 5 year old boxer and he's mush for sure. However, if I take him walking/hiking and we run accross people and some he loves and others he foams at the mouth and lurches and acts like he's going to attack. Those dogs know when we maybe in some sort of trouble or at least mine knows who he doesn't like.
Gotta trust the puppies, they're great judges of people. 0 -
my german shepherd likes to protect me from yorkies, westies, beagles (all of the dogs, infact), birds, bats, cats, rabbits, snails, neighbours, postman etc by barking his face off at all of them
gotta love him though :S0 -
Unless your dog is specifically trained in protection work, chances are nothing.
Dogs have two reactions - fight or flight. They'll try one and resort to the other if needed. When they are growling at a stranger in the bushes, that would be fight. If the threat continues, and your dog has the option, there's a good chance they'll opt for flight.
What people view as a dog being "protective" is often more of a weak temperament or possessiveness than it is protection.
Not sure about this. I have had 3 German Shepherds, none trained in protection. Two of which stepped in to protect myself and family members. They had sound temperaments and no resource guarding tendencies.
Some dogs/breeds are more naturally protective than others.
I agree with this guy.
Dogs don't have to be trained to be protective in order to be protective. My German Shepherd had never been trained to protect and typically if other dogs were fighting or something was going on, she was usually between my legs (when she was a puppy) as she got older, she would put herself between me and anyone walking towards us, if other dogs came running at us she wanted to protect me. She liked other dogs, just didn't like them charging us.
It depends on what you consider protective. I also have two German Shepherds. They are territorial and a great deterrent. Only one would I rely on for protection.
I know my opinion isn't popular. I'm ok with that. My biggest concern is people who rely on their dog as protection. I don't want to see anyone in the position of the above poster who was mugged and her dog did nothing.0 -
I have a 14 year old golden retriever who will bark at any squirrel or rabbit in the yard, but he gets all excited and whines if a car pulls in. He loves people so much that he gets upset if I don't let him greet them at the door. I don't think he would do too much to protect me, he'd probably be begging for a belly rub.0
-
I recently adopted a Pitbull/Rottweiler cross. Great dog. Gentle with my small child, not food protective, great recall, well socialized with other people and dogs. If I invite someone in the house she's very cool about it. Her only negative is she is FAST and likes to catch and kill small animals. I've already seen that she is VERY protective. If someone or something came at us, or broke into our house they'd be in for a world of hurt.
To the person who thinks dogs don't have an instinct to protect their owners, I can tell you that you are wrong. Every dog that I have ever owned has been protective and not run away in scary situations (when I was there), from labradors to chihuahuas. Dogs definitely are instinctual as PACK animals. Their owners, and family, are their pack.
I do agree that some breeds or individuals wouldn't necessarily defend their owners physically, but they would usually stay by them and maybe at least make a ruckus and attract attention.0 -
My dog drinks beer, eats bbq, and sleeps. The end.0
-
Unless your dog is specifically trained in protection work, chances are nothing.
Dogs have two reactions - fight or flight. They'll try one and resort to the other if needed. When they are growling at a stranger in the bushes, that would be fight. If the threat continues, and your dog has the option, there's a good chance they'll opt for flight.
What people view as a dog being "protective" is often more of a weak temperament or possessiveness than it is protection.
Not sure about this. I have had 3 German Shepherds, none trained in protection. Two of which stepped in to protect myself and family members. They had sound temperaments and no resource guarding tendencies.
Some dogs/breeds are more naturally protective than others.
I agree with this guy.
Dogs don't have to be trained to be protective in order to be protective. My German Shepherd had never been trained to protect and typically if other dogs were fighting or something was going on, she was usually between my legs (when she was a puppy) as she got older, she would put herself between me and anyone walking towards us, if other dogs came running at us she wanted to protect me. She liked other dogs, just didn't like them charging us.
It depends on what you consider protective. I also have two German Shepherds. They are territorial and a great deterrent. Only one would I rely on for protection.
I know my opinion isn't popular. I'm ok with that. My biggest concern is people who rely on their dog as protection. I don't want to see anyone in the position of the above poster who was mugged and her dog did nothing.
I agree with you on your biggest concern. Personally, I don't want my dogs to protect me. I want to protect them. That's my job. My dogs now, in the earlier story where an aggressive dog was circling myself and my dog, all I could think in my head was if this dog attacks my dog (who is one of the sweetest most loving dogs on the planet) I'm not above kicking that other dog until it stops. Now, I am NOT an animal abuser, nor do I believe in harming animals, nor would I...but if a dog whose attacked other dogs and killed a cat attacks mine, you better believe I'm in that fight to protect my dog.
I also think that if someone were to break into my house, I'm shutting my dogs in a room so they won't get hurt. They are big dogs 78 lbs and a 46 lb pit bull. It's not for them to protect me.0 -
They would totally cuddle you to death.
0 -
They would totally cuddle you to death.
Love it!!! Looks just like my two fur-balls......though different breeds0 -
I have a jack Russell he doesn't care if pele come to the door when my husband is home but if a repair man or delivery man comes when my husband is not home he follows them around with his fur up. Unfortunately no one is really scared of my 12 lb ball of chub.0
-
My Mini Aussie in my profile picture wiggles his butt and draws in even the scariest looking people on the walking trails. I know that he loves me but I am not kidding myself, if things got hairy, he would run once he realized it wasn't patting-and-adoration-time.0
-
test:
Get somebody to star pushing you around and see how defensive he gets. If he gets mad growly and not playful growly, then likely yes.
We did this test with my bfs Italian Greyhound. BF started shoving me around and punching my arm to see what the dog would do. Not hard but it started to hurt so I started screaming I'm gonna get you back for this and the dog went all crazy "Yayy we're getting her" and started nibbling on my arm. Protection fail
0 -
My sister was babysitting my boy (2 yrs) and dog (Mastiff). A disgruntled, former employee of her husband hopped their fence to steal some power tools (we determined that because he broke into a shed and was carrying tools back toward the fence when he was accosted by the dog). Unfortunately for him, my boy was in the yard with my dog. My sister's Rottweilers didn't do anything (maybe because they didn't feel protective of my son), but my dog, who is very protective of my kids/family, saw the dude walking toward my son (he had to pass him to get back to the front of the house...guess the dude picked the wrong side of the house to walk around), and she charged. Dude almost made it to the fence...but he didn't. Dog mauled him pretty good. Sister came out and finally got Hula (my dog) to quit chewing on the perp. Police came. Neighbor across the street saw what had happened and made a full report. Cops didn't give my sister a citation, but did arrest the guy and then took him to the hospital to get stitched up. 180 lb dog beats 150 lb meth addict.
ETA: Not the best pic...but here's Hula:
0 -
I have a cat. He would protect me by hiding until my body was dragged off.0
-
My sister was babysitting my boy (2 yrs) and dog (Mastiff). A disgruntled, former employee of her husband hopped their fence to steal some power tools (we determined that because he broke into a shed and was carrying tools back toward the fence when he was accosted by the dog). Unfortunately for him, my boy was in the yard with my dog. My sister's Rottweilers didn't do anything (maybe because they didn't feel protective of my son), but my dog, who is very protective of my kids/family, saw the dude walking toward my son (he had to pass him to get back to the front of the house...guess the dude picked the wrong side of the house to walk around), and she charged. Dude almost made it to the fence...but he didn't. Dog mauled him pretty good. Sister came out and finally got Hula (my dog) to quit chewing on the perp. Police came. Neighbor across the street saw what had happened and made a full report. Cops didn't give my sister a citation, but did arrest the guy and then took him to the hospital to get stitched up. 180 lb dog beats 150 lb meth addict.
ETA: Not the best pic...but here's Hula:
OMG, I am in love with that dog. She's gorgeous and she righteously kicked butt.0 -
My sister was babysitting my boy (2 yrs) and dog (Mastiff). A disgruntled, former employee of her husband hopped their fence to steal some power tools (we determined that because he broke into a shed and was carrying tools back toward the fence when he was accosted by the dog). Unfortunately for him, my boy was in the yard with my dog. My sister's Rottweilers didn't do anything (maybe because they didn't feel protective of my son), but my dog, who is very protective of my kids/family, saw the dude walking toward my son (he had to pass him to get back to the front of the house...guess the dude picked the wrong side of the house to walk around), and she charged. Dude almost made it to the fence...but he didn't. Dog mauled him pretty good. Sister came out and finally got Hula (my dog) to quit chewing on the perp. Police came. Neighbor across the street saw what had happened and made a full report. Cops didn't give my sister a citation, but did arrest the guy and then took him to the hospital to get stitched up. 180 lb dog beats 150 lb meth addict.
ETA: Not the best pic...but here's Hula:
WTG Hula!!!!
Beautiful dog BTW! 0 -
OMG, I am in love with that dog. She's gorgeous and she righteously kicked butt.
WTG Hula!!!!
Beautiful dog BTW!
Thanks peeps.
The beauty of it too is that she is otherwise exceptionally gentle. My son still loves to climb all over her, pull her ears, poke her in the eyes, kiss her on the mouth, etc. She just lies there with a "grin" on her face and occasionally looks at me like, "really, you're letting him do this to me?" She's our gentle guardian. 0 -
My Sam, a Jack russell/border collie mix would keep people away from me purely out of jealousy. He hates sharing his Mom, but Franny, the pug/shih tzu mix is fiercely protective of both me & Sam, I've seen her go after doberman & shephards who sniffed either of us just a second too long. She really is a little 'b*tch" lol0
-
Just barking inside the house when someone comes to the door has been show to be a pretty big deterrent from theft and home invasions. I'm good with that. They don't have to know that if they actually came inside a little love would come the "beasts" down.0
-
test:
Get somebody to star pushing you around and see how defensive he gets. If he gets mad growly and not playful growly, then likely yes.
We did this test with my bfs Italian Greyhound. BF started shoving me around and punching my arm to see what the dog would do. Not hard but it started to hurt so I started screaming I'm gonna get you back for this and the dog went all crazy "Yayy we're getting her" and started nibbling on my arm. Protection fail
But doggie win!! My little dog is extremely people friendly, but he is a bit fearful/aggressive with other dogs. We are working on this. Our big dog was abused as a pup by her previous owner. Due to that abuse, she had a fear/aggressive response with some men, generally ones of a certain build with hiking boots on. We were able to nip it in the bud and in 10 years she hasn't been anything but friendly. So in answer to the question of "would your dog protect you?", no, they certainly would not. But, they bark when someone comes to the door. Sure, it's a tail wagging, greeting bark, but it lets people know there are dogs there and intruders won't want to risk it.0 -
OMG, I am in love with that dog. She's gorgeous and she righteously kicked butt.
WTG Hula!!!!
Beautiful dog BTW!
Thanks peeps.
The beauty of it too is that she is otherwise exceptionally gentle. My son still loves to climb all over her, pull her ears, poke her in the eyes, kiss her on the mouth, etc. She just lies there with a "grin" on her face and occasionally looks at me like, "really, you're letting him do this to me?" She's our gentle guardian.
LOL....sounds like you have a wonderful dog! I love my little barker!! She is like a child to me! Very protective...and can tell when you are playing like you are attacking as well usually...like someone hits me to gage her reaction...she knows its play sometimes joins in sometimes doesn't..but will protect anybody she perceives as being attacked.0 -
The current family dog is a lover not a fighter for sure. If my fiancé and I play fight he just watches and when we're done he comes up to me to make sure I'm OK. But he has no intention of protecting or intervening.
My poodle-terrier growing up would protect us from anything though. He was super-friendly but I remember taking him for a walk and a stray dog (a little bit bigger than he was) came charging at me (not to say hello, but a charge) and Toby ran in front, jumped and pinned the stray to the ground. They didn't fight, there was no blood but once he let go the stray got up and went the other way0 -
My dog is RIDICULOUSLY protective.
When I lived 'at home', my step-dad once attacked me, and my dog bit him so he had to get a Tetanus. Whenever, my bedroom door would open, he'd go mental to stop anyone coming in. He still does this now.
If someone's near me and I scream, he gets aggressive. If a strange man comes over to me, he gets aggressive.
He's my bestbestbest friend, and the thing I love most in this World He's lovely most of the time, but would bite anyone who got close to me. 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions