3 Day Military Diet (Cardiac Diet)
Replies
-
The first thing you need to do is accurately log your food:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1234699-logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide
Then set reasonable goals and eat at a reasonable deficit:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
or
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1235566-so-you-re-new-here
Then if you still are not losing weight after a month see your doctor and get a blood panel done to have your thyroid checked.0 -
Having actually served in military, I can tell you 100% that this is misnamed and a load of bovine feces. Having eaten in chow halls and out of the MRE bag, I don't know how this has been associated with the military outside of it being a sales tactic to make it seem all "hard core".
Even a week of this would drive me mad, and probably land me in the hospital (I'm only 5'2" and 137 lbs, but I support my activity by eating close to 1800cal/day and still lose fat). So no, I do not think this would be your best way to start losing weight again.
Re: the stalling at 1200 or less calories:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/why-big-caloric-deficits-and-lots-of-activity-can-hurt-fat-loss.html
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/another-look-at-metabolic-damage.html#more-9313
the second is a casual interview with Alan Aragon so the language is a little less than professional, but gives another look at the ideas behind the first link.
Not saying this is for sure it, but the insight can be used by anyone eating at a major deficit and exercising a lot as to why they have "stalls" in weight loss.0 -
My usual calorie intake is typically under 1200 anyways. So this wouldn't be horrible for me. The 1500 calorie plan isn't part of the original military diet plan, that was added by whomever made the site, therefore ignore that part. Just the three day diet plan is what I am talking about. I would stick to my under 1200 calories a day after the three days.
The breakfast sounds filling to me, I usually eat very little for breakfast anyways.
I need something to boost my system though because I can't handle not losing anything while I'm working my butt off in the gym and eatign healthy stuff while everyone else eats pizza, cookies, and soda. lol.
If you're concerned about health and nutrition at all, do not follow that diet. It's not going to adequately cover your micros or your macros if protein intake is important to you at all (and it should be).0 -
if it is only 3 days and not a gimmick u have to pay for, involves eating real foods and not pills, I say give it a try. Three days of change wont make or break you.
It also won't teach her anything when she gets stuck next time.
QFT0 -
I appreciate the advice I got from those of you whom were actually decent. I went ahead and talked to my doctor and he said I could do this for three days, and that it would in fact be beneficial as the combination of the foods actually does speed up your metabolism. I also will be taking the advice in upping my calories. I actually have where I intake 1340 but after exercise, it shows less than 1200, this is where I got confused. However, I will be upping my calories to 1140. Thank you for that info
I do not need to " Learn" how to be healthy, I simply am unmotivated at times. And the only 12 lbs in two years is due to an illness which resulted in harsh medications and an inability to move out of a bed for quite sometime. So I hope you sleep good tonight whoever it was that made that extremely rude comment.
As much as I appreciate the helpful comments that were made, whether they are what I was hoping to hear or not, I will never make a post again on here.
I was under the impression this wasn't a "bash your neighbor" social networking site and was used for advice and support with fitness and nutrition. I am impressed by what those of you can say behind a keyboard, especially the guy with a picture that includes his hand being down his gym pants...yes, that thing you are searching for is missing, a common side affect of steroids
Thank you again for the helpful advice give, it is greatly appreciated.
Best wishes!0 -
My usual calorie intake is typically under 1200 anyways. So this wouldn't be horrible for me. The 1500 calorie plan isn't part of the original military diet plan, that was added by whomever made the site, therefore ignore that part. Just the three day diet plan is what I am talking about. I would stick to my under 1200 calories a day after the three days.
The breakfast sounds filling to me, I usually eat very little for breakfast anyways.
I need something to boost my system though because I can't handle not losing anything while I'm working my butt off in the gym and eatign healthy stuff while everyone else eats pizza, cookies, and soda. lol.
There's your problem right there.0 -
Oh and the measuring thing, It has been about 6 months since I have measured myself. I know I need to do this lol. "The scale is the enemy," says my doctor. lol.0
-
The name of the diet is irrelevant. Thus, me putting in parenthesis Cardiact Diet.
I go to a doctor for my weight loss and he recommended 1200-1500. He said as long as I eat healthy snacks throughout the day it will not matter. I could just make an appointment, but I do not feel like making the payment for it
lol
I am sure he would snub his nose at this, or any diet. However, my body needs a kick. Something has to change. "Living a healthy lifestyle" takes a long time to show weight loss. I will continue with it of course, but I am looking for a kick.
can you explain precisely what you mean by "give your body a kick"......... and what results you expect to get from it?
what signs have you noticed in yourself that indicate that your body "needs a kick"?
"a kick" isn't a biological or medical concept, and unfortunately a lot of fad diets are peddled under terms like "kick start your metabolism" which is biologically impossible, but sounds good so it sells. But if you say what *you* understand by these terms, then maybe someone can advise you what steps to take to get better results... which is what you want, right?
If you want to speed up your metabolism, you need to do exercise (preferably lifting heavy weights) and eat more food.... I've seen this 3 day military diet before, and it's not going to speed up anyone's metabolism. If anything, it'll slow it down. If you want to speed up fat loss, then you need to understand that the human body burns fat slowly, and that fast weight loss mostly isn't fat that's being lost, and you set yourself up for rebound weight gain (sometimes ending up fatter than you were before you started). Fat loss is a slow process, you have to do it the healthy and sustainable way and be patient.0 -
Having actually served in military, I can tell you 100% that this is misnamed and a load of bovine feces. Having eaten in chow halls and out of the MRE bag, I don't know how this has been associated with the military outside of it being a sales tactic to make it seem all "hard core".
Even a week of this would drive me mad, and probably land me in the hospital (I'm only 5'2" and 137 lbs, but I support my activity by eating close to 1800cal/day and still lose fat). So no, I do not think this would be your best way to start losing weight again.
Re: the stalling at 1200 or less calories:
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/why-big-caloric-deficits-and-lots-of-activity-can-hurt-fat-loss.html
http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/another-look-at-metabolic-damage.html#more-9313
the second is a casual interview with Alan Aragon so the language is a little less than professional, but gives another look at the ideas behind the first link.
Not saying this is for sure it, but the insight can be used by anyone eating at a major deficit and exercising a lot as to why they have "stalls" in weight loss.
^^^^ this is good advice0 -
I am you there - i have often done this - and usually lose 5 lbs. Food is pretty basic and a part frankfurters and ice cream is quite healthy. This is not forever so 3 days is perfectly acceptable to me.0
-
Intermittent fasting. Try skipping a meal and see how you feel. Drink water instead. If you feel ok , 2 days later, skip 2 meals.
When you do eat, up your macros o that you get 50% of your calories from protein foods like meat fish and eggs. Skip dairy for a bit, skip carb and skip beans. Try to eliminate as much sugar as possible except in fruit, and even so, limit fruits. I hope this helps.0 -
I am you there - i have often done this - and usually lose 5 lbs. Food is pretty basic and a part frankfurters and ice cream is quite healthy. This is not forever so 3 days is perfectly acceptable to me.
You do this often and usually lose 5 lbs yet still have weight to lose? If you don't see from your personal experiences what a load of crap this diet is there really is no way of making the obvious more clear, is there?0 -
The first thing I change with clients is exercise. The body adapts to exercise pretty quickly, so infusing a different type of workout can shock the body.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness industry for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
I appreciate the advice I got from those of you whom were actually decent. I went ahead and talked to my doctor and he said I could do this for three days, and that it would in fact be beneficial as the combination of the foods actually does speed up your metabolism. I also will be taking the advice in upping my calories. I actually have where I intake 1340 but after exercise, it shows less than 1200, this is where I got confused. However, I will be upping my calories to 1140. Thank you for that info
I do not need to " Learn" how to be healthy, I simply am unmotivated at times. And the only 12 lbs in two years is due to an illness which resulted in harsh medications and an inability to move out of a bed for quite sometime. So I hope you sleep good tonight whoever it was that made that extremely rude comment.
As much as I appreciate the helpful comments that were made, whether they are what I was hoping to hear or not, I will never make a post again on here.
I was under the impression this wasn't a "bash your neighbor" social networking site and was used for advice and support with fitness and nutrition. I am impressed by what those of you can say behind a keyboard, especially the guy with a picture that includes his hand being down his gym pants...yes, that thing you are searching for is missing, a common side affect of steroids
Thank you again for the helpful advice give, it is greatly appreciated.
Best wishes!
Get a new doctor. Or go back to him and ask him to show you the evidence to support that claim. That combination of foods will speed up your metabolism is similar to the way my pet unicorn dispenses rainbow ice cream from his left butt cheek.0 -
I don't understand why people torture themselves on restrictive diets with boring food when they could easily lose weight eating a sensible plan with foods they actually enjoy. There's no foods that magical burn fat off your body. You could get fat off of broccoli, but you'd sure have to eat a lot of it. Eating more nutritious foods helps a whole lot with satiety and health but in the end weight loss always comes down to a calorie deficit.0
-
I don't understand why people torture themselves on restrictive diets with boring food when they could easily lose weight eating a sensible plan with foods they actually enjoy. There's no foods that magical burn fat off your body. You could get fat off of broccoli, but you'd sure have to eat a lot of it. Eating more nutritious foods helps a whole lot with satiety and health but in the end weight loss always comes down to a calorie deficit.
Not all diets are comprised of boring foods and not all of us are able to stick to a 'sensible meal plan" without a guideline to follow. Plus your idea of sensible might be different then mine. I don't think this diet is sensible, nor do I think it is good for you. but not everyone can stop at one cookie. It's no secret that eating less is what helps you lose weight. It's so much easier said then done. If everyone could do it by practicing moderation and eating sensibly then there'd be no overweight people and no fad diets. Obviously some people need guidelines, meal plans or diets to follow that work and make sense to them. I just wish that the diet industry would offer diet that are geared toward healthy eating and rather then severe restriction and deprivation or relying on pills, chews or other weight loss gimmicks.
(ps i'm one of those people. Left to my own devices i'm eating the entire box of girl scout cookies)0 -
Perhaps your issue is that you've been undereating (you say you eat less than 1200 calories a day) for two years and your metabolism WAY down. You may need to eat more to get it back to a normal level, then eat at a REASONABLE deficit and the weight will come off.
Oh, and this diet is in no way associated with any branch of the military. Some doofus named it that to try to make it sound legitimate.
military diet was a yellow sweat shirt, pistol belt with canteen, salad and PT, PT, PT, PT........salad.......PT PT PT......salad.....PT PT PT PT sleep....repeat...lol0 -
This diet is no indicator to how people who are IN the military eat. But there is a reason it is called the military diet! This is actually a "meal plan" that recruiters will give to people who are looking to join, but don't quite meet height/weight requirements. My recruiter recently provided this as a suggestion.. it is not meant to be something that you stick to for long periods of time, just something to help you with a few stubborn pounds. When joining the military, recruiters just want to get you a few pounds under maximum requirements. Once you meet requirements, if you gain those few pounds back, it doesn't matter to them. It's simply for weigh-in purposes. Once you qualify for weigh-in at MEPS, it's up to you to take care of yourself and get in shape for basic training. But like I said, this is a quick fix to help you qualify at weigh-in, not something guaranteed to keep weight off. It can help you get over a weight loss plateau, but it's once the diet is over that is going to take the most will power.. not during. It's easy to stick to this for three days, but once you are done you have to have the will power to not binge and to continue eating clean, healthy foods if you want the weight to stay off.0
-
This diet is no indicator to how people who are IN the military eat. But there is a reason it is called the military diet! This is actually a "meal plan" that recruiters will give to people who are looking to join, but don't quite meet height/weight requirements. My recruiter recently provided this as a suggestion.. it is not meant to be something that you stick to for long periods of time, just something to help you with a few stubborn pounds. When joining the military, recruiters just want to get you a few pounds under maximum requirements. Once you meet requirements, if you gain those few pounds back, it doesn't matter to them. It's simply for weigh-in purposes. Once you qualify for weigh-in at MEPS, it's up to you to take care of yourself and get in shape for basic training. But like I said, this is a quick fix to help you qualify at weigh-in, not something guaranteed to keep weight off. It can help you get over a weight loss plateau, but it's once the diet is over that is going to take the most will power.. not during. It's easy to stick to this for three days, but once you are done you have to have the will power to not binge and to continue eating clean, healthy foods if you want the weight to stay off.
I've never met a recruiter advocating this in over two decades.0 -
Its from the right butt cheek.I appreciate the advice I got from those of you whom were actually decent. I went ahead and talked to my doctor and he said I could do this for three days, and that it would in fact be beneficial as the combination of the foods actually does speed up your metabolism. I also will be taking the advice in upping my calories. I actually have where I intake 1340 but after exercise, it shows less than 1200, this is where I got confused. However, I will be upping my calories to 1140. Thank you for that info
I do not need to " Learn" how to be healthy, I simply am unmotivated at times. And the only 12 lbs in two years is due to an illness which resulted in harsh medications and an inability to move out of a bed for quite sometime. So I hope you sleep good tonight whoever it was that made that extremely rude comment.
As much as I appreciate the helpful comments that were made, whether they are what I was hoping to hear or not, I will never make a post again on here.
I was under the impression this wasn't a "bash your neighbor" social networking site and was used for advice and support with fitness and nutrition. I am impressed by what those of you can say behind a keyboard, especially the guy with a picture that includes his hand being down his gym pants...yes, that thing you are searching for is missing, a common side affect of steroids
Thank you again for the helpful advice give, it is greatly appreciated.
Best wishes!
Get a new doctor. Or go back to him and ask him to show you the evidence to support that claim. That combination of foods will speed up your metabolism is similar to the way my pet unicorn dispenses rainbow ice cream from his left butt cheek.0 -
Please let me know how this worked out! I am starting today.0
-
I lost 6 lbs in one week using this as kind of a guide. I did not follow it exact (no hot dogs) and I eat frozen lowfat Greek yogurt, not ice cream.0
-
And a 3 day diet.....is just WRONG0 -
Anything worth doing is worth doing for longer than 3 days.
it's 3 days on, 4 days off for however as long as you want0 -
Anything worth doing is worth doing for longer than 3 days.
it's 3 days on, 4 days off for however as long as you want
http://www.answerfitness.com/532/top-10-fad-diets-diet-reviews/
The 3 Day Military Diet (Cardiac Diet) is #110 -
I lost 6 lbs in one week using this as kind of a guide. I did not follow it exact (no hot dogs) and I eat frozen lowfat Greek yogurt, not ice cream.
You lost 5lbs of water and 1lb of lean mass and fat (what ratio...who knows?)0 -
It could work, I have seen word from two different trainers Chris powers and Pauline from Fighter diet .com that talk about about Refeeds.. and really what that is , is just increasing your calorie intake by 500+ calories for a week or two with little to no exercising.
Then after two weeks try again.0 -
In for ridiculousness. And moron doctor.0
-
Agreed! Increase your caloric intake..... Its amazing how much u can lose when u fuel your body right. I always weigh less the days I up my intake seriously!0
-
I am still stuck on the doctor and his claims that this diet will kick your metabolism. The less food you eat, the slower your metabolism is going to be. A properly fueld body (ie more than 1000 calories a day) is going to have a better metabolism.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions