Confused. Mfp has dropped my calorie intake to 930 per day? Pls help
snakecake
Posts: 19 Member
hi everyone. I started MFP 5 weeks ago. I weighed 165 and want to weigh 135. I put I would like to loose 2lbs per week. So off I went. Eating 1200 calories per day. Working out 3 times a day. I was right on target and lost 10lbs in 5 weeks. So then MFP wants to update my calories so I can continue to meet my goals. I click yes and it updates it to 930 per day. Now I understand I get more calories when I work out but I only go to my fitness class three times a week. Now obviously I'm active other than that. You know errands cooking cleaning work etc. but I don't really include that. So some days when I have no exercise and I meet the 930 calories for the day MFP says I'm not eating enough. What gives ?
0
Replies
-
I'm guessing it might be a glitch in the system? I've never seen it lower than 1200. Maybe contact customer support?0
-
karen_fitzgibbon wrote: »I'm guessing it might be a glitch in the system? I've never seen it lower than 1200. Maybe contact customer support?
No there has been lots of these recently0 -
Right. I'm confused. I do also understand as you loose weight it takes less energy to do fitness so you are not burning as much as you once were at a heavier weight...0
-
Let's back up a moment here. At 155lbs with 20 to go you should NOT be attempting to lose 2lbs per week.
Change it to 1lb/week at least for a little longer, then go to 1/2lb per week when you get into your last 10. What you are trying to do is dangerous.0 -
It's because the closer you get to your goal, the more unreasonable it is to expect to lose 2 lbs per week. Your goal should no longer be 2 lbs per week... but more like 1 or even 0.8 lbs per week.0
-
I think you are all over looking the fact that it is CLEARLY either an error on MFP part OR the user has input some data wrong somewhere (dosen't seem likely)0
-
hi everyone. I started MFP 5 weeks ago. I weighed 165 and want to weigh 135. I put I would like to loose 2lbs per week. So off I went. Eating 1200 calories per day. Working out 3 times a day. I was right on target and lost 10lbs in 5 weeks. So then MFP wants to update my calories so I can continue to meet my goals. I click yes and it updates it to 930 per day. Now I understand I get more calories when I work out but I only go to my fitness class three times a week. Now obviously I'm active other than that. You know errands cooking cleaning work etc. but I don't really include that. So some days when I have no exercise and I meet the 930 calories for the day MFP says I'm not eating enough. What gives ?
You can set your calorie goal manually. Personally I eat around 1600 calories a day with light exercise and still lose weight. Eat more than 1200.0 -
Ok thanks. I'll try that. I'm new to this I realize 930 is way too low which is why I asked. Thanks for the imput0
-
Let's back up a moment here. At 155lbs with 20 to go you should NOT be attempting to lose 2lbs per week.
Change it to 1lb/week at least for a little longer, then go to 1/2lb per week when you get into your last 10. What you are trying to do is dangerous.
So it's not ok to continue to drop 2lbs a week?0 -
myfatass78 wrote: »karen_fitzgibbon wrote: »I'm guessing it might be a glitch in the system? I've never seen it lower than 1200. Maybe contact customer support?
No there has been lots of these recently
One of the mods was saying there was a glitch in the systen which is supposed to be fixed now.
OP, MFP does not set your goal below 1200 (except with this glitch). Try inputting the information again, it should give you 1200. I also agree with those saying at your current weight and considering your goal, that 2 lbs per week is unrealistic.0 -
myfatass78 wrote: »hi everyone. I started MFP 5 weeks ago. I weighed 165 and want to weigh 135. I put I would like to loose 2lbs per week. So off I went. Eating 1200 calories per day. Working out 3 times a day. I was right on target and lost 10lbs in 5 weeks. So then MFP wants to update my calories so I can continue to meet my goals. I click yes and it updates it to 930 per day. Now I understand I get more calories when I work out but I only go to my fitness class three times a week. Now obviously I'm active other than that. You know errands cooking cleaning work etc. but I don't really include that. So some days when I have no exercise and I meet the 930 calories for the day MFP says I'm not eating enough. What gives ?
You can set your calorie goal manually. Personally I eat around 1600 calories a day with light exercise and still lose weight. Eat more than 1200.
Thanks. Well I think I'll put it back to 12000 -
There is a problem with the system. There have been alot of posts by new members asking the same thing. Before it wasn't possible to go under 1200 cals a day. I would ask tec support, although the above posters are right, 2 lbs a week is too much when you don't have alot to lose.0
-
snowflake954 wrote: »There is a problem with the system. There have been alot of posts by new members asking the same thing. Before it wasn't possible to go under 1200 cals a day. I would ask tec support, although the above posters are right, 2 lbs a week is too much when you don't have alot to lose.
Ok thanks. I thought 2lbs even for a person of my weight was ok. So is 1 pound per week more realistic for my current weight?0 -
snowflake954 wrote: »There is a problem with the system. There have been alot of posts by new members asking the same thing. Before it wasn't possible to go under 1200 cals a day. I would ask tec support, although the above posters are right, 2 lbs a week is too much when you don't have alot to lose.
Ok thanks. I thought 2lbs even for a person of my weight was ok. So is 1 pound per week more realistic for my current weight?
That is what I would think. If you are aiming for 2lbs and can't achieve that then you will get discouraged.0 -
Let's back up a moment here. At 155lbs with 20 to go you should NOT be attempting to lose 2lbs per week.
Change it to 1lb/week at least for a little longer, then go to 1/2lb per week when you get into your last 10. What you are trying to do is dangerous.
So it's not ok to continue to drop 2lbs a week?
Not for someone your size. That setting is for people with a significant amount of weight to drop.
0 -
I am not an expert--the others above are. They seem to agree to do 1lb for awhile and then on your last 10lbs drop to .5 lbs. Good luck.0
-
snowflake954 wrote: »There is a problem with the system. There have been alot of posts by new members asking the same thing. Before it wasn't possible to go under 1200 cals a day. I would ask tec support, although the above posters are right, 2 lbs a week is too much when you don't have alot to lose.
Ok thanks. I thought 2lbs even for a person of my weight was ok. So is 1 pound per week more realistic for my current weight?
Yes - at least for now. When you get into the last 10lbs you should consider slowing it down even further.
This is done, in part, so that you gently ease yourself back into eating at maintenance. If you cut weight fast, then start eating more suddenly you are likely to over-do it and go right back to where you started. It seems like it will take forever doing it this way, but the reality is that is the best formula for long-term success0 -
snowflake954 wrote: »There is a problem with the system. There have been alot of posts by new members asking the same thing. Before it wasn't possible to go under 1200 cals a day. I would ask tec support, although the above posters are right, 2 lbs a week is too much when you don't have alot to lose.
Ok thanks. I thought 2lbs even for a person of my weight was ok. So is 1 pound per week more realistic for my current weight?
Yes - at least for now. When you get into the last 10lbs you should consider slowing it down even further.
This is done, in part, so that you gently ease yourself back into eating at maintenance. If you cut weight fast, then start eating more suddenly you are likely to over-do it and go right back to where you started. It seems like it will take forever doing it this way, but the reality is that is the best formula for long-term success
Ok thanks for the advice. Would it just be ok for me to set it back to 1200 calories per day you think? Because at that amount I was doing really well. Most importantly I felt like I had more energy and didn't feel too deprived.0 -
Do .5lb/week. What you have is a glitch, and 2lbs/week is too aggressive for your goals.0
-
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.0
-
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally true. Did this happen to you? Why do you suppose it happens?0 -
missiontofitness wrote: »Do .5lb/week. What you have is a glitch, and 2lbs/week is too aggressive for your goals.
Can I ask you why is it too aggressive for my goals?0 -
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally true. Did this happen to you? Why do you suppose it happens?
I didn't happen to me, but I adamantly believe that this is the WORST thing a glitch could produce. Some will have eating disorders affirmed, others will find weight loss so onerous that they give up and get even more unhealthfully obese. I think 100% of MFP energy needs to go to fixing the glitch. It's dangerous and setting them up for a lawsuit possibly.0 -
I noticed the app,on my phone dropped me down to 960 this afternoon. I logged on from my computer, and switched my goal from 1/2 pound a week to 1 pound a week, then back to 1/2 pound. It reset and put me back up to 1550 calories.
Tried to change my goals again from the phone app-- and it dropped me back down to 960. I'm not sure if the glitch is only on the phone, but it definitely happened to me as well.0 -
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally true. Did this happen to you? Why do you suppose it happens?
I didn't happen to me, but I adamantly believe that this is the WORST thing a glitch could produce. Some will have eating disorders affirmed, others will find weight loss so onerous that they give up and get even more unhealthfully obese. I think 100% of MFP energy needs to go to fixing the glitch. It's dangerous and setting them up for a lawsuit possibly.
Agreed. This is not safe, and we see enough people who manually override the settings as it is.0 -
I noticed the app,on my phone dropped me down to 960 this afternoon. I logged on from my computer, and switched my goal from 1/2 pound a week to 1 pound a week, then back to 1/2 pound. It reset and put me back up to 1550 calories.
Tried to change my goals again from the phone app-- and it dropped me back down to 960. I'm not sure if the glitch is only on the phone, but it definitely happened to me as well.
Does it to me on the iPad app0 -
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally true. Did this happen to you? Why do you suppose it happens?
I didn't happen to me, but I adamantly believe that this is the WORST thing a glitch could produce. Some will have eating disorders affirmed, others will find weight loss so onerous that they give up and get even more unhealthfully obese. I think 100% of MFP energy needs to go to fixing the glitch. It's dangerous and setting them up for a lawsuit possibly.
Yes very scary. I hope it gets fixed right away0 -
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally agree.0 -
I noticed the app,on my phone dropped me down to 960 this afternoon. I logged on from my computer, and switched my goal from 1/2 pound a week to 1 pound a week, then back to 1/2 pound. It reset and put me back up to 1550 calories.
Tried to change my goals again from the phone app-- and it dropped me back down to 960. I'm not sure if the glitch is only on the phone, but it definitely happened to me as well.
Does it to me on the iPad app
Also. Someone mentioned I should try to reset it too. Didn't even think of that so I did. And it then changed from 930 calories per day to 920!! Wtf.0 -
I really hate this glitch. It's DANGEROUS. They need to focus on fixing it, it's easy for a well-informed person to second guess and know it's a glitch, but for every person like OP who instinctively thinks, "that's not right" there are probably 3 who are assuming that that must be right because the computer says so. Really not cool.
Totally true. Did this happen to you? Why do you suppose it happens?
I didn't happen to me, but I adamantly believe that this is the WORST thing a glitch could produce. Some will have eating disorders affirmed, others will find weight loss so onerous that they give up and get even more unhealthfully obese. I think 100% of MFP energy needs to go to fixing the glitch. It's dangerous and setting them up for a lawsuit possibly.
I tried to reset it as someone suggested. This was after a day of this glitch. So I went and reset it. It went from 930 calories a day to 920 per day. *kitten* up!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions