3500 mg Potassium in 1200 calories? Diet suggestions?
deaterrae
Posts: 25 Member
I keep being frustrated by the 3500 mg daily value of potassium. It seems impossible, in my mind, to have a varied, tasty, and nutritionally complete diet of only 1200 calories and achieve 3500 mg of potassium.
In a related post, someone pointed out that 100 g of white beans have a whopping 1200 mg of potassium and "only" 300 calories, not counting anything you cook them with to add a modicum of flavor. For me, 300 calories is a meal. That is a quarter of my daily calories! And, it's not quite half of the amount of potassium recommended.
Has anyone formed a daily meal-plan that succeeds at 3500 mg of potassium with only 1200 calories? Any nutritionists out there with practical suggestions? (Listing foods that are high in potassium is not helpful without looking a full daily nutrition requirements and calorie intake.)
Thanks for the input! (This has been bugging me for a long time.)
PS - Yes, 1200 calories is about right for me. If I succeed in losing weight, my BMR could drop to 1050 or less. I'm short.
In a related post, someone pointed out that 100 g of white beans have a whopping 1200 mg of potassium and "only" 300 calories, not counting anything you cook them with to add a modicum of flavor. For me, 300 calories is a meal. That is a quarter of my daily calories! And, it's not quite half of the amount of potassium recommended.
Has anyone formed a daily meal-plan that succeeds at 3500 mg of potassium with only 1200 calories? Any nutritionists out there with practical suggestions? (Listing foods that are high in potassium is not helpful without looking a full daily nutrition requirements and calorie intake.)
Thanks for the input! (This has been bugging me for a long time.)
PS - Yes, 1200 calories is about right for me. If I succeed in losing weight, my BMR could drop to 1050 or less. I'm short.
1
Replies
-
Do you drink coffee? Coffee is high in potassium for almost zero cals. Another is salt substitute which is potassium chloride. You should look outside of MFP for potassium in foods, lots of entries show zero potassium even though a food is loaded. The meat entries are probably the most glaring.2
-
Do you drink coffee? Coffee is high in potassium for almost zero cals. Another is salt substitute which is potassium chloride. You should look outside of MFP for potassium in foods, lots of entries show zero potassium even though a food is loaded. The meat entries are probably the most glaring.
Oh no! So glad I read this, I have been taking a supplement with potassium in it. On top of the pot of coffee I drink each day I'm clearly getting too much. Thanks for this!1 -
It is indeed difficult to have a nutritionally complete diet at 1200 calories, it tends to need to be regimented: humans evolved to eat more and move more than sedentary dieting westerners do. Good sources of potassium include various non starchy vegetables and low sugar fruits which you should be eating nine servings of, and dairy like yoghurt and milk which you should be having three servings of anyway. For tasty add herbs, spices, garlic, chilli, balsamic vinegar, lime juice, reduced sodium soy sauce and so on.
Since your diary is locked I don't really see what else you want those who hold qualifications in nutrition to do except signpost you to lists?
http://nutritiondata.self.com/foods-000122000000000000000.html
http://nutritiondata.self.com/foods-000122000000000000000-w.html
http://www.permanente.net/homepage/kaiser/pdf/55929.pdf
BTW it worries me you are dismissing beans as being too high calorie, you need something for minerals and fibre and I am guessing you are not eating much in the way or nuts or seeds at that calorie level.0 -
Double-check actual values, however. 6 ounces of coffee have a mere 124 mg. Daily requirement is 3500 mg. Most daily supplements only provide 300-500 mg. Unless you're eating a lot of foods that are truly high in potassium, it is doubtful that you are over-doing it.
I also just saw an article that indicated that diuretics (such as coffee) can decrease potassium levels.1 -
I'm really short, too (5' 1). I just exercise a lot so I can eat back those calories because I like eating. I eat a lot of spinach and a banana everyday for potassium.0
-
Oh no! So glad I read this, I have been taking a supplement with potassium in it. On top of the pot of coffee I drink each day I'm clearly getting too much. Thanks for this!
The potassium supplements that I have found are only 99 mgs., while a single banana is something like 400 mgs. I decided potassium supplements are a waste of time.1 -
low sodium v8 has 70 calories and 1180 mg of potassium in a 11.5 oz can and only (relative) 200 mg sodium
coconut milk is low calorie and high potassium...something around 45 calories and 600 mg potassium in 8oz or thereabouts.
Coffee is fairly high in potassium and very few calories
Greens like spinach and kale...but chard rules all with 800 mg of potassium per 3 oz serving, but is also naturally high in sodium.
Quite a few other fruits and veg as well.2 -
Do you drink coffee? Coffee is high in potassium for almost zero cals. Another is salt substitute which is potassium chloride. You should look outside of MFP for potassium in foods, lots of entries show zero potassium even though a food is loaded. The meat entries are probably the most glaring.
Oh no! So glad I read this, I have been taking a supplement with potassium in it. On top of the pot of coffee I drink each day I'm clearly getting too much. Thanks for this!
You're probably alright. 3,500 is the DV, but if you do a bit more research you will find that most recommend 4,700 mg for adults without kidney issues. I eat a lot of high potassium foods and I still struggle to get there...I'm usually around 4,200-4,300 mg per day.0 -
Double-check actual values, however. 6 ounces of coffee have a mere 124 mg. Daily requirement is 3500 mg. Most daily supplements only provide 300-500 mg. Unless you're eating a lot of foods that are truly high in potassium, it is doubtful that you are over-doing it.
I also just saw an article that indicated that diuretics (such as coffee) can decrease potassium levels.
This is why, if you ask a question like this, that you open your diary so we can see what you are logging. I am not suggesting you start to drink coffee, my suggestion was that if you already do, make certain you log it with the correct potassium and it will help you reach your goal.0 -
Yams have a lot of potassium, a little over 900 mg for a small yam. Oranges, beans, lentils, and tomatoes are good sources too0
-
Double-check actual values, however. 6 ounces of coffee have a mere 124 mg. Daily requirement is 3500 mg. Most daily supplements only provide 300-500 mg. Unless you're eating a lot of foods that are truly high in potassium, it is doubtful that you are over-doing it.
I also just saw an article that indicated that diuretics (such as coffee) can decrease potassium levels.
I doubled down on the Viactiv with Potassium and took two though, that is %100. Ouch. Bad me. And I eat meat which has a bit in it, and cheese.
Really gotta watch that, it's one of the vitamins that can kill you.1 -
Since I don't count calories I can't really address that part of your question. Personally, I don't feel 1200 calories is enough for a bird. But you can get a lot of potassium in coconut water and also in raisins. Both are very high in that nutrient. Coconut water has very few calories. Also leafy greens and salmon. None of those are high in calories and all are healthy foods.0
-
I look to vegetables for a low calorie source - spinach, mushrooms, sweet potato, green beans and asparagus all add a decent amount of potassium for very few calories.0
-
In over a year of tracking what I eat, I have never had more than 3500mg of potassium, ever. I've come close, but never over, I'm starting to think that 3500mg is to much0
-
Many foods show 0 potassium in nutrition data although they have plenty of potassium. It's not required info on the label so lots of companies don't add it. I look up foods on nutritiondata.com if in doubt. And I drink coconut water for a quick low cal source of potassium.2
-
I eat avocado, banana for potassium or spinach. I keep my calorie goal between 1200 -15000
-
Oh no! So glad I read this, I have been taking a supplement with potassium in it. On top of the pot of coffee I drink each day I'm clearly getting too much. Thanks for this!
The potassium supplements that I have found are only 99 mgs., while a single banana is something like 400 mgs. I decided potassium supplements are a waste of time.
The reason why is because it's actually possible to overdose on potassium unlike sodium which can lead to very serious problems. Over-the-counter potassium supplements cannot be very high as a result.
OP: You are going to be quite challenged to get sufficient potassium in your diet at 1200 calories. Most potassium-rich foods are things like potatoes, beans, and starchy vegetables that are higher calorie also. One medium to large baking potato contains almost 1,500 mg of potassium alone, but it's also 200+ calories.
Also, as others have mentioned, MFP does not record potassium content of non-raw foods (packaged foods). Entries without an asterisk beside them in the database do, however, contain potassium information.0 -
I've had similar potassium concerns. I drink about 4 liters of water (not including my morning coffee & post workout protein shake) most days and was noticing that I was getting a lot of leg craps.
I dug out my recipe for oral rehydration solution (i.e. homemade Pedialyte)
1 quart water
3/4 tsp salt substitute (potassium chloride)
1/2 tsp baking soda
2 TBS white corn syrup
1 pkg unsweetened Kool-Aid
I don't add the corn syrup or Kool-Aid because of the sugar and taste isn't an issue for me. This can add 1950mg of potassium without any calories. Granted it tastes like sweat but I only drink a quart a few days a week.0 -
I've had similar potassium concerns. I drink about 4 liters of water (not including my morning coffee & post workout protein shake) most days and was noticing that I was getting a lot of leg craps.
I dug out my recipe for oral rehydration solution (i.e. homemade Pedialyte)
1 quart water
3/4 tsp salt substitute (potassium chloride)
1/2 tsp baking soda
2 TBS white corn syrup
1 pkg unsweetened Kool-Aid
I don't add the corn syrup or Kool-Aid because of the sugar and taste isn't an issue for me. This can add 1950mg of potassium without any calories. Granted it tastes like sweat but I only drink a quart a few days a week.
Review your magnesium intake not just sodium and potassium.1 -
Be careful with potassium supplements, there is a reason they're only 90mg.1
-
Eggplant is high in potassium (I eat it with skin). A cup of mashed eggplant has 1261 mg of Potassium, 13 g sugars and 6 g protein. While a cup of mashed banana has 805.5 mg Potassium, 27.5 g sugars and 2.5 g protein.
You may use Coconut Water, without pulp, no sugar added. 250 ml of coconut water has 350 mg of Potassium, 12 g sugars, 0 g protein. I use it to avoid cramps in my zumba class and it has worked OK.
Walmart sells Grace (the less expensive), Vita Coco, and O.N.E . Publix sells Vita Coco and O.N.E. They are in the Water Aisle, in Tetra Paks. The coconut water in cans taste ugly from my point of view and several have sugar added or pulp (that implies more calories). These are the images of the tetra pak ones that tastes similar to the real coconut water:
http://http://vitacoco.com/
http://www.onedrinks.com/ --> It has 1g less of sugar than vita coco, and you notice the difference in the flavor0 -
Once I started logging my coffee and mentally adding in the potassium of meat, I was reaching the 3500 pretty easily. It wasn't that my diet was low in potassium, I wasn't logging correctly.0
-
The DRI for potassium for females between 19-30 yrs old is 4700 mg (not 3500). But don't despair, you're likely getting more potassium than you think. __Potassium is NOT required to be listed on nutritional labels__!
The chicken breast and salmon I just ate at dinner shows 0 potassium on MFP because it is not listed on the label. But last year I contacted my supermarket who contacted the manufacturer and got me the answer. Combined they actually contain 725 mg. The broccoli on MFP shows 0 potassium too, but 1 cup actually contains over 500mg.
If you're eating plenty of fruits, veges, dairy, meats, and/or nuts chances are you're getting well over the potassium you need!0 -
The DRI for potassium for females between 19-30 yrs old is 4700 mg (not 3500). But don't despair, you're likely getting more potassium than you think. __Potassium is NOT required to be listed on nutritional labels__!
The chicken breast and salmon I just ate at dinner shows 0 potassium on MFP because it is not listed on the label. But last year I contacted my supermarket who contacted the manufacturer and got me the answer. Combined they actually contain 725 mg. The broccoli on MFP shows 0 potassium too, but 1 cup actually contains over 500mg.
If you're eating plenty of fruits, veges, dairy, meats, and/or nuts chances are you're getting well over the potassium you need!
Exactly! I had to read through several entries to find the potassium content in a t-bone steak. Turns out a 9 oz. t-bone is about 700 calories and 1700 mgs. of potassium. My planned menu for tomorrow will put me over on potassium big time! There are lazy people who enter minimal nutrient contents on MFP and other people log different nutrients according to what is important to them. If a nutrient is important, search an independent site. The entries on MFP are dependent on the honesty and diligence of the person entering it.0 -
Have you ever had your potassium levels checked? It is hard to become deficient in potassium, we get quite a lot through our diets.
Not all foods that contain potassium label it, so you're getting some from those foods as well.
Bananas, dark leafy greens, melon, nectarine, apple, blueberries, potatoes, legumes, beans, oranges, pears, tomatoes, milk, yogurt....
Stay away from supplements, as having too much potassium can be very dangerous to your health.0 -
Exactly! I had to read through several entries to find the potassium content in a t-bone steak. Turns out a 9 oz. t-bone is about 700 calories and 1700 mgs. of potassium. My planned menu for tomorrow will put me over on potassium big time! There are lazy people who enter minimal nutrient contents on MFP and other people log different nutrients according to what is important to them. If a nutrient is important, search an independent site. The entries on MFP are dependent on the honesty and diligence of the person entering it.
I don't add micronutrients because MFP asks for several as a percent daily value, meaningless given it's for a 2000 calorie diet and (presumably) the arbitrary recommendations of one country when MFP members are 'multicultural'. Sodium is listed in mg on our UK nutrition box but potassium is not listed at all.1 -
Definitely do your own research via google but I recently discovered a snack of celery and two tablespoons of good peanut butter is a great way to get 300 - 400 mgs of potassium. Obviously it depends on the pb brand. A 12" stalk of celery has around 150 mgs of potassium. I slap love russet potatoes cut in wedges and with some onion and garlic powder baked in the oven. 620 mgs of potassium in one potato. Hope that helps but yeah, keep doing research and you'll get there!0
-
1kg chicken
500g pumpkin0 -
Which coffee is high in potassium?1
-
I'm on 1200 as well, and while it's hard I've discovered that if I eat a zucchini or yellow squash omelet (saute squash in 1 tsp olive oil till brown with minced garlic, yummy, then add egg or egg whites) and also a milk and a yogurt and an orange and 1/2 cup of beans during my day with other fruits, veggies, lean protein, I can get my 3500 in while keeping my calories at 1200 plus activity. Also I wrote a list of high potassium items; dairy 400, potato 1000, zucchini 800, tomato 300, orange 300, salmon 500, this helps in my meal planning putting it into things I enjoy. works for me, hope it helps0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions