If the av person should eat 2000, then why can I only eat 1650 to maintain? Bummer!!
Replies
-
whoops
0 -
I too am at 1650 to maintain. So far, I've found this to be pretty accurate as my weight only fluctuates a pound or two and I don't religiously log my intake like I did when I was losing.0
-
RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.0 -
RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:)0 -
tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
Also, I'm losing on 2100 Gross average weekly calories.
What are you losing on? What do you gain on? Everyone is different. It all depends on activity levels and the amount of muscle mass you have. There was nothing rude in what I said.
Maybe I misinterpreted it then. I'm in maintenance mostly. When I was losing I did 1200 net. I am not sure now and am trying to figure it out for maintenance. Mfp gives me 1440 net, but its going to be more because I walk a lot during the week and run on weekends. Been on maintenance for close to two years now mostly not tracking, but I'm curious to track and see what my actual number is now. My weight is low at 105ish though, so it isn't going to be that high, but I could probably stand to gain a few pounds.0 -
Aviva, sorry I didn't answer sooner, I didn't see your comment. The way they test your metabolism is you go to the nutritionist's office before eating anything or doing any exercise, first thing in the AM, and they have you breathe into a tube for several minutes while sitting still. It collects things from your exhalations that allow it to compute your metabolism. Then it prints up a readout. So this will be your BMR. Then the nutritionist takes that and adds up your lifestyle factors to get your maintenance calories. In this method, exercise that is purposefully done isn't counted in; you add it in yourself separately and you can either eat more on the days you work out, or you can do a calculation to even it out to the same calories each day (provided you stick to your program and don't throw the numbers off.)
Interesting. I'm going to a health spa next month. I wonder if I can get that done there.0 -
Katerina9408 wrote: »Lrdoflamancha wrote: »It depends what you eat. Carbs burn faster then fat so try to concentrate on simple carbs like fruits and veggies for protein : you can make chickpease, lentils,beans
I must ask are you a troll or do you believe this?
Could you please quote correctly. Now it seems like you posted the nonsense.
It is not nonsence research for yourself
Just love it how people get all in a bunch that the answer really is more fruits/veggies and plant proteins. Every. Time.
Plants. Rule.
:-D
The answer to what?0 -
Katerina9408 wrote: »Lrdoflamancha wrote: »It depends what you eat. Carbs burn faster then fat so try to concentrate on simple carbs like fruits and veggies for protein : you can make chickpease, lentils,beans
I must ask are you a troll or do you believe this?
Could you please quote correctly. Now it seems like you posted the nonsense.
It is not nonsence research for yourself
Just love it how people get all in a bunch that the answer really is more fruits/veggies and plant proteins. Every. Time.
Plants. Rule.
:-D
The answer to what?
Life, the universe, and everything?0 -
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »Katerina9408 wrote: »Lrdoflamancha wrote: »It depends what you eat. Carbs burn faster then fat so try to concentrate on simple carbs like fruits and veggies for protein : you can make chickpease, lentils,beans
I must ask are you a troll or do you believe this?
Could you please quote correctly. Now it seems like you posted the nonsense.
It is not nonsence research for yourself
Just love it how people get all in a bunch that the answer really is more fruits/veggies and plant proteins. Every. Time.
Plants. Rule.
:-D
The answer to what?
Life, the universe, and everything?
I thought that was 42.0 -
jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:)
I didn't read ahead when I said that and afterwards took back my opinion0 -
cyberblonde wrote: »I know I am most of the day inactive as I have a desk job, but i exercise 3 to 4 times a week which I will be adding to the 1650 cals I have been given.
Just seems cray to me that we are alway told that 2000 cals a day are the amount an average person should eat per day. I would put on weight at that level.
Maybe the average person runs 5km per day too?!
In short, yes, the "average person" in question does exercise.
If it makes you feel any better, MFP suggests something like 1650 for me to maintain also. Turns out MFP is wrong. I've made a lot of adjustments and found that I maintain on around 1800 calories. Add a little exercise and I'm at 2000+.
Everyone is different. There are too many factors to get bent out of shape over.0 -
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »Katerina9408 wrote: »Lrdoflamancha wrote: »It depends what you eat. Carbs burn faster then fat so try to concentrate on simple carbs like fruits and veggies for protein : you can make chickpease, lentils,beans
I must ask are you a troll or do you believe this?
Could you please quote correctly. Now it seems like you posted the nonsense.
It is not nonsence research for yourself
Just love it how people get all in a bunch that the answer really is more fruits/veggies and plant proteins. Every. Time.
Plants. Rule.
:-D
The answer to what?
Life, the universe, and everything?
I thought that was 42.
My mistake
0 -
Average people leave their homes to work, walk across parking lots, move about through the halls of schools, offices, etc.
I work from home - my commute is less than 50 steps. Even walking around the halls of my house and going up and down the stairs to my basement doesn't get me the same amount of activity as my husband who leaves the house and goes to an office.
I was gaining weight at 1620 calories per day.
So I tuned into my fitness tracker a little better. Took one day off from exercise and discovered that my average day with no exercise is really around 1400 calories. That discovery empowered me to get maintenance under control.
I set my calorie limit to that manually in MFP and now I know just how much I can have, how much exercise really does for me on those days and I've been having great success maintaining within 1 pound of my goal on a consistent basis.
Everyone's average is different - understand yours and the rest is easy!
Oh and I eat anything I want - IN MODERATION including bacon, fast food, wine, ice cream - it can be done if you put your mind over the matter.0 -
jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:)
it's all in how you say it 
0 -
RunRutheeRun wrote: »jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:) it's all in how you say it
True.
And as such, I would like to amend my previous statement:
My maintenance calories are ~3400...
...and that makes me better than everyone else.
0 -
LOL... some might say, lucky thing...but if you earn it ..you just go ahead and eat itjofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:) it's all in how you say it
True.
And as such, I would like to amend my previous statement:
My maintenance calories are ~3400...
...and that makes me better than everyone else.
0 -
RunRutheeRun wrote: »
LOL... some might say, lucky thing...but if you earn it ..you just go ahead and eat itjofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:) it's all in how you say it
True.
And as such, I would like to amend my previous statement:
My maintenance calories are ~3400...
...and that makes me better than everyone else.
These is my pre-exercise TDEE. There is no "earn" here...unless you count my generally active lifestyle and outgoing personality.0 -
I am 54, are 1250 cal enough for me? I am always under, I feel like it's too much for me to eat, I exercise at least 5 days out of the week, sometimes 6.0
-
jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »
LOL... some might say, lucky thing...but if you earn it ..you just go ahead and eat itjofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »jofjltncb6 wrote: »RunRutheeRun wrote: »tinallen863 wrote: »I'm a 52 yr old female 5' 1", 114 lbs. If I go over 1200 calories I gain weight.
How sad!
I'm 42, female 5'2, 129 pounds. If I go over 2400 I gain weight
Wow, rude post
^ how is this rude? some people are active and their TDEE's reflect that, I also am 5ft 2, 45 yrs old, 134lbs and I gain if I go over 2300. Everyone is different. If your sedentary your TDEE is low, if your active its not,..so not a rude reply at all, just a different opinion.
Saying those two statements together was braggy and seemingly rubbing it in her face imo.
My maintenance calories are ~3400.
Or said another way, if I go over 3400, I gain weight.
(You're welcome, RunRutheeRun...because your post now seems comparatively less rude. :flowerforyou:) it's all in how you say it
True.
And as such, I would like to amend my previous statement:
My maintenance calories are ~3400...
...and that makes me better than everyone else.
These is my pre-exercise TDEE. There is no "earn" here...unless you count my generally active lifestyle and outgoing personality.
And you're a guy which means your TDEE is naturally higher anyway .....I'll just have to take your word about your personality 
0 -
I am 54, are 1250 cal enough for me? I am always under, I feel like it's too much for me to eat, I exercise at least 5 days out of the week, sometimes 6.
Are you making reasonable and satisfactory progress towards your goals? Are you goals reasonable? Are you confident (or at least as confident as you can be) in your calculation of calories consumed because you weigh and measure appropriately? Are you meeting your nutritional targets/minimum to avoid any deficiencies? Do you feel adequately fueled for your exercise? Are you sleeping well? Do you have any symptoms that might be attributed to insufficient calories/nutrition? Do you mean you "feel like it's too much...to eat" because of the quantity of food? If so, have you considered more calorie dense foods?
TL;DR - It depends.0 -
Agreed.
The 'average' intake guidelines (in the UK at least) are 2000 for women and 2500 for men. I am 5"8 (i.e. about 2 inches taller than UK average) for a woman and MFP calculates my TDEE to be 1950 at sedentary.
0 -
I am 54, are 1250 cal enough for me? I am always under, I feel like it's too much for me to eat, I exercise at least 5 days out of the week, sometimes 6.
I'm 56 and my BMR was calculated by a device my trainer used as 1136 sedentary. I also exercise, so tend to eat between 1300-1400 a day. I have to admit that if I eat under 1200, I usually feel hungry, and I do try to keep to nutrient dense lower calorie meals and small snacks. The only time 1200 seems like "too much" is if I have a long day and am just too stressed and tired to cook.0 -
-
The average person has less than two legs. Why do I have two legs?0
-
WTF is an average person? Idiotic concept at best.0
-
SweatLikeDog wrote: »WTF is an average person? Idiotic concept at best.
yeah, i said a bunch of times that 2000 is not average, but just a round number they came up with based on self reported data, but seems like everyone has me on ignore or something.0 -
cyberblonde wrote: »I know I am most of the day inactive as I have a desk job, but i exercise 3 to 4 times a week which I will be adding to the 1650 cals I have been given.
Just seems cray to me that we are alway told that 2000 cals a day are the amount an average person should eat per day. I would put on weight at that level.
Maybe the average person runs 5km per day too?!
try to use https://cronometer.com/ this site 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions