For some, has avoiding fat been more effective than avoiding carbs for weight loss?
Replies
-
I got real lean on a low fat diet but I had excessive cravings and had to work out constantly. Back then the whole idea of low-carb dieting seemed ridiculous to me. I thought the idea of cutting out refined sugar was just hippy talk.
Now I keep my daily carb intake relatively low and try to avoid processed sugars as much as possible while still letting myself indulge. I increased my intake of fat significantly as well. Now I don't get cravings and eat only the calories I need to meet my goals. It has never been this easy in the 20 years I have been trying to stay fit. I can now live my life without feeling deprived.
I agree that weight loss is simply calories in / calories out, but the foods we eat vary in terms of satiation. Maybe there are people out there that can eat all the sugar and carbs they want and still remain fit. Recent studies have shown that doesn't work for most people. A handful of fitness fanatics on MFP who can burn through any kind of food is not representative of what works for the general population.0 -
FitnessTim wrote: »I got real lean on a low fat diet but I had excessive cravings and had to work out constantly. Back then the whole idea of low-carb dieting seemed ridiculous to me. I thought the idea of cutting out refined sugar was just hippy talk.
Now I keep my daily carb intake relatively low and try to avoid processed sugars as much as possible while still letting myself indulge. I increased my intake of fat significantly as well. Now I don't get cravings and eat only the calories I need to meet my goals. It has never been this easy in the 20 years I have been trying to stay fit. I can now live my life without feeling deprived.
I agree that weight loss is simply calories in / calories out, but the foods we eat vary in terms of satiation. Maybe there are people out there that can eat all the sugar and carbs they want and still remain fit. Recent studies have shown that doesn't work for most people. A handful of fitness fanatics on MFP who can burn through any kind of food is not representative of what works for the general population.
What studies? Please link
Nobody here ever said they eat all the sugar and carbs they want
All I ever see is people saying they hit their macro and micro nutrient targets (the macros being protein and fats) and then can eat whatever they want to their calorie limit
I'm no fitness fanatic but I can accommodate any food within my diet if I am careful with my calories .. anybody could0 -
Avoiding food groups/entire macros is what made 80% of the time I spent dieting harder, mentally challenging and less efficient.
I started adding back lots of good, nutritious carbs and healthy fats in my diet and while I wasn't even trying to lose anymore weight, I did naturally. I was feeling better, I had ridiculously more energy and a better mood/less prone to mood swings. Just because I was eating what I, what my body felt like eating (i've developped a habit of eating healthy and my cravings are as well so i never worry about accidentally falling in a pool of mcdonalds burgers), my general well-being improved and the pounds intuitively shed without needing me to be extra cautious and always so anxious about if i should eat this, or that, oh no not that. Eat. Enjoy it. Eat of everything, in moderation, and you'll be in the happiest, best shape of your life.0 -
Ok, as another person with pcos, I have seen weight loss without cutting carbs. HOWEVER, if you are wanting to lose weight to regulate your cycle, and are looking to increase your fertility a large part of that is making sure you control your insulin levels as this will impact your levels of testosterone and DHEA and estrogen. I would imagine you want to lose weight for the same reasons I do which is to control the androgen hormone side effects such as excess hair etc. and we are looking to start a family.
A lot of the advice I have seen above is solid weight loss advice, but may not go a long way in helping you with the other side effects of having insulin resistance and hormones that are out of whack. Low carb, low glycemic index/load or medications are the only thing I know that will help.0 -
I should also note, I have lost 40 lbs in the past and not regained my cycle by simply cutting calories. This time, doing low carb/low GI I have had my cycle all but one month since January which is when I started, and it happened pretty much right away before any significant weight loss.0
-
You guys bashing sugar and fat can take a look at my diary entry from yesterday. I did Stronglifts 5x5 and a small amount of cycling (only about 150 calories), and even with all of what many consider "junk food" in my day, I won't gain an ounce (of fat; water is another story, but meh). Know why? Because I burned more than I consumed. That's how it works.0
-
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »The fact of the matter is that people have been trying to pin down the "cause" of weight gain for many years. One day it's fat, the next day it's carbs, then it's gluten, then back to carbs again but only in the form of added sugars. Truthfully, the only thing that matters is calories, plain and simple.
You need to invest in a food scale. Get one on Amazon or Wal-Mart for $10-15. Use it to log your calories as accurately as possible. Work on finding a macronutrient balance that keeps you feeling satiated. For some, high-carb/low-fat works best. For others, low-carb/high-fat works best. For a lot of people, a more balanced approach works best.
One macronutrient is not going to impact your weight loss. It comes down to your overall caloric intake.
I use a food scale, measuring cups, measuring spoons, etc. Thats what made this all so fascinating. I measured my food the exact same way when I did eat paleo/whole 30 and lost more weight when I was eating grains and more carbohydrates. That's why I was curious if anyone else had found their macros mattered but in the way of fat rather than carbs.
0 -
Eating higher fat, moderate protein, and under 100grams of carbs per day help me stay in a deficit, have clear skin, and a happy gut. High carbs and low fat cause me to struggle with keeping the deficit, destroy my skin, give me a stomach ache and a bad attitude. I believe macro needs are individual, but you definitely want to be getting good fats in your diet for overall health.
This chart explains what those good fats and oils are and which to avoid:
Edit: I can't get that image to show up here, so here's the link to it:
https://eatingrules.com/Cooking-Oil-Comparison-Chart_02-22-12.pdf0 -
Yeah, sugar is not the devil, and calories in vs calories out is the main cause of weight gain. But posting that it doesn't matter to do low carb to someone who very likely suffers from insulin resistance as a result of pcos isn't really helpful for their medical condition. It is just a fact that for diabetics and those with insulin resistance the number of carbs matter as it impacts their insulin response.0
-
sdraper2014 wrote: »Yeah, sugar is not the devil, and calories in vs calories out is the main cause of weight gain. But posting that it doesn't matter to do low carb to someone who very likely suffers from insulin resistance as a result of pcos isn't really helpful for their medical condition. It is just a fact that for diabetics and those with insulin resistance the number of carbs matter as it impacts their insulin response.
or wait until there's an actual real life medical diagnosis of IR before jumping on a bandwagon?0 -
Maybe the OP doesn't have insulin resistance, but since they go hand in hand and the majority of people with one have the other, something to consider.0
-
sdraper2014 wrote: »Maybe the OP doesn't have insulin resistance, but since they go hand in hand and the majority of people with one have the other, something to consider.
And PCOS is often misdiagnosed as it's a diagnosis of exclusions .. it was for me0 -
Yeah, but if the op says they have it, and a doctor diagnosed her, I am not going to undiagnosed her over the internet because she lost weight eating carbs. I will assume the diagnosis is correct and give advice in line with sound medical advice I have received for the same condition.0
-
IR does not automatically mean you have to eat LCHF. You can eat carbs and still lose weight with PCOS and IR. You just have to be mindful and moderate them.0
-
sdraper2014 wrote: »Yeah, but if the op says they have it, and a doctor diagnosed her, I am not going to undiagnosed her over the internet because she lost weight eating carbs. I will assume the diagnosis is correct and give advice in line with sound medical advice I have received for the same condition.
and additionally diagnose her with IR?0 -
Alyssa_Is_LosingIt wrote: »The fact of the matter is that people have been trying to pin down the "cause" of weight gain for many years. One day it's fat, the next day it's carbs, then it's gluten, then back to carbs again but only in the form of added sugars. Truthfully, the only thing that matters is calories, plain and simple.
You need to invest in a food scale. Get one on Amazon or Wal-Mart for $10-15. Use it to log your calories as accurately as possible. Work on finding a macronutrient balance that keeps you feeling satiated. For some, high-carb/low-fat works best. For others, low-carb/high-fat works best. For a lot of people, a more balanced approach works best.
One macronutrient is not going to impact your weight loss. It comes down to your overall caloric intake.
This^
Unless you have a diagnosed medical condition......it's calories, calories, calories. I'm fat because my portions are too big.
Pick something you can sustain for a lifetime. Weight loss is just half the battle.....maintenance is the other half. Maintenance is the part so may people fail at miserably.0 -
Maybe she doesn't have it, I was pretty clear before maybe she doesn't, but what do you think the likely hood that she does is? 40% end up with it and the best way to avoid developing it is to manage it properly. I didn't say she had to eat low carb, I did say eating whatever she likes and not worrying about the carbs or its impact on insulin as Long as it is within your calories may not not be the best advice for someone with this condition. That is all.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
What in the what is going on in this thread??
Kudos to the few in this thread wading through all the derp to give good advice.0 -
^^This!!0
-
Eating higher fat, moderate protein, and under 100grams of carbs per day help me stay in a deficit, have clear skin, and a happy gut. High carbs and low fat cause me to struggle with keeping the deficit, destroy my skin, give me a stomach ache and a bad attitude. I believe macro needs are individual, but you definitely want to be getting good fats in your diet for overall health.
This chart explains what those good fats and oils are and which to avoid:
Edit: I can't get that image to show up here, so here's the link to it:
https://eatingrules.com/Cooking-Oil-Comparison-Chart_02-22-12.pdf
Tada!
0 -
I've tried paleo/whole 30 because people swear by it and I also have PCOS, which is a condition that has low carb diets recommended for it. When I've done 30 day challenges for these types of diets, I would still watch portions or count calories but I actually lost less weight than when I ate normally. I lost even more weight when I tried a plant based challenge. All you hear about on forums and in the news nowadays is about how bad carbs/grains are for weight loss. Has anyone else found the opposite to be true that cutting fat has effected your weight loss rather than cutting carbs?
Weight loss is not about carbs or grains, it's about eating at a calorie deficit. Type of diet is individual and works only if it works for you.
If your doctor has recommended low carb for your PCOS, then I suggest you follow that advice. Keep in mind, however, that weight loss is still dependent on calories/in calories out, but with medical conditions it might take longer to find your correct calorie goal.
For me, I eat a balance of fat/carbs/protein and I've lose 44 pounds and I've been maintaining for a year and a half. My diary is open.0 -
Speak to your doctor about insulin resistance because with pcos nearly all cases have this metabolic disorder. Do you crave carbs all the time? Sugar then carbs then you feel like more sweets etc etc?
Most people with pcos can't tolerate high gi foods and need to limit sugar and carb intake. Low fat "anything" is not a good option as the sugars are increased compared to the full fat option.0 -
BILLBRYTAN wrote: »It is not a simple matter of just cutting fat and carbs; manufactured fats like canola, corn, safflower and soybean oil should be eliminated entirely because they serve no nutritional purpose. Most fats, like bacon and eggs, butter, coconut oil and other saturated fats should be increased because saturated fats and cholesterol are healthy. Same thing with refined white sugar, white flour, white rice etc. If it is manufactured you should not ever eat it. If the sugar is in whole raw fruits or vegetables you can eat lots. Nutrition is far too complex to be based merely upon macro-nutrients: CARBS, FAT, PROTEIN.
Nooooooooo.0 -
ceoverturf wrote: »What in the what is going on in this thread??
Kudos to the few in this thread wading through all the derp to give good advice.
Gee, now that I'm a the end, I echo this....
Mmmmm.........0 -
Rabbitjb -- perhaps we are dealing with semantics. I will agree that CICO is a 4 Laws of Thermodynamics fact when it comes to machines -- but when it comes to weight loss it is almost meaningless, because so many factors (which you yourself mention: hormones, bacteria, medicine etc) affect how our bodies respond. People are told (often so quickly and often smugly -- though I did not feel you were smug at all), "It's so simple, stupid -- eat less, move more." When it's not simple at all: Eat less, move more, but steroids can make you put on weight despite what you do. Eat less, move more -- but insulin levels affect how much fat you hold onto. Eat less, move more.... but antibiotics fed to mice (and cattle and babies) lead to changes in gut flora and weight gain independent of intake and exercise.
In such cases, and when it comes to a lot of people on this site and others, CICO as a useful concept is practically worthless and it doesn't help to beat people over the heads with it. People come here for help to figure out what is happening with their bodies. Why is it that, using the best instruments at hand -- MFP for CI, Fitbit or Bodybugg or whatever for CO, their bodies are not responding according to the CICO numbers? Why is it that I've lost 5 more lbs in these 14 weeks than I "should" have, and 5 less lbs the last time around than I "should" have? If the most meticulous methods of measurement are off by approximately 140 calories a day this time, then what does that mean for the "cut out a soda a day and you'll lose 15 lbs in a year" kind of simplistic advice that people so often are given?
The endocrinologist I mentioned said she didn't believe in gluten sensitivity for non-celiac people. I said, "So why is it that when I eat pasta, keeping sodium levels the same, I immediately and invariably put on 5 to 8 lbs of water weight overnight? Something is obviously going on in my body to have that reaction." She had no answer for that. I expect there is an answer, and someday science will discover it. For now, I have to go with how my body responds to different things going in. That's all any of us can do.
That's why I keep on saying, people need to find out what leads to weight loss for them.
End of my rant. I have to go to the oral surgeon today and see how last week's tooth extraction is healing.0 -
-
Though I'll add the advice to all: based on my experience this week, if you want fast and easy weight loss, go have a tooth pulled. Because pain killers and a soft food diet really really work if you can stay off the ice cream!0
-
-
Proving that CICO is worthless when it comes to real health and helpful advice.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions