Squat Pains a Plenty - Low Bar
Replies
-
I read that squating below parallel puts undue stress on the knees. Some people, genetically, can overcome this but most may experience knee problems in the future. I noticed that smitty's lower back is rounding a bit at the very bottom of the squat. That may be a reason to not squat so low, at least until you've stretched out enough to squat low without rounding you lower back.
mho0 -
Eeeek nooosmittybuilt19 wrote: »Bracing has always been an issue. I feel like I take a deep breath into my belly but sometimes I think I subconsciously let it go during the descent. It seems that when I focus on keeping a tight back and full belly one or the other always disappears throughout the movement.
Breathing properly makes such a difference. If it helps, take a huge gulp of air before a rep, hold it, descend, and keep holding it until you start grinding up, then release.
0 -
I always squat below parallel. If there is one thing I put zero thought into it's am I going low enough because I know I am. That being said, I do see the lower back rounding (had not noticed it before). Is this something, depth, I should retrain while using lighter weights? Or do I just need to work on hamstring flex?0
-
It actually seems like I put more stress on the knee if I try to control it and go at or above parallel because I'm 'stopping' my decent. Going parallel or below allows me to drive from my heels instead of trying to straighten my knees. ...Not sure if that makes sense. Lol.I read that squating below parallel puts undue stress on the knees. Some people, genetically, can overcome this but most may experience knee problems in the future. I noticed that smitty's lower back is rounding a bit at the very bottom of the squat. That may be a reason to not squat so low, at least until you've stretched out enough to squat low without rounding you lower back.
mho
0 -
yeah, stopping above parallel puts massive shear force on the knees, basically the opposite of what shimaura suggested.
It actually seems like I put more stress on the knee if I try to control it and go at or above parallel because I'm 'stopping' my decent. Going parallel or below allows me to drive from my heels instead of trying to straighten my knees. ...Not sure if that makes sense. Lol.I read that squating below parallel puts undue stress on the knees. Some people, genetically, can overcome this but most may experience knee problems in the future. I noticed that smitty's lower back is rounding a bit at the very bottom of the squat. That may be a reason to not squat so low, at least until you've stretched out enough to squat low without rounding you lower back.
mho
0 -
I'm going to ask this in relation to staying tight in the core and for no other reason. Would there be any upside to me trying a belt, only as something to press my belly against just to get the feeling. I wouldn't use it for long as I don't want to use a belt for work weight (personal preference). I think I've heard this mentioned before, but would like more input on the matter.0
-
smittybuilt19 wrote: »I'm going to ask this in relation to staying tight in the core and for no other reason. Would there be any upside to me trying a belt, only as something to press my belly against just to get the feeling. I wouldn't use it for long as I don't want to use a belt for work weight (personal preference). I think I've heard this mentioned before, but would like more input on the matter.
I actually have seen this recommended. If you buy the belt and use it for a set, focus on bracing your stomach correctly (this came up because a whole bunch of people were being told to brace, and everyone was talking about how they sucked their stomach in). It's easier to focus on when you physically have the belt to push against even though you don't need the belt in the traditional sense.
ETA: And I would definitely not use it all the time, but every now and then when you feel your form slipping and you need to double check.0 -
I use a belt when my back's not feeling up to the task that day and when I'm trying at 85-90+% of my 1RM. It helps to use it to prevent injury at higher weights, but it shouldn't be used as a crutch during working sets. If you feel like you need it, use it.smittybuilt19 wrote: »I'm going to ask this in relation to staying tight in the core and for no other reason. Would there be any upside to me trying a belt, only as something to press my belly against just to get the feeling. I wouldn't use it for long as I don't want to use a belt for work weight (personal preference). I think I've heard this mentioned before, but would like more input on the matter.
I'm not sure if your back is actually rounding, I can't really tell.
I do pause squats for core strength though and explosive power. It helps me keep my torso more upright and my back tight, especially when I need it most--in the hole.
0 -
smittybuilt19 wrote: »I'm going to ask this in relation to staying tight in the core and for no other reason. Would there be any upside to me trying a belt, only as something to press my belly against just to get the feeling. I wouldn't use it for long as I don't want to use a belt for work weight (personal preference). I think I've heard this mentioned before, but would like more input on the matter.
I actually have seen this recommended. If you buy the belt and use it for a set, focus on bracing your stomach correctly (this came up because a whole bunch of people were being told to brace, and everyone was talking about how they sucked their stomach in). It's easier to focus on when you physically have the belt to push against even though you don't need the belt in the traditional sense.
ETA: And I would definitely not use it all the time, but every now and then when you feel your form slipping and you need to double check.
That's what I'm thinking. Simply a training aid.
0 -
Squating below parallel is something i used to do years ago. Just thought i'd put that out ... food for thought and if its urban legend i'm open for input.
not sure what you can do about working on not rounding you back other than not squating so deep. You may be able to squat deeper overtime. I do alot of stretching and not sure if that has helped me. As was mentioned previous, it would be safe to unload some weight to work and perfect form. I was into 20 rep squats and would stop if i felt like i was getting too sloppy in form due to fatigue.-1 -
I don't see any rounding... I see stretch reflex as he reverses out of the bottom.0
-
This is rather tongue in cheek, but a fun read.Squating below parallel is something i used to do years ago. Just thought i'd put that out ... food for thought and if its urban legend i'm open for input.
not sure what you can do about working on not rounding you back other than not squating so deep. You may be able to squat deeper overtime. I do alot of stretching and not sure if that has helped me. As was mentioned previous, it would be safe to unload some weight to work and perfect form. I was into 20 rep squats and would stop if i felt like i was getting too sloppy in form due to fatigue.
http://tonygentilcore.com/2010/12/let-me-know-if-youve-heard-this-one-before-a-personal-trainer-walks-into-a-bar-and-says-squatting-below-parallel-is-bad-for-the-knees/0 -
dbmata: Thank you for the link, I enjoyed reading the article and the information provided. i have a adominal hernia of sort now and gave up lifting "heavy". currenly doing low weight high reps until i find a way to go heavier.
OP, hope you can resolve your knee problem.
take care.0 -
Just to be clear, I don't see any lower back rounding, there's just some butt wink at the bottom of the movement. This is likely caused by a bit of excess depth. I don't think it's a big deal, personally. Everyone has at least a small amount of butt wink.
Good video:
If it bothers you or causes pain or you want to decrease ROM on squats, then limit depth slightly. I used to squat that low but I gradually limited my depth to keep form better (I commonly would "fall" forward at the bottom of a squat). Plus I can squat more weight without going so deep. Depends on your goals.0 -
I don't squat as wide as possible either. Try shortening your stance and see if the pain goes away.0
-
Dopeitup - Thanks for posting the video, great watch.0
-
Eddie Munster lifts?0
-
smittybuilt19 wrote: »I always squat below parallel. If there is one thing I put zero thought into it's am I going low enough because I know I am. That being said, I do see the lower back rounding (had not noticed it before). Is this something, depth, I should retrain while using lighter weights? Or do I just need to work on hamstring flex?
If you find out, let me know pls. I'm the same, in that, I'm always below parallel - I don't even need to think about it. But I've managed to pick up a bit of butt wink since widening my stance (on advice of strength coach - stance was too narrow so not hitting hammies). Seems like when you fix one thing, something else goes
I personally, didn't notice any rounding on your video but those wrists didn't look good - that'll be fine just now but not so good when it gets heavier - looks like a lot of weight sitting on your wrists.
And like everyone else says, didn't notice you bracing before the start - you're probably doing it, it just wasn't noticeable.
0 -
Just to be clear, I don't see any lower back rounding, there's just some butt wink at the bottom of the movement. This is likely caused by a bit of excess depth. I don't think it's a big deal, personally. Everyone has at least a small amount of butt wink.
Good video:
If it bothers you or causes pain or you want to decrease ROM on squats, then limit depth slightly. I used to squat that low but I gradually limited my depth to keep form better (I commonly would "fall" forward at the bottom of a squat). Plus I can squat more weight without going so deep. Depends on your goals.
Good post! All of the "butt-wink police" are friggin' ridiculous already.0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1f6mk1aVuA
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions