What to cut out from your diet?
Replies
-
DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
Probably not, unless all you eat is chocolate and crisps and you go over your calories every day!
I haven't cut out anything, but I don't eat chocolate, cake, sweets every single day either. I rarely drink alcohol, but that's more because I have 3 young kids and my social life these days involves meeting friends at soft play and drinking coffee lol.
I had a real craving for something sweet yesterday so I made some oat raisin cookies and had 1.5 cookies. That was enough for me, and didn't put me over my daily calorie allowance. I'm fairly sure it won't make me gain weight.
I think when you tell yourself you can't have something, that's when you want it. I'm not bothered by not drinking much, but when I was pregnant I found myself really craving alcohol a couple of times, and that's probably because I couldn't have it!
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
0 -
Wine as an almost daily thing. I've cut it down to one night a week max at the moment as I just don't have room for a 300cal glass of wine (or likely 600 cal for 3/4 of a bottle!)....
Wow, how big are your glasses? A 5 ounce glass of wine is roughly 125 calories. I have one most evenings.0 -
I got rid of weight by -
- I cut off processed/packaged food and started eating less at restaurants.
- I started cooking at home more and more pretty much everything that they serve at restaurants including international cuisines.
- I now control calories in by eating more 80% nutritious dense food. I reserved 20% treat for a week.
- I now control calories out by being more physically active.
- I weigh every food, that I eat, on a kitchen scale in grams. Since I prepare most food at home it's become easier.
0 - I cut off processed/packaged food and started eating less at restaurants.
-
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
Probably not, unless all you eat is chocolate and crisps and you go over your calories every day!
I haven't cut out anything, but I don't eat chocolate, cake, sweets every single day either. I rarely drink alcohol, but that's more because I have 3 young kids and my social life these days involves meeting friends at soft play and drinking coffee lol.
I had a real craving for something sweet yesterday so I made some oat raisin cookies and had 1.5 cookies. That was enough for me, and didn't put me over my daily calorie allowance. I'm fairly sure it won't make me gain weight.
I think when you tell yourself you can't have something, that's when you want it. I'm not bothered by not drinking much, but when I was pregnant I found myself really craving alcohol a couple of times, and that's probably because I couldn't have it!
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
Probably. If you make a huge list of banned foods then you are more likely to binge eat. If you're of the mindset that anything is ok, so long as you don't overdo it, then you're more likely to be successful. Unless you're very singleminded and happy to live on a diet of oats, chicken and kale every single day
0 -
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
While I do understand what you saying, believe me, I had to change what I brought home from the grocery store.
If it is in the house, I will eat the whole family size bag of potato chips in a day. I will eat a whole sleeve of crackers or cookie as well.
I tell myself I am on a "break". I did not give them up altogether but at the moment, not buying them for the pantry. We would always have chips, crackers, etc. in the pantry at all times.
0 -
SwankyTomato wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
While I do understand what you saying, believe me, I had to change what I brought home from the grocery store.
If it is in the house, I will eat the whole family size bag of potato chips in a day. I will eat a whole sleeve of crackers or cookie as well.
I tell myself I am on a "break". I did not give them up altogether but at the moment, not buying them for the pantry. We would always have chips, crackers, etc. in the pantry at all times.
I definitely was NOT saying that you should bring foods that cause binging issues home from the grocery store just because.
Honestly I'm not really "saying" anything, just musing. But if I have a point, it has nothing to do with how often you choose to eat whatever food. It has to do with how two people who have chosen to eat them with roughly the same frequency can see their choice through vastly different lenses.0 -
The first thing I cut was soda. It was easy, because I've never had a strong attachment, and it was a choice I'm happy to maintain. Since joining MFP, I've easily cut chips and frozen meals, because I want to. Again, if I wanted to eat these types of foods I would, but for me, it is well worth eliminating them. Like you, I've cut out all sorts of sweets, because they were not serving me well. I love enjoying select dark chocolate on occasion.0
-
mburgess458 wrote: »Wine as an almost daily thing. I've cut it down to one night a week max at the moment as I just don't have room for a 300cal glass of wine (or likely 600 cal for 3/4 of a bottle!)....
Wow, how big are your glasses? A 5 ounce glass of wine is roughly 125 calories. I have one most evenings.
Well in the UK a large glass of wine is 250mls. Two of those seems a nice amount to me....
0 -
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »Need2Exerc1se wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
I would imagine on an individual level it could matter a great deal. For example, I frequently see posts on this site where people say they immediately start wanting something the minute they say they can't have it or that it's 'bad'. For those people, saying "I'm cutting X out" is probably not a good idea.
But for others it is easier to just say "I cut X" and it doesn't trigger the emotion that others experience.
That's pretty much how I am. Same reason when my high school boyfriend told me I couldn't cut my hair I went home and gave myself a pixie cut with kitchen scissors. :laugh: I should have just lost the boyfriend.
I'll admit I was pretty surprised by the number of people that feel that way on this site.0 -
I agree with the poster who said there is a bit of a question of semantics. Things that I now only eat occasionally I would class as "having cut from my (regular) diet". The only think I never, ever eat is chocolate.
Some people say they eat exactly the same things, but in smaller portions. That's fine, but if all you ate previously was chips, battered fish and pies washed down with coke you are going to have microscopic portions if you try to stick to 1,200 cals a day.0 -
arilongworth wrote: »
Well, you don't just eat junk food. I don't. But I have days where I have chocolate or chips or beer. I just make sure it fits. I tend to stick with meat, vegetables, grains, etc. only because they are satiating. But you better believe I have chocolate in my diet and tortilla chips. It's not about deprivation, it's about moderation.
Here's how I'm losing weight:
I stay at or under my calorie goal
I weigh my food/liquids
I pre-plan if necessary for days I want to fit in something special
I workout
I log it.
It's really that simple.
0 -
I cut out chicken breast - it's dry and rubbery and I hate it. Thighs thighs thighs!!!0
-
I cut out chicken breast - it's dry and rubbery and I hate it. Thighs thighs thighs!!!
I don't know. My local grocer has the best breasts ever.
But seriously, their chicken breasts are the only ones we buy now. They are juicy, tender, and just perfect. However, we still prefer the drumsticks and thighs overall but when breasts are needed in the recipe, they are the ones we use.
0 -
Embrace the breasts! Embrace the thighs!
I am sure many would agree. Breasts and thighs are both lovely.
0 -
-
Nothing! All things in moderation. I might only have something as a treat once every few months but I will not totally cut something out...that would only make me want it that much more! I just make sure everything fits into my calorie goal.0
-
0
-
I haven't cut out ANYTHING from what I used to eat. I continue to include junk food, fast food along with healthy meals. How do I lose weight then? By eating WAY LESS than what I used to eat before. Sticking to my daily calories works wonders... :drinker:0
-
Fried stuff. I tried a couple times to eat something fried over the past year, and each time it ended in serious colon blow. Forget that, not worth it, not doing any more!0
-
-
DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
Probably not, unless all you eat is chocolate and crisps and you go over your calories every day!
I haven't cut out anything, but I don't eat chocolate, cake, sweets every single day either. I rarely drink alcohol, but that's more because I have 3 young kids and my social life these days involves meeting friends at soft play and drinking coffee lol.
I had a real craving for something sweet yesterday so I made some oat raisin cookies and had 1.5 cookies. That was enough for me, and didn't put me over my daily calorie allowance. I'm fairly sure it won't make me gain weight.
I think when you tell yourself you can't have something, that's when you want it. I'm not bothered by not drinking much, but when I was pregnant I found myself really craving alcohol a couple of times, and that's probably because I couldn't have it!
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
Probably. If you make a huge list of banned foods then you are more likely to binge eat. If you're of the mindset that anything is ok, so long as you don't overdo it, then you're more likely to be successful. Unless you're very singleminded and happy to live on a diet of oats, chicken and kale every single day
I worry that it's a change that can't/won't be permanent. I think some people succeed at weight loss but fail at maintenance because they have a list of things that they can't eat while dieting but when they're "done" it's woohoo! Break out the Oreos!
Of course, I realize that's not true for everyone but it would definitely be a concern for me. That or I'd cave before I reached goal and eat all the things.0 -
No more cakes, candy, chips, white carbs and soda0
-
Need2Exerc1se wrote: »
YES!! Brining for the win. My daughter and I love to make homemade chicken fried chicken. When we remember, we put them in a salt water bath for 4-6 hours. HUGE difference. :-)
It's all yours
0 -
ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
I wonder about this all the time. I've tried to get clarification from people who say they've cut it out (but still consume) on their thinking. One person told me that they put it that way because they hoped they'd never have it again.
I'd love to understand the mentality of making a sacrifice ("I've cut out/eliminated/never eat") vs. feeling the freedom to eat what you like as long as you can fit it into your calorie goals.
0 -
DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
Probably not, unless all you eat is chocolate and crisps and you go over your calories every day!
I haven't cut out anything, but I don't eat chocolate, cake, sweets every single day either. I rarely drink alcohol, but that's more because I have 3 young kids and my social life these days involves meeting friends at soft play and drinking coffee lol.
I had a real craving for something sweet yesterday so I made some oat raisin cookies and had 1.5 cookies. That was enough for me, and didn't put me over my daily calorie allowance. I'm fairly sure it won't make me gain weight.
I think when you tell yourself you can't have something, that's when you want it. I'm not bothered by not drinking much, but when I was pregnant I found myself really craving alcohol a couple of times, and that's probably because I couldn't have it!
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
Probably. If you make a huge list of banned foods then you are more likely to binge eat. If you're of the mindset that anything is ok, so long as you don't overdo it, then you're more likely to be successful. Unless you're very singleminded and happy to live on a diet of oats, chicken and kale every single day
I worry that it's a change that can't/won't be permanent. I think some people succeed at weight loss but fail at maintenance because they have a list of things that they can't eat while dieting but when they're "done" it's woohoo! Break out the Oreos!
Of course, I realize that's not true for everyone but it would definitely be a concern for me. That or I'd cave before I reached goal and eat all the things.
I think that's valid. At the same time, I've heard others say that it isn't really a "lifestyle change" unless you cut out all the "bad" foods and completely change how you eat. They worry that continuing to include those foods in their lives will result in regaining the weight. (I'm not one of them, I'm with you).
In the end I think maintenance is hard regardless, and one of the keys is to understand yourself and what mindset/behaviors will make it doable for you.0 -
Initially when I lost weight, I didn't cut out anything. However I'm starting to notice that the less dairy and sugar I eat, the more energy I have.0
-
Nothing. I still eat all the things. Just not the sheer volume I used to eat. And I am significantly more active. I don't work this damn hard in the gym to NOT eat ice cream.0
-
I've added protein powder and Quest bars for some variety. I haven't really cut anything, but there are things I don't eat (gluten) for medical reasons, and lots of things I don't eat out of personal preference (I'm a vegetarian and since I hit menopause, I've oddly gone off chocolate in the past few months).0
-
DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »DawnieB1977 wrote: »ILiftHeavyAcrylics wrote: »I find word choices interesting in threads like these. There are people like me who will say they don't cut anything out, but if you looked at my diary you would only find alcohol once or twice per year. You'd almost never find anything fried. You'd very rarely find things like bacon or sausage. If you asked me whether I've cut those things out I'd say no. But on the other hand, you've got people saying that they do cut out all kinds of things "except once or twice per week," which is probably more often than I have those things that they've "cut out." I wouldn't say I've cut something out unless I actually never have it and never plan to do so.
I'm curious about the difference in mindset and whether it matters which way you think of it.
Probably not, unless all you eat is chocolate and crisps and you go over your calories every day!
I haven't cut out anything, but I don't eat chocolate, cake, sweets every single day either. I rarely drink alcohol, but that's more because I have 3 young kids and my social life these days involves meeting friends at soft play and drinking coffee lol.
I had a real craving for something sweet yesterday so I made some oat raisin cookies and had 1.5 cookies. That was enough for me, and didn't put me over my daily calorie allowance. I'm fairly sure it won't make me gain weight.
I think when you tell yourself you can't have something, that's when you want it. I'm not bothered by not drinking much, but when I was pregnant I found myself really craving alcohol a couple of times, and that's probably because I couldn't have it!
I didn't mean whether it makes a difference in weight loss. I just meant I wonder if the mindset behind it makes a difference in whether a person is successful or not. I'm like you-- telling myself something is off limits is the best way to make me want it.
Probably. If you make a huge list of banned foods then you are more likely to binge eat. If you're of the mindset that anything is ok, so long as you don't overdo it, then you're more likely to be successful. Unless you're very singleminded and happy to live on a diet of oats, chicken and kale every single day
I worry that it's a change that can't/won't be permanent. I think some people succeed at weight loss but fail at maintenance because they have a list of things that they can't eat while dieting but when they're "done" it's woohoo! Break out the Oreos!
Of course, I realize that's not true for everyone but it would definitely be a concern for me. That or I'd cave before I reached goal and eat all the things.
I think with maintenance you just carry on as you are, just add a few extra calories! I don't know, when I got to goal weight I got pregnant lol.
Personally I have nothing banned. I say I eat a pretty healthy diet anyway, but if I fancy a treat I have one.0 -
There are actually more things I added, or added more of, than I took away. I added protein shakes for breakfast which are convenient and satisfying. I added a lot of mushrooms and green peppers. I am pretty sure I added more eggs, more oatmeal. There are things I take away like 98% of the time, like candy/cookies/etc, and then there are things I'm taking away forever because if every time I eat something I get sick, then I'm done with that thing! Like greasy sausages, or fries, ugh, the very thought. X( I used to be ok with those things but nowadays I absolutely cannot digest them. IDK if it's age or just acclimating to a totally different eating style that did it. You may have this happen too eventually. A baked potato though is no problem for me. I can eat a potato fine, just not eat it fried. If you have to take some items out of circulation, there's usually plenty of good things you can add instead.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions