Do you still feel "fat" mentally after a lot of weight loss?

Ha, I still remember looking at my mom in the dressing room and saying in bewilderment, "Well, if I wear a size 4, what size do the skinny people wear??"

Totally know what you mean.

Here's my latest mentally fat moment- I walked by the mirror yesterday in my size 2 work pants and realized I needed to suck it in. THEN I realized how weird it was to feel fat while comfortably wearing a size 2 anything and especially after once comfortably fitting the same pants in a size 16. I understand my body composition could be improved, but I don't think my perception should be so dramatically skewed sometimes.

I have also noticed that I'm harder on myself now because I pay more attention now. When I was heavier, I didn't think much about my weight and only ever felt self-conscious if my clothes were considerably tighter than usual or if I caught an unflattering glimpse of myself in a reflection. Now I tend to study my body more and in turn, find more to criticize.

I completely agree!

Ha, I still remember looking at my mom in the dressing room and saying in bewilderment, "Well, if I wear a size 4, what size do the skinny people wear??"

Umm a size 0? 00? 4 is not skinny at all ..

Where do you get off saying something like that? Especially when you write this on your profile...
"I'm done accepting requests from guys. Also had to make my diary "friends only" because some of you people are too judgmental and rude "
I think a size 4 is a size 8 in the UK and that's pretty small. There was absolutely no need for you to write that statement, and considering your dislike of 'rude, judgemental people', I would have thought you would be more considered in your contribution to this thread.

I think she was joking. Chill out!

I went from a US size 22 to a size 4 in one year, everybody tells me how skinny I look.
There are a few floor to ceiling mirrors in my home, Yet when I look in the mirror, what goes through my mind is Hmmm this mirror must be one of those slenderizing ones.
Though I see a smaller sized person, somehow its not me.
I wear smaller clothes, yet I feel that people who I know are in larger sizes, are somewhat smaller in size than me.
I call it my body dysmorphia phase of weight loss.
I am not unduly worried, hopefully my mental weight, will catch up with my physical weight soon.

Sometimes. I think in my case, it's more related to dysmorphia. I'll occasionally see parts of my body as bigger than they are. Never the entire body.

I do still have a big person mentality, though. It's hard not to. The weight loss was drastic for me, too drastic. So, my mind didn't have enough time to catch up.

Sometimes, I look in the mirror and see a different person. That both astounds me and confuses me. My confidence is boosting, the more I progress, but it's taking time.

Also, size is... relative. lol I have been told - by both people here and offline - that I'm thin. And I was called skinny at my lowest weight. I am now a size 7, and I was a 5 then. Size has a lot to do with body type, and where a person carries their weight. I carry my weight in my hips and thighs. People often guess I'm a few sizes smaller than I am. I get 4 a lot, for example. They're always shocked to find out. Although, I hate when they guess. Feels like putting me on the spot. Especially since, at my highest weight, I looked like I should have been an 18... but not even the 20's at Ross would fit me. So, I kind of... trained myself to never, ever, ever answer that question. Even now, I feel a bit uncomfortable saying my size.

I do think that person was being sarcastic, though.

Why are you saying "always"?? Change it, see what is really there, tell yourself that you're not and if that doesn't work, maybe you need to talk to a professional to work through that.

I will always still feel mentally fat and see flab and saddlebags....

I know I'm still fat, but I'm having this weird thing where I don't feel (or think I look) any different. Then again, photographs used to shock me, and now I go, "Yeah, that's what I look like," so maybe I've just lost weight to become the person I always thought I was.

Me and a friend were discussing this the other day. Part of me when I was bigger tricked me into thinking I looked better than I did especially when wearing clothes that were flattering. Now iv lost some of the weight I now look like I tricked myself to think I looked like when I was bigger. I feel as fat now as I did then. Its very frustrating. Still got a bit to go though so there is still time