Planet Fitness removing squat racks? Aroo?
Replies
-
Apparently, they just don't want to risk the possibility that one of their members might actually ... build muscle.
They don't want any beefcake there. Beef is only okay on pizza.
This is fraught with hearsay, but I trust the source. My BIL told me husband that he ran into someone they know. This is a woman is is very into fitness and does CrossFit and the like, I believe. She's in very good shape. She went to the so to open/newly opened PF in our area to get the cheapo membership, I think just to have access to some of the cardio stuff for non CrossFit days or bad weather or something. Anyway, she went in in workout clothes, I'm assuming a tank top of sorts. She was denied a membership based on her looks because other patrons might find her intimidating. Seriously. Again, way hearsay, but I thought I'd throw it out there.
I never got how they could say they're a judgment free zone, when they clearly are judgmental of those they deem lunkheads.0 -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXwMXp0NV1I Might provide relief for some. I found this hilarious. 0 -
This just astounds me. There was a woman at my YMCA that complained about dropping weights. B!tch, YOU deadlift #225-235 and tell me you don't grunt and/or clang the weights at the bottom a bit. :huh: Thankfully, she left when Gold's Gym opened around the corner.0 -
Leading up to the new year were a whole bunch of threads from users complaining about all the newbies who would be joining THEIR gym (because clearly only their money counts). Threads about how the newbies would be taking up all the equipment, using it wrong, and how the newbies should just hurry up with failing so the gym can be less crowded again. It was almost as though people thought these newbies didn't belong at THEIR gym (seriously, the newbies money was probably worth less than their money right?). It was almost as though people wished the newbies would all go someplace else. Like, hmm, I dunno, a gym aimed at newbies?0
-
The owner of Planet Fitness must of been traumatized by that bodybuilder in his past that beat him up and then sexed his girlfriend right in front of him.
Lunk Alarm.
0 -
hmm didn't realize they were so bad...I'm glad I use the Y with the rest of the lunks.
I had planned to join the Y with my daughter next month, but my bff bought me a PF membership for Christmas. Y'all are scarin' me!
if you are just going to use the treadmill and dumbbells that I guess that is a good investment...0 -
The owner of Planet Fitness must of been traumatized by that bodybuilder in his past that beat him up and then sexed his girlfriend right in front of him.
I love the use of the word "sex" as a verb this way.0 -
how about Planet Epic Failure0
-
Leading up to the new year were a whole bunch of threads from users complaining about all the newbies who would be joining THEIR gym (because clearly only their money counts). Threads about how the newbies would be taking up all the equipment, using it wrong, and how the newbies should just hurry up with failing so the gym can be less crowded again. It was almost as though people thought these newbies didn't belong at THEIR gym (seriously, the newbies money was probably worth less than their money right?). It was almost as though people wished the newbies would all go someplace else. Like, hmm, I dunno, a gym aimed at newbies?
I don't completely agree with your characterization of those threads but that's an argument for another time. What I will say is that a gym aimed at newbies, which removes the tools which can increase their chances of success and improve their health, is a much bigger disservice to those newbs than real or perceived slights on a pre-NY thread. You can create a beginner-friendly culture without shielding them from having to witness effort.0 -
Leading up to the new year were a whole bunch of threads from users complaining about all the newbies who would be joining THEIR gym (because clearly only their money counts). Threads about how the newbies would be taking up all the equipment, using it wrong, and how the newbies should just hurry up with failing so the gym can be less crowded again. It was almost as though people thought these newbies didn't belong at THEIR gym (seriously, the newbies money was probably worth less than their money right?). It was almost as though people wished the newbies would all go someplace else. Like, hmm, I dunno, a gym aimed at newbies?
I did see some of those threads and they are unfortunate. I do get very nervous in crowds, and so I dread going anywhere crowded in January. I do not wish for the failure of the newbies though, that wouldn't be a very good attitude to have.
If Planet Fitness wants to be the newbie gym, then they ought to offer a less intimating way to get starting with strength training. Like have a class where a trainer explains the equipment, demonstrates proper technique, and mentions the benefits of maintaining/building muscle. Instead they're setting themselves up as the anti-lifting gym. I don't think that business model is beneficial to their members.
When I started going to the weights side of the the gym I was terrified. But it was very good for me to overcome those fears. If people had just told me "oh, it's okay, those people are awful anyway and you don't want to be one of them" then I would still feel weak and I would be in more pain than I am now. Lifting weights has dramatically impacted my quality of life and has directly impacted my medical conditions. I dislike the idea that Planet Fitness would discourage others who have similar medical issues from trying something that could help them. And I dislike the fact that they are telling people they can and should look down on others just because they lift. As if a person who lifts couldn't possibly have other interests or any intelligence-- they must by definition be dumb and rude and one-dimensional.0 -
Leading up to the new year were a whole bunch of threads from users complaining about all the newbies who would be joining THEIR gym (because clearly only their money counts). Threads about how the newbies would be taking up all the equipment, using it wrong, and how the newbies should just hurry up with failing so the gym can be less crowded again. It was almost as though people thought these newbies didn't belong at THEIR gym (seriously, the newbies money was probably worth less than their money right?). It was almost as though people wished the newbies would all go someplace else. Like, hmm, I dunno, a gym aimed at newbies?
PF may be aimed at newbies, but only insofar as that they are easy to exploit.
Planet "Fitness" doesn't actually help people become fit. It actively obscures the path to fitness, demonizes the people who have actually achieved success, and fails to provide the most useful and efficient tools and instruction to become fit.
People complain about ignorant newbies because they make no effort to educate themselves or learn how to do things properly. These are people that are unprepared mentally to actually succeed. No amount of time at Planet Fitness will imbue some newbie with the mindset and education to succeed. I've seen so many people just show at the gym and just make it up as they go. When I first showed up at the gym, I had educated myself beforehand and made sure that what I was doing made sense.
PF simply exploits the ignorance of newbies by playing on their fears and inadequacies in calling successful people "lunks" and so forth. It provides an environment where unfit people can feel better about themselves because at least they're not some a-hole bodybuilder. It relies on this to sustain membership dues and, as an organization, it clearly doesn't give a damn if anyone actually gets fit.0 -
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.0 -
I have no other gym near me and I live in a crappy upstairs apartment so I have no other ways to exercise. It's an ok gym for the money. The employees are kinda snotty. I got sick from idiots sneezing and coughing right in front of me. (don't go to the gym sick!) And there are way too many 13 year old girls!! That's my main complaints. Just wanted to rant. :devil:0
-
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.
Like I said in my post above-- I think there are much better ways that they could make their gyms more accessible to newbies without demonizing those who are successful and fit.
I am glad you have had a good experience and feel comfortable in a gym setting.0 -
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.
if you have been working out for a year and have never attempted a barbell squat or a deadlift then you are just setting yourself behind the eight ball as these are the moves that are going to provide the most gains and increase overall strength and aid in decreasing body fat..
Wouldn't you have rather spent a year learning all the necessary movements to make a better you? Rather than find out a year in that you now have to re-learn certain moves, and are, essentially, a newbie all over again?0 -
*shrugs*
I like Planet Fitness. It's (relatively) close to where I live and it's cheap. My husband has the black card so I get to go for free as his guest. Any other gym we'd have to either get separate memberships or the "family pack" which isn't that much cheaper. The people who work there are wicked nice and friendly. Always saying hi when they see us on the floor and stopping to chat for a second. While I'd like to have a squat rack it's not really necessary. Neither is a billion pounds of free weights. If my goal was to bench 2x my body weight than yeah, I'd have an issue but that's not my goal. I lift heavy (for me) but I'm not aiming to be a power lifter or someone who struts around and asks how much others bench and then brag about how much I can lift. Don't get me wrong I think it's awesome that people can lift huge amounts of weight but what's the point but it's not about the amount that you lift but your form and really targeting the muscles that you're working (and FWIW that advice came from my huge body builder friend who was working out with us one day).
As for the removing of the squat racks again, it depends on the PF location as they're independently owned it's up to the owners as to what they want to do.
I also can deadlift at my PF without getting yelled at. I've done it in front of the owner and the manager and they've never stopped me.
I've barbell squatted in the past at the fitness center I used to go to where I worked. I've also squatted with the smith machine. I never felt I had to "relearn" the movements. If my gym were to put in a squat rack I'm pretty confident that even though I've been squatting with the smith machine that I'd be able to squat in a squat rack with perfect form.0 -
I'm not aiming to be a power lifter or someone who struts around and asks how much others bench and then brag about how much I can lift.
Planet Fitness has clearly succeeded in demonizing weightlifting for you. You equate progress with the lifts you're already doing as becoming some "lunk" to "struts around" and "brags."
That's... not reality. As you progress in your lifting, you don't suddenly turn into some huge jerk.
You don't mention what your goal is, but presumably it's progress and not stagnation.0 -
PF Employee: "I'm sorry, but we're going to have to ask you to leave. You're sweating. Sweating is strictly prohibited as it intimidates the other clients. You're just not the type of person we want at Planet Fitness."0
-
I'm not aiming to be a power lifter or someone who struts around and asks how much others bench and then brag about how much I can lift.
Planet Fitness has clearly succeeded in demonizing weightlifting for you. You equate progress with the lifts you're already doing as becoming some "lunk" to "struts around" and "brags."
That's... not reality. As you progress in your lifting, you don't suddenly turn into some huge jerk.
You don't mention what your goal is, but presumably it's progress and not stagnation.
Read into things much? I used to work out at a fitness center where I worked that had decent equipment including a squat rack. My goal has never been to become a power lifter or to lift 2x my body weight just to say that I can. Perhaps I worded my comment wrong.0 -
I'm not aiming to be a power lifter or someone who struts around and asks how much others bench and then brag about how much I can lift.
Planet Fitness has clearly succeeded in demonizing weightlifting for you. You equate progress with the lifts you're already doing as becoming some "lunk" to "struts around" and "brags."
That's... not reality. As you progress in your lifting, you don't suddenly turn into some huge jerk.
You don't mention what your goal is, but presumably it's progress and not stagnation.
Read into things much? I used to work out at a fitness center where I worked that had decent equipment including a squat rack. My goal has never been to become a power lifter or to lift 2x my body weight just to say that I can. Perhaps I worded my comment wrong.
You equate "lift 2x my body weight" with "strutting around" and "bragging."
What ARE your goals?0 -
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.
if you have been working out for a year and have never attempted a barbell squat or a deadlift then you are just setting yourself behind the eight ball as these are the moves that are going to provide the most gains and increase overall strength and aid in decreasing body fat..
Wouldn't you have rather spent a year learning all the necessary movements to make a better you? Rather than find out a year in that you now have to re-learn certain moves, and are, essentially, a newbie all over again?
Wow. I never said that. I have done squats, just not on a squat rack. I'd never even heard of such a thing and I have some pretty athletic and in shape friends and relatives. And I haven't done a deadlift because my goal in starting my journey was to start with cardio and ease myself into weight lifting. And I did that, by using the weight machines and getting a friend of mine to show me the correct form on the free weights. So, I did learn the proper form for some things and will continue to learn the proper form on other things as I advance. And I did in it a place where I didn't feel stupid while learning.
I'm not saying that people who are more serious about weight lifting should be satisfied with Planet Fitness. If PF doesn't have what you need for your regime, then by all means, don't waste your money there. But for those of us that Planet Fitness does help, don't make us feel less than because we're at the level that they are offering.0 -
Leading up to the new year were a whole bunch of threads from users complaining about all the newbies who would be joining THEIR gym (because clearly only their money counts). Threads about how the newbies would be taking up all the equipment, using it wrong, and how the newbies should just hurry up with failing so the gym can be less crowded again. It was almost as though people thought these newbies didn't belong at THEIR gym (seriously, the newbies money was probably worth less than their money right?). It was almost as though people wished the newbies would all go someplace else. Like, hmm, I dunno, a gym aimed at newbies?
That's actually not what those threads are about. It's a discussion about a cycle, a cycle that happens every year. The gym fills up in January, and empties back out by February.
It happens, there's no denying it.0 -
we're at the level that they are offering.
That doesn't really mean anything, honestly. There's no "level" you need to be at to do squats and deadlifts. I'm not sure what weight training you're doing at PF, but they clearly fail to offer the most effective tools out there for people in your situation.0 -
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.
if you have been working out for a year and have never attempted a barbell squat or a deadlift then you are just setting yourself behind the eight ball as these are the moves that are going to provide the most gains and increase overall strength and aid in decreasing body fat..
Wouldn't you have rather spent a year learning all the necessary movements to make a better you? Rather than find out a year in that you now have to re-learn certain moves, and are, essentially, a newbie all over again?
Wow. I never said that. I have done squats, just not on a squat rack. I'd never even heard of such a thing and I have some pretty athletic and in shape friends and relatives. And I haven't done a deadlift because my goal in starting my journey was to start with cardio and ease myself into weight lifting. And I did that, by using the weight machines and getting a friend of mine to show me the correct form on the free weights. So, I did learn the proper form for some things and will continue to learn the proper form on other things as I advance. And I did in it a place where I didn't feel stupid while learning.
I'm not saying that people who are more serious about weight lifting should be satisfied with Planet Fitness. If PF doesn't have what you need for your regime, then by all means, don't waste your money there. But for those of us that Planet Fitness does help, don't make us feel less than because we're at the level that they are offering.
I am just trying to point out that you are missing out on two of the most efficient moves for increasing strength and reducing body fat…
I am saying that people that join a gym that restricts them from using two of the most efficient moves in the weight training tool box are missing out, and it is going to make their performance and/or goals suffer.0 -
I'm not aiming to be a power lifter or someone who struts around and asks how much others bench and then brag about how much I can lift.
Planet Fitness has clearly succeeded in demonizing weightlifting for you. You equate progress with the lifts you're already doing as becoming some "lunk" to "struts around" and "brags."
That's... not reality. As you progress in your lifting, you don't suddenly turn into some huge jerk.
You don't mention what your goal is, but presumably it's progress and not stagnation.
Read into things much? I used to work out at a fitness center where I worked that had decent equipment including a squat rack. My goal has never been to become a power lifter or to lift 2x my body weight just to say that I can. Perhaps I worded my comment wrong.
You equate "lift 2x my body weight" with "strutting around" and "bragging."
What ARE your goals?
< can lift two times body weight and is not a power lifter…just saying...0 -
Well that's just dumb? Don't they have people there to help make squat racks LESS intimidating... and if they are going to get rid of them, maybe they can give one or two to a city rec/fitness center... I know ours could use a few more.0
-
I've got to say, for someone like me who was completely intimidated by going to the gym at the beginning of my weight loss journey, I was relieved and glad to have a place like Planet Fitness. I didn't feel as self-conscious or uncomfortable while I learned fitness. Now that I'm almost a year into my new lifestyle, I've grown more comfortable in a gym setting and would be confident enough to go to another gym. But I'm still grateful that I had my time at Pf in the beginning. I think if I had not had the experience there that I had, I would probably not be where I am now. Perhaps many people who go there are like me and actually need and appreciate their approach. What is so wrong with starting at PF and then moving on to something more advanced once you're ready?
Also, in my time there, I've never seen a squat rack but have seen and used lots of other amazing equipment including weight machines, all types of free weights, three different kinds of bike machines, treadmills, and ellipticals.
if you have been working out for a year and have never attempted a barbell squat or a deadlift then you are just setting yourself behind the eight ball as these are the moves that are going to provide the most gains and increase overall strength and aid in decreasing body fat..
Wouldn't you have rather spent a year learning all the necessary movements to make a better you? Rather than find out a year in that you now have to re-learn certain moves, and are, essentially, a newbie all over again?
Wow. I never said that. I have done squats, just not on a squat rack. I'd never even heard of such a thing and I have some pretty athletic and in shape friends and relatives. And I haven't done a deadlift because my goal in starting my journey was to start with cardio and ease myself into weight lifting. And I did that, by using the weight machines and getting a friend of mine to show me the correct form on the free weights. So, I did learn the proper form for some things and will continue to learn the proper form on other things as I advance. And I did in it a place where I didn't feel stupid while learning.
I'm not saying that people who are more serious about weight lifting should be satisfied with Planet Fitness. If PF doesn't have what you need for your regime, then by all means, don't waste your money there. But for those of us that Planet Fitness does help, don't make us feel less than because we're at the level that they are offering.
I am just trying to point out that you are missing out on two of the most efficient moves for increasing strength and reducing body fat…
I am saying that people that join a gym that restricts them from using two of the most efficient moves in the weight training tool box are missing out, and it is going to make their performance and/or goals suffer.
I think the point is not everyone wants or likes to lift. In addition if made to start with lifting someone may not stick with it. People have different goals and reasons for what they do.0 -
we're at the level that they are offering.
That doesn't really mean anything, honestly. There's no "level" you need to be at to do squats and deadlifts. I'm not sure what weight training you're doing at PF, but they clearly fail to offer the most effective tools out there for people in your situation.
There are levels. And the first one is "beginner". At least that's how it was for me. I didn't stay at the beginner level. I've progressed beyond that and I plan to progress beyond the level I am now to more advanced things. And working my way up slowing and adding different activities as I go is how I build discipline. It would mean nothing for me to start at a more advanced level, get frustrated with myself, and then quit. Which I have done in the past. But, when I started off slowly at a beginner's level, I gained confidence, strength, and discipline. And, when I outgrew the beginner's level activities, it made me want to push myself to more. That's all I'm saying. Joining PF helped me do that. I NEEDED that to get myself where I am to day and to help motivate me to more in the future. I will probably outgrow PF soon. And when I do, I'll move on to something else. And that's fine too. As a matter of fact, that was always my goal. The fact that I can say that I am outgrowing PF is a HUGE accomplishment for me when two years ago, a twenty minute walk was painful for me.0 -
This has always been their corporate policy since their inception. It's just that many franchise locations were free to disregard that policy, or just plain ignored it. PF has decided to crack down now, and the franchise locations that have been allowed to go on disregarding their "no squat racks" policy are going to have to become fully compliant. I used to be a member of a PF that was "100% compliant." It had no free weights except for a relatively small selection of dumbbells, a single Smith machine, a bunch of isolation machines, and row upon row upon row of cardio equipment. Sooner or later all all PFs will go this route as a result of corporate cracking down.0
-
we're at the level that they are offering.
That doesn't really mean anything, honestly. There's no "level" you need to be at to do squats and deadlifts. I'm not sure what weight training you're doing at PF, but they clearly fail to offer the most effective tools out there for people in your situation.
There are levels. And the first one is "beginner". At least that's how it was for me. I didn't stay at the beginner level. I've progressed beyond that and I plan to progress beyond the level I am now to more advanced things. And working my way up slowing and adding different activities as I go is how I build discipline. It would mean nothing for me to start at a more advanced level, get frustrated with myself, and then quit. Which I have done in the past. But, when I started off slowly at a beginner's level, I gained confidence, strength, and discipline. And, when I outgrew the beginner's level activities, it made me want to push myself to more. That's all I'm saying. Joining PF helped me do that. I NEEDED that to get myself where I am to day and to help motivate me to more in the future. I will probably outgrow PF soon. And when I do, I'll move on to something else. And that's fine too. As a matter of fact, that was always my goal. The fact that I can say that I am outgrowing PF is a HUGE accomplishment for me when two years ago, a twenty minute walk was painful for me.
Are these Planet Fitness "levels"? These don't make any sense.
The absolute first thing I would teach an absolute, know-nothing newbie is how to squat. Period, end of story. It's the single most effective and efficient exercise you can do for fat loss, strength, and muscle development.
I'm happy for your progress and all, but you're really selling yourself short by convincing yourself (or letting other people convince you) that you're not ready for "real" exercise or something.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions