New to Eating clean! And new to mfp this week
gemma7115
Posts: 15 Member
Struggling eating clean, add me please could do with good support and advice 
0
Replies
-
Everyone has a different definition of eating clean. Personally, I think it's best to start out by sticking to your calorie limit, getting that under control, then making substitutions to make your feel better, if you need to.0
-
What are you struggling with? What do you consider "eating clean"? Agree you need to have a reasonable calorie goal and stick with it because even "clean eaters" can gain weight by going over calories. Need more info to help you with your question.0
-
Well I've done loads of reading lol, but find it hard as I'm a fussy eater. Mainly been eating chicken various ways, cut bread out all together, substituted it with rye bread which not eaten much of, and brown rice and soups. Is pasta ok?0
-
Well I've done loads of reading lol, but find it hard as I'm a fussy eater. Mainly been eating chicken various ways, cut bread out all together, substituted it with rye bread which not eaten much of, and brown rice and soups. Is pasta ok?
Okay for what? I eat all foods in moderation. Some "clean eaters" forgo all grain, which would include rye bread. Some eat only organic this and that. Some don't eat wheat/flour. Some only eat raw foods. Some only eat things they make themselves from scratch, so grain is okay but pasta wouldn't be.
What is your goal?0 -
Well My goal would be to loose 2stone, honestly I haven't a clue what I'm doing, I think I need to read up more just seems all the food which is ok seem to be fish based which the thought make me sick lol x0
-
A question I would ask is, why are you making the choice to "eat clean"? Is the reason why you want to do the whole eating clean thing because you feel you need to in order to lose weight? You can eat all kinds of foods and still lose weight. You will find that as you get used to your calorie goal and weighing your food, you will slowly begin to gravitate towards healthier/lower calorie foods since you can get more "bang for your buck" and you can still work in treats here and there depending on your calorie goal.0
-
Clean eating can mean anythimg, and thus it means nothing.
To lose weight you can eat anything you like within your calorie goal.
To be healthy you should eat a variety of foods from all food groups every day.
Don't eat anything that makes you sick.
Don't believe something is bad for you just because you've read it in a magazine.
If you want to, you can train your taste to like more foods.0 -
I have to eat clean I have to follow the Mediterranean diet, for me my doctor told me too.0
-
britishbroccoli wrote: »Everyone has a different definition of eating clean. Personally, I think it's best to start out by sticking to your calorie limit, getting that under control, then making substitutions to make your feel better, if you need to.
Exactly this! It'll take time, but slowly incorporate small substitutions, such as swapping full fat for diet, then to sugar free, and then eliminate it completely (except for cheat days ofc if you plan to incorporate them). It's going to take time, and patience will be your best friend in this game!
Welcome, and good luck!
0 -
Eat all your calories, and read the forums, search for any questions you have. Try and stay on target, but don't beat yourself up if you have a moment.
I can't reitterate better what was already said about to each their own.
Clean eating to me is trying not to eat a lot of processed foods, but it is HARD because that's the world we live in. Ultimately, make smart healthy choices, but if you want something eat it (as long as it fits your macros! 
) 0 -
nicklaunch91 wrote: »britishbroccoli wrote: »Everyone has a different definition of eating clean. Personally, I think it's best to start out by sticking to your calorie limit, getting that under control, then making substitutions to make your feel better, if you need to.
Exactly this! It'll take time, but slowly incorporate small substitutions, such as swapping full fat for diet, then to sugar free, and then eliminate it completely (except for cheat days ofc if you plan to incorporate them). It's going to take time, and patience will be your best friend in this game!
Welcome, and good luck!
Why does she have to substitute sugar free?
0 -
I'm a lifelong clean eater too! Yes, I always clean my plate of its food whether I am eating at deficit, or surplus, depending on goal.0
-
OP, it sounds like you haven't done a lot of reading yet, you have some goals in mind but not sure how to achieve them. MFP is a great place to start. Ultimately to lose weight, what matters is that you are in a calorie deficit. There are a number of ways to achieve that calorie deficit. Some people restrict certain food groups or eat "clean" but as others have pointed out, that word has variable definitions for different people. A number of folks here on MFP have had great success eating all the same things they love, just doing so in moderation.
You may find some helpful tips in this link - there's lots of good info so read it as many times as it takes for it all to make sense.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1080242/a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants/p1
Good luck.0 -
Well My goal would be to loose 2stone, honestly I haven't a clue what I'm doing, I think I need to read up more just seems all the food which is ok seem to be fish based which the thought make me sick lol x
clean eating has noting to do with weight loss, all you need is a calorie deficit.
0 -
britishbroccoli wrote: »Everyone has a different definition of eating clean. Personally, I think it's best to start out by sticking to your calorie limit, getting that under control, then making substitutions to make your feel better, if you need to.
^^^ I will second this statement. Focus on eating at your calorie goal and exercising. As you move along you can start to substitute/eliminate certain foods. Clean eating is what you want it to mean. For me its limiting processed foods. I do not claim that processed foods are "bad", I just believe in making sure I limit added surgars and other additives, but its a personal choice and has nothing to do with weight loss.0 -
Eat all your calories, and read the forums, search for any questions you have. Try and stay on target, but don't beat yourself up if you have a moment.
I can't reitterate better what was already said about to each their own. Clean eating to me is trying not to eat a lot of processed foods, but it is HARD because that's the world we live in. Ultimately, make smart healthy choices, but if you want something eat it (as long as it fits your macros! )
weight loss does not have to be hard. Enjoy the foods you like and just eat less of them. Get a food scale and weight everything. And make sure that you log all your food into MFP and eat to the number that MFP gives you ...0 -
My goal has been to eat all natural foods. Nothing processed nothing with added sugar. I also eat at a deficit. I have lost 20lbs since Feb 23rd. I do workout most days. I think the all natural foods has given me lots of energy to workout.0
-
rebeccaschlaht wrote: »My goal has been to eat all natural foods. Nothing processed nothing with added sugar. I also eat at a deficit. I have lost 20lbs since Feb 23rd. I do workout most days. I think the all natural foods has given me lots of energy to workout.
so "non natural foods" provide less energy than natural foods???
pretty sure that 100 calories of organic apples = 100 calories of twinkies from an energy perspective...0 -
Get used to staying under your calories. Everything in moderation. Take the time to measure out your food by serving size if it looks to much cut it in half. Everybody is different. I just started 15 days ago and with the right amount of food and exercise i have lost 2lbs. It may not be much but my goal is to lose a lb or so a week and I'm happy with my progress.0
-
Eat all your calories, and read the forums, search for any questions you have. Try and stay on target, but don't beat yourself up if you have a moment.
I can't reitterate better what was already said about to each their own. Clean eating to me is trying not to eat a lot of processed foods, but it is HARD because that's the world we live in. Ultimately, make smart healthy choices, but if you want something eat it (as long as it fits your macros! )
weight loss does not have to be hard. Enjoy the foods you like and just eat less of them. Get a food scale and weight everything. And make sure that you log all your food into MFP and eat to the number that MFP gives you ...
Shhh... You're intercoursing the construct! Weight lost is supposed to be difficult, expensive, and involve a secret sold by a MLM company.0 -
nakedraygun wrote: »Eat all your calories, and read the forums, search for any questions you have. Try and stay on target, but don't beat yourself up if you have a moment.
I can't reitterate better what was already said about to each their own. Clean eating to me is trying not to eat a lot of processed foods, but it is HARD because that's the world we live in. Ultimately, make smart healthy choices, but if you want something eat it (as long as it fits your macros! )
weight loss does not have to be hard. Enjoy the foods you like and just eat less of them. Get a food scale and weight everything. And make sure that you log all your food into MFP and eat to the number that MFP gives you ...
Shhh... You're intercoursing the construct! Weight lost is supposed to be difficult, expensive, and involve a secret sold by a MLM company.
I thought dr oz had all the secrets???0 -
Rofl. He haz all the moneyz.nakedraygun wrote: »Eat all your calories, and read the forums, search for any questions you have. Try and stay on target, but don't beat yourself up if you have a moment.
I can't reitterate better what was already said about to each their own. Clean eating to me is trying not to eat a lot of processed foods, but it is HARD because that's the world we live in. Ultimately, make smart healthy choices, but if you want something eat it (as long as it fits your macros! )
weight loss does not have to be hard. Enjoy the foods you like and just eat less of them. Get a food scale and weight everything. And make sure that you log all your food into MFP and eat to the number that MFP gives you ...
Shhh... You're intercoursing the construct! Weight lost is supposed to be difficult, expensive, and involve a secret sold by a MLM company.
I thought dr oz had all the secrets???0 -
OP here is my advice for you.
set MFP to .5 pound or 1 pound per week loss and eat to that number
get a food scale and weigh all solids and as many liquids as possible.
log everything you eat into MFP.
make sure that you are hitting your macro (protein/carb/fats) percent's and your micros.
realize that no foods are bad and that you can eat the foods that you want and still lose weight. Yes, this means that you can eat pizza, ice cream, cookies ,etc; however, this does not mean that your diet should be composed 100% of said foods. You should also fit in some nutrient dense foods like vegetables, rice, chicken, fish etc.
If you want to work out then find something you enjoy and do it, not necessary but it does help with overall health and body recomp. I like heavy lifting but that is just me...
repeat until you get desired results.
0 -
A question I would ask is, why are you making the choice to "eat clean"? Is the reason why you want to do the whole eating clean thing because you feel you need to in order to lose weight? You can eat all kinds of foods and still lose weight. You will find that as you get used to your calorie goal and weighing your food, you will slowly begin to gravitate towards healthier/lower calorie foods since you can get more "bang for your buck" and you can still work in treats here and there depending on your calorie goal.
I'm doing a fitness programme and it is recommended to 'eat clean' to help achieve my goal x0 -
kommodevaran wrote: »Clean eating can mean anythimg, and thus it means nothing.
To lose weight you can eat anything you like within your calorie goal.
To be healthy you should eat a variety of foods from all food groups every day.
Don't eat anything that makes you sick.
Don't believe something is bad for you just because you've read it in a magazine.
If you want to, you can train your taste to like more foods.
Thank you I didn't even think of it like that! I do try to stay within my calorie goal or at least be a bit under x
0 -
OP, it sounds like you haven't done a lot of reading yet, you have some goals in mind but not sure how to achieve them. MFP is a great place to start. Ultimately to lose weight, what matters is that you are in a calorie deficit. There are a number of ways to achieve that calorie deficit. Some people restrict certain food groups or eat "clean" but as others have pointed out, that word has variable definitions for different people. A number of folks here on MFP have had great success eating all the same things they love, just doing so in moderation.
You may find some helpful tips in this link - there's lots of good info so read it as many times as it takes for it all to make sense.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1080242/a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants/p1
Good luck.
Thank you - I'm doing a fitness programme and it was recommended for me to 'eat clean' I will have a look at that discussion thanks again x0 -
nicklaunch91 wrote: »britishbroccoli wrote: »Everyone has a different definition of eating clean. Personally, I think it's best to start out by sticking to your calorie limit, getting that under control, then making substitutions to make your feel better, if you need to.
Exactly this! It'll take time, but slowly incorporate small substitutions, such as swapping full fat for diet, then to sugar free, and then eliminate it completely (except for cheat days ofc if you plan to incorporate them). It's going to take time, and patience will be your best friend in this game!
Welcome, and good luck!
Thanks so much feeling a bit more positive free reading through xx 0 -
Thank everyone maybe I am being too strickt! I will concentrate on staying within my calorie goal. Still cutting the bread and spuds out haha!
I really appreciate all your comments 0 -
OP, it sounds like you haven't done a lot of reading yet, you have some goals in mind but not sure how to achieve them. MFP is a great place to start. Ultimately to lose weight, what matters is that you are in a calorie deficit. There are a number of ways to achieve that calorie deficit. Some people restrict certain food groups or eat "clean" but as others have pointed out, that word has variable definitions for different people. A number of folks here on MFP have had great success eating all the same things they love, just doing so in moderation.
You may find some helpful tips in this link - there's lots of good info so read it as many times as it takes for it all to make sense.
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1080242/a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants/p1
Good luck.
Thank you - I'm doing a fitness programme and it was recommended for me to 'eat clean' I will have a look at that discussion thanks again x
I'm not sure what the fitness program is, or who gave you the advice to "eat clean" but generally personal trainers have no credentials to be able to give nutritional advice. As others have said, you don't have to eat clean to lose weight, or to meet a variety of other health and fitness goals. If you choose to do that, it is fine, but many people find the concept of "clean eating" to be difficult, which is what you put in your original post, and we are telling you that is generally unnecessary.
0 -
Thank everyone maybe I am being too strickt! I will concentrate on staying within my calorie goal. Still cutting the bread and spuds out haha!
I really appreciate all your comments
Being too strict too fast is where many people fail. They make too many changes, can't find balance, and ragequit.
Don't do that.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions